The service and the food was great. We ordered a couple pizza and the battered fries. We also tried the fresh turnovers which were a bit hit. Great stop near Lake Findley for fresh pizza. read more

Vinnies Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Findley Lake, New York

Vinnie's is incredible! The service was extremely friendly and our waitress was amazing and caring despite being short staffed. Definitely recommend getting their pizza and wings. The sauce on their spicy oriental wings is super tasty, and we really enjoyed the nightmare pizza. They definitely don't short on the toppings! The food was hot and tasted fresh. With their fair prices, amazing food, and extremely kind staff Vinnie's is definitely the place to try out. We look forward to coming back! read more

This was a terrible experience. 1. Timing of food delivery to table was the worst. My friends dinner came out first. Then 10 min later my salad. And after about 35 min they brought out my mini pizza. 2. When I lifted the first slice of pizza to eat a bug crawled out of it. I dropped the piece showed the bug to the person who brought it and told her to just take it away and remove from our bill. They offered to make another and I said no thanks no desire to eat after seeing the bug. 3. Waited for bill for another 10 minutes. When we went to bar to pay bill in hand was $19.44. They ran the credit card and charged $36. I was trying to explain that they charged us the wrong amount and asked for them to refund the wrong amount and charge the correct amount. Some lady who must have been a friend or something of the restaurant came up behind me and started yelling at us. I asked her to back away from me and stay out of the conversation because it was none of her business. She kept getting closer and closer to me. 4. When we finally got them to correct the overcharge and were leaving some obviously intoxicated guy followed us out to our car waving his hands and threatening us. If you like each person at your table eating at different times,bugs in your food, being charged for someone else's bill and then being threatened and intimidated by patrons then this is the place for you. If you want good food,service and a safe atmosphere I DO NOT Recommend Vinnies. read more

Pork lumpia was so good, I almost ate them both. The sauce and veggies are perfect. Golden parmigian with a little mild hot sauce Was the wing flavor we got and they are a hit!! Very tasty! Cuban sub was toasted just right and filling, brought half home. The buffalo cheese wontons are really good too. We totally recommend this mom and pop restaurant that has something for everyone on the menu. The service is fast and so nice. Looking forward to going back for sure. read more

If you're in town definitely check out this little spot! It doesn't look like much but the food is phenomenal and the service is equally amazing. The owner cooks herself and even came out to chat with us. read more

Buffalo chicken wing pizza is to die for if I'm not mistaken I'm pretty sure it's why china wants our country

Pizza was really good but pricey. Maybe because of it was the only one around and they sort of have a captive clientele sort of thing. Friendly staff and accurate times to when things would be ready. read more

I've been coming to Vinnie's for 4 years now and it's the best restaurant around they have amazing authentic pizza. authentic chinese food is very good. Also mexican food, where else can you get all three of those in a sit down restaurant. they also have a bar like a store set up it's just very down to earth foods amazing and people are better. Breakfast Lunch and Dinner are gas! read more

Anything you need they probably have it. A book, a watch, a purse, Kimchee, hot cuttlefish, coconut candy, ice cream, furry slippers? Oh the food...yes...great pizza, good Chinese, and wings. If you're ordering, and they tell you a time, add 30 minutes....other than that great local place close to the slopes! read more

If I could give negative stars I would. I ordered 2 pizzas at 6:15 and by 9:00 they still never showed up. I called 3 different times to check on them. The first time I called they just yelled that it was on its way without even asking who I was and hung up on me. The next time at about 2 hours in, they said it was just going in the oven. After almost 3 hours, I called again and they said I had to come get the pizza, they weren't delivering it. They had decided that without informing me of that. Weird, right? Who does that? Long story short: don't get delivery here. We ended up making grocery store oven pizzas. read more

