We love this place ! This year we stopped in on National Ice Cream Day (unknowingly). We were itching to try their rainbow cookie ice cream. It lived up to the hype. Everything about it was great. The ice cream had a subtle almond flavor and the chunks of rainbow cookie were perfect (in size and dispersion). Death by chocolate is always a favorite and doesn't disappoint. Service was quick despite the line/ crowd and there were plenty of tables! read more

Twist & Shake - an ice cream cone on a window ledge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New City, New York

See all

Classic roadside ice cream stand with a time-warp twist. Grabbed a NY egg cream (yes, they make them!) while 60s beach tunes blasted from the speakers. Great menu of soft serve, sundaes, floats, and hard scoop favorites--bonus points for the endless flavor options. A little nostalgia, a little sugar rush, and a perfect pit stop on a sunny day read more

See all

Their ice cream is so delicious! All of the hard flavors are homemade and sooo good. Wish they were open all year round.

At the end of a long work week, my colleague and I stopped by Twist & Shake on our way back home. There's only a few parking spots but I'm so glad we made it work. I had a small peanut butter soft serve and my friend had a small pineapple/watermelon swirl dole whip. Both were delicious! At $11 for both, it was a little pricey but totally worth it. If we're back in the area, we'll definitely be making a stop. There are picnic tables around the building but no indoor seating. read more

Twist & Shake - Peanut butter soft serve and dole whip swirl (pineapple and watermelon) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New City, New York

Cash only ice cream shop! They have both hard and soft serve ice cream! We got the soft serve and they had Fourth of July sprinkles which was very nice! I really like the ice cream too! The portion size is large, so come ready for a sugar high. I would return here! read more

See all

I've been coming here for the past 3 years now and all I can say is that this place never disappoints!! From the amazing staff to the ambiance! (I travel all the way from nyc it's a sweet escape!) I LOVE TWIST AND SHAKE! read more

The soft ice cream was terrific. The service was excellent and it has the vibe of a old school family ice cream stand that's been around for decades. read more

Cool little ice cream shop with Italian ices to boot. Will be going back there often. read more

Twist & Shake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New City, New York

LOVE Twist and Shake. We are there all the time. The best ice cream around! Fun atmosphere! We always meet the nicest people while eating our ice cream at the tables on the side. The staff is the best! I left my credit card there and they went above and beyond to locate me and return it! read more

Hands down my favorite spot for ice cream! The staff is amazing and so is the ice cream. Even when the line is long it moves quick! I look forward to opening day every year! read more

I love Ice Cream. They have a great selections of other types of treats besides soft serve. Great service and very nice people work there. It does get very busy on hot summer nights. Plenty of tables with nice background music. Dogs like Ice Cream too so bring them too. Street parking is okay but Main street is busy at times. My go to place for years. YUMMMMMMMM read more

I'm a die hard cold stones fan... for life.... But my mom wanted ice cream, and they were closed. Pros: Cheap ice cream, you get a good amount for what you pay, ice cream tastes normal(no complaints),& they're fast. Cons: I have none. I'm honestly just not a fan of regular ice cream. But if you are, this is a great, quick spot to get your fill. They have quite a variety of soft and hard ice cream, the toppings taste pretty good. I would definitely return for ice cream for the family. read more

See all

Haven't seen an ice cream joint like this in ages! Root beer floats and egg creams transported me back to my childhood. Glad I discovered it. Can hardly wait to try the sundaes and banana boats read more

If you are craving something sweet definitely stop at Twist & Shake for a yummy treat. Both hard ice cream & soft serve. Friendly staff & quick service read more

Twist & Shake - Vanilla & Chocolate Soft Serve with Sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New City, New York

Great hometown vibe with great service! Recommended if in the area! The ice cream is so creamy and delicious! 10/10

Everyone I know loves it here! The best ice cream around. Owned by a super nice husband and wife team. They go above and beyond when serving my kids with food allergies which we always appreciate! Highly recommend read more

The most delicious ice cream, milkshakes, and blizzards, My wife loves their frozen yogurt too. The service with a smile is so refreshing. The husband and wife owners and their staff are always pleasant. I always feel like my business is appreciated there. Which is why we are there so often. read more

