Pretty good pizza Nothing unusual but I think the crust was made In shop with a good consistency and the sauce had a good flavor. I'd go back if in the area and wanting pizza. read more

My wife and I spent a few days in Gualala recently and went to this place hoping for a good pizza after reading some of the reviews. We got there at 7 pm but we're rudely told "if you didn't call ahead and order a pizza for pick up then, sorry we're done for the night. Keep in mind their posted open hours were from 4 - 8 pm. We just kind of looked at the guy and he just stared back. Wow! Really!?! We're just done for the night, an hour before they were supposed to close! Ok then. So I can't comment on the pizza because we didn't have any! If you're in Gualala try Bones Roadhouse. Very good food, friendly staff. read more

Well under new ownership it started out great. However with the shortage of GOOD competent workers the service levels and quality soon went down. Does greed show sooner or later in tourist season? Raising prices and lowering of service levels and quality of pizza dooms local businesses. It could improve as tourist season ends? read more

Best pizza place nearby! Ever since it went under new ownership, the place has really improved. It's been fixed up with new flooring, TVs, and tables. More beverage choices than there was with the previous owner. The people here are friendly. read more

Husband and I were craving good pizza for days after reading all of the awesome reviews for this place...showed up at 7pm on a Thursday night, waited 10 min to get to the counter to order, and the gal said "we ran out of dough." How do you run out of dough, on a Thursday, during peak traveling season?! Crazy. So we never tried it. Be sure and get there early or call ahead, there's not many options to eat around here. read more

Sorry, but I don't get why all the good reviews. Maybe it was just an off night but our pizza (sausage, shrooms and onions) was very bland and the crust was like cardboard. I was expecting too much maybe? read more

Excellent pizza, friendly service. A favorite pitstop for us. Spot is small. They may want to make sure individual locals do not take up the large table in front of the TV for a seating of one when families of 4 -6 enter and have no place to sit themselves. read more

Yum! I only eat pizza once or twice a year when on road trips. This place was totally worth it !

After seeing great reviews on Yelp, we decided to have lunch at Upper Crust. It was fabulous. The new owner was very friendly so we enjoyed our visit. We have been visiting Gualala for many years and this place has dramatically improved with new ownership. read more

Good, but not great; way too expensive. Picture Round Table pizza and 10% more costly. For $40+, we got one large pizza, two small (and stale) side salads..... We may get the pizza again, but only for lack of other options. read more

Pizza. Its whats for dinner. What a nice surprise, to have excellent pizza away from home. We had the Mediterranean, delicious. I wanted to have it again for breakfast lunch and dinner. : ) Wished we had time to try all offerings. The staff was efficient and pleasant read more

Unexpected gem on the Sonoma Coast. The gluten-free pizza was crisp and brown and indistinguishable from a gluten bomb, and the calzone (alas, not gluten-free) with tomato, mushroom, and sausage was superbly crisp. read more

Just as it was two years ago, these guys do a very good job delivering a good pizza at a fair price. No junk here. Very busy but worth the wait. read more

Very solid pizza place. This is located in a touristy area so it's hard to know where the solid places to eat are. I'm glad we found this pizza place; a wide variety of toppings and quick service. read more

Absolutely delicious!!! Pizza comes across as Round Table style, not soggy, lots of flavor, hand tossed dough--just an excellent pizza for an excellent price! Great service, very friendly staff--A definite must when traveling thru Gualala! read more

To preface, I am not a pizza lover. Like it, but doesn't come in the top 20 for last prison meal selections. Rock the house. I can't find pizza this good in most cities for those around me who have the pizza love going on. Seriously impressed. Place was packed. Wish had taken pics but we'll be back. Had ordered before and was just as good so should have reviewed then. Ordered three zas. One was pepperoni, jalapeños, pineapple, onions, and peppers. Others were veggie which had artichoke and other veg, and small cheese and bacon for the kid who is quite picky but ate it for the next few meals until gone. Crust was not overpowering or thick and doughy and all the ingredients were a perfect combination of oohhh and ahhh. Had me reconsidering my lack of love for pizza. If you aren't up for cooking and want some of the best pizza ever, do it. We are still talking about how spectacular this place is. If you're renting a house in the area, are a permanent fixture, or just passing through, stop off and get your pizza groove on. We ordered takeaway so cannot review service, but some family members have enjoyed nice cold bevies while waiting for the order. read more

DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!!!! BEST PIZZA FOR MILES! Staff was super nice- love the new owners!