Ugh... We were on a weekend ski trip and the resort recommended this place as having the "best" pizzq around. I should have known better coming from a place that is known for good pizza and wings.... So we ordered a large pizza with just cheese, pepperoni and onion. Well We expected it to take a while because we had read reviews of the delivery taking a while. But, believe it or not they came within an hour They delivered the pie and when we opened it we were disappointed to see raw onion om top of the cooked pie. There was barely sauce, barely cheese and the crust was so thin you could probably see through it. The ONLY highlight was the very pleasant delivery man. read more

Wish this place was better. Nice people, nice looking place and would be convenient for us. However, doesn't seem they take a lot of pride in their craft. Pizza is bland and crust is always too soft. They need to turn the ovens up. Add some seasoning to the sauce. Salt? Herbs? Or straight out if a can? If it was better food I'd use them twice a week. read more

I'm from NYC and was hoping to have some great pizza while visiting the area but this didn't do it. The pizza was not fully cooked and too doughy read more

I would really give it 2, but you were so open minded and asked about my Google review so I'm going a notch up for attitude :) Google doesn't allow a reply so I'm putting it here. I didn't like the pizza; I thought the crust and sauce were wrong. The pepperoni ball wasn't bad but the sauce didn't taste very good. I wondered about the Filipino food and was interested to try it. I asked the guy working of all the things on the menu what was the most authentic and he said 'it's all pretty awesome'. So I went with pizza. I probably should have gotten Filipino food. I will do that next time because you were so nice in your reply. But I do not want styrofoam: It's bad for the environment. If some very casual restaurants in the area are using paper boxes instead of styrofoam, you can as well! I'll see you next time around...though I hope for a paper box when I do! Cr Oh--I bought a box of jasmine tea--it was amazing :D read more

We got the bacon chicken ranch pizza and some mozzarella sticks. They were both amazing and we would eat here again. It was perfect because it was right on our way home from evening ski time at peak n peak. Talked with the owner and said he has fresh deliveries daily and has the best prices in town. It's where everyone who lives there eats read more

Vinnies Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Findley Lake, New York

I would like to start out by saying the food we got was pretty good. But it took 2 hours to get it. Well the soup I ordered came in about a hour. It tasted pretty good but it was only half full. I wanted to say something but I saw how poorly they treated another person that had issues with his meal. I was with a small group of people and I didn't want there meals to get ruined and told to leave. The one waitress was a little nice. She came over and apologized for the wait and explained the kitchen was short staffed. But the funny part was from where I was sitting I could seen the kitchen and they had 3 people. Three people that spent more time talking than anything else. If it wasn't for some of the treatment I witnessed of the other costumers, the half boul of soup, the extremely long wait times I would be back. read more

Food isn't bad but the wait time sometimes is ridiculous. If you need a quick dinner this isn't the place. But the pizza is great. Sometimes worth the wait. read more

Nice place , exceptionally clean and they're very accommodating when you come in doesn't matter what you order it all taste great. It's really great because they let you park snowmobile trailers so you can ride all day and then pull in there and eat dinner before you go home. I highly recommend it read more

Great burger, friendly atmosphere. Found this place late after arriving at my place . Even gave a discount for paying with cash.

Honestly, I can't begin to fathom how this restaurant is still open. In the last two years I can count on one hand the number of times my orders have been finished correctly and in a timely manner. In many instances, my husband has just sat down at the bar for a beer, or three, while waiting for the food to finish, or start, cooking (after already waiting 35 minutes, an hour, or even longer at home). They clearly have a poorly designed system and skip the step that tells the kitchen there is an order to be cooked. But the thing is, I have never ONCE heard them apologize. One time when my sister was hugely shorted on her order, the wife of the owner screamed in her face, claiming she didn't know there was more than just a pizza on the order, while the owner ran his mouth loudly about his political views at the bar. I witnessed another local woman who complained on Facebook about terrible service and having to wait hours for the food she ordered before taking it home to feed her family, and they publicly berated her instead of just APOLOGIZING for their mistake. Most recently, two of my friends sat in front of me and called in an order for their dinner. They were told it would be 35 minutes before they could pick it up. I live about five minutes from the restaurant, and knowing the food usually takes longer than they say, they decided to wait the full 35 minutes before leaving to pick up their meal. Upon arrival, the bartender (the same one they placed the order with over the phone) stated that they had never placed an order and it would be at least another 25 minutes before their was food cooked. They were then, for the first time ever, offered a 20% discount on a *future* order because of this order that was allegedly never placed. They left, hungry and upset. As someone who has worked in the restaurant industry for many years, customers should never be treated as they are at Vinnie's. Do yourself a favor and drive the extra few miles to one of the many other places in the area that sells pizza to get good food on time and with a smile. read more

