First and foremost, especially for the out-of-towners, THIS PLACE IS CASH ONLY. Yes they have an atm but you should know this before you walk in, unlike myself. With that said this still should've been a five star experience if not for a couple tiny hiccups. First off, I started off drinking at their bar and bottle shop across the parking lot. In fact, I was going to get a pizza over there, except I wanted to be all healthy and get a salad as well, which was not offered on the limited, pizza and snacks only menu available at the bottle shop. I closed my tab and walked across the parking lot only find a very interesting set up of a to go area very much separated from a sit down only restaurant. Quickly figured out I need to be in the to go area, where I was able to get a draft beer while I waited for my pizza and salad to go. Luckily I asked for a min to settle my tab as I wanted a can to take with me, at which point I found out about the cash only aspect. Last part of slight disappointment resided in the fact that they let me sit there with an empty glass without telling me my pizza was ready, until I finally went to the counter and they asked if I was ready to go. Uh yeah I was actually. By the time I go back to the hotel 14 minutes away, the pizza had gotten cold and required reheating. Fortunately, it was good enough that even with the reheat, revealed itself to be one hell of a pizza. Subtract another fraction of a point for not putting any plastic silverware for my salad. By the way, salad was fine, but pizza slaps. read more

Welcome food believers to another review video. Today I am at Sabatini's Pizza in Exeter Pa where I ordered a cup of chili which has a little spice to it, it was a meaty chili where even though it had a little bit of heat behind it, their chili is delicious. Now I also ordered their cauliflower crust pizza with the veggie toppings, they have an amazing cauliflower crust, but I have learned you have to eat it there, unlike the regular crust. As you can see this pie was packed full of those healthy vegetables. The crust was nice and thin, normally I am not a crust person, but I like how sab's does there's. Whether it's a plain or specialty pie sab's pizzas are simple and delicious. They are a cash only place with an ATM on sight. Definitely recommend if you have never been here before. Until next video, be blessed and stay safe. Watch Our Food Review on YouTube 3.20.2026 @ 12 AM https://youtu.be/OcICpevUV3Q Visit them online for their menu items https://www.sabatinis.com read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Cauliflower Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

The best Pizza in Northeastern Pennsylvania is always a big debate, much like the best cheesesteak in Philadelphia. There are many different versions of pizza style in NEPA and everyone has their favorite and think it's the best. I've been a Sabatini's fan since childhood and make an effort to go there whenever I'm back in the area. If you are looking for an old-fashioned family run pizza parlor with a modern touch, with a unique thin crust, savory sweet sauce on top of the cheese, you'll be in heaven. Great selection of beers in the Bottleshop and Bar Nextdoor. read more

If you're looking for solid pizza spot this is the one. They had so many different craft beers and their tap room was huge! They even had a store full of craft beers you could take home at reasonable prices. Their pizzas are great. We tried their plain which was like a sweet sauce and the buffalo chicken. Both were great! read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

See all

Love this place for their vast selection of interesting beers and great wait staff. Sadly the pizza isn't so great and that's the only food they have. read more

We Drive up from Allentown, PA on a weekend ( 1 hour drive ) about every 6 weeks to visit relatives and get pizza / refreshments. We like our pizza with extra sauce and this place provides a perfect pizza every time! The beer selection is fantastic and the bourbon selections are second to none. The young lady who waits on our table is great! Can't wait to go back in mid April. Only constructive feedback is the seats at the tables. You are sitting on a metal chair / metal frame. . It would be nice if they put cushions on those seats. read more

Old school pizzeria with massive beer list. The smell, the taste, the wooden booths are all a time capsule to be cherished. This is an institution and worth traveling for. Canned mushrooms is another plus. read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Mushroom medium - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

The pizza here is just amazing from the crust, cheese, to the sauce everything about it is just perfect! Nice atmosphere with adequate lighting! Great mixture for a great pie! Keep up the great service Lindo!! read more

Awesome service and food. We waited at a previous restaurant for 1 1/2 hours and never got order taken or glasses for were given. We got here, they sat us and took or our order and we had our food quthb1t minutes. So pleased and food was delicious. ​​ read more

Great selection and wonderful service. The atmosphere is and always has been very clean and comfortable

I ordered my wife's and I favorite pie. Large x sauce onions and hot peppers!!!I have a bad knee and when I arrived I called and they graciously brought it out to me. Love you guys!!! Joe G and Linda read more

Really cool casual place to get a lengthy menu of different beers from craft, seasonal, and specialty. The outdoor patio is a good choice when the weather permits but the indoor has a dark, woodsy and intimate feel even though the place is rather large. Enjoy pizza from their restaurant next door or just drinks. This place is 21 up only (if I'm not mistaken) and also has a large selection of brews you can purchase to take home. Service is always great. I ordered the Italian Greyhound which is a martini and contrary to the typical greyhound they add some elderflower liquor, absinthe and an orangey gin. Wish there was a garnish to elevate the drink but it was pretty good and I enjoyed it! read more

See all

Always a good pie if you like sweet sauce. I agree with Dave Portnoys review when he had it a few years ago.

