Five stars with a bullet! Delicious pizza with creative toppings. Super friendly staff. I brought…read morethree cans of IPAs up to the counter and they said, "you know, it's buy three IPAs, get one free so just grab another one on your way out." How cool is that?

Best pizza in Lynchburg, we're obsessed 10/10 recommend!! Our favorite is the pepperoni ricottaread more

The pepperoni pizza we got was really yummy and was made fresh right in front of us. The crispy and…read morecrunchy crust had to be the best part I stopped eating the pizza halfway through to get the crust first. The service was just as amazing quick and easy with limited interaction, just like I like it. Brent was a little cute too. The walls and the arcade really add to the aesthetic. It reminds me of community togetherness which is what Lynchburg is supposed to be like. Supposed to.

Looking for an original slice of pizza? Look no further!! This place is an adventure in pizza…read moreeating. The pizza is 28 inches across. A slice is 14 inches long. That's the same size as a dominos large pizza. Get a slice, add extra toppings and prepare to enjoy a crisp cracker like crust and a mess of toppings. Service is quick and the ambience is typical of a college town. Don't miss this opportunity to indulge in a pizza that is borderline ridiculous.

I'm new to the area, and have been making it a point to try local restaurants. While I'm…read moredisappointed immensely in the lack of Italian restaurants in the area, I was very pleased with my order from Vinny's. I had the eggplant parm dinner (which is how I personally gage every Italian restaurant I eat at), with a side salad with homemade ranch dressing. I love that it's not Ken's from a giant jar. Nothing beats house made. The eggplant parm was delicious, and the sauce had a nice flavor. I'm from a massive Italian town up north where you can throw a stone in any direction and hit an Italian restaurant or pizza joint, so I'm very particular. I also have a culinary degree, which makes me even pickier. I will absolutely be returning, and can't wait to try other items from the menu.

We ordered takeout. The pizza was the highlight of the meal. The crust had a nice chewiness with a…read moreslight crunch on the outside, and it tasted like house-made dough rather than a pre-made crust. I would order the pizza again. Unfortunately, the chicken Marsala was disappointing. The sauce was very thin and watery, with a large amount of liquid collecting in the bottom of the container instead of coating the pasta and chicken. The mushrooms had a texture and flavor that reminded me of canned mushrooms. While the dish lacked the consistency I typically expect from chicken Marsala, the sauce was still very rich in flavor and savory. Based on this experience, I'd recommend the pizza, but I would skip the Marsala. They gave an accurate estimate of wait time, prices were reasonable, and from what I saw the restaurant was clean. I would also like to acknowledge it was later in the night and they were going to be closing in the next hour, which might have caused a bit of a rush on the food, I'm not really sure.

This might just be the best gluten free pizza I've ever had! They were fast and affordable. I was…read morehomesick for some family restaurant style pizza and this pizza hit the spot!

I just did takeout. Staff seemed nice enough. Some of the…read morehigh end reviews confuse me a little. It was mid and as others had mentioned, low sauce. I ordered extra marinara and was glad I did. I got the wings, regular with extra cheese, and a gluten free. Wings were meaty, gf was ok, and reg pizza was ok. Nothing bad about the food, just pricey for what you get.

We are in from TX for a track meet and found this place on yelp. And WOW!! If we could give 10…read morestars they'd have earned every one of them! Everything was AMAZING. It's all fresh and homemade and a cute little family run business. We had the sausage and peppers special with caramelized onion white sauce. So delicious. Crust was crispy, light and buttery. Perfect amount of cheese, sausage and peppers. We also had the Sansa which was pepperoni with hot honey. Perfect amount of hot honey and the pepperoni was cupped and delicious. Before all of that we had the Greek salad with homemade dressing. Best I've had. Fresh, thinly cut lettuce and generous with the feta and peperoncinis. A must have. I also had a freshly squeezed mimosa with raspberry. Amazingly fresh and delicious. You will not be disappointed. Seriously. This place is it! We will be back next time we're in town!!!

