Village Pizza is amazing! Not only is the food fantastic! The owner and his wife are so friendly and accommodating! They are my go to for lunch 3 days a week! read more

Village Pizza - Broccoli and White pizza with fresh garlic! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

We had a great time ordering from them. The staff was very helpful, and kept socially distant. The pizza was incredible and so were the wings. The order got to us quicker than anticipated. The prices were fair too. I would definitely recommend to anyone who needs a break from their own home cooking and wants an enjoyable meal. read more

We were past hungry when we found this pizza place. We decided to stop looking for food and just go in, fingers crossed that they had slices everyone would like. There were a bunch of pizzas on the counter to choose from - maybe 5. There was also a stuffed pizza and sliders made on garlic knots. There a sandwich menu on the wall, but really we were here for pizza. In the end, I caved for the stuffed pizza. It was filled with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, broccoli, onions, peppers, tomato, and cheese! It was FULL to the brim. I recommend getting a side of red sauce to dip it in. The others with me ordered: chicken bacon ranch pizza, pepperoni pizza, and broccoli/ricotta pizza. Throw in a meatball slider and we called it a day. There are 6-8 tables inside if you eat in. It's a bit run down looking (inside and out). There's also an ice cream window attached to the building but it wasn't opened for the season at this point. The food hit the spot and was inexpensive. There are probably a lot of pizza places in the area since this is a college town, so I don't know how it compares to the others. read more

See all

Awesome place! Pizza is always so good, staff is friendly, and owners are dedicated to your delight! Been there several times when in the area, and everything has been fantastic. And don't forget the ice cream!! Our first time there, the pizza was cooked PERFECTLY!!!! You know sometimes you get a pizza when the cheese is barely melted and and it seems like the place was just in a hurry to pull your pizza out and put the next one in? Well Village Pizza is NOT that place! Our pizza was piping hot, and had a wonderful roasted look to it. Cheese fully melted (but not scorched), pepperoni was toasted nicely. So, so good! We've also fallen in love with their "stuffed" pizza. The veggie stuffed is our favorite so far. Anyway, what else can I say... EAT!! read more

Village Pizza - Pepperoni pizza and Stuffed Slices with marinara dipping sauce - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

The icecream was amazing. I got the one that had m&m's, cookie dough, etc. SO SO good. read more

Village Pizza - a hand holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

I used to eat here as a college kid. Now I came here with my children to eat ices and the tables outside were absolutely disgusting. Literally looks like they have never been cleaned. See the photo I took... Years of filth. This speaks volumes to me about how this establishment feels about cleanliness and the experience of its patrons. Never again. read more

Village Pizza - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Very disappointed. Waited an hour for the pizza after being told it would be forty minutes. Pizza soggy and undercooked. Meat toppings not even hot. Veggie topics soaked in liquid. Maybe we hit a bad night but as soon as we came home we had to throw the whole pizza away after taking a bite. Worst pizza experience ever. read more

This carnivore LOVES the stuffed veggie pizza! Actually- everything I've had has been delish! The eggplant or meatball sliders, the mozzarella "wedges"- no sticks for this place, even the boring old plain cheese pizza that my hubby eats is great! Thin, but crispy crust- not oily! And- I'm anxiously awaiting the return of soft serve ice-cream. The staff here always has a smile on- and the owners are some of the most community minded people I know! Keep up the great work! #ittakesavillagepizza read more

Pizza ok at best. Cheese and sauce seems low quality. Drive thru is a huge plus for on the run. Outdoor seating is great. Just wish pizza was made with better quality ingredients. Customer service is good. read more

Absolutely the worst sandwich I have ever had! Cheap tasteless ingredients. Slimy American cheese. The bacon was nasty little crumbles. My wife and I were flabbergasted at how bad these sandwiches were.... and way over priced too. I can't even describe anymore how disappointed we were. What a waste of $25! We took a few bites of each sandwich and then threw the rest out. All around terrible! read more

I ordered the vegan pizza and received the gluten-free crust. It was disgusting "Crust" is a misnomer really, because we nearly broke our teeth on it. I phoned to inquire why the crust hadn't risen, and was told defensively "we don't make the vegan crust here." This was puzzling to me since I assumed I was getting the regular crust. Finally the manager said the vegan pizza comes with gluten-free crust because the regular dough has eggs in it. There was no explanation offered as to why I hadn't been told this when I placed the order. I will not be returning. read more

So happy to see that this place has NEW OWNERS that now offer a full VEGAN menu with many GLUTEN FREE options! YES! They also offer so many yummy dipping sauces, which is great, and they even have ice cream, including vegan ice cream! Yum yum yum! When I went in, they just got their permit to sell beer on tap, so that's pretty cool. So happy to see that the new owners are offering a little bit of everything for everyone to enjoy. read more

Village Pizza - Vegan/gluten free menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Best pizza and amazing cheesesteak! Sorry we missed the ice cream window! You will not be sorry!!!