Visiting from Oklahoma, I stopped in and ate with my family and it was wonderful. I ate here a few times over the last 2 decades and it is always consistent and memorable. Will come here anytime I visit! The sauce is amazing and wings are perfect. read more

Service is terrible. Food changed. Take out is awful. I called to complain after spending $92 on pizza be basically be told that I was wrong and they were right. Well Sabs, look at this picture and I should have taken more but didn't. I felt like you guys would do the right thing, not was I wrong! Burnt dried buffalo bites with fries in them( the fries were not ordered) read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Burnt dried chicken bites, with French fries in them. - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

I don't really ever write bad reviews as I think it's often one sided and doesn't show the whole picture. However, my experience with Sabatini's was so distasteful I felt I had to. My daughter is turning two and loves pizza. We decided to book her birthday party at Sabatini's in their back room. We first called and spoke to Jay to get information on minimums and all the details. We called him back the next day and confirmed. He told us there was no further communication needed until a day or two before hand. Today, we are 8 days out from her party and decided to call once more to confirm as we already have our final count and wanted to get a cost estimate since parties are cash only. Upon calling they told us we were not booked and that they had another party booked. The same guy speaking to us acted like he had no idea what happened and had no recollection of speaking to us. Despite us knowing his name and all the previous details we spoke about. Basically we got the boot with no solution. I have 45 people RSVP'd with invites made and no backup. Mistakes happen and I believe in human error. But there was a sense of arrogance in what felt like them trying to pull one over and pin this mistake on us. This ended with the owner saying we were mistaken and his employee has worked with him for 20 years and has never made a mistake. I'm not sure how one would even respond to a claim like that. read more

I've been coming here for many years. Always a satisfying experience. I like the many choices of beers. But I usually get birch beer. Recently we had a big family party and we got a big order for take out. The pizzas were ready right on time and the order was 100% correct. The staff is friendly and very helpful. I will be back again and again. read more

I've always gone to the bottle shop for beverages but never went to the restaurant until this weekend. Pizza was good, unique. We went with light sauce on a cheese and then regular sauce with half mushrooms. The light sauce or extra cheese would definitely be how I'd order in the future. The sauce has a semi sweet taste which I do like. Ambiance... when I walked in I was kind of shocked how the more "modern" exterior doesn't really match the interior. I felt like the interior was something I'd see while living in Oklahoma for a bbq place, not a pizza place in NE PA. Service was good, it's cash only and you pay at the front counter. Limited menu options. read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

Yes definitely! Food is fantastic! Pizza & wings are both delicious. Beer, well, as you can guess... great!

Decent place to stop by for a slice. Nice staff,really enjoyed the . I will be back again.

Excellent beer selection on tap and in bottles. They have a selection of beers from all around the world. They also had like four or five Belgian beer towers too. Pizza was solid so was the service. Highly recommended if you like pizza and beer! read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - IPA - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

See all

One of my favorite spots. Lots of craft beer and liquor choices. Pretty sure they have quite a few good bourbons Pizza is different than anything else around. Thinner crust. Absolutely delicious. In the warmer months the outdoor seating area is great. Highly recommended read more

Casual atmosphere. Always great food and good service! Veggie pizza a must. And so much variety in drinks I can never decide. read more

See all

Lots of seating, lots of parking. Service is superb. This is by far the best pizza in the area. Their beer list is amazing, lots of stuff you can't find anywhere else. If you love craft beer and pizza, this is your spot. read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - Large pie with sausage and jalapenos - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

Probably best pizza you'll find in Pa plus they are quick and it is delicious!! and the place looks so cool.and the service was very quick And nice read more

The place is SO dated. Needs a refresh. I'm sure it USED to be Good... but the pre-cooked discs and the baked on sauce & cheese doesn't cut it. Spin fresh pies, and use better dough, or just give it up. read more

