Stopped in to grab a sandwich today. Passed it many times before and never tried it. The young lady who took my order was very polite. And the woman who made my sandwich was very kind. I ordered the classic American hero. It was a well made hero, filled to the brim with turkey, American and roast beef. What I liked was there was cheese on the sandwich but not an overpowering amount like some delis. The deli itself was clean, a typical old school deli with lots of drinks, chips and snacks. I'll definitely be back!!! read more

Wading River Deli - Classic American Hero - Delis Near Me - Wading River, New York

Ordered a child's size sandwich which they would normally charge me less for and instead they charged me for a regular sandwich. Ending up with two sandwiches with hardly any meat on them but cost a bunch. When I asked about the girl looked at me like she had no idea what I was talking about. I've been going there for years before hitting the beach with my kids. read more

These guys make a great sandwich. Place is clean, and they have a good amount of options. Hardworking and friendly staff.

I called in a order for lunch today. 2 sandwiches. Roast beef with cheese on rye with lettuce, tomato and Mayo. Ham and Swiss with lettuce, Mayo and mustard. Both orders were wrong. The roast beef had globs of mustard which couldn't all be scraped off. I can't eat mustard. The ham and Swiss had tomatoes and no mustard. In addition the roast beef was so full of hard fat that most of it I couldn't bite through and had to put to the side of my plate. I was very disappointed. read more

Wading River Deli - Hard, fat roast beef and mustard that was scraped off. - Delis Near Me - Wading River, New York

Excellent service. Great food. A lot of food. Fresh hot coffee. Very friendly. Steve just took the deli over. Had spinach and feta omelet with home fries and toast. Food was hot. Great place in area to get sandwiches and egg sandwiches. read more

I visited on a Thursday morning and had a nice experience. I was greeted by two people behind the counter and did not feel rushed to order. They got my BEC perfect and (maybe because I'm always sweet as pie to service workers or maybe it was an accident) they gave me both a coffee and a juice with my sandwich. I will be back to try some lunch sandwiches read more

What a joke. I'll bet that these new owners are out of business already. The deli is empty. No chips, no snacks, minimal liquids. At lunch time I was the only person in there. I'm sure that the vendors that supply these clowns are owed money. The worthless hero's are way expensive, especially compared to other delis in the neighborhood. Go to Wine Country where you get quality and have selections yet less expensive than this bomb of a business. read more

New owners have cleaned the place up and improved the quality of the food. Very friendly and quick service.

Wading River Deli has a awesome menu with their daily specials and the portions are huge and delicious as well, I'll see you soon David, be well and always stay safe Joey LV read more

Best neighborhood deli around. Service with a smile; and decent prices. Not trying to rip you off like other delis try. There's a place closer to me in Shoreham I could get egg sandwiches from, but this place is faster, much nicer staff and cheaper to boot! I will drive cross town any day to come here for breakfast or lunch. read more

Half of the time, this deli is really good. The other half, it is a mess. There is one guy who is always so kind and a pleasure to see! The food he makes is always phenomenal and it's made with care. The rest of the staff wouldn't know their job if you smacked them with it. They are rude, impatient and the food is always lacking with them. I only come to this deli because of the one guy and hope he's there when I order. It's really unfortunate because if he was there a little more often, the deli wouldn't leave such a bad taste in my mouth. Overall the food is pretty good and it's unfortunate that the staff is what brings this place down because it has great potential. read more

Ordered chicken cutlet ham Swiss Russian which I believe is called the West Hampton something or other, I believe that the chicken was cooked for the third time making my sandwich horrendous, like chicken jerky,13 dollars no drink no chips no good ,sorry read more

I desperately want to like this place, they have landed on my travels on the weekend often . their bread is amazing , they have a great sandwich menu . the service is slow and often borders on rude and they aren't cheap so I don't want to give my money to some little 15 year old who hasn't mastered manors . Or the plethora of other young people who border on nasty . read more

Don't waste your time. Went there on a Saturday and it was moderately busy. I ordered 3 egg sandwiches. Waited for my order, for about 10 minutes. No food yet. Everyone else after me had gotten their food and left already. I asked what was going on, and they hadn't put my order in. Waited another 10 minutes for my food and the order was wrong. I haven't gone back since. This deli used to be good. I'm not sure what happened, I think new owners may have taken over. You're better off going to the diner a few stores over, you'll get way better food, and you'll be finished quicker anyway. read more

Waiting River deli is a solid deli all around delicious signature sandwiches daily specials excellent breakfast it's a must to visit enjoy read more

Wading River Deli - Chicken cutlet ham melted Swiss cheese Russian dressing on a toasted Kaiser roll delicious - Delis Near Me - Wading River, New York

Delicious salami and cheese sandwich. Potato salad has way too much sugar. Courteous staff.

Never get the sandwiches right. Vety annoying when u get to work and ur order is wrong.

If you like insects all over Everything then maybe it's worth the trip. Flies everywhere plus little flying bugs in were the baked good were kept. Not just one or two, I'm talking dozens. Filthy place, I hate giving low reviews but they need to do something about the bugs. I wanted to try some of the pasta salads but they didn't look fresh at all. I did end up trying a wrap, hope I don't get sick. read more

If I could give this deli negative stars I would. On a Sunday morning, the only bagels they had were salt and everything flagels. When we called to order, we ordered an egg everything bagel...didn't tell us there weren't any. The deli made iced tea tastes like watered down tea bags. The staff is rude and unhelpful. The order is never right. You won't save time ordering ahead, they don't move fast. Please save your money and go elsewhere, even if you have to drive out of your way. read more

