This is a great pizza joint in town. Delicious crust! We didn't know what to expect going in, but we're completely surprised.

Amazing wings and pizza! We loved the garlic pizza and the bbq wings. Cool atmosphere and great customer service. I highly recommend this place and we'll definitely be returning! read more

I called today to get pizza delivered and they don't deliver to Herriman anymore because they can't find people to do it? Are you serious? That's your excuse? That is such a disappointment. I guess they don't care in losing customers that have ordered from them since the day they opened. read more

I love the Brooklyn! SO good! I want this place to succeed and be here forever. The name is a bit confusing and it could be a touch less expensive. Even so, I can't say enough good about their pizza! Please support this fun local business! read more

Best pizza I've had since moving to Utah. They don't over do it on the sauce. Crust is thin and perfectly done. Service was great too. Will definitely be back. read more

Best NY in the valley. Rusted Sun, DeLoretto's back in the day, Big Apple, Pie Hole, I love you all for providing decent NY style in an otherwise arid pizza climate. Thank you Wicked Peel for opening in the southwest part of the valley. read more

This may be the best pizza place I've had in Utah. The classic pepperoni is amazing. It's got this fantastic seasoning on it that blows your tastebuds away! Do the right thing and go no further! read more

Best Pizza in the Intermountain West!! The crust is perfection- nice chew, crisp. Topping are top quality. The service is quick and so friendly. We just keep coming back. read more

We love to come here. The crust is so amazing I have to assume that ALL of the pizzas are delicious. We come here almost every week because we love it so much. If you want an amazing dessert try their Carmel Apple Delight! It's SO GOOD! read more

Ordered take out last night from here. Took only about 25 minutes which for a Friday night at 7pm was impressive. The Smokey pizza and cheesy garlic bread were so delicious. Definitely will order from here again! read more

Waited 2 hours for our meal, someone who didn't look like they worked there (the owner, I found out) dropped off the wrong pizza at our table and didn't check in with us (at the time we were our drinks were empty). Our server was able to eventually correct the wrong pizza... the standard crust pizza was decent, but the gluten-free crust was atrocious - a mixture of soggy/underdone and burned/black crust. I ended up telling some friends about the experience after learning they had gone their, and their time at Wicked Peel was nearly identical... but the kitchen ran out of dough and no one told them their pizza wasn't coming... read more

Owner is terrible. Pizza is okay. Will never return. Had a terrible experience, shared it with friends and then heard about their terrible experience. read more

$45 for two pizzas that were only slightly better than frozen. Rarely would I have preferred Dominoes, but here we are. I am so sad. The South end of the valley needs more places where you can get a good pie and a pitcher of beer. This is not it. read more

Stay away during the Covid 19 shut down. They were seriously backed up and the wait time was ridiculous. There were way to many people waiting inside the restaurant all together and some waiting outside too. No one would answer the phone or come outside to see who had arrived to pick up their orders. Additionally, the blond women working the counter was being SHOCKINGLY rude to the customers, talking to them like third graders. Really bad experience! read more

So tasty! I loved the New Yorker pizza and the Alfredo pizza. My husband really enjoyed his calzone. We have gone twice and intend on putting this place in our regular rotation. read more

I'm always looking for a great pizza. I drive by this place every day, tonight I stopped and ordered a pizza and was somewhat disappointed. The pizza was good, but not $24 good. Way overpriced. Save your money and order Papa John's. Taste the same for half the price read more

Quick, friendly service. The crust was thin and crispy and delicious. We had the cheesy breadsticks made with a butter garlic sauce. The garlic sauce on the Garlic Formaggi pizza was flavorful without being overpowering. They added pepperoni to it for us and it was a great alternative to the traditional red sauce. So nice to have a great pizza place in the Herriman area. read more

Seriously the best pizza within 30 miles. The first time we went in with our 18 month old son the hostess automatically brought him some grapes to eat/play with without any prompting (phenomenal customer service). The pizza is delicious made with the same cheeses the top dogs use in jersey and New York. Keep it up guys you rock! read more

The pizza is pretty good and it's a nice local spot. We've ordered take out a number of times.

Went to Wicked Peel tonight at 845pm they close at 9pm...they were so sweet and nice and happy to serve, there service was excellent and food was amazing. Thank you Wicked Peel, a great restaurant close to home read more

Came here on a Saturday afternoon with my fiancée for some lunch. The interior is very nice and clean. Good colors and their logo is pretty cool. It wasn't super busy which was nice. Our waitress Heather was super helpful and friendly. Service was really quick and everything we had was awesome. We started with the cheesy garlic bread. Probably the best garlic bread I've had. Garlicky, salty, cheesy. Aw yea. Definitely not a place to go to if you're dieting. I was a big fan of the crust on the pizza. We had the Brooklyn pizza which was very tasty. Lots of topping and we were super full with the pizza plus the appetizer for two of us. Pitchers of beer were very reasonable priced and nice and cold which is all you can ask for. We tried the strawberry shortcake which was very not overly sweet so that was perfect. A little cold for the cake but not a dealbreaker. The presentation was very pretty and the mix of strawberry and chocolate sauce on top was awesome. Overall great experience and will definitely be back to try some pasta and other sides. Highly recommend! read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

Delicious fresh pizza and attentive service! They have awesome and unique flavor combos and I've yet to try a pizza there that I didn't like. The crust is perfectly chewy and crisp and has excellent flavor on it's own. I drove out there a few Sundays ago for lunch and about cried in the parking lot not realizing it was closed on Sundays. Love Wicked Peel! read more

So happy to have found this place! We've order from them twice now, both time went beyond our expectations. Reminds me of actual NY pizza! And delivery was super fast. read more

We ordered one garlic cheese sticks and two 11" pizzas: The Smokey and Salsiccia Primo. I loved the crust, probably the best I have ever had. Both pizzas had amazing flavor. My complaint is the lack of toppings, I would love to see even a handful more of stuff! The portions size seemed to be small, but maybe with more toppings it wouldn't seem like that. The cheese sticks were amazing and the marinara had the perfect amount of yummy chunky tomato goodness! read more

Fun pizza combinations. We tried the Wicked Vodka and it had peas on it. the kids meals are reasonable and good portions. We went during an NFL football game and pleased with tons of TVs to view the game. The cheese bread sticks in the appetizer menu was very garlicky but we loved it. Reasonably priced and calm environment. Loved it! read more

I never try new places but decided to try this place after hearing friends tell me about how good it was. Entering the restaurant I was pleased to see it was clean and had a nice ambiance. The weather was beautiful so we asked to sit outside. They weren't prepared for this request but jumped to accommodate us with our kids. They were super friendly and hospitable. The food was great but the pizza really won us over! The crust is delicious and the flavor from the oven just made it amazing! I'll definitely go back! And take friends! read more

They have the best pasta and pizza. We love their vodka sauce it's amazing!!! The owners are the nicest and they have a great staff. We love this place. Everything is made from scratch. read more

Nice new place to grab a bite. Pizza is pretty good but the pepperonis were kinda of burnt. Cheese sticks were tasty enough. Staff was kind and courteous. Waitress did seem a little distracted and forgot about a refill a couple of times, nothing major but something worth mentioning. Would give it another go in a few weeks to see if they've improved and might update my review then. Still recommended on the fact that you should come out and support local! read more

The pizza here is pretty good, they use an excellent sauce and good cheese. Service is ok. Both interactions I've had with managers (once eating in and once taking home) leave a lot to be desired. They aren't rude, just not terribly helpful. As long as you don't ask for too many modifications you should be ok. read more

Decent pizza, good cheese bread an only ok wings. However, if I'm going to pay $90 with tip for 2 pizzas, 2 drinks & 2 appetizers to feed 4 Adults then it should be amazing. For the price, I was wishing that we went to The Pie. The service was great! read more

We love this place and find ourselves here regularly. It's an easy place to go with young children and they can accommodate larger parties without squishing people in. It's so refreshing to have a delicious "non-chain" pizza. read more

Really good pizza. Love the old world and Quattro. One of my new favorite pizza joints. Staff has always been great.

We called in for a large pizza and chicken wings. We were told "15 minutes"... 50 minutes later, still no food. If you're hungry, go someplace else. read more

Had lunch with friends yesterday and I was impressed!!! I am a NJ transplant with Celiac . Gluten free Pizza has been a huge disappointment until now! The crust...over cooked and AMAZING, the sauce and mozzarella smelled and tasted like I was back home. Large Beer & wine menu, staff was great! Looking forward to taking my husband & son. read more

Nice little local pizza joint! Great atmosphere and awesome pizza. Quality service and ingredients shine through!

Gross... all of it. Pizza breadsticks and fettuccine. Cold rubbery and bland. Save your time and throw your money in the trash can

The pizza is good. Best NY/NJ style pizza we have found in Utah in 10 years but......... The prices are obscene. $26.50 for take out pizza. Come on man. Cheese pizza with sliced black olives and red onion on half of it. This pizza would literally be half that price in NJ. $26.50 is ridiculous for a simple pizza.......won't be back. read more

Excellent pizza. Perfect crisp yet chewy crust. The right amount of cheese to sauce. And the tiramisu.....holy crap it's good. My only issue is service is a little slow. But the food is worth it. read more

The pizza was great, we got a couple of different flavors. Cheese breadsticks were soooooo good. Mozzarella triangles had a lot of breading. Every interaction with the staff was pleasant and we had a super attentive server. We will definitely be coming back! But I can't in good conscience give 5 stars with Pepsi products on the menu. ;) read more

Wish I could give this place ZERO stars but that option is not available. Just called there to find out if they could deliver a Detroit pizza since I saw it on their sign for months. The manager was beyond RUDE! Don't worry Mr. rude manager I will NEVER call you again to ask if you deliver or ask any other questions for that matter. I also will be sure to tell everyone NEVER to eat here. Not even sure why I tried again with this place but apparently you still don't have your act together, good luck with repeat business! read more