So if you're in Findley Lake, NY at the Holiday Inn off of I-86, it occurs to you that the hotel is pretty much the only thing immediately off this exit. I checked with the front desk to see if a pizza place delivered, and they gave me a menu for Vinnie's. The pizza wasn't that bad, the crust is huge and fluffy. It sorta reminded us of school lunch pizza, and I think that says what you need to know. Since they were out of mozzarella sticks (really? at a pizza joint?), we tried the cheesy bread sticks, which was just pizza dough with some oil and cheese and a side of marinara - perhaps better than the pizza. read more

If you find yourself In the small lil teeny tiny town of Findley Lake, New York you are more likely to see a bear than you are a traffic light. I am serious. So, the fact that a pizza, sub, salad and more place even exists in this area is amazing. "I wouldn't call this a restaurant, but you can take the family inside and put food in their bellies or drive there and take out" They can take your order on a late cold winter night when NO ONE ELSE IS OPEN! For me the food has always been good and was made quickly. I am a local and typically order pizza. I drive 10 mins to get there. There are some bars closer for me but Vinnies's pizza is way better. I have never had a bad pizza from them and I consider Vinnie's to be one of my favorites for pizza. Fresh dough, fresh ingredients, not greasy. Simple food and they are probably open right now. Are you from outa town and you are hungry? They are a very small and very BUSY Pizza place. You are FAR AWAY from civilization and they may be your only choice, seriously. Tired? Family on your case? Kids are hungry? Get YOUR BUTT into a car and PICK UP THE FOOD YOURSELF! This place exists in the snow belt and it could be snowing for all their deliveries but not at your hotel. Don't drive to fast in the dark and watch out for deer and bear. read more

The pepperoni pizza is not bad. Very cheap price, but is good for being the only pizza place for miles. Have a huge menu, so you dont have to have just pizza. read more

Vinnie's Pizza is our favorite. I especially like the sweeter sauce. The fresh dough is just right. Not too thick that so you can taste the ingredients. read more

I cannot rate the food because we have yet to receive our order and it has been over an hour, but the service so far is terrible, only one person working, we ordered pizza and was there over 30 minutes when we asked how much longer, the kid working went to ask and I over heard the lady in the back very rudely stating "I have other stuff to do", he came back out and stated it will be atleast another 45 minutes, He repeated what the lady in the back said about having other stuff to do and take out orders ahead of us, I would not recommend this place based on service, they really need to hire more help read more

This has got to be the most ridiculous excuse for a restaurant. It's part thrift store, part bar, part restaurant. The pizza doesn't even taste like pizza, and they stretch the dough thin to save money. Their mixed drinks are way overpriced. If you order and they forget about your order, they'll tell you that you called back to cancel. The wait time for food is also unacceptable. They treat their employees like absolute shit, and talk to each other horribly in front of other customers. Do yourself a favor and don't even order a stick of gum here. Go to nearby North East which has a variety of pizza places to choose from. Fail. If I could, I would leave a negative star. read more

If the owners arent working you might as well go somewhere else, food is delicious but the help is lazy

Waited for our food for over 1 hour and 30 minutes. We are all starving. We called twice to find out where our food is, first time was told the food is just now leaving the kitchen (50 minutes after we ordered), then the second time we called (1.5 hours later), we were told that they are bringing our food with another order in our hotel. Huge disappointment! read more

