Walking into a restaurant at 12:30 in the afternoon and no one is in there is a red flag. But was excited to try under new management. This is so disappointing. This place used to have great wings. Very little crisp, good size, but taste, well there was very little. If this is hot I don't know what the mild would taste like. And the mango habanero is all mango no habanero . Sauce to wing ratio was more like a dry rub than any sauce on the wing. Wife got a cheeseburger sub. Dry roll and not much to the sub. The waitress came out and got our drinks, then our order, then brought our food, then MIA. My wife wanted more ice tea but could not find the waitress. Had to get another waitress to get our bill and a to go cup of tea. My favourite part was the Spanish rap music coming out of the kitchen. Rap is bad enough but Spanish rap is worse. Only reason they did not get a one star review was because the fries were good and they finally accept credit card. read more

Westgate Restaurant and Lounge - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

If lousy service, terrible food, and surly ownership is what you're after, then head on in to Westgate. First we had to grovel to get drinks. Two bartenders and small Sat afternoon crowd and still had to wait forever. Glass empty? Good luck. Staff will walk right by over and over again like you're invisible. Chicken wings were cold. And we got treated to watching the owner harass a female patron. Never again. read more

If your not already a fan, give this a try. Im sure you will become a regular. Its clean and friendly. Try the pizza. go home happy.

I use to live a couple blocks down the road from here and every pay day was take out night from Westgate. My go to was the Stromboli and wings. Was there not too long ago one night with coworkers to grab a few drinks at the bar and we split a stromboli. It's still holds up but the bar is getting run down. The restaurant side is still nice on the inside. The bar is cash only, need to update the bar. read more

My husband and I have this ongoing conversation about little locally owned joints that have been around forever and how they have to have something good that keeps them in business despite competition and chains with brand recognition. We walked into Westgate on a Saturday night, around 8, with low expectations and high hopes. There weren't very many people in the dining room. The menu looks really old school. Still we walked in with what we would be having in mind and ordered just that despite being tempted by numerous options on the menu. We wanted chicken wings and pizza. I'm a wing traditionalist- I like a medium buffalo sauce- and my husband prefers the weird stuff. I won this night and we got the buffalo. We also ordered a medium pizza with half mushrooms and half sausage and sautéed onions. I then later ordered some pierogies because carbs are yummy. The wings came out first and looked really good. Saucy. The way I like them. They appeared to have some kind of dredge on them but it was light and helped the sauce cling and gave them a little extra crispiness. We devoured them. They were absolutely delicious. I asked for celery but I guess our server didn't hear me because we didn't receive any. Our pizza came out a little smaller than I expected but it looked amazing as our server set it down on the table. The crust was puffy and my perfect shade of golden brown. The division of toppings was a little muddled but that was fine too. It was nice that when I picked up a slice to eat it, the slice could support it's own weight and didn't droop disappointingly. The cheese blend was delicious. As was the sauce. I am still talking, days later, about the amazing crust. It wasn't just a bland base for the toppings. It had flavor and character that I really enjoyed. The pierogies were clearly Mrs T brand but they were cooked with butter and onions and I enjoyed them. Our server told us she was new but she got answers to our questions and kept our cups topped up with Diet Coke. The prices were low. We received great service and we really enjoyed the food. I actually just asked my husband when we can go back for some more wings. read more

See all

Have been going to westgate over 20 yrs. Yes the Stromboli and pizza are good. When you phone in an order good luck getting what you want, the way you ordered your food. 5 times in the past yr my order was not correct. There have been many times the phone will ring well over 20 times before someone answers. Was not like until the past 2 or 3 yrs. read more

I tried to call in my order. I called twice . They didn't pick up the phone. So I work close by and I just stopped in: they were not busy and took my order quickly. Order came out fast. I got the order back to work and it was cold. ( cheese not melted) meat was Luke warm. After I heated it up it had good flavor. The value for what I paid for was very reasonable. Service was friendly and professional. They have a nice selection on their menu. They even offer a children's menu. The worst thing Is that they only take CASH. Maybe that is why their menu is good value. This place has been around for many years. They must be doing something right. read more

