I was home visiting my parents and decided to try Whistle Stop in Mt Top since I've heard good things and it looked legit from pictures. Holy sh-t balls! I was blown away happy with it. Thin crust and crushable, but still sturdy with substance to it. The cheese/traditional sauce was flavorful and outstanding right out of the oven piping hot. I got half pepperoni, but in my opinion this pizza is so good it needs no help with toppings. Next time I will stick to a plain cheese pie and might try the sweet sauce. I highly recommend skipping the takeout if you can and eating this there in their cozy restaurant right out of the oven. Perfection. For context, I'm a pizza snob and tough grader. My local faves are Sabatini's and Pizza L'Oven in Exeter pending what style I'm in the mood for. Whistle Stop was outstanding and every bit as good as the best NEPA has to offer. I'm not a score guy, but if pushed it was easily 9 out of 10. On the Portnoy scale, I bet he would give it mid 8's. Maybe upper 8's or better. read more

Our favorite pizza in Mountain Top! Crust is perfect everytime and love the diced onions. Call ahead and ask for wait times as they get pretty busy and sometimes you have to wait a little longer than they say. But worth it. read more

We ordered a pie to go. The ordering, wait time, and pick up were quick and smooth. Priced fairly as well. The pie was everything a person would want in a good basic pizza. We ordered it plain, and we were greatly surprised at the taste, quality and crust. I usually dont eat the crust, but this was delicious! We will certainly be back and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it! read more

This place is awesome. Their pizza is extremely good & very underrated. They deserve a One Bit review. read more

Whistle Stop Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Top, Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in the area. I won't order anywhere else. Pizza crust is nice and thin and crispy with lots of cheese and a savory sauce. Their Chicken wings are better than any others. They are meaty and crispy. The restaurant is small but very cozy and cute with the trains running above you. The service is sometimes slow for pick up orders. Sometimes I had to wait 15 minutes to get my order. They are very busy, especially on Friday and Saturday. Sue Harding read more

This is a very tiny, cute little pizzeria! Inside it is loaded with neat, art, and trains. We got a meat pizza, it was delicious. We got a side of french fries that were golden and crispy. The service was good and the bonus is you get to get your own refills. read more

See all

After being recommended by several friends, I recent decided to try Whistle Stop. I must say, the pizza is delicious and very friendly service. If your looking for a tasty pizza and your in mountaintop, stop in! read more

Whistle Stop Pizza - Plain large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Top, Pennsylvania

See all

Great pizza; but cash only payment which makes it inconvenient. Very nice people who manage it.

Probably the best pizza next to Kings. Wings are really good too. Small little place that is probably overlooked with great food.

Whistle stop pizza is amazing, best pizza in mountain top, you need to order a large pie with extra sauce best pie it's like a flavor explosion in your mouth. Wings are good as well read more

Small cash only pizzeria in Mountaintop, PA. Small menu but with a good specialty pizza selection. Also have great crispy wings and fries. About 10 booths and tables. No alcohol sold here. I hate giving great reviews because then the places I like get too busy. But this place have a plus pizza game. BTW don't expect fast service, food is made to order. read more

Whistle Stop Pizza - Whistle Stop Special, mushrooms, peppers, sausage and pepperoni. A+ - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Top, Pennsylvania

See all

Still our FAVORITE pizza! AND they make the BEST wings, according to my son! (Cash only) no credit cards. read more

The pizza is outstanding. For a more widely-known comparison, picture a larger Grotto Pizza with tastier sauce. The wings are always fresh and crispy with a delicious, light hot buffalo sauce. A basket of fries is more than an entire table would ever need. Very friendly staff, really gives you a sense of the 'local pizza place.' Oh, and they're cash only, of course. read more

Not only the Best Pizza on the Mountain but definitely best in Northeastern PA! Classic tomato pie style pizza. They put the cheese down first then a swirl of delicious sauce! Crust is always crisp and heavenly. Specialty pies are great too; White, White\Broccoli, & 4 Seasons (family favorite, very yummy!). Wings are dynamite too! Extra large in size and really meaty, plus fried to perfect crisp; we love to order them extra crispy! Highly recommend the Hot or BBQ sauces. Super friendly family run business + great service whenever we stop in. read more

Oh how I love this pizza! The sauce is amazing, the crust is beyond words, and the staff are always super kind.

Nice quiet place, good Pizza, wings and other Italian American style foods. The pizza crust was an excellent thin crust and the wings were moist and crisp. The wait staff was limited and slow but not overly so. Over all a nice little place to grad a bite. read more

Whistle Stop Pizza - Whistle Stop Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Top, Pennsylvania

Very greasy pizza . This is the worst place on the Mountain for pizza . Giving it star is generous. Services is lacking .

Great pizza. Always got takeout, never ate in. Would give 4 stars, but they don't serve beer. Very friendly staff. Worth trying.

I really like the chicken wings -- nice and crisp, perfect sauce. Our daughters loved to watch the toy trains setup. It was great for family dine out occasions. read more

I love this pizza.. My family has a summer home in this area and we order pizza every once and while and this is the only place I get it from. Def worth it. read more

We order from Whistle Stop every now and again (maybe every two months or so) when looking from a change from our usual spots. Very consistent...nothing earth shattering...just a good, solid pie. read more