I just did takeout. Staff seemed nice enough. Some of the high end reviews confuse me a little. It was mid and as others had mentioned, low sauce. I ordered extra marinara and was glad I did. I got the wings, regular with extra cheese, and a gluten free. Wings were meaty, gf was ok, and reg pizza was ok. Nothing bad about the food, just pricey for what you get. read more

Fantastic food always served with a smile. Best pizza on this side of town. I highly recommend. The ambience reminds me of most walk-in pizza joints in New York City. read more

We enjoyed a whole pie today from the food truck, at the touch a truck in Bedford! Pizza was great! The dough is so soft it's wonderful. Had to track down the brick an mortar place can't wait to have another! Great price btw read more

"Toodleloo" makes a mean pizza! Never disappointed when I order Upper Crust Pizza. Been coming here for years and one of my favorite pizzas in town. The owner and his staff are very personable and the prices are reasonable. read more

See all

Had their pizza this evening. Pros: cheese and sauce were pretty good. My pizza was ready very quickly. Good service. Cons: crust was really doughy (that may be a pro to some but not me) Kinda expensive. $20 for a pizza that was the size of most everyone else's medium was a bit high to me. Definitely better pizza places for the money in town. read more

Staff was super friendly. Clean place. Pizza was spectacular. A little pricey but definitely worth every penny! Will be back!

Delicious! I had looked at this place a few weeks ago but I don't eat takeout often on purpose. However since I am nowhere close to my favorite pizza restaurant in Chicago or Michigan I decided to try this place. I have to say from the outside it's very unassuming but what comes in that cardboard box is very good! The first bite always tells me everything I need to know about a pizza and this one said many things. I ordered the Carnivore which has pepperoni, ham, and ground beef on it. Even with all that meat, the pizza wasn't greasy, the crust was light and crusty. Overall a good pizza. However, with a name like "The Carnivore" there should be way more meat. I would still buy the pizza again. Street parking and great customer service. Stop by if you are in the area. read more

See all

My new favorite pizza restaurant in town! I tried this place when I first moved here and was honestly not too impressed, but I decided to give them another try. So glad I did! I think they may have new management or changed things up. The interior looked different, too. Either way, I highly recommend Upper Crust for local and quality pizza! I was able to even get a custom whole wheat pie, which I was so happy about because I am health conscious AND love good food. The only problem I have is the steep increase in price when you start adding toppings. I am overall very happy, especially with the crust, which I am very picky about. (Yeah I guess it's in the name.) I'll be back soon! read more

See all

I was hopeful after reading some of the reviews for Upper Crust, but after sampling their fully dressed pizza, the best I can say is that it's marginally better than Domino's. The pizza was okay, but that's about it. I would say their biggest problem was their sauce. There wasn't much of it, and it just struck me as being kind of bland. The cheese was similarly unexceptional. The search for exceptional pizza in Lynchburg continues. read more

Food made fresh, and served by regular nice people. Enjoy! It's conveniently located on the main drag in a nice little town in Virginia.

Good whole wheat and gluten free crusts! Very small eating area but take out is quick.

Cute little spot with some good pizza. The workers seemed nice as well. The only thing is that it is pretty overpriced for what you get. It was 18 or 19 I believe for a 12 or 14 inch pizza. Not crazy high, but certainly more than usual. The pizza was good though and had some nice floppy thin crust. Hope to try it again in the future. read more

Upper Crust Pizza Company - Half chicken bacon ranch, half extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Don't mind the bite I couldn't help but have before taking this photo.. so deliciously fresh, hot and flavorful! What a unique, thin crust throughout the pie, and thicker, soft-with-a-crunch crust on the outside! We got half Fully Dressed (combo style) and half Herbivore (veggie with a Greek twist) with added chicken breast. New favorite in the Burg! read more

Upper Crust Pizza Company - Half Herbivore with chicken breast, half Fully Dressed - Pizza Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Good local pizza!! Was not disappointed in flavor however the crust was a bit undercooked. Other than that like the local vibe.

Found this place on Yelp after me and my buddy were looking for some good pizza in town. Glad we came here instead of going to some joint off wards. The wyndhurst area is really stepping up with their food game, and this place helps a lot with that. The crust is what's to rave about here. The dough tastes fresh and not overly cooked. We had the carnivores, essentially a meat lovers pizza, and it was delicious. We're two big dudes, and a large (8 slices) was good for the both of us. read more

Upper Crust Pizza Company - Carnivore - Pizza Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

The pizza was bland, really needed seasoning. We've had Upper Crust Pizza in the past and it was great. This time everyone at home said the same thing about it not having much flavor and being just meh and disappointing. read more

This pizza is amazing. Best crust, sauce and service. Very friendly. Always my go to pizzeria in Lynchburg.