Keep in mind I only went to the bar portion located on the side end of the building, and I am comparing this to like bars. But its a small town bar, usual everyday people taking the edge off. Karaoke can be entertaining to watch. Fist walking in for really do not expect the layout to have a somewhat balcony level inside. All the usual domestics are on tap with a to go cooler as well. Usually there is a decent to good craft beer option or two on tap as well. Price are pretty good and I have never really been disappointed. The wings are tasty in my opinion only rivaled by the Kadillacs in york haven. There is an ATM inside, or go to the rutters near by for a fee free atm. They do only take cash, but I get it. Never felt unsafe in the place. But if your looking for a low key stop for a few brews and bar food this is a good option. read more

Please update your hours on yelp. We arrived at 11pm only to find out that food is not served after 11pm and you close at midnight. Incredibly disappointing and upsetting. read more

I wish I didn't like this place. It's definitely highly caloric. It's a hole-in-the-wall. Yet it has memories. After work in 1998, my best friend and I would pop in for pizza, wings, beer... all the good bad stuff. As years past we developed more sophisticated tastes... but man, there's just something about a big greasy pizza after a rough day, isn't there? I just wish that the jukebox had new music from when I worked across the street in 1998. Not kidding you, it's 90% the same! read more

Pizza is ok if you like a real heavy dense dough. Subs are above average (for the area). In a pinch, not bad overall.

I've been looking forward to getting back out to the bar scene since the pandemic. I went here previously without concern (during the pandemic)- ordered wings up to midnight and drank until 1 or 2am. I tried to order wings at 11:05, was denied as the kitchen closes at 11 now?... At 11:38pm, last call was announced. Despite their sign saying open until 2am, it was clearly different. We are taking an Uber to Chilis to finish the night. read more

Only reason I gave them a 1 star is because no stars wasn't an option. Paid 3 dollars for a cover charge on a Friday. J knew they were busy but was told by door attendant if I sat upstairs a waitress would be by to place food and drink order. Waited 8 minutes no attempt was made. So now myself and a friend are out our cover charge and had to stop somewhere else for food. Definitely will not be back. read more

Best Stromboli around! Have been eating here for years! I have never had a bad experience! Highly recommend this place! read more

Westgate Restaurant and Lounge - Best Stromboli around! - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Had a group of friends over and ordered delivery from Westgate. Was told 45 minutes. After 2 hours we were concerned (not to mention hungry) so we called to check status. Turns out order hadn't even left the store yet, after two hours !! Manager was indignit and could have cared less. He launched into some speech a out serving in the military? Really??? We just wanted our food. As mentioned, we had guests over and very hungry kids. Needless to say we called a national chain because at least we knew we would get our food. We would have really appreciated them being upfront with us when we ordered regarding how long it would take. Again Mr Manager, claimed that he would never be dishonest because he served in the military, but telling someone 45 minutes and not even leaving the store after 2 hours certainly isn't good business. Also note, this is the second time Westgate did something like this. Last time they did get the food to us, albeit after 1hr 45 min. We will not order from again. read more

This bar is dark and stank. I like the dark, cause you can see less stank. The clientele on this fine Friday night is the age range of 40-65. Most are wearing bandannas or nascar hats. There is a middle aged woman getting dry humped by a much older drunk dude across the bar. Next to me is a super loud racist chick talking shit on "the blacks". I cannot believe she has not gotten thrown out yet for just being a dick. My beer is good but my dirty glass is not. I looked at the menu, or at least tried to but it is laminated and is so greasy it kept slipping out of my hands. I wish I brought my hand sanitizer with me. I saw a decent selection of bar foods, the norm, before I had to put the menu down for fear of getting hepatitis. Anyways...I give two stars for the fact that the beer is cold and they have a nice bartender lady. She is well dressed, polite and efficient. Oh yeah...the music? Sucks. Listening to a hip hop mixed version of Folsom Prison. Cash is rolling over in his grave. One last thing. Cash only. In 2013. Really?? read more