The food was not terrible. The pizza was okay and the wings were throughly cooked. I personally like my wings extra crispy, so I was a little disappointed. If I had been at home, I would have just popped them in the oven for a bit. The girl at the counter was busy and over worked, but very polite and friendly. They did have a lot of customers and some appeared to be regulars, which is usually a good sign. read more

We were extremely disappointed in our experience with Vinnie's. We'll make sure to avoid this restaurant in the future. We ordered 6 pizzas for delivery to feed a big party, everyone was very hungry after skiing. I was told on the phone it would be an hour to 1.5 hours. I already thought that was a crazy wait for pizza, but hoped it would be closer to one hour. Well, it took 2 and a half hours!!!! The girl on the phone was super rude when I called to ask about the status of our delivery. When the pizza FINALLY arrived at 9 pm, it was cold and doughy. read more

What an incredibly crazy (in a good way) place this is. First time we went we got the chicken quesadilla, the calzone and pizza. All were outstanding! We saw the menu has an Asian section which is sorta funny for a pizza place called Vinnies. Next time we went we decided to try the Asian food. It was awesome! Lo mein with chicken and a fresh veggie sandwich of sorts. Super! Now, when we are at Peak n'Peek we have Vinnies! read more

Excellent pizza, fast service. Nothing bad to say. Ate in, small dining room but plenty of room. Pizza crust was perfect.

Quick service and unexpectedly large portions. Food was tasty and super affordable. Good experience.

Ordered and employee was...well... unintelligent to say the least. She told us 1 hour and 1 hour 20 min later we were calling to find out where our order was. Same employ answered and got smart about it ("you know it's snowing and the roads are bad"...wasn't snowing by the way). Soon after food shows up and it's cold and the salad we ordered for a vegetarian had ham and turkey on it. I called to complain and same employee answered so I asked for a manager. No resolution and will never order again. The food was mediocre and the service was the pits! Order at your own risk! read more

They take almost 1 1/2 to deliver & half of the time, try to make excuses as to why they cant deliver. I've called them, trying to order food FOUR times this week and as usual - excuses. Will never order from here again & that's a promise. read more

Just received our delivery after over an hour wait, I guess they got busy after our order...that's understandable. When the food showed up cold and slightly the wrong order I was a little disappointed. The pizza was nothing great. I think I had frozen pizza that taste better. I wouldn't order from here again. read more

This is some of the best food I've had in a long time. This is a hidden gem on the lake. Service was amazing. Calzones out of this world Don't even get me started on the desserts and fresh cut fries. I would gladly go back and would make the 30 minute trip with out hesitation. 5*! And super affordable. read more

Literally the worst pizza service I've ever had. We ordered at 615, called back at 745, called back at 845 and she told us we were rude at 745 so she said we should've canceled the other order. Who runs a business like this? DONT EVER ORDER FROM THESE SLUM DOGS read more

NEVER GO HERE. This was the worst dinning experience I have ever had, we were told a short 30 min wait but that was the wait for any type of menu or interaction. We had to go to the bar to request service, which never came until we asked again!!! We finally got drinks and food orders in and we wait another 40 minutes to get some of our food. After everyone else had eaten I decided to stop waiting for my food to even come out of the kitchen so I NEVER GOT MY FOOD!!!! This place is a waste of space and a waste of any of your time or money. NEVER GO HERE. EVER! read more

We got to the restaurant and sat ourselves, waited at the table for 10 minutes and then decided to go up to the bar. When we tried to order drinks with the bartender she told us that she would be over to our table when she had time, probably 10 minutes. A half hour or so goes by and we still haven't been checked on so two of us from the group decided to try the bar again. At that time someone came to our table and told us that it would be probably 20 minutes, a half hour if we got wings. 40 minutes go by and we still haven't gotten any of our order, not even drinks and a table behind us with more people who came in probably a half hour after we did were served. We had to go back up to the bar and then someone finally started to fill our drink orders. We were at the restaurant for a total of 2 hours and one of us didnt even get his food and it was not taken off of the bill! Very bad experience, we will not be returning read more