Not only is it the best value you can find, it is also the best NY Style Pizza you can find in Austin. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - 18 Pizza (X-Large) Plain Just perfection. - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Amazing pizza in the Austin area! The cinnamon bites were delicious! Pizza had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Cinnamon Bites - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

See all

This pizza used to be one of the best places in town, and I stayed loyal to it even as it was in decline. However, it's now time to cut ties. The one star is for the service only. Ambiance is same as always, a bit tired but clean. The quality of the pizza and quantity of ingredients has diminished with time and today I paid almost $3 more for my lunch than I used to. Bye Yaghi's. read more

Pizza was just OK, nothing great for the $24 coat. the Philly Sub was lacking in meat... will not order again. read more

Best in Pflugerville, easily. I won't drive 20 minutes into Austin very often now that I found Yaghi's

Had a pizza delivered by door Dash. Family got sick with diarrhea . Meat was old (Italian sausage) and spoiled . Will never order from this place again! read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Old spoiled Italian Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Georgetown..... Do NOT order calzones from Yaghi's!!! I just received one and thinner than a slice of pizza. Less than 1/4 inch. Called store and all they could say is "sorry that's the way they are made with out a lot of toppings stuffed in. Door dash can give you a credit. Do not order, so disappointing! read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

I don't know what happened their quality has just severely decreased. This used to be my favorite place but now they either burn the dough or it tastes like cardboard. Ya'll need to call back the old chef and give him a raise... read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Ordered the fresh mozzarella and pesto pizza, a pepperoni and onion pizza, and the greek salad. I'm a huge Greek salad fan and this one hit all the key points-fresh veggies, feta cheese, and house made dressing. The pizzas are loaded with cheese and toppings, and the crust is flavorful and garlicky. This is my husbands favorite pizza. I like it as well, but there are a few things I would change. The pizza is a little dry (needs more sauce-it hardly has any,) and is it just me or could it use some salt?? Only knocking off one star because it is still a good place to order from, just not my absolute favorite. read more

See all

First time here, as an ex-ny'er pizza snob I give the pizza 2 enthusiastic thumbs up! The pizza crust hot out of the oven is thin and crisp (if you get takeout just do a quick 2 mins in a 425 oven, directly on the rack to get the texture back), the sauce is perfect, tastes like marinara should, all savory, no hint of sweet (like one of the big box pizza pushers) I had the 2 slice lunch special and soda, just under $8.00. A great lunch and value, will def return read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Two slice lunch special, one plain, one mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Whoever made this pizza really hates their job. No reason I should receive a pizza with no toppings on half the pizza. Unbelievable... read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Miserable person who made this pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

They do not wash their vegetables. There was a lady bug in my Caesar salad! Something like that could have easily been washed off. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Lady bug in my Caesar Salad - would have easily washed off, if they washed their vegetables. - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Yaghi's has been around for a while. I think if anyone needs to try anything they should order a meatball sub. They are always generous with the mozzarella and the meatballs are awesome and to kick it up a notch add red onions or other toppings. read more

I checked on Yelp and saw they had a lunch special and a wing special on Wednesdays. It was $.50 a wing. I jumped right our of the car. I showed them the coupon and what I didn't see what it was during the month of July. On top of it it was an old coupon. I still ordered the wings in the medium buffalo with extra ranch of course and the lunch special of two slices of cheese and a soda for $4.99. That is a steal. Once my food was ready I put cheese and peppers on it before I left. Who doesn't like cheese and peppers on top? LOVE IT! I did take a small bite and it was good. I got home and the pizza and gotten a little cold but it was still good. I ate one piece and dived into the wings. The best I have had in a long time. They even made them extra saucy when I asked. Perfect heat, nice and moist. And can I say it again? The best I ever had in a very long time. I will be back for the lunch special except I will eat it there. and of course the wings. You have to try the wings. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Lunch special two slices of cheeses for $4.99 - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

See all

Great pizza place. The staff is super friendly and so helpful! I needed pizza for an elementary school part, the staff member I spoke with came in early to make sure pizza was ready as soon as they opened at 10a. He brought pizza out and loaded it in the car for me (new mom with a newborn). The kids loved the pizza and I loved the service! Win win! read more

I was eager to try this place. Last time I went in, it was a little past lunch. The gentleman told me they were out of pizza by the slice and I could wait a few minutes and he could make more. I told him I was on a time crunch, he apologized and told me next time he'd have some ready for me. Fast forward till today, I walk in and the lady clerk is drinking a soda, wiping her mouth with her shirt. I asked her if there were any other options for pizza by the slice and she quickly responded "NOPE" so I said thank you and left because she was not welcoming nor did she have any customer service skills. Walked down to Subway where I was greeted with a smile. Customer service goes a long way. I will try to come back when the nice gentleman that helped me last time is there. So disappointed!!! read more

The pizza was good but for $14.99 I expected the cheese sticks to be cheesy and not thin and dried like they were over cooked

Tried this pizza for the first time today. Not sure where these 5 star reviews are coming from. But being married to an Italian from the east coast, this was a disappointment. First thing...uh...where's the sauce? It took 1/2 way through the first slice to realize it was just cheese on bread! I've had pizza from New York and if I remember...there was sauce! I really wanted this to be a go to place. But I don't think so. If you want a quesadilla...this is the place. If you want a pizza...try someplace else. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

Since living in Pflugerville my husband and I have had a hard time finding good pizza. We aren't a fan of the typical chain places or some of the local ones. However, we both really have been enjoying this place. The pizza is a bit pricey compared to other places but I feel it's worth it. I get the Buffalo chicken pizza. The pizza is also good leftover. I'll 100% be back read more

The crust is good. Well it was on my pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza but my wife said the crust on her Veggie was soggy. She did say hers tasted good despite the crust issue. My pepperoni, sausage and mushroom just lacked any taste. We won't be back because for the cost it just wasn't worth it. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - 14" pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

See all

Always hard to find great NY style pizza and this place never disappoints. I get a pie here once a month.