Westgate Restaurant and Lounge - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

The restaurant food and selections and prices are impressive ! The service / systems however are not. I have eaten in the restaurant as well as had food for take out and have had food in their ashtray ( aka bar ) and flat out the food is good. If you don't mind your hair / clothes stinking of an old smoking jacket do not set foot in the bar area! ( unfortunately you have to go in there to get / pay for late night food ) . Yes, this place is from the 1900's and they stayed there! You may find some modern amenities like bands with electric guitars and amplifiers but you can't use your credit / debit card, because who carries cash today other than your grandparents ? read more

Being a smoker it is great to have a place to go with friends for dinner and drinks and be able to have a cigarette without having to go outside in the elements! I know a lot of people complain about the smokiness but if you are not a smoker and do not want a smoky enviornment, pick a non smoking place to hang out! Simple as that! It is a "dive bar" but I have never left there disappointed in my evening. Always a great time there. They have the best stromboli in town and the wings are to die for! Great selection of beer and also offer 6 packs to go. If you are looking for a cheap fun night out, go to Westgate!! read more

Just around the corner from Regal Cinemas, this is a good choice for pre- or post- movie watching. Entire restaurant is smoking - which for us was the only downside. They have an adequate selection of beers - most are domestic, and 2/3 are light, but I had a Bass and my friend had a Blue Moon. They also offer amazingly tasty pizza for a very low price - we each had a beer, and split a medium pizza, and the tab was $11- The same as you'd spend for a medium soda and popcorn at the theater. Two thumbs up on this place! Cheap tasty food, conveniantly located, and you can get Pizza and Beer at the same place. read more

Went here one time with my husband and friends. We all got wings. Both my husband and I got physically sick that night into the following morning. Maybe old fryer oil? I will never go back after that. read more

This place only accepts cash. Good to know ahead of time. They make a great mushroom pizza and regular Stromboli. My kids love their plain cheese pizza. Bathroom is clean, it's kid-friendly, and service is fantastic. There's a rubber ducky claw machine inside. Everyone is a winner every single time! read more

Great wings, jumbo not the pigeon wings like other places, pizza, stromboli best in York, subs are a great value for the price. Micro brew beer is a plus. Stop in and make new friends. They alwalys have great specials. Thanks for the great times. read more

Westgate Restaurant and Lounge - This place is just like this. - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Don't ever go to Westgate restaurant with the large party. There were 10 of us and it took over an hour and a half for us to get our food. We ordered clams and sides, it was ridiculous. There were only four other people in the restaurant and they tried telling us they were slammed. Will never be going back! read more

I've eaten here since I was a kid. 20+ years. The last 3 times I've eaten here.. No joke.. there was hair in my food. Baked in to srromboli. Dangling over a plate of hot wings. Baked into a slice of pizza. They have such amazing food and I love the servers, but they need to start wearing hair hats in the kitchen. Mgmt, please contact me. read more

Ah..the Good 'ol Westgate lounge where everyone knows your name and they are so glad you came so you can buy them a beer. BTW, I also met my ex here, so that should sum it up, lol! read more

This place definitely caters to smoking clientele. Went to see the Love Haters here, there was a $4.00 cover charge. Great band but very small venue for dancing. There was no table service, but was able to get Tanqueray and tonic promptly from a packed bar from a friendly, efficient bartender. There is a second floor balcony area that would possibly give respite from the pervasive smoke, but we elected to leave after the second set. There is a restaurant area in the front, the lounge is a side entrance. read more