THINK some of these 5-star reviews are overblown. It is highly mediocre pizza, in our estimation. Good, not great! Essentials, crust & sauce are fine, and they have excellent fine-tuning - like a checklist for Extra sauce, Light on the cheese. EVERY pizza place should adopt that feature. We got EXACTLY what we ordered, which sets it a cut above many... Unlikely that we'll go back AND if we have to have a pizza in Gualala, it may be the way to go. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff. Went here twice on a recent short stay in Gualala. Got the Western pizza each time, how can you pass up cashews on a bbq pizza? Recommend giving it a try at least once. I recommend getting your food to go as there isn't much room inside. Helpful tip: talked to the owner, and he said if the flag is outside in the front he's open for business regardless of what the hours may say here or on their website. read more

Wow! Great crust and pesto sauce is legit! For our last night in Sea Ranch, we wanted an easy dinner. We ordered the Margareta but substituted pesto for red sauce, so good! Pepperoni and mushroom was also good. And, friendly staff!! read more

Upper Crust Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Gualala, California

Great Pizza! It gets busy, so plan for at least a 45min to hour wait. We called ahead for pick up and it worked out perfectly. Definitely give Upper Crust a try! read more

Great pizzia with new ownership. Been coming to Gualala for over 10 years.... this is the best ever. Change is good!

One of the best Pizza's I've ever had. Location is small and you might have to wait. That's because the ingredients are so fresh and made to order. Lots of topping options. Good beer on tap while you wait. We ordered or pizza and salads to go. The salads were crisp and full of nice mix of vegies. Meat Lover was just the right ratio of meat and mushrooms. Margarita with basil was excellent! I would go back tomorrow if it wasn't 4 hours from my house. Hit this spot on vacation and will make it a point to go back. We were on vacation when we discovered this little gem. So good, my kids at it cold for breakfast the next morning. Always a good measure of a great pizza. read more

Since new people took over its horrible my son ordered 2 large pizza took over an hour to get then when he got them home it was the wrong order worst pizza ive ever had won't go there again read more

The main business seems take-away but there are some tables to eat onsite, inside or outside. We seated outside in a nicely windy and sunny evening. We had two pizzas (one Mediterranean and one Blue Cheese Chicken) and two draft Sierras. Pizzas were very tasty and perfectly cooked. Nice welcoming staff. Fair prices. Highly recommended. read more

On a holiday weekend and with the other pizza place in town closed, the owner and his team of three did an amazing job at balancing a crush of customers both in-store and on the phone without sacrificing a bit of service or quality in their pizza. As a restaurant owner, I was duly impressed by their ability to do a great job. read more

Great pizza in a beautiful, relaxing area. Great service, very friendly. Owner was very accommodating after my husband left his sunglasses there, a rarity these days!! Will be back next time we are in town! read more

Got pizza after a subpar dinner. Nice folks. The pizza was very tasty. Not thin crust but well worth it.

Great pizza and great people. The pizza is made with a fresh crust on site. Place is small with one oven but worth the wait! Staff very friendly and accommodating. read more

We ordered a small Mediterranean and a small pepperoni. Both very good. Sauce is yummy and pepperoni had a lil bite to it which was really good. Good ranch. read more

Very impressed with the pizza here....crust was good and tasted better than I had thought. This is a little hole in the wall that looks very popular for takeout as quite a few people came in to pick up orders. read more

Dude, this place is great. Surprisingly delicious pizza. I wasn't expecting much considering it is one of the few restaurants in Gualala, but it is bomb! Their salads aren't that great, but their pizza more than makes up for that. Do it! read more

So nice to know there's a good pizza place around when we travel to Sea Ranch. My family likes the pizza and we enjoy supporting the local businesses. read more

Had the margarita pizza here. Not bad at all, but nothing particularly wow. I'd give it a 3.5 stars. The service was good though! Perhaps the margarita isn't the star of their menu according to other reviews which felt the pizza was outstanding. read more

Stopped by this place with the kids and the pizza was great! A much better experience two years later. The thin crust was perfect. They have salads to go. Remarkably quick for a busy summer Saturday night too. read more

I've even convinced my husband that this is a great place to eat at Gualala and he's not a pizza fan (health nut!). While good dining options are limited in Gualala and therefore, we cook-in a lot, I can honestly say this is one place we eat at when we're up there. The pizza is thin-crust (the way they should be, in my opinion!) and just chewy enough. The owner is so friendly! I can't recommend this place enough! read more

Oh my dear lord, they make a tasty pie.....well worth the stop, if you're having a hankering for pizza.

Middle of the road pizza. Nothing special as far as the pizza. The staff was SUPER friendly. We had a party of 6 with 2 small kids. There was no place to sit comfortably with a party of six unless you sit outside on picnic benches. It's definitely better pizza than the other place in town. I would say it's better for take out or just couples dining. read more

Great pizza! Lots of local charm, friendly service, and the house combo was so tasty! Definitely coming back here again when in town :)

Super delicious and it's so very right when it's cheesy and hot and you've just spent the day hiking around the beaches in chilly weather. It's like a hug on the inside ;) read more