Everything bagels are weird, taste burnt and not really coated the same way as most everything bagels are for some reason ... Bagel Factory on Montauk Highway in West Babylon much better! Plus the parking is a nightmare and have to back up or turn around onto 109 instead of them removing the grass on the side of the building there and making them parking spots so people can exit on the back side street would make a lot more sense! read more

West Babylon Bagels & Deli - Everything toasted with butter and egg salad - Bagels Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Ordered sandwiches for the beach. There was hardly any meat on the sandwiches. Mayo missing even after I said it twice. How do these ppl stay in business?!! Never again. read more

I was looking for an early morning breakfast and coffee before fishing and this place was a short detour from our route. Clean. Busy. Great selection! What else can you ask for at 5:15am? BEC and SEC rocked. Coffee was great and tasty. Turkey sub to go was made with care and made me drool as it was being made. The super nice blond woman with the wrist tattoo made us feel like regulars. If we lived closer, I would be. read more

I changed my route to work and started passing WBB&D so I was curious, there are always cars in the lot so I figured it had to be good. Stopped in for breakfast this morning and I wasn't disappointed. Such a clean and welcoming atmosphere followed by friendly staff and great food. Definitely recommend and I'll definitely be back again! read more

West Babylon Bagels & Deli - a sandwich cut in half - Bagels Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Stopped here for breakfast the other morning. Seems to be a very busy place especially on the weekends. They have a small parking lot in the front and a small space inside. They have small bagels besides the regular size bagels. The cream cheese is homemade which all look delicious. Their vegetable cream cheese I hear is top notch! I saw that they also had rainbow bagels which are very trendy! They have lots of sandwich options and you can get them on rolls, wraps etc. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a sesame bagel. It came out to about $5.50. It wasn't my favorite but the bagels were really tasty and soft. Would totally come back again in the future! read more

Best bagels in town!! This place holds a very special place in my heart i worked there about 14 years ago I live in Florida now but they always had great food and bagels and i loved the owners treated me very good I worked for the first owners and the second owners both were great. read more

I knew this place was the real deal when I saw people lining up to the back of the store to place their breakfast orders. Look no further for you breakfast/sandwich spot because here it is. I placed an order for 4 and everyone loved their sandwich. It's hard to find true breakfast gems in Long Island so bookmark this spot. bacon egg and cheese spot on, turkey bacon egg and cheese and two bagels cream cheese. Yum. read more

BLT on a roll with salt pepper vinegar ketchup SLAPS. I love this place. Incredibly convenient and delicious. Thanks for being awesome.

I don't know but the bagels doesn't really taste that good but that's not the reason of my review the reason is I asked I need a garlic bagel doble toasted they didn't even tried plus the avocado is so dark come one not more read more

West Babylon Bagels & Deli - Bagels Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Never disappointed here, the breakfast is always fresh and tastes great...staff is very friendly as well. Prices are not bad, this is part of my weekly weekend routine. If you like cream cheese, they have a nice assortment of different tasty flavors...must try! read more

I don't know what happened to this place. they used to be so good. now, I get a bagel with cream cheese and they barely put any cream cheese on at all. I asked for veggie cream cheese the other day and I was watching her put it on the bagel and I had to ask if that was veggie bc they were NO veggies in it. then the other girl told her to scrap from the other side to get some veggies bc it was almost empty. I barely got any cream cheese let alone veggies. and this is what I got..... such a shame and they've invreased their prices too. read more

West Babylon Bagels & Deli - a half eaten bagel - Bagels Near Me - West Babylon, New York

this is the worst bagel i've ever had. one slice of cheese melted on the bagel. and it's an "everything bagel" yet there's like 3 sesame seeds. never coming here again. and the lady who helped us clearly hates her job. read more

West Babylon Bagels & Deli - the worst bagel ever - Bagels Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Good bagels, good sandwiches, friendly staff, decent coffee, always clean , would definitely recommend!