They have mastered a pizza with that crispy buttery crust! Wow! We tried both red and white sauces…read moreand everyone agreed white was the winner. Not only was the pizza amazing the family that owns it is too. Pouring their hearts into quality food and meeting their customers, they should be proud of what they've started. We suggest having a reservation or getting carry out, as the shop can seat 11. We will be frequent guests. Thank you cast iron pizza for investing in downtown Lynchburg.

Friday night = pizza for us and we love trying different Mellow Mushroom locations…read more Around 530, it was beginning to get full but we secured a table near the kitchen. Having been to a few... and memorizing our previous pizza orders, we only needed to glance at the apps to try something different. I opted for the meatballs and was not impressed. They were warm, at best, and dry. The wing sauce was good but they also were barely warm when they got to the table. The salad is always better with the Esperanza dressing; it's good. Our pizzas were good and hot when they arrived to the table! I'd order the pizzas again and skip the appetizers. Service was standard.

This is our sons favorite place to eat. Great atmosphere and the pizza is always delicious. Don't…read moresleep on their salads!

Milano's is really a hidden gem in Lynchburg…read more They have a very interesting and unique menu for the area which is great for when you want to try something new. The restaurant is really pretty and great for a date night. If you have not been yet I highly recommend.

I would really love to love this restaurant because it is so near my house but after two visits, I…read moreleave frustrated. Why, because there are many good things about it but key areas are weak. The good: staff. Excellent hostess and service. Wine list. Lovely choices each visit with reasonable prices Bread service. The warm yeast rolls and herby dipping oil is wonderful The bad. Beets are diced into tiny cubes and mixed in with dressing and other toppings, dumped on top of spinach then covered with very unappetizing looking goat cheese. A little bit of care in plating would made a big difference Chicken Parmesan. The chicken was so thin I had to analyze closely to find it! Sadly, the marinara sauce and cheese topping was good but lack of protein was disappointing Pizza. The crust seemed premade and toppings barely cooked. Same tasty marinara sauce couldn't overcome the overall weakness Simple adjustments could make this a great option.

Continuing alphabet series with V for V is for Vinny's. My girlfriend & I were at Smith Mountain…read moreLake the week of 4th of July 2024 as her parents have a home there. My g/f recommended Vinny's as being very good. Originally, we were going to go here for an early dinner on Thursday, July 4, but when we were driving from Franklin County, I exclaimed Prime Rib Thursday at Copper Kettle! So, I had her U-turn, and we tried that instead. Please see my 5-star of them from August 2024. We ended up going on Saturday, July 6. We arrived in this cramped front area, and someone sat us at a booth at a reasonable time. We sat in the booth over 10 minutes without anyone coming to even get us water or check on here. We were hungry, and I was already annoyed for this long wait and was looking on Yelp. I asked my g/f about trying Bella Vita, which she agreed and left about 15 minutes after being seated. It was a big disappointment. However, after my 5-star Yelp review of Bella Vita (which I got to reviewing in April 2025), my g/f said Bella Vita is a better Italian than Vinny's, so maybe for the best. Since I didn't actually eat at Vinny's in the end, wasn't actively denied water, or had some other terrible experience, it would be unfair to give than 1-star in this case.

We have eaten here 3 times since we moved - Sept 2025. I was afraid I would miss the other…read moreVinny's... NO way!! This place is awesome!!! The food is delicious and the people seem very genuine. I love pizza, I know it, being originally from the southwest side of Chicago and living in the suburbs, WE have the greatest pizza there! Vinny's is great and really satisfies! I also LOVE the tilapia Vinny - U must try, i just love! My Husband always orders the Stromboli and calamari - it's wonderful... love the food, salads, nice deserts - everything and the restaurant....love the high ceilings, decor, and the space... I don't feel jammed together! This is a great place to sit eat unwind and refresh! Thanx for exceeding things i love to enjoy! SEE you soon!