This is the ice cream store you remember from your childhood.The ice cream is always fresh ,always with a smile,and always just the way you want it .Served by the nicest people around. read more

There was a long piece of HAIR literally stuck in my icecream. It was so stuck inside it was hard to get out. The icecream tasted very cheap and definitely not worth the money. Never coming again. read more

Love this place! The staff is friendly and they have a good selection of ice cream. We come here a few times a month, I would definitely recommend it! read more

Always the best. John and his family are the nicest in the world and are always there. Best ice cream in the new city area. True old school ice cream parlor. read more

If your in the rockland county area, and just happen to pass by new city stop to this ice cream joint! I'm here very often and I have to get a cone! Pros -any type if size they have is crazy huge because of the portions they serve. Your gonna need a extra cup and napkins cause it will get messy quick (^_^) -they have outdoor seating so you don't have to stay in your car if you don't want to when the weather is sunny sit out side it's nice -they have hard ice cream and soft ice cream with the standard flavors -milkshakes are so smooth and milky you might just die and come back to life Cons - it's cash only no debit or credit Overall come to twist&shake and get yourself a giant cone! read more

Pretty good spot, drive up order and eat some ice cream! brought my cousins here and we just chilled for about an hour and just ate. For the people not accustomed to New City, this is one of the ice cream spots on main street where the local teens meet up. Pros: Ice cream Some seating Nice Local spot Cons: Small Parking watch out where you park ( a lot of mom's and new drivers are here ) definitely would come back tho. read more

Such friendly girls. Very aware of food allergies. Delicious ice cream and good prices.

Expired cookie crunch, watered down chocolate, and bugs everywhere. Yikes. Definitely will not return, despite the convenient location. You're better off going to 16 handles or Dairy Queen read more

Excellent, classic retro-style ice cream drive-up with lots of places to sit down. The very kind server guided me through my options so I could find a great gluten-free choice. The ice cream was fresh, delicious, and not overpriced. Win-win-win, all around excellent. PLUS they're open late! read more

Twist and Shake is super good. The ice cream is so creamy and yummy. Best ice cream in New City. 5/5!

Great ice cream, excellent service. The guys who made our ice cream and froyo (yeah, I wrote froyo) were so nice. Definitely check it out.

The soft serve ice cream here is so good!! There's a large variety of flavors and toppings. You have to park on the main street. Lines can get a little long because it is so popular, but the wait time is short and goes by really quickly. read more

Came here the other night and the kid at the counter was rude. Also the ice cream is really full and poor tasting. They have ice cream you get literally get at shop and stop. Nothing special here and very bland.. read more

Such a great place! Everyone comes here and it's always packed. Serving sizes are awesome and they have loads of options, toppings, and creations. read more

Great soft serve ice cream. Nostalgic feel. Low prices and friendly service. Great place

best ice cream in new city hands down. the flavors are plenty and the combos are endless. also have an ice cream of the month which is typically fantastic and creative. great prices too! read more

Gave this place 4 only because the 5 star goes hands down to King Kone in Pearl River. They dont make classic vanilla and orange twist here and thats disappointing(especially when "Twist" is your name- maybe add it?. My wife and I then ordered egg cremes that we havent had for what seems ever- way back to our "yuths". They were a staple on LI during the 60s and were so good. So I went with my vanilla and my wife got chocolate. They were "ok" not overwhelming or "wow". The parking is atrocious and at times dangerous. Why they have parking spots in front is kind of strange actually when the lines form there and block motorists from parking. In our case it was pure defiance as we were on a long slow line and the people behind us said when a car was looking at us to get in - "ignore em we dont move- let them go away" and we just stood our ground and off they went. A real busy place like KK and obviously good. Its always nice to see young kids acting well and laughing and enjoying their time without any bad manners as was case this night. Perhaps we need to try ice cream next time for a better opinion but 4 stars not bad. read more

Love the ice cream there! Great atmosphere, pleasant owners. An old fashioned stand. Fun place!