Eh.. Too hit or miss for me to be positive about this place. Maybe if they knew how to take and/or execute an order, I'd recommend it... maybe. Probably not, but maybe. The only reason I'd go here is for the convenient location when on my way to work. It's a shame because years ago when I worked near by I was there often, and not only did they get orders wrong a lot less back then, the egg sandwiches were always perfect in every way- Not anymore :( read more

I worked at this establishment, a co-worker at the company through an industrial mat that weighs 30lbs at me. I, in self defense pushed him. He's a shit brickhouse so it did nothing to him but I fell on my ass and then got fired for defending myself. The bagels are NOT made fresh there, they come in from a commissary and pretend they are fresh. Look for the bubbles on the bagels, it means it's old dough. I recommend Wellwood bagels where it is done. correctly. No stars read more

Great bagels. I have brought these bagels to friends in the city and they loved them. The staff is friendly and they make a great deli sandwich. some local deli workers look miserable that customers actually showed up. Most delis these days are cheap on the meat. There old school with like 4 inches of meat. Salad or pickle with sandwich is nice and they have a punchcard so you get a free sandwich after 10 purchases. Nice gesture. read more

I grew up on Kellum St and this was 109 Deli - Viking Farms was across the street. We stopped there on our way to the 3rd St Park Bus stop for .99 cent egg sandwiches almost every morning. If you wanted Bacon or Ham it was $1.25. I do have a confession, when we slept out during the summer in our backyards and snuck out to go pool hopping we would head up to the deli and garb a few of the Fresh Bagels the bakery dropped off...Great memories. 109 Deli, Pizza Town, Beaver Lake, The Town Pool and the Islanders winning Stanley Cups! What more could a teenage kid want. read more

Great bagels.. Good condiments.. Poor , unfriendly staff that doesn't listen to your Order. Don't expect much from the staff. read more

This place has really good bagels! And that's the end of the good for this place, they are confused and don't remember who they are helping!!! It's pretty pathetic. I ordered a toasted bagel and stood there for at least 15 minutes waiting just to see how long it took the deer in the headlights girl to figure out that it was my bagel sitting in the toaster. I finally told her to keep the bagel and paid for my drink I already opened and bounced. That happened on more than 1 occasion. Not worth standing on line unless you like to watch a bunch of confused idiots try and make people their breakfast!! read more

I used to be so thankful of this place as is was the only biz open at 4am when I was headed to work. Fast forward 6 yrs and I was back again for some breakfast goodies (although at 10am). The deli has been renovated semi-recently and is far from the dingy bagel cave it used to be. It's still just as spacious inside as it once was, but it's cleaned up and way easier on the eyes. Big shout outs to the dude working the register this morning, as he really had his A-game on. Taking my order, helpful and chatty, letting me try a few new menu items... it was not the normal deli experience (which is staring off into the tropicana aisle of the fridge until your order is ready). In a few min my food was ready and I was on my way. Easy deli experience. I'm not going to comment on the food much, bc I got a lame egg white wrap, but 6 yrs ago this place was tops for a bagel with too much cream cheese and your classic BEC. Hopefully I'll be back soon to snag one! Protip: the sriracha chicken salad I tried was solid! read more

Best bagel sandwiches around hands down! I always get my bagels here and we always stop here to bring them to family who live out of state who miss the true delicious NY bagels. read more

Their bagels are mighty fine and service is consistently pleasant and prompt. Why don't they place tables on the lawn and spruce that spot up a bit with a garden? read more

I have been going to this bagel place for the past 8 years and I have to say they are hands down the best Bagels around. The flagels and bialeys are amazing. You know you have a good bagel because the boil and bake them plus use real onions. Try the salads they make a cranberry walnut chicken salad that was really delicious!!!!! read more

Anytime I visit my buddy in the area, I always hit Bagelicious in the morning. They seem to be always busy but with good reason, the can make a mean breakfast sandwich. They also have your usually deli items that look good but I seem to only make it here for breakfast. read more

Worst customer service, hang up phone when trying to place an order very unprofessional

I go here in the mornings on my way to work. I prefer this one compared to another bagel shop that I won't mention by name in the area that is...not somewhere I will be going back to. But I digress lol, lines move quickly, food is fresh and they always get my order right. I love the different flavored coffees and did I say quick service? That is so important especially when I am short on time. They might not be super chipper but that's ok by me...because let's face it I'm not always Suzy Sunshine especially before I've had my coffee. They are polite enough and never rude! I once brought my son with me and the person behind the counter was very patient while he counted the money to give to her. Prices are fair as well. I'm sure I'll be going back soon. read more

Best bagels in town! the past few days there has been an older gentleman working there and its been so pleasant to go in and actually have someone greet you-typically the workers just stand there and don't say a word. The whole place was re-done recently and is clean and modern. read more

Best bagel store ever. Great food excellent service. Denise is excellent goes out of her way to give the best service ever!!!!!!