Went there for wings Took 15 mins to c the waitress Ordered 4 orders of wings they came out so over cooked could barely eat them. Told waitress she could care less..never again read more

See all

I had a great experience at Sabatini in Trastevere! If you are looking for a classic Roman meal in a beautiful setting, Sabatini is the place to be. With its option of outdoor seating, I was able to eat right in the center of Piazza di Santa Maria, watching the crowded streets and viewing a gorgeous fountain in front of an even prettier church. The food was fairly standard. I would say the meal met my expectations, but didn't exactly exceed them. I ordered Tonnarelli cacio e pepe -- a dish I order often at many different restaurants in Rome. The meal was super flavorful, creamy, and had just the right amount of pepper. The pasta could've been a little more firm, given that cacio e pepe is traditionally cooked al dente, but overall it was really tasty and consistant in each bite. This restaurant achieved an aestetic vision of an old-school and elegant setting. Red chair cushions pop out against the white table cloths. It feels a little fancy but still relaxed. This meal helped me understand how simple some of the dishes are in Italian food culture. Just pasta, cheese, and pepper was able to be prepared deliciously for my cacio e pepe meal. I also can see how important the location is, as I am sure this restaurant's popularity is credited to its outdoor area that allows customers to feel as though they are not missing out on the excitement of the night in the piazza. read more

Best pizza in the world. Nothing like it. Family place on one side of property and beer bar/bottle shop on the other. Can easily eat a whole tray myself. service is always good. read more

This is the first rant regarding a business I have ever made, but I am angry over the treatment my family recieved by Lindo Sabatini, the owner of Sabatini's Pizza in Exeter. I have been a customer of Sabatini's Pizza in Exeter for over sixty years, almost as long as they have been in business, and before Lindo the current family owner was born! As a matyer of fact it WAS my favorite pizza place! My guess given my experience with the current owner Lindo Sabatini is he won't care! Our family booked a birthday party, on March 13th. for my granddaughter on April 12th. When we called to confirm the number of people attending we were told they didn't have a reservation for us and there was nothing they could do, since they were overbooked. We sent invitations to forty-five people, some from other states traveling to the party. I called the restaurant to speak to Lindo Sabatini the owner, and when he answeered I asked if I was speaking to Lindo Sabatini and after five requests he finally said yes, even before I told him why I was calling.. When I explained our situation his answer was his employee, Jay has worked for him for twenty years and " has never made a mistake on a reservation". He then told me it was Friday and he was very busy! His arrogance was inexcusable. His suggestion that we did not make a reservation for this party was reduculas at best. When we made the reservation, we were told we could call a day before with a final count. We were also told we could show up a half hour before our three o'clock reservation to decorate. Jay (him employee) also told us we were not to put up anthing on the walls. We called a week in advance, not a day, to confirm head count and get an estimated costs since they only accept cash. Fortunately, we called a week ahead of the party given the problem. If we called the day before as suggested we would be in trouble with forty guests coming to the restaurant. Most of all, after sixty years of patronage, to have the owner, Lindo Sabatini refuse to one, acknowledge who he was, and two tell me "it's Friday and he was too busy", and then tell me his employee of twenty years "never made a mistake", was beyond reasonable. At the very least, he should have acknowledged what was clearly a mistake. I understand that mistakes happen, but Lindo Sabatini's arrogance was not only inexcusable but an indication of lack of concern for a customer, let alone a lifelong customer. We now have to scramble for a new site for the party and contact everyone attending. Frankly, even if I were a first time customer I would expect better treatment. Having been the owner of a small food service business my response would have been, I'm sorry we made a mistake. what can I do to make it right! But instead Lindo Sabatini chose to blame us, a loyal customer after what was clearly a mess they caused! I am certain this post will not put Sabatini's out of business and that is not my mission, but I hope it will help Lindo get his act together! read more

Never a disappointment! My family's favorite is the vegetarian special with whole wheat crust. Love the oven taste. Enjoy it with some birch beer. The leftovers are even delicious heated up. Been coming here since the '80's. Perfection! read more

Outstanding pizza and wings!!!! Get the butter garlic wings with a side of hot sauce!!