IMO. This place is a joke! Really old pizza, rude and slow service! Not a good place anymore , until they change their attitudes or owners. IMO Save your money and eat somewhere better, plenty of great places near by! GL read more

Mmmmm best cheesesteak in life.. these people Bake their own bread.. even though I live a distance away once in a while I make a special trip to New Paltz for one of their cheesesteaks read more

Food steadily has declined over the years. Used to be out go to piZza place. Customer service it the worst. Rude is more like it. I would travel to NJ before going 10 minutes to this establishment. Don't waste your time read more

Oh Man, Vegan Cheese for the spouse and Tomatillo Sauce, in place of tomato sauce, for me, on a thin crispy crust with eggplant on half and roast garlic and spinach on half. I'm a happy man and the vegan spouse is happy. Total Win Win! read more

Although there are only two other people in place there are two staff. The senior staff member asked Junior to assist us so she could continue making pizzas; he seem to have trouble understanding most everything we were asking. All we wanted was three slices of pizza warmed and 3 sodas to go,as we were in a hurry On our way to a lecture. They did have sliders in the case which looked interesting as they were done on garlic knot and I read and other reviews. Customer behind us requested them so they appear to be popular. It was nice to see that beer was available in an another night I might've had one with my pizza. Unfortunately the pizza was not warm enough for me. But it was tasty. Although it was not an optimal experience, I would give this place another shot. And try the ice cream. They also didn't have a drive-through window which was interesting. read more

Our favorite pizza place in town. Village has kinda an 80s vibe about it. Nothing chic or new about the place but they tick the boxes that matter. Village serves good tap beer along with their tasty pizza. They have both patio and booth seating. Plus a couple of cool retro pinball and video games to amuse the kids (and parents) while we wait. Fun to come with the dog in the summer and eat outside. Friendly, if occasionally befuddled, staff make a great pizza, calzone, hero etc. Rarely crowded, I hesitated to write this review lest we have to fight for a table sometime....but I think I'll chance it. read more

Great pizza and friendly service! Lots of new menu items including really good and BIG sandwiches! I highly recommend the chicken cheesesteak. Honestly the best cheesesteak I have ever had. The best pizza in the area (and I'm from Long Island originally). Nice retro feel in the restaurant with ms Pac-Man and 2 pinball machines read more

I've only just tried this place recently but have ordered to-go twice and delivery once. I honestly can't explain how good this pizza is and every employee I've talked to is very nice. When I ordered delivery the other night the food came in about the time or less that they said and was still very hot and fresh which I'm so thankful for. Our delivery guy was also really very nice and helpful and even came back to say thank you for the tip. Great service and great food, thank you Village Pizza! read more

Good pizza. Especially after a ball game and then you get ice cream too?!?!?!?! You're stomach and bowel system will hate you afterwards but you only live once so go for it you animals. read more

Pizza was great. The staff was friendly. Plenty of sitting and some outside. The crust was nice and crunchy and i love that. Flavorful.

This place is under new ownership since earlier this year (2019) so if you haven't tried it lately, give it a try. They are making improvements, including more menu items and now beer on tap, as well as bottled and canned beer and wine. A group of us stopped by on a recent Friday and ordered some food. I had a specialty slice loaded with spinach, and it was very good. Others in our party had a stuffed pizza (top and bottom crusts) which came with a container of pizza sauce to dip into, and they liked it a lot. The crust on the pizza is just right, with enough firmness to fold and stay straight as you hold it. Good quality cheese, and the sauce is delicious too. We had some ice cream for dessert and I enjoyed my Panda Paws cone (vanilla ice cream with peanut butter chocolate cups) and one of us also had the cappucino ice cream which was a group favorite. All in all, a very casual and comfortable place where you can get good quality and very reasonably priced food, ice cream and drinks. Eat inside or outside, and there is even drive-thru for pickup! Gotta love that. read more

Village Pizza - Comfortable and friendly place to have some pizza, sandwiches, drinks, and ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Paltz, New York

Rodney was super helpful. His pizza is great and he knows how to treat his customers!