The place is a little dirty. Can use a thorough cleaning. The staff isn't too friendly. They actually seem miserable most of the time. They forgot to put ketchup on my eggs a couple times. That being said, they're the best in the area. Bagels and sandwhiches are 4 or 5 star! read more

BEST BAGELS EVER! They have every type of bagel you can imagine. And you can get them any way you like so when it comes down to it this place crushes all competition read more

good bagels, but that's as far as my rating goes. Unfriendly staff, there's always a line out the door because their service is so slow. They seem to care about talking to eachother more than listening to the customers order. I'm always asked 3 times "what did you order?" "Was that butter or cream cheese?" "How did you want your coffee?". I passed by it today and went right into Bagel Creations up the block. Was in and out in 1 minute and my order was correct. Won't be coming back to this dump again. read more

JUST LOOK UP AT THE CEILING when you walk in the door at the vents And then think of all that dirt going all over your food ! The place is filthy . Got coffee was going to get something to eat until I saw that . Maybe some people don't care about cleanliness ? read more

The food/bagels are really good. Much praise to the guys cooking in the back. However, the front of the house, not so good. They constantly talk among themselves, instead of staying on top of their orders, which then causes confusion on who ordered what. Also, the one girl who has been working there a while with mousy brown hair, is so rude to female patrons, but friendly to male patrons. Hmmmm. Her attitude is horrible and maybe should not be working in a place that opens so early because she's a bit cranky. I have since decided to no longer go in there and to take my business elsewhere because such a bad attitude at the start of the day is not how i want to kick off my long day ahead. Sucks, because again, the food is delicious. read more

The best bagels around. Went in at 11 am and got hot bagels. Line out the door but moved fast. Very friendly staff. Undergoing a remodel and looks terrific so far. read more

Worst experience in a bagel place ever. No one in the place about 6 employees all confused about who was taking our order. All of them a bit rude. Made us pay before the order was even made to find out thee were no rolls to make the sandwich I ordered or any kind of sandwich for that matter. At 145pm? So I paid for a sandwich they couldn't even create. The only thing they had was white bread or wraps. Change the name to just bagels and not deli if you can't execute proper deli sandwiches. Part of our order was a simple egg bagel with cream cheese. Cream cheese wasn't even spread and bagel wasn't event cut in half. The Babylon sandwich on a wrap - chicken cutlet. Melted muenster, and bacon. Cheese wasn't even melted. Definitely will not be coming to this place again. read more

great bagels. what gives it only 2stars is the cleanliness factor. every time i've been in the people behind the counter wear the plastic gloves but keep them on while taking and giving money and don't change them before touching food. yuck. read more

I've been going to this bagel store since the original owner opened it up. BEST EGG SANDWICHES EVER!! Bagels are delicious too. I'm giving it 4 stars cause I now live in Florida, Orlando to be specific and can't find a GOOD bagel store, believe it or not, and I was on Long Island a few weeks ago. My daughter loves egg bagels and will only eat the ones from this bagel store so I placed a TO GO order, WHICH I PREPAID, on the first day of my trip, to pick up on my way off of Long Island cause I wanted to make sure I got LOTS of egg bagels for my little girl. Went to pick them up and they never prepared the PREPAID ORDER?? WTFudge? Seriously? Not a good business practice - they should've been prepared and ready to go since I paid for them days prior. Luckily they had what I ordered and put it together quickly, (they always give MANY EXTRAS when you order by the DOZEN. Could've been a disaster. GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER GUYS, PLEASE :) OH, and could you change your YELP page and PLEASE ADD YOUR STORE HOURS so people know when you open & close. Thanks :) read more