Went in for breakfast with my family and received the worst customer service. They were very rude when I inquired about alternate meat and bread options. Aka Turkey sausage and Sour Dough. You would have thought I was asking them something outlandish. On top of all that.. they got the order wrong. My personal opinion? Go to Bagel Palace across the street. The girls there are wonderful and will most definitely have turkey sausage. read more

So my client and I have been going to this deli for about four years now, we both enjoy it very much. They are very kind and give great customer service. That's very hard to find these days. They are very fast and get you in and out. Foods delicious and priced reasonable. read more

The food at the deli is very good. The people who work at the deli are also very nice. The management seems very unorganized and the place itself doesn't look clean. I always go here and I order the same thing every time and they charge me a different price every time. Extremely disorganized. If you call to place an order two things will happen; 1) They just don't pick up even when they're open 2) they will pick up but they will put you on hold and two minutes later a completely different person will answer the phone like you just called. The food is really good but the service/management, not so much. read more

I stop here to pick up some breakfast on my way to Great Rock Golf course. The deli is clean, and has a great selection of sandwiches, hot and cold foods, hot and cold drinks, pastries and beers. The guys and girls behind the counter are quite nice and usually strike up a nice chat while waiting for the grub. Prices are reasonable and the portions (for the sandwiches) are sizable! read more

Stopped in on my way home from Mattituck. Has anyone ever noticed how many flies are in this deli? Got a bad vibe. I agree with other other comments posted on Yelp about how the establishment appears dirty and unorganized. Totally screwed up my sandwich orders. Place needs work. read more

Been going here for a while they never get my order wrong I rarely wait for food here bagels are always fresh

Great food great prices Fast friendly service centrally located plenty of close parking. I was in the buisness for many years this place is top notch. read more

Wading River Deli - Wading River Deli Great food great prices Fast friendly service. I was in the deli buisness for many years Top notch all tw - Delis Near Me - Wading River, New York

Been coming to this deli over 25 years. Has a much cleaner look and feel with the new owners who put money into it. Nice menu with locally named sandwiches too. Only deli in town, they can slack but they don't. read more

just when you though this deli had hit rock bottom, they manage to get worse.

Incredibly unorganized and semi-rude staff. New management needs to come in and fix everything about this place starting with the little details & the big details because they all add up. The customer experience here is very much thumbs down. read more

Just had a sandwich delivered from this deli, order was 100% right, sandwich is perfect, bag of chips is what I ordered. After bad experiences with delis this is the light in the storm awesome sandwich and great service thank you! read more

Never in my life have I experienced such bad catering. Ordered one of their super bowl packages - when picked up, they handed me ice cold food for me to heat up at home -- WTF?@! plus gave me the penne ala vodka to mix myself. Pretty sure I paid for them to make the food and give me trays of food ready to serve to my guests. read more

Most awful services I've ever expirenced. Not only did they charge me wrong the delivered it to the wrong location after I specified the number of the building and address and even named the location so I had to take time out of my work day to come and get my order from the different building and then they didn't know how to put the money owed on my card and told me if I wanted it I had to come get that too! The are very rude! Good food but not worth the trouble I rather starve read more

I ordered a Reuben wrap and somehow got a hero with chicken and bacon on it. Definitely not what I ordered. Also my husband ordered one of their special sandwiches and it was missing several ingredients. Also, we were the only ones in the place and it took twenty min at least to get our food. read more

This place needs new management or a new owner. I was here a few weeks ago and they blatantly forgot my order and never apologized for the mix-up. Today I ordered 2 egg sandwiches and it took 35 minutes. It was not even that busy. I have literally never been to a deli that is this slow. read more

I love this little deli. Whenever I go there, the staff is pleasant. The bagel sandwiches are delicious!

Overpriced and the service is terrible almost every time I'm in there and order something; the older gentlemen behind the counter rolls his eyes and clearly has an issue with making my order...they act like its a chore to take my money....If you call up to place an order they have to take a second to think if they actually want to take it or not....always have issues, I one time was charged way too much for a sand which and noticed it on the receipt...girl behind the counter said " I don't know how to fix it so come back tomorrow and I'll take care of you ." Next day they said that was bs and yea....don't go here....waste of your time and money and you can get way better food elsewhere... read more

Meh. The guy taking my order today acted as if he were doing me a favor. I ordered two heros, one was a triple Decker that has ham, turkey, roast beef, LT and Russian dressing. I asked for American cheese and no tomato on it. What I got was very disappointing. My sandwich has a few slices of turkey and some sad looking grey roast beef, LT and honey mustard, no cheese. I took my sandwich to the beach, so at that point I wasn't able to take it back. I ate it because I was hungry but it Was not enjoyable and not worth the almost 9 bucks I got charged for it. I won't be going back there again. It's too bad that they don't seem to care about food quality or service. read more

The best Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich around!!!! Food is always fresh, Staff is always friendly!!

Just...wow. Like some dystopian farce here. The first time a few Saturdays ago I waited nearly a half hour for two simple breakfast sandwiches. There were literally more people behind the line taking orders (very good at that and taking the money) and cooking than there were customers. As mirrored in other reviews, several customers coming way after me and leaving WAY before me. Other customers frustrated, grabbing their order and mumbling "this is the last time they'll see me here". But the sandwiches were actually good. This time, mere moments ago, same exact circumstances and experiences only they shorted me a sandwich in the bag and I didn't bother to check it before leaving. I started to stir and raise my voice, so the counter cashier probably thought "let me just get this guy out of here with the shorted order before he causes chaos, he probably won't notice until it's too late"...and he was right. I actually would have raised more stink, but an active duty soldier in battle fatigues was standing nearby and waiting for his order, so...you know, self shame and perspective and all. So, a real shit hole and they probably won't last much longer. read more

The best egg sandwich I've ever had! I usually order a sausage egg and pepper jack cheese on an everything bagel! Omg so so good!!