Food was great! French fries were to die for! It the best thing about this place was Tanner very…read morenice gentleman. He is the kind of frontman that makes or breaks a restaurant.

This is a decent, no frills chicken wing joint in the heart of Greeley. If you're craving wings…read morethat aren't from Wingstop, this will certainly scratch the itch. It's exactly what you would expect it to be, and nothing more. Tables and floors are little dirty, because why wouldn't they be? Chicken wings are a messy business. Their wings are on the small side, but pretty meaty nevertheless. They have a great selection of sauces too. The sauces don't taste as good as they could however. Though, it is cool how they have their own beer available for purchase. That's probably the one thing that I think makes this place stand out. But although everything was okay, for someone just passing through Greeley who doesn't live there, I found this highly forgettable.

Me and my fiancé and his friend came here after me and Xavier had not had Wing shack for three…read moremonths!! We LOVE Wing Shack! Gavin was sooooo helpful and a GREAT worker. 10/10 recommend. Two thumbs up. DEF GET THESE WINGS

Wing shack on 35th and 10th. Smallest , most overdone , worst overly greasy sauce , simply the…read moreworst wings Ive ever had. And I don't usually do bad reviews

I come here a lot and one of the workers 'Yesenia' continuously helps me whenever I'm there as well…read moreas the other employees when they are able to. 10/10 recommend

There is something definitely fishy going on with Wingstop reviews. They can't ALL be this bad,…read morelol. From Fort Collins to Denver they are all ranked below a 3.0. I've been to two locations and sure this one was slightly dirtier, but the food and staff were both great! Far better than BWW and Wing Shack. Everyone was respectful to me and I like that the location isn't as rambunctious as BWW but still has some TV's. At this one they were playing some TV drama without subtitles and TV was on mute so kinda need them but they had sports on too. One TV's contrast was set to a really blue hue, haha, but seriously, I don't understand the trash ratings

Do not order through the Fat Shack website for delivery. Had our order delivered and we were…read moresupposed to have a milkshake, milkshake was not delivered. But since we ordered via the website, when I called they said I needed to sort it out through door dash and through door dash there isn't an order to dispute. Definitely disappointing to not receive the item or a refund.

The best part of my experience was the burger. "The Classic" is a 2-patty all-American…read morecheeseburger. (Combo meal, $14.) But even though I really like salt (it's fat free!), the patties were too salty for me. Speaking of salt, does Fat Shack know there are other seasonings for fries? My SUPER salty fries seemed to have no other seasoning. Fat Shack's management needs to take a field trip to Red Robin, to study how they season their fries. A pet peeve of mine is when you're the customer, you say "thank you", and the person *you're giving money to* says nothing. Doesn't matter if it's in the checkout line at the grocery store, or when someone brings your food to the table as happened here. In fairness, 10 minutes later he did ask how everything was from across the room, and I (untruthfully) gave a thumbs-up. Fat Shack and every other restaurant asking for tips before service need to just stop. It's a hostage situation: "We're about to cook your food and can do whatever we want to it; would you like to tip?"

My husband and I have been coming to this location since they opened. In the beginning, they were…read morefantastic, but over time their food quality has gone downhill. I order our wings extra crispy and extra saucy, and they come bone dry and looking like they are barely cooked, or we are missing wings. I call and report the issues, and while they do give a few dollars off for next time, they never address the issue and it happens over and over again. It is extremely disappointing that things have gone downhill. We will not be returning to this location.

We eat at Wing Shack many time but this time it was horrible. Wings were so small and sauce tasted…read morestrange. Spent a lot of money there for horrible food. Service even forgot one of our meals. Went to get the missed meal and the food he got was cold to lukewarm. Had been sitting for a while. I thought they use to cook it as ordered but they DO NOT. I usually don't go to any restaurant for ambiance but we will not be coming back. No wonder your ratings have gone way down.

I truly don't understand the poor reviews so I feel like I have to post my experience. The only…read morething I can say that is a drawback is the wait to be seated. They have ample seating and I still had to wait over an hour. Honestly though I think that speaks to the quality and popularity of this place with the locals. I ordered oysters ( first time for me and the oysters and thought I would hate them but wow they are good!) and the 2 person meal, basically a seafood boil, Garlic with extra seasoning. It blew our minds! So juicy and the butter sauce . My dad couldn't stop talking about the potatoes of all things. He said it's the first time he's ever actually liked oysters too. The restaurants atmosphere felt great, everyone was happy, even a few birthdays going on. All I'm thinking about now is when can I go back?! Definitely going to call ahead next time.

Be careful...this place doesn't weigh by pounds like they advertise. They count pieces. We ordered…read more4 pounds of crawfish and the manager says that's 40 pieces. Make it make sense? Crawfish are all different sizes ma'am. You guys are advertising the wrong thing and screwing people over.

Friendly young counterman. Lunch special just the right price. Close to NY pizza (from this New…read moreYorker). Glad they added a west Greeley location. Garden City was out of the way for us. Brighter, newer setting.

I've eaten here a few times over the last decade or so while staying in g Greeley. The pizza is…read moregood, thin crust style pizza. At some point, they eliminated Hawaiian from their menu, so if you like Hawaiian style, you're SOL. It used to be one of their best pies. We ordered some large orders of 8 or more pizzas a few times for business meetings and they got our order wrong every time. Calling to resolve issues was tedious, but they did get is taken care of. They're ok in a pinch, but I wouldn't recommend them

I can't say enough good things about this place, but especially about our server, Danny. She's the…read morekind of person who makes you feel like a regular from day one. By my second visit she had already memorized my drink order, and from then on it was like she knew exactly what my friends and I needed before we even asked. Danny has this rare balance of being personable and professional--always checking in at just the right time without ever hovering. She made sure our group felt taken care of every single time, and honestly, she's a big part of why this spot became my everyday hangout. If I hadn't moved out of town, I'd still be coming here just to have Danny as my server. She's one of those people who turns a casual night out into something memorable. 100% recommend asking for her if you stop by!

We came in to watch the Broncos game and had an amazing experience! Jenna was hands down one of the…read morebest servers we've ever had--even with the bar completely packed. She was always checking on us, super attentive, and made sure our beers were never empty. Outstanding service and a great game-day atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!