Used to like going to village for ice cream after our kids' ball games. Yesterday, 5/2/19, our ice cream experience was unsatisfactory. Cone sizes are not standard, using small, regular, medium, large. Small is more aptly named a kiddie size or baby size. The ice cream tasted and felt texturally like what you might find at a Chinese buffet or college dining hall - super cold and grainy. Chocolate sprinkles tasted stale. Service was slow and inefficient. Village Pizza has a corner on the soft serve market but would do better if it improved quality of soft serve. We won't go back for ice cream. We miss Dressel's! read more

The pizza is DELICIOUS! I went there last week for a make your own pizza party - it was so fun and such a great idea- they showed us how to make it and provided us all the supplies and toppings and it came out perfect! The sliders and garlic knots are also delicious- I love that the garlic knots came marinara dipping sauce . I will definitely be back- I'm from New York City so I know good pizza is hard to find when u leave the boroughs but at village pizza I felt right at home. The people who work there and the owner Renee is a doll. It's a city pizza taste with a small town friendly feel. read more

Came to visit a good friend of mine from Brooklyn,Ny and I have to say the best pizza I've had around these neck of the woods! My favorite was their pizza and chicken cheesesteak's Yummmmmmm! Can't wait to hit this place up when I come back :) read more

Great pizza, sliders, and chicken cheese steak! The crust is very fresh. Cute space, loved coming here! Very friendly staff as well.

Came here while visiting a friend . Being from nyc I am very picky with my pizza and this place does not disappoint . I found the staff very friendly and I left stuffed and happy ! read more

The Pizza here is pretty good. it's right off the rail trail so I usually come through for a slice after taking a long walk/run. The staff are always doing a good job keeping the place clean and making good NY pie. They also have an Ice cream stand which you can easily get stuff from during the summer. I gotta say getting a nice stuffed slice of pizza and then getting a cone of ice cream will hit the spot for anyone. read more

Came here to get a slice with my sons after a Goshen farmers market, place was well decorated and the pizza was amazing. I've been to NYC and this was right up there with the best. Local Goshen-ite and I've found my new pizza place. read more

One of the best pizza places in New Paltz. True New York slices, and a big variety of other foods to choose from. They also have a built in ice cream stand for the summer! read more

Garbage. One star is generous. Literally any other place in town is a better idea than the overpriced quarter scoop of ice cream they serve here. The girl behind the counter said "yeah, we get that a lot". Sums it up pretty nicely... read more

The definition of mediocre. Had the chicken roll-bland flavorless greasy and just boring. The sauce same review. Just blah. Had a "regular " sized cone-I detest not having standard sizing. What is wrong with small medium and large! The vanilla was awful. Again tasteless and grainy texture. Almost 4 dollars and it was hollow inside the twist. Chocolate sprinkles also flavorless. The place is dirty. There is a birds nest above the ice cream window. And dead worms in the counter. One and only chance given. Won't be back. read more

I totally disagree with the reviews of this place. We have tried about 20 other pizzerias in the area, most of which are overrated and overpriced and village pizza is still our favorite pizza. I grew up on great pizza from Philadelphia and NYC and this place has that solid, no frills great cheese pizza. Also, the cheesesteaks are great! They make their own bread and it's best cheesesteak I've had in the area and again, I'm from the Philly area. I recommend giving this place a chance for just solid good pizza and cheesesteaks. Also they have a drive thru! Bonus! read more

Friends who live in the area order from this place a lot and enjoy it so we ordered together recently. I ordered a roast beef and fresh mozzarella hero - but they had no fresh mozzarella - huh? Ok so I had to settle for sliced mozzarella - but it they used shredded mozzarella - like the kind they would put on a pizza. The roast beef was of good quality but it wasn't as rare as I like it to be. The "bread" was pizza dough shaped into a hero roll and then baked - the taste was strange. We shared an order of wings - did not like the sauce at all - and we shared a pizza - the cheese slid right off the pie which meant it wasn't cooked all the way - and the sauce was very bland. If I do order from them again, I might try a calzone or stromboli and see if these are any better, but otherwise I would not order from them again. read more

Just ordered 3 pies, regular, meatball, & mushrooms plus 24 wings for the Giant play off game. No specials, the pizza is mediocre, the wings are the tiniest I've ever seen, no celery, no carrots. They insist they use small wings to keep the prices down, $14 for 24 isn't the best deal I've heard of. $55 for blah. read more

This is a pretty standard pizzeria. Not bad at all, not amazing though. The italian ices are great in the summer, otherwise I'd usually hit up other spots in town before I'd go to Village. This establishment does have one attribute that sets it apart from every other pizza place.....possibly in the world: A DRIVE THRU. Thats right folks, drive thru pizza. See it to believe it. read more

$4 pitchers for happy hour! Little known deal but it was always there when I needed it.