I truly don't understand the poor reviews so I feel like I have to post my experience. The only thing I can say that is a drawback is the wait to be seated. They have ample seating and I still had to wait over an hour. Honestly though I think that speaks to the quality and popularity of this place with the locals. I ordered oysters ( first time for me and the oysters and thought I would hate them but wow they are good!) and the 2 person meal, basically a seafood boil, Garlic with extra seasoning. It blew our minds! So juicy and the butter sauce . My dad couldn't stop talking about the potatoes of all things. He said it's the first time he's ever actually liked oysters too. The restaurants atmosphere felt great, everyone was happy, even a few birthdays going on. All I'm thinking about now is when can I go back?! Definitely going to call ahead next time. read more

Wing’s Pier - Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Be careful...this place doesn't weigh by pounds like they advertise. They count pieces. We ordered 4 pounds of crawfish and the manager says that's 40 pieces. Make it make sense? Crawfish are all different sizes ma'am. You guys are advertising the wrong thing and screwing people over. read more

First thing I wanna say is when we walked in we had 4 adults and 2 kids (kid under 2). The manager told us we'd be charged 18% gratuity for a group of 6. The children shouldn't count but that's whatever that's fine. Then we ordered 4 pounds of crawfish and about 15 of them were black inside and basically melted to pieces. It looked like about 2 pounds of crawfish so we asked and the general manager told us that 4 pounds should be 40 pieces. Since when did they not weigh but count by pieces? So be wary guys, they don't weigh but count by crawfish. Doesn't seem right as all crawfish are different sizes. read more

Terrible the food the service everything they will not care how much money you spend they still treat you garbage

FOOD BEST SEAFOOD AROUND TOWN. Service always good and Ambiance very clean and comfortable. read more

The food here is really good and makes up for some other minor issues. Wait times can get pretty long and it is on the higher end for the price. However, I do recommend stopping by around lunch time to avoid those wait times and splitting a combo to keep it affordable! read more

We spent about $100 on our to go food. Only to get home and see we had tons of muscles covering our food. (We did not order them) We called back and advised we received many muscles instead of our ordered crawfish. The restaurant called us back to let us know that they rewatched the cameras and saw that they put the crawfish yet the cook is denying playing the muscles. Ironic. How is it that the cameras show the cook placing the crawfish but not the muscles. This restaurant lacks attention and accountability. Not to mention, the woman on the phone had nothing but a snotty attitude. I don't recommend giving them any of your money. Although they're the only seafood boil place in Greeley, you might as well drive instead of pay these people. read more

Wing’s Pier - muscles they denied - Seafood Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Food was excellent and the service was great the new canopy made it great to eat indoor.

Overpriced for what you get. The seafood itself is flavorless. The outdoor seating area is nice.

This place is amazing. Seafood on point - spicy and delicious. It's busy (probably because it's so good), but it's a fun atmosphere. I'd eat here every week. We should've ordered the garlic sticks for the leftover butter/seasoning! read more

First night opening waited a tad over a half hour to sit. All staff had been friendly and helpful. Fun casual atmosphere inside. Food just like Juciy, flavorful, and right amounts. We WILL be back sooner than later! read more

See all

This place is very over priced for what you get, the food is good , not great but for the money I was expecting much more, the most expensive combo plate was more of an appetizer and not so much of a meal. Would def not go out of my way to go again read more

First time visiting and we were impressed. We ordered the Seafood boil for 2 and added 1/2 lb of green mussels, 1/2 lb of shrimp and 4 boiled eggs. We visited at lunch, place was full. It didn't matter. We were seated, orders were taken and food came out at a decent time. Everything was delicious. We will definitely return and put this on our restaurant rotation! read more

Wing’s Pier - Seafood Boil for 2 - Seafood Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Just got back from dinner at Wing's Pier. The service was very good, the food? Not so much. We got a fried oyster basket, a fried catfish basket and a lobster roll basket. My husband never had a lobster roll, and loves lobster, but it was way too salty. The oyster basket was ok, but the breading was too thick. The sweet potato fries were excellent. The catfish basket was disappointing. While there were 4 pieces of fish, the breading overwhelmed the meager fish. I ate a piece and a half but could not eat any more, way too much breading. The onions rings suffered the same fate, way too much breading. I ate a half of a ring. We left all the food we did not eat because there is no use trying to heat up a piece of fish covered in breading. We got there at 4:30 and got right in, but by the time we left the tables were full and people were waiting. Probably would not go back. read more

Food choices are great. Service was fast and efficient. Very flavorful, nice to have something like this in Greeley.

Happy with the options and flavor. Price was reasonable and the only complaint I have was the lack of spice level. The extra hot doesn't live up to a heating rating as such. We will be back! But I will bring my own hot sauce for the boil. read more

First time awesome. Second time disappointing. Got a lb of empty clam shells. Bottom of the bag didn't have 1 clam. Got a beer. Didn't see the server again until the bill. Saved me money. Crab legs were ice cold. I know the server heard us talking about it, probably why we didn't see him. Half lb of shrimp is 4 small shrimp. However I got 6 potatoes that were great! The catfish tasted very farm raised. You know that poo aftertaste. But I drowned it out in the bottom of the bag. Hope this helps read more

Fantastic low country boil, cooked and flavored as good as any. Service could be a bit more attentive but not bad. Prices a bit higher than others but not bad considering you don't have to drive to Denver. read more

First and LAST time visiting. Ridiculously expensive. We ordered take out "create own bag" with a lb of scallops and a lb of king crab. Got it home NO scallops and 2 crab legs for $125.30 (don't forget the bag fee of $0.10), 2 corn and a few potatoes. Extremely frustrated, called & spoke with "The Manager" she said that she would check the cameras and call us back - No phone call back! Pretty shitty customer service for a new place in Greeley that's over priced! Wont be spending my money there EVER again! read more

Lack of care we came in and were told 30 minutes waited beyond that and people coming in after us got seated first even though there was a ton of seating huge let down and super frustrating you guys could do way better especially for what you expect people to pay read more

6 of us went there opening weekend and the food was great!! Our server was not. She didn't write any of the order down and managed to miss our appetizer and and entire order of crawfish. And tried to lie and say the appetizer took longer because it was fried food but we could tell by the ticket she forgot to ring it in. Part way through the meal we asked for more tarter sauce and she never brought that either. When I reminded her of that she blamed it on the managers said she was taking care of too many tables. No manager ever came and checked on our table which was suprising since they were just opening. Never got offered any drink refills and never checked on. We tried to be nice about things and she then became rude. read more

They where assholes we went there and they told us a 45 minute wait we went 45 minutes later because we got a text saying our table was ready and they told us another 30 minutes and we said we wanted to talk to a manager and they said she was on break and laughed in our face as we where leaving read more