There aren't words for how amazing this place was .. but here I go anyway. Upon walking in you get the scent that floats you to your booth as you drool in anticipation of what your future will hold. Being from out of state, I wasn't sure what I was about to bite into. Little did I know that my life would be changed forever. It was like the ultimate left swipe, zodiac match of the pizza world. Saucy, crispy, and most importantly flavorful! I still dream of this pizza and nothing ever compares. It's like I'm left with an emptiness in my heart that only this place can fill. One day soon, we shall meet again read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - The cheese pizza of my dreams - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

Takeout pizza done well! There's always a line out of the door for take out pizza at Sabatini's. We're in Dallas and there are a couple of decent pizza joints in our neighborhood, but we don't mind taking the longer trip to Sabatini's for the delicious pizza and of course all the craft beer you can get next door. We're hoping to dine in after the COVID-19 restrictions are lifted. read more

Let me first say the selection of bottles and drafts, plus liquors is top notch for our area. This review is completely about an interaction with the owner/manager. I was in today for a couple drafts, a pizza, and some to go bottles. I picked two single bottles and a four pack. The singles ended up mispriced when I got the payment receipt. Apparently the staff couldn't correct. One was $0.50 over and the other was $2.45 over. The boss came up and said they can't keep up with all the price changes and he would just pull them from my bill if that was OK. I said I'd rather you just honor the price you have marked. We went back and forth with the same chat and after he said everyone else is OK with the price not being the price he says ' what you just need $3'? So he pulls his 2inch thick(folded) wad of cash out and throws 3 bucks down and walks away. Bottom line is I'm sure he knows what he pays for the beer on his shelf. Plus, to argue with me over his mistake and 3 bucks on a $70 bill for 1 person I'm not going back. read more

Sabatini's Pizza Inc - My receipt with what I should have been charged written. - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, Pennsylvania

I'm mildly obsessed with pizza. For years now my NEPA coworkers have told me to make the trip to try the pizza up there. Sab's was "ok". Definitely came off as a pizza that you need to grow up eating to have a serious liking for. Otherwise, it's a good pie if you want a break from a normal pizza. The quick and dirty is the sauce is very sweet relative to most pies (eating it cold it almost tasted like BBQ sauce) and it's a very thin pie. Both are things I personally do not go to first. The service was terrible, the place was busy, and we saw our actual waitress two times and the second I had to flag her down. I noticed other customers doing this as well. Finally, the cash only thing is silly. There's only one reason to be cash only in 2019 and it ain't cause of visa surcharges ;) read more

See all

Hello food crew! Welcome to another edition of "Friday Night Pizza Night". Now today we are doing a takeout from a place we did a review a few years back. We are doing a takeout from Sabatini's Pizza in Exeter. Where before we had the good old plain pizza, today's show I got a medium pie with hamburger and onion. Adding hamburg and onion puts a unique spin on a pizza, also really good. Recommend everyone to check out Sabs. Thank you all for watching the shows and supporting SGW. Until our next food adventure be blessed and stay safe everyone! Good day food crew! Today's show is a continuation. Now you're probably wondering about the other video that is now showing also. See that video is when I did a takeout review showing the hamburg and onion pie. In part 2 we, the GF and I are in house trying their cauliflower pie. We started out both getting a cup of their homemade chili, now are server stated it was not spicy at all, she was wrong. This chili had a major kick to it, now if you like spicy as much as I do then you're really enjoy this, we also tried their mozzarella sticks, these were nice and hot. Now are main course is here. The cauliflower pizza. Now this was absolutely delicious! A nice crisp crust. Now the best way to eat this is in house. This is only offered as a personal pie, 8 cuts. I recommend everyone to try this pizza out. Until next week everyone, be blessed and stay safe. (Sorry no pics for this one) https://youtu.be/nSoF_is6ld4 - Medium Hamburger & Onion TO Review https://youtu.be/IPa3Owd1AUI - Cauliflower Pie Review read more

See all

Would never ever ever ever ever recommend. The food was not good to me at all. Dough tasted like cardboard and the toppings were nowhere close to fresh. I was STARVING when I got the food and still it tasted horrible to me. Tried wings and pizza and wouldn't recommend either. A regular pizza tastes like spaghetti-o's but not even name brand. I absolutely do not like leaving poor reviews and I normally don't, but this place was just too gross. Beware. read more

Wings in nothing but oil. They were disgusting! I don't recommend these at all. They were soggy as well. read more

See all

Pizza was ok but service sucks! I ordered a pizza to go. The guy taking money and getting orders was extremely rude! I didn't know it was cash only! I went to hand him my debit card and he says cash only - ATM is there! And there ATM charges a $3 fee - nice! So I got 20 bucks out and he literally ripped the 20 out of my hand. Then leaves my pizza sitting on the counter. I had to ask if this was my pizza. Never again - terrible customer service! read more