Being a new transplant to the area I have tried a majority of the pizza places. Most are pretty awful but this place has tasty offerings that are affordable. I sometimes catch their food truck in downtown Lynchburg too. Definitely worth checking out. You won't be disappointed ! read more

If you prefer your pizza to have a lot of sauce, this isn't the right place for you. Additionally, they hardly cut our pizza, and they gave us the wrong breadstick. It was decent but not the best around. read more

If I'm splurging on pizza, I'm going to Upper Crust!! This place is amazing and has ruined all other pizza places for me. Love this place!! And they're always super friendly and fast -- whether you're eating in or getting take out. read more

Pizza was very dry and hardly had any sauce. I was advised it would be extra for more sauce but I just wanted a normal pizza

I am a big fan of Upper Crust for just overall good pizza and fantastic service - never met a rude or unhappy employee at the counter. Really love their lunch deals! I would put this as one of my top three places for pizza. My only feedback would be not to order the boneless wings if you have a craving. I recently needed to get a take-out order during work hours (which, is why I needed boneless) and wasn't quite in the mood for pizza. Since the business is nearby and reasonably priced, I decided to give their wings a go. Big disappointment! They reminded me of the nuggests in the frozen section of the grocery store: small with lots of breading, soft (no crunch at all), and there was barely any sauce on them. I was so hungry that I finished them, but felt like my $8 was completely wasted - but, you live and learn... as I know that's not what they are known for. Will certainly be back - just not for the wings. read more

In my opinion the best locally owned Pizza in the area. Their Conniver (all meat) pizza is the best. This locally owned business supports local school and area functions. A must try when in town.. read more

Great pizza, great staff! The use of quality ingredients is obvious. Roy yourself a favor and take three steps up from the other delivery guys and order yourself an Upper Crust Pizza. They use only premium toppings and it shows... read more

This is the best place in town for delicious, glutinous, quick, take-out pizza. For veggie lovers like myself, they have fresh ingredients. As someone who usually passes on cheese pizza, theirs is remarkably satisfying! Perfect for a lazy Friday night at home. The owner is also very supportive of local nonprofits - you can't argue giving your business to a restaurant eager to give back! read more

Amazing Pizza! Delivery was fast within the Wyndhurst community. Finally tried this instead of a local chain and this place is GREAT! Loved the buffalo chicken pizza and the buttery garlic munchies for appetizers. Will be ordering again soon! read more

I've been going to Upper Crust for 2 years and have ordered from their Wyndhurst, Forest, and food truck locations. Their gluten free pizza is fantastic and their customer service is amazing! read more

Love Upper Crust! Their pizzas are definitely well-made and a treat compared to the chain restaurants. The only reason for taking a point off is that I wish they had more coupons and night discounts - the lunch discounts they offer are amazing! You can get a small pizza and drink for under $6 at lunch! So amazing deals there. You may pay more but the pizza is definitely above average and nothing like the pizza chains. The delivery drivers are super-nice and delivery is FAST. Oh and you can order online!!! read more

Stopped by late last night to get a pizza to go. We were just passing through Lynchburg and found this place on Yelp. Oh man, was this pizza delicious! Wings were great too, very friendly staff! A+! read more

Upper Crust Pizza Company - Cheesy, fresh, great flavor - Pizza Near Me - Lynchburg, Virginia

Good variety of toppings and specialty pizzas. Generous amount of bacon and cheese on the pizza which is rare. Definitely a step up from the typical chain pizza shops. I will definitely be back read more

I love the pizza here! Its amazing some of the best pizza in town!

This place has pizza. I like to eat pizza. My mommy makes it the best. But its pretty good here. Get take out... not that good environment to eat in. read more

I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and it was fantastic!! The staff was and always is friendly and courteous. They got us clean silverware when I pointed out there was none available and they were so apologetic over forks!!! That's incredible. Good food. Great experience. read more

Good pizza, but the menu is deceiving- though a large may be $9.99, every topping is like 4 bucks. My friend got a extra large with jalapeños and mushrooms and it was eighteen bucks! read more

My family loved the pizza...the guys behind the counter were very friendly. Only downside is the size of the dining room. Fortunately for us the day we visited it was a beautiful day outside and people were lined up waiting for the outdoor tables and chairs. read more

I eat here literally every other week, and the pizza is pretty good! It may not be the best ingredients from the best of the land, but you are getting a great buy for your price! read more

We have visited the store front location once and the food truck numerous times. The cheese bread is fantastic and enough for 2 people. Their pizza is very good and all made to order. Fresh ingredients and a great sauce. The staff is always friendly and the food is great. Their prices are very good! read more

Such great crunchy thin crust and amazing vegan cheese! Staff is so polite and friendly and I loved getting my pizza from them ! Me and my fiancé loved the pizza so much that if we want pizza, we go here ! read more

I eat at this restaurant often because their pizza is about the best in town (especially the flavor of the cheese and crust). My order from yesterday (9/3) was not prepared correctly, because they were not given the instructions ahead of time. When I got to the store, the cashier and cook were very patient as I asked several questions regarding the preparation of one of the pizzas. After we determined the pizza wasn't prepared correctly, they very kindly offered to bake a new pizza without charging me again. Their customer service is unparalleled! read more

Love there pizza, very fresh ingredients. However after being a loyal customer for many years the owner decided to change their rewards program to compete with Domino's. After doing that I lost all my current points and started at zero. Made a complaint but got no response, haven't been back since. read more