Westgate is split into two places: pizza shop in the front and lounge around the side. The food here is great, all the wing sauces are made from scratch, they have some of the best fish and chips I've had, and the pizza is really good. If you're looking for a great local dive bar, the smoking lounge is honestly one of the best I've been to in my travels across almost all 50 states. The drinks are cheap and the bartenders are friendly and know how to mix an awesome drink. All in all, Westgate is definitely worth a visit. read more

Every now and then I just crave a cold beer in a frosty mug and some hot wings. I will NOT, I repeat not settle for anything less then Westgate wings. Sure the restaurant isn't exactly impressive, but for these wings... I will deal with it. Trust me, over the years I've tested many and to date have not found anything that compares!! read more

westgate has the best wings and pizza and their subs are pretty great too! there are two parts of this place - the restaurant side which faces kenneth road and the lounge side that faces the side of the rutters. the lounge (aka bar) is extremely smoky but i believe the restaurant side is non-smoking. great prices, excellent food, good service....love it! read more

I have been here many times....the only gripe I have is they don't let you pay by credit. Unless that has changed in the last year? But the Stromboli is the BEST ever!!! The pizza isn't bad but the boil....mmmm read more

Best wings (I wasn't a wing fan til trying Westgate's), pizza and stromboli in York! Dough made fresh daily. Stop in to enjoy theur friendly atmosphere and great service. read more

Going downhill ! Got their signature stromboli to go, got home, it was raw underneath. Called them, they said bring it back. Of course, not driving 20 minutes back at 9 pm. They apologized but didn't offer a credit or anything. I tried to bake it but it was still awful and additionally had large/wide strings of onion inside (like the outer layers you throw away). Not going back. read more

Best wings, tacos and stromboli in town! Staff is very friendly and welcoming! Bar is smoking but still have a good time on karoke nights! Overall I enjoy coming to this place! CRABBY PRETZELS AND CRAB DIP ARE AMAZING! read more

place use to be great back then pizza now is very gross how can they sell it i don't know the wings have breading on them which makes them soggy don't go here the tacos on Sundays are 1 dollar the meat is not ground beef what so ever i left them sit eat at the bar because the guy in the dinning room is a smart ass and rushes a person out they need to get rid of him but it isnt going to happen because hes probably part of the family that owns it read more

I liked the bar, but the bartender was too involved in the customers conversation. And wanted to judge people. And I'm putting it nicely!!!!! read more

This was the worst bar service I have ever seen. The bartender was rude and very arrogant. It was all about him not the customers. I waited and waited and waited while he smoked a cigarette before I could get a drink. I would not recommend this place. read more

Westgate Restaurant near the West Manchester Mall in York is one of those places with good food that you forget delivers. My family and I have recently started ordering over the phone and having food delivered from there on the weekends. The staff is very friendly and the delivery time is faster than most pizza places. The food has been excellent every time we have ordered so far. The only thing I wasn't impressed with was the size of the kids drink, beyond that I love this place. read more

If I could give negative stars I absolutely would. To be fair though, if you are a regular and are there to drink, you must think it's five star; you don't get flagged, drink what you want, it's perfect. If, however, you happen upon this place with a friend, than I'd say turn around, there are WAY BETTER places within a few miles, it's not worth your time, or money. The fact that I'm even wasting my time on a review relates to the fact that, not only myself, but my DD, were both 'flagged' with our aforementioned friend. The bartender decided that since our friend was intoxicated and should be flagged (correct assessment, in her defense) that myself, and DD should also be flagged. Please, keep in mind 'regular' customer, who (at this point) can barely form complete sentences, it's still being served. I will be meeting with the manager and hopefully owners at some point tomorrow. My frustration reaches beyond simply being annoyed or angry for being flagged. As a past server/bartender myself, I am reviewing this in an attempt to raise awareness, if at the right bar you can drink yourself to death, if at the wrong bar you will remain thirsty... either way it's BAD business. #lcb read more

this place is a cigarette smoke jungle good lord my eyes were burning ,the next day my throat was sore ,sinus stuffed up and headaches. good god get some dam smoke eaters read more