I was sooo disappointed. I saw zeppoles on the menu so we stopped by to grab an order for the road. I asked the girl at the counter about them first. She mentioned they weren't round. Ok I can deal with a funny shape. But I asked if they had powdered sugar on them. She said yes. ..but that they came with gelato. Um, ok... seems strange but why not. What I received did not have powdered sugar on them. It was cinnamon sugar. Basically these were more like smooth churros. I can't speak to anything else on the menu, so I'll keep it at a 3 star. read more

Wow, I'm blown away!! I overheard some people talking about the cheese bread and chef salad at Vitales. I had a pizza before and wasn't the most impressed, but I was willing to give them another try. Craving a salad tonight I decided to order and I'm so glad I did! The large chef salad is huge and packed! Tons of meat and cheese, literally a whole hard-boiled egg, four slices of tomato, multiple slices of cucumbers, etc. There were also 2 large cups of ranch and the ranch was just as amazing! This quite possibly the best chef salad I've had in over 20 years. It really took me back! It's so big I can easily get 2 meals from it. I added a pic under the photos so be sure to check it out. The price was even quite affordable. The only thing I could possibly think would make this better was if they cooked their own bacon, but the bacon bits on the salad were all real and great quality. None of the cheap stuff or artificial bacon bits. I also ordered the cheese bread to have a little something extra with the salad. I was thinking it was going to be cheesy bread sticks maybe, or one of those oval shaped breads covered in cheese. This is actually much bigger and about the size of medium pizza. There is plenty of cheese on it and the olive oil and garlic really put this cheese bread on another level. The crust tastes like pizza crust and the flavor is incredible. I had a large cup of marinara and it is also really good. Everything was exceptional, including the temperature, time, and service. And it may sound odd but the utensils included were also great quality, very durable. I could easily cut up the veggies and meats without concern the utensils would snap. I will most certainly be regularly visting Vitales and ordering this same meal. It's so good I don't know how I could go and not get the same thing. I'm telling everyone I know. Run, don't walk and you can thank me later! read more

Vitale's Pizza Kitchen - Chef Salad - Italian Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Ordered 2 pizzas and a sub to go. Both were done just right and delicious. We and our 5 grandkids ate them up and enjoyed!

Its just ok. I felt was a little salty. Was close to new York style but for me for the price just missed a little.

It was good pizza, not the best but certainly not the worst. They have basically 2 tables to sit and eat.

We were in town for my son's wedding and craving some good pizza. We found Vitale's on Yelp and read some of the reviews, so we decided to try it. We were not disappointed. We had the meat pizza, mozzarella sticks, and cheese bread (it was a lot of food for a family of 3). Needless to say, everything was axing. If we're ever back in town, we will definitely go here again. read more

Probably my favorite pizza in the Burg. High-quality ingredients. Love the mozzarella sticks and Caesar salad as well. And all very reasonably priced to boot! read more

Vitale's is by far our favorite pizza in Forest! Fresh dough, great sauce, and good toppings. Highly recommended! read more

See all

It's official, Vitale's has the best gluten free pizza in Lynchburg. I don't know if they changed their recipe as we do not remember the dough being this good. It was exceptional!! Lord willing; we will be back. Blessings. read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE their pizza, especially their white pizza! I add artichoke hearts and onions, and mmmmmm...perfection!

I got a slice of Pizza and it was great. I'm from NJ and it hit the spot. Best place to get a slice in town!

The pizza was really good! We ordered through DoorDash and it was hot and fresh when it arrived . Will definitely order from them again!! read more

We tried the cheese bread, pepperoni pizza, the Beefeater and the Pizza Rustica. The cheese bread was phenomenal- some of the best I've ever had. The Pizza Rustica was delicious - the flavors are strong, but they all work so well together. Overall, I think our group preferred the Beefeater - flavor was more mild than the Rustica, but a fantastic meat lovers pizza. All in all, great place! Looking forward to trying more! read more

Closest to a New York pizza that I've found in a long time and they were quick to deliver.

Food is absolutely delicious! I've only been in twice and the staff recognized me enough to ask if I wanted the same order. I enjoy mustard on my subs, so this may have been why I was so recognizable. One of the ladies said they didn't have any mustard last time, but this time, she packed a couple packets in my to-go order. Melted my heart! I can't recommend this place enough! The inside is small, they cook delicious food, and it's fast! read more

Chicken parmigiana sandwich was very good. I'm not a fan of the bite size chicken pieces, but the bread was soft, perfect amount of cheese, and the marinara was delicious. read more

We were excited to try a new pizza joint in the neighborhood, and the menu looked promising! We ordered the Godfather and ordered it well done because I can't stand a limp, soggy pizza. Well, it was far from well done, and kind of tasteless! We ended up throwing half of the pizza away! I doubt we will be back! read more

One of the BEST NY style pizzas I've ever had and my new go to spot in Lynchburg! The pizza was ready in under 20 minutes and they were VERY friendly with the toppings! read more

Vitale's Pizza Kitchen - Large NY style pepperoni pizza. Half sausage, half sun dried tomatoes - Italian Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

They had the best mozzarella sticks! They were so huge and delicious. I would say they need to give you more sauce though. Not enough sauce for how big they are. Pizza was filled with flavor. But more sauce needed on the pizza as well. Tons of toppings. Crust was a tad thick for my liking but still really good. read more

Decided to try something new so we ordered the Tuscan Chicken Lettuce Wraps, Fried Mozzarella, Stuffed Shells, Pizza and Zeppoli & Gelato and a pizza. The chicken was so dry it literally scratched my mouth and throat. Nothing was "wrapped" there was just a bunch of tomato's and dry chicken on top of wilted lettuce leaves. The stuffed shells were overcooked and pasty and the cheese filling was a runny tasteless mess. The pizza was lukewarm and dry, it had very little sauce and the dough itself seriously lacked flavor. The Zeppoli's were hard, like they had been sitting for awhile or microwaved and the Gelato came prepackaged and was half melted because they put it in the same bag as the other food. It seems with this place the food is hit or miss. The only thing that we ate was the Mozzarella sticks and they were pretty good. To spend $55 on food you have to throw away is shameful and I won't be doing it again! read more

Vitale's Pizza Kitchen - Food receipt - Italian Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

See all

First visit. Ordered a 16" pepperoni and after getting home found a cheese pizza. The business was not busy. Very few customers there. The crust was over cooked with charring on bottom crust. There was plenty of cheese & it was good. Sauce was not my cup of tea. Quite herby in my opinion. read more

New York style pizza and cheese steak sub were delicious! Fast and friendly service. Highly recommend.