Always looking for a NY type pizza. Yaghi's comes close. Medium thin crust, not too much sauce, good toppings, and cheese. Definitely recommend. read more

The pizza was great and the Stromboli calzone was even better! Highly recommend that. I got the meatball topping and it was flavorful. The ham was good too. It wasnt overly greasy and the crust was good. Pizza could use a little more sauce but they gave us sides of sauce so it was fine. And the sauce tastes fresh and delicious. A little bit pricey but most things are moving that direction. I know 5 stars is a bit of a stretch but this is rated too low IMO so... read more

Stopped for the first time after being highly recommended for having beef products and immediately after asking the gentlemen at the register to confirm the pepperoni is in fact beef he rolled his eyes walked off nodding his head and sarcastically said he would ask. I walked out because if your service is bad my guess is the food might be also. I hope you work with your employees on customer service etiquette. read more

Best pizza in Pflugerville. Ordered right before closing on New Year's Day. Pizza arrived promptly, hot and fresh. They are expensive but worth it. The menu is expansive; they have a lot of vegetarian options and I appreciate that because I don't eat beef or pork. We ordered the Spinach Roasted Garlic Chicken Pizza and the Margherita Pizza both with red sauce. I ate waaay too much. The crust is light, buttery and flaky sooo good. I haven't ordered Yaghi's in awhile but definitely plan on going more often! read more

This review has two purposes : 1. To give recognition to one of the hardest workers ive ever seen 2. To hopefully have this make it to the owner somehow to help him realize how great of an employee they have! We've been to this location twice & David helped up both times. Among them being short staff (which we don't care about we understand) he was RUNNING to help customers make every pizza answer the phone & still check on us to make sure we were doing okay while maintaining a smile on his face. I have never seen somebody work so hard & care so much to help..& now a days you don't find employees like that! David if your reading this you are truly amazing & deserve a huge recognition...plus you make some damn good pizza lol! read more

My husband and I wanted a gyro, so started searching local restaurants that deliver. Found Yaghi's, ordered two gyros with extra meat and extra sauce. We always do that no matter where we get gyros from. Have to say we were pleasantly surprised how delicious they were, especially coming from a pizza place. We've never even tried their pizza, but have ordered the gyros three times now in a short period of time. The meat is very tender, and the sauce is delicious. Maybe one day we'll try their pizza. read more

So disappointed basically bread and cheese sandwich. Just lost a customer! read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Philly cheese steak. Barely enough meat for a piece of a sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

When it comes to pizza, I'm pretty easy to please. Today was one of the few days where I did not enjoy my pizza. We ordered a Margherita pizza from Yaghi's. It was literally a cheese pizza with a cherry tomato on every other slice. That is not a Margherita pizza. It was also burnt in some areas, and uncooked in other parts. Very sloppy and below average quality. When you think to yourself,"Should have gone to Cici's", you know the pizza is pretty bad. The pizza was edible, but just barely. read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - $18.99 for this mess. - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

I love finding any pizza place that isn't Domonoish or Gattiish. That's why we tried Yaghi's. We got a x-large 1/2 cheese, 1/2 hamburger/peperoni. Also got a dozen boneless BBQ chicken wings. Pizza was pretty darn good...Chicken wings, not so much. As mentioned in other reviews you basically have to get your food to go as the seating is extremely uninviting. Bar stools against the walls with a 12" wall mounted shelf. Baris pizza has been our staple for pizza for years. And you can actually sit down in comfort. Yaghi's is a step above the other massive chain pizza places but not quite up to Baris's standard. So when we need take out, we'll be back to Yaghi's. read more

Best pizza in town! Good Italian food overall. I'm from New England and miss the pizza there yet this is reminiscent. Milto's in Austin and Campisi's in Dallas are my favorites for pizza when I am in those cities. Polite friendly staff you want to tip big. Delivery folks always nice too. read more

Went to place an order in store and dude tossing dough with his bare hands and sweaty hairy forearms. Disgusting seeing flour clump up on his arm. Pizza is overpriced and it felt musty in there. I would not return to this location based on that alone. A few years ago I came here to place an order as well and the slices they had out had flies on them and they were still selling them! Things have not changed. I'm from MA and been trying to find a good pizza in the area. read more

Fast friendly service. Ordered the Lunch Special $4.99 for 2 slices & a drink!! Good "New York Style" thin crust pizza. Crunchy & chewy read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Lunch special $4.99 yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

After coming to this location and seeing how their "sandwiches" are prepared, you could not pay me to eat here again! This is a GYRO?? Seeing how the carefree staff handