I have tried at least a dozen in the SEATAC area... As a native New Yorker, it's my obligation to seek out the best pie in the area. This is in the Top 3 best NY-style pizzas in the PNW. Great crust, great cheese blend. great flavor, great selection of toppings. However, I always just get the OG cheese pie, and ask for it well done cuz I like a little more char. I have ordered from this place half a dozen times, and they are ALWAYS consistent. I know what to expect. They deliver as well. Oh! And their cookies are gigantic, thin, and crispy. Check them out. read more

Wicked Pies - 18" Nice and Simple Whole Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

Easily the best pizza in town as far as I'm concerned. The salads are really good as well, and the staff is always very friendly and helpful. read more

I got here around 12:30pm on a Thursday. There were only about a half dozen people. A nice little place to get a quick slice. They had about 5-6 kind of slices ready to reheat. The slices were thin crust and folded nicely for eating while writing this review. They were a little greasy after reheating but not as bad as some chains. I would come again if I lived closer. read more

Wicked Pies - A slice of pepperoni and a slice of veggie along with a cheese stick. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Huge delicious pizza..environment wasn't my style. Bathrooms were stocked but not as clean as I like

Friendly service and we thought the food was good. My wife got the $8 special, which consisted of a slice of pizza and a Caesar salad. She liked both quite a bit. I had two slices of pepperoni and thought it tasted really good. No real complaints. The restaurant itself is nothing special inside but no real issues with dirtiness or anything falling apart. We would eat here again. read more

Wicked Pies - $8 special.... 1 slice and a Cesar Salad. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

Service is kind. The pizza we have had is pretty good. The issue is how limited the options are for on demand pizza. Very. Very Limited. The desserts are clearly an after thought. Inside has a reasonable amount of seating, although not comfortable, and it's walking distance from plenty of downtown Oly options of things to do. We did love that they have a few games to play. read more

we loved the khachapuri, really unique and new to us! the plain pizza was really good and affordable too compared to other places nearby! read more

Wicked Pies - Khachapuri (Georgian Cheese Bread) - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

This spot offers pizza by the slice, including daily specials, which works perfectly for a drop-in while tooling around downtown. When we went, it was really hot out, and they don't have a/c, but fans and a screen door kept it cool enough. Service was quick and friendly, and there was plenty of seating, although most of it was in the adjacent dining room, so if you just peek in the windows it might look like there's not much. The pizza by the slice is a little over $5, which isn't unreasonable, but I will say I've had better pizza in the greater Oly area, but not much; this was very, very good. read more

Wicked Pies - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

We stopped by Wicked Pies in Olympia and absolutely loved it! The place is super clean, cozy, and everyone there was so kind and welcoming. And the Turkish pide... wow! Honestly, we haven't had a pide this good even in Türkiye. It tasted like home -- fresh, warm, and perfectly made. Their pizza was also amazing. We left with happy hearts and full stomachs. Thank you for such a lovely experience -- we'll definitely be back! read more

Wicked Pies - Turkish Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Slices are so freaking good!! Second time here and am so pleased. Fresh everything. Nice people. It's fantastic. read more

Wicked Pies - Pepperoni and Summer Slice (so good)!! - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Wow, Wow, Wow! I'm from Brooklyn and this is the BEST NY pizza I've had in the 30 years that I've lived in WA state! SO authentically delicious! Would love a big plate of shrimp parmigiana with this delicious cheese and sauce! Thank you! read more

I haven't ordered from wicked pies in awhile. Wicked was one of my favorite places until now. Things have changed. The crust is terrible and the sause is even worse. I don't know when things changed but I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Good crust, excellent sauce, and they use the good small disk pepperoni that cup when they cook them. This was our first time in but we will definitely be back for another pie soon. See the photo for a view of our 14" double pepperoni with minced garlic. It was delicious! read more

Wicked Pies - 14" Double pepperoni with minced garlic. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

This would be a top-tier pizza -- balanced, flavorful, and executed with care. WE LOVE IT read more

Wicked Pies - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Great crust and they use fresh jalapenos. Also, excellent specialty pizzas with interesting toppings.

this place is the definition of Oly pizza. Local, fresh and friendly. I have to say this is one of the best, hands down! Ilkin is in the works of making a new addition to his amazing menu and I had the honor of being the first to try it. I have to say that the ingredients are fresh and you can taste the difference between other local pizza shops! It is very pleasant inside, good music and a comfortable atmosphere. Thank you Ilkin (I hope I am spelling your name right ) very awesome. We will be back for seconds and I suggest Oly should visit this hidden Jem. Shakir and Demetria read more

We stopped here spontaneously while visiting from out of town. The pre-made slices were actually really delicious & they toast them in the oven before serving so you still get all the crispy goodness. I tried the veggie pizza slice & my husband had two other flavors. Huge slices + good ingredients + thin crust for the win! read more

Seriously great pizza! Enough said. Just try it you won't be disappointed. We stopped for lunch and they had a great price on a lunch special which was a piece of Pizza and a salad. Truth be told I didn't go with the lunch special but I seen what others got and it look great! I choose to go with 2 slices of pizza I coUld resist! I'd definitely be back again! read more

Wicked Pies - two slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

someone named big and stinky came in and took a fat poo on my pizza don't come here if u don't want ecoli the pizza gave me ecoli and aids read more

Wicked Pies - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

Ordered a slice of pizza for about $4 bucks and some change. I was Leary when first walking in because the pizza on display appeared as if it had been sitting out and was cold. The cashier placed it in the oven to reheat it and it brought the slice to life. The pizza was hot and the cheese was quality. Loved the curled pepperoni. If ordering to go, they do not have to go boxes, but will double plate it for you. I would visit again if looking for something quick and easy. read more

Wicked Pies - Pepperoni pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Their order half a pizza to make a whole is a bit unusual. Heard good things and it was not bad pizza but seemed over priced for what it was. 3 stars IMO. read more

Wicked Pies - Half one eyed jack and half great northern. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

This place was found while looking in the area my daughter was getting her haircut. First place we walked into had no dine in. Thank god they didn't, because we found this AMAZING spot!! I can't say enough about how great these pizzas were! We will be back without a doubt!! The combinations are truly "wicked"! read more

See all

My husband and I happened upon Wicked Pies about a year ago and we cannot get enough of their pizza!

Excellent service, excellent pizza. This is definitely the best pizza I've had in Olympia by far. As a pizza snob, I'd highly recommend trying it. read more

placed an order for delivery, one item was 1/2 of an 18" pizza. $60+ for 2 items, tax, delivery, service fee, tip. Shortly after placing the order I received a call from an employee. He was very difficult to understand. No real clue what he said. Order was delivered and there was a whole pizza instead of a half. My guess is the call was about the pizza. Pizza was ok, lukewarm. Threw out the cheese bread boat with egg. Very unappetizing, especially lukewarm. A few hours later I got an email and text from Yelp about the increase in my bill via grubhub. I was being charged for the whole pizza so now my bill is $76+. I take partial blame for the inability to understand the phone call. However why is a 1/2 pizza on the menu if it can't be delivered? The food itself is not worth $76 and I won't eat here again nor will I recommend it to any friends or neighbors. read more

I have eaten at both their storefront and food truck at the Tumwater Farms Market. The pizza is absolutely delicious but it is very expensive for what you get. The crust is very thin and crispy which is awesome but it doesn't allow many substantial toppings, leaving you still hungry after a slice. I ordered a slice for 4.50 and although delicious was very light on toppings. If the price for a slice was less, or they put more toppings on, it would be a full 5 stars for this place. If you come maybe just get a whole pizza which would be a better value - although I guess that defeats the purpose of being able to buy slices and try different kinds of pizza. Love the creative toppings and flavors. Super friendly service. read more

Wicked Pies - Get in mah belly!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

one of the tastiest pizzas I've ever had! we did uber eats and it came right on time. hot and ready. love it! try the great northern pizza--delicious! read more

Reportedly the best pizza in town, I loved my pie here. Can't say how it compares to other local za makers but I have to say that is was among the top 3 places Ive had pizza between Northern California, Nevada and Washington. The crust was thin and just the right blend of crispy / doughy, the sauce was zesty and flavorful and the cheeses and other topping were very high quality and tasty all served up by an enthusiastic staff. read more

The special pizzas are great. The large pizza is HUGE!!!! Love the Twin Peaks themed pizzas. This is my go to place for a really good pizza.

I feel very on-the-fence about this place. It would be excellent in a lot of towns, but Olympia already has quite a few decent pizza places, so Wicked Pies gets buried in the competition for me. The weird flavors and Twin Peaks themed pizzas were too interesting to pass up, so over the weekend, my husband and I got a half White Lodge, half Laura Palmer pizza. I did not care for the White Lodge. I blame the rosemary. I love rosemary but, apparently, not on a pizza. It was... too weird for me, even for a Twin Peaks pizza. The Laura Palmer was fascinating. Have you ever eaten salt and vinegar potato chips? It's the weirdest thing because you keep eating more of it to figure out if it's the best flavor in the world or the worst. What isn't up for debate is that it's fascinating. Every bite of the Laura Palmer was like that. I just couldn't figure it out, but I couldn't stop eating it either. Anyway, I feel this place is worth a try. You might find your favorite pizza that they don't make anywhere else. For me, the flavors were odd together, and the crust was a little overdone. I did eat it, though, and I'm usually pretty picky, so... You decide. read more

Wicked Pies - Pizza with two slices gone. Half White Lodge. Half Laura Palmer. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Ok, my daughter was in NYC and sent me a picture of her at an authentic NYC pizza place. Looked so good. We go every year usually in September so I won't be able to get a slice myself for a while. Moved to the Olympia area right about a year ago. Her picture sent me on a search for some type of New York City style pizza around here. That is how I found this place. I walked in and was greeted right away. While I was enjoying my slice, I noticed that they greeted everyone in a timely manner. Very good staff, and similar to New York City. They had the appropriate amount of time focused on the people and the food. Just like in the city is probably 80% on the food and 20% on the people which is perfect. The overall layout of the place definitely reminds you of a New York City pizzeria. It was clean and the pizza slices presented well. I ordered a traditional pepperoni slice and then a slice of a specialty pizza that had artichokes onion, bacon, little feta cheese, etc. The sauce had a good tang to it and had a good balance of cheese. Not too much and not too little. The crust was good and thin and had a nice little crunch around the edge. It really did not have the traditional chew of a New York City pizza and that's why I gave it a four instead of a five. I did enjoy both slices and will visit again. PS: their homemade rice crispy treats were better than moms. read more

My search for the best pizza in Olympia finally lead me here... I definitely place them in the top tier. I ordered a 20" 1/2 and 1/2 MEAT Pepperoni, house-made sausage, bacon, black forest ham, prosciutto, meatballs THE LAURA PALMER Prosciutto, Gorgonzola goat cheese blend, fresh arugula, toasted pecans topped with a drizzle of house-made fig compote, with light shredded mozzarella, olive oil base And a very yummy Brown butter chocolate chip toffee cookie read more

See all

We recently visited this pizza joint on a recent trip to Olympia, based on all the great reviews. However, our experience didn't match. We placed our order online- cheese pizza, gluten free cheese, breadsticks and some desert treats. Our online order stated it would be ready in 30 mins, however it took almost 60 mins. Maybe we hit this place on an off day. The sauce seemed pretty plain - just tomato. It needed some seasoning, garlic, something. The gluten-free crust wasn't the best either. It has turned mushy, inedible by the time we reached out hotel to eat it. The brown butter snacks- rice crispy and cookie, were not very good. Both were wrapped in plastic wrap, they need more environmental friendly packaging options. Overall, we ended up throwing most of this food away. We should have taken it back and asked for a full refund. read more

See all

A bit on the pricey side but definitely a reliably good pizza, reliable service. Really happy they have vegan cheese!

Horrendous customer service. If you want good pizza with good customer service. This is not it. Shame on you!

Good pizza and good service. Friendly staff. Wish new owners success for the future

I just want to add to my review that this pizza cold is AMAZING it honestly was better cold than hot. Go get one of there slices a d try it cold. read more

Wicked Pies - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

I usually rate a pizza joint by starting with the cheese pie. We ordered a 14", which we find perfect for 2. See if you have any crust left over. Check the chew on the cheese. Make note of the quality of the marinara. After you try that start piling on. Many of their house built are adventurous and hit a sweet spot if you're in the mood. Guaranteed the ingredients will be superior for Olympia and the technique will be well Studied and well executed. read more

I wish they had one of these places in Tacoma. No complaints here. I yelped the place and thought I would go for a drive to Olympia. I got a couple of slices of pizza here. The pizza here is bomb, the cheese, the flavor and texture of the crust was on point. The slices was a decent size, I could of ate more but that would of been all bad. I'm not in Olympia very often, but if I am I'm definitely coming back here again read more

See all

I'm in Portland for the week and my Daughter Mercedes and I worked out meeting here for lunch today. She lives in Auburn. We both love good pizza. The reviews for Wicked Pies are over the top so of course this is where we met. We thought the pizza was good, but no way 5 star good. I had pizza yesterday from Flying Pie in Portland. It is great pizza and one of the very best on the West Coast. Today's pizza came up short. read more

See all