The wife and I were staying at the Seacliff on the bluff, The front desk recommend it we had ordered over the phone for take out but we arrived and asked if we could eat in they all obliged. Everyone at pizzeria was very nice and friendly the pizza was average. I would eat here again read more

Delicious pizza, wings, calzone and salad. A must when in Gualala. Reasonable prices, good menu.

Awesome town & great pizza! We loved the outdoor seating with our dogs. We'll definitely come back next time we're in town. Thank you!!

this was good pizza. generally, i dislike pizza. It's a lot of dough, not much flavor, just mediocre. This place was the exception. hot, good and tasty. only thing that could make it better is if they delivered read more

My husband and I try to visit Gualala once a year and we look forward to eating at the Upper Crust Pizzeria. Unfortunately, we have to wait until 4 pm when they open, but it's worth the wait. The crust is excellent, sauce tasty. The staff are always local and very friendly. We are planning our annual trip to Breaker's Inn in a few weeks and are looking forward to a great Pizza! The only downside is they do not serve beer! read more

We had a horrific experience at Shoreline restaurant and didnt finish any of our dinner there. Walked over to the pizza shop and life became good again. Friendly people working there willing to chat it up with us, Giants game on TV. Pizza was really good. read more

Pizza was ok but not awesome they hand toss it which is cool but overall the woman begin the counter was kind the man wasn't to friendly and just a par or a little mediocre meal read more

Great customer service and pizza. The woman working the orders was buzzing around taking care of everyone and doing a thorough job. We would definitely come back if we are in the area again. read more

Fantastic pizza! Never had pizza without sauce, got a mendicino, no complaints. Really tasty crust too.

Came to Gualala for a weekend getaway and since there are not a lot of restaurant options we decided to try Upper Crust. It did not disappoint. We ordered a house salad and a small combo pizza. Both were very good. The salad was fresh and had a lot of yummy toppings. The pizza crust and sauce were delicious. We had a few pieces left over that were just as good the next morning :) read more

This is a great little place. Enjoyed a high quality pizza (chicken pesto) and a salad made with very fresh vegetables. Friendly service from three young ladies who seemed happy to be there. Try it, you can't miss with this one. read more

We stayed in Point Arena and took a drive to close by Gualla Excellent pizza, crisp crust! Very friendly staff helpful too!

Had a chicken pesto pie and it was awesome! Great pizza, great crust. Definitely a great place to stop for a bite on the coast.

Yummy pizza. We have ate here twice since we've been in town, and will probably go another, before we leave.

Surprisingly good! Crust was decently good. The Pesto chicken that we ordered was better then expected. (definitely better then the Round Table, Domino of the world...) read more

A tiny little place right on the highway with really good pizza and funny, pleasant staff (at least when we went there this weekend). I wasn't expecting anything much -- I was hungry and just wanted pizza, any pizza -- but the complicated order we put in over the counter was done perfectly, and the results were well-cooked and delicious. The only reason they lose a star is that the pace is too small and uncomfortable for sitting around in -- it's definitely more of a take-away / to go type of place in my opinion. read more

If you like thin crust - Round Table style pizza, this is the place for you in Gualala. Not as fancy, not as pretty. It is a small town restaurant in a small town, don't expect too much. Pizza was good, price was fair. So amongst it's peers, its a 4-star. read more

Hard to say what was better; the pizza or the witty banter of owners and locals - both made for a very nice dinner. I was staying at the Breakers Inn right across the way and it's nice to stroll over for a bite. Four stare may be generous based on the pizza alone, but the whole experience is fun. read more

What a pleasant surprise to find such great pizza on the North Coast. Very friendly staff. We stayed at the Breakers Inn across the street and had dinner twice from here. One night pizza and the other night a calazone. I spend a lot of time on the road so it's always great to have good takeout that you can take back to the room. So next time you are in the area, get a pizza, head back to the motel, open and drink wine, enjoy the view and chill. read more

Seems like a mom and pop type place. Very friendly and very good pizza. Highly recommended!

This place is the best..the good is always fresh & all the pizzas are good here..Try the buffalo wings those are the best I have ever had...the calzones are to die for not all soggie and toasted just right... read more

Really good pizza & staff were awesome. The Caesar Salad was great as well as the pizza.

Delicious and not greasy! Small menu. Quick service. Extremely tasty, but so tasty I ate too much. Lol I would definitely go back!

Gualala, at this posting, (2-24-2017) has limited eatery's and this place is BUSY! not just because the town is limited.... But it is the best pizza on the northern CA coast. It gets a tad busy, but it's worth the wait. read more

Make sure you check your order before you leave..got home Friday night only to get the wrong pizza. No biggie right. Called and told them, they acknowledged that it was wrong,and was told to come again and they will give us a free pizza Sounds great right? Saw the owner in the grocery store on Sunday only to get verbally attacked because I was a liar and if I needed a free pizza that bad then come and get it. First off I don't need a "free" pizza I have plenty of money. I WILL NOT EVER spend my money in this place EVER AGAIN. REMEMBER ROB the locals are the ones who keep you in business... read more

Simply the best pizza. Our habit is to walk in and order, then go next door to the Gualala Hotel bar for a glass of wine while our pie cooks. Then take it home and enjoy. I usually order more than enough so I can have it cold for lunch the next day. read more

This place has great pizza and an array of toppings from which to choose. I would recommend calling ahead to order, as the wait times can be long. The crust and sauce were delicious! read more

Great Pizza, good atmosphere and the staff are very friendly. I'll be going back before the week is over, and on my list for future visits for the area. read more

Wonderful pizza! Yum! We got the Mediterranean & it was very flavorful! Staying in Gualala for the weekend we might just go back again tomorrow. Fast service was a plus! read more

Pizza was OK and certainly quick, but nothing to write home about. Restaurant is very small with only 4 or 5 tables, so it fills up quickly - I think most of their business must be take-out. read more

Love this place. Kids beg for it nightly when we are up in sea ranch. Reasonable prices too and the nicest people working here!

Really sad I had to give this place such a bad review considering it's ranked highest out of the whole town, and my family and I were very excited to try this place because we hadn't ate a good dinner the whole week. This place definitely did NOT live up to our expectations. We pulled into the parking lot at 8:36. The place claimed they did not close until 9, but as soon as we walked into the pizzeria, we did not feel welcomed at all. We walked up to the counter and asked to order two medium pizzas, one pepperoni and one cheese. The lady said," this is the last customer of the night." The girl I ordered with said, "well why don't you order a large half and half?" I explained that I wanted a medium cheese and a medium pepperoni, not a large pizza. The girl replied "Fine." and kind of rolled her eyes and huffed. When it was time to pay, I stuck my card into the machine and she said, "Great, you waited too long and it timed out." After my son and I paid, the girl told us it would be 10-15 minutes until it was done. We said okay. She stood and looked at us and said "well it will be 10-15 minutes if you guys will come back." I don't understand why we were treated this way considering we were paying customers and they said they didn't close until 9. All in all, average pizza, terrible customer service, and extremely disappointing. Will not be back. You are better off just cooking your meals while staying in the Sea Ranch/ Gualala area. read more

Great pizza, ordered a medium Mendocino for 2 of us. We are stuffed and we had 2 slices to bring home. Service was friendly and there was hardly any wait time. Beer on tap too. Only bummer is they were out of salad but the pizza made up for that! Definitely coming back! read more

Great Pizza. The girls who work there are really nice and helpful.

By far some of the best pizza in Nor. Cal. The place was clean and the staff were friendly. Will be enjoying many more pies in the future.

Best pizza ever. If you know it's gunna be a busy week/weekend call ahead, way ahead. Never know how many people are coming in so make sure you're prepared. The wait could range from 15 minutes to 2 hours. read more

Decent pizza; grumpy service. We ordered a couple of pizzas (one pepperoni; one veggie pesto) a couple of nights ago while on vacation (in person). We were told at around 5:40p that we'd only get our pizzas at 7:40p. Seems like there's something (i.e., equipment) missing here...two hours is a very long time to wait! In any event, the team was kind enough to prioritize our order and we got our pizzas right then. Quite tasty. Note that the side salads here are kind of wimpy and aren't worth your time based on looks. read more

The pizza is really good. The crust I think is homemade. The service.... not so good. I mean, not to knock all of the girls who work there because that's just not fair or true but the girl on the register when we visited was mediocre. She wasn't friendly and didn't seem to know or even care about her job or treatment of customers. So, go for the pizza only but don't expect much in terms of customer service and you'll be okay. read more

Pizza was great, with a view. Came in 20 minutes before they were closing.. Let's face it, everything in this town closes at 8 it seems like... The girls had absolutely no problem serving us and insisted we should eat in instead of take out. Overall great in all aspects and tasted delish. Go read more

best pizza and service! my husband and i went up to gualala for a weekend trip. we stayed at the breakers and noticed the pizza place across the street. since it was a rainy day, a hot pizza sounded glorious. we chatted with the staff and drank a few beers while waiting. everyone was super friendly and gave us tips stuff to do on our weekend trip. when the pizza came it was absolutely delicious! the best part was the sour dough crust, omg yum! we liked it so much that we decided to go back our second night in town! but we were out having cocktails for so long we lost track of time and by the time we walked to upper crust the lights were out and the doors were locked. we were so bummed out! but the owner came walking across the street, remembered us from the night before and offered to re-open just for us! i mean that just doesn't happen in the city! we felt like regulars after just one night! and the second night's pizza was just as delicious as the first! while waiting for the pizza the second night we were chatting with the owner about his amazing sour dough crusts. he offered for us to come back the next morning before we left town and he would give us some dough to take home! we left that night with our pizza raving about how nice people are in the town, and especially at upper crust! the next morning we wondered if the owner would remember that he offered us the dough, so we did a slow drive by and there he was waving us in! he spent over a half hour constructing a make-shift cooler out of a box and bags of ice for us to transport the dough back to the city with us. i mean, he took so much freaking time and effort to do this for us! we were totally blown away! we made pizza (yes for the third night in a row) the night we got home and it was totally delicious using his sour dough. but, man, not as delicious as it was up there. we decided that we are going to make gualala a yearly trip. stay at the breakers inn and then pizza every night! all in all, this is our favorite pizza place ever. even more than all the choices we have in san francisco. hands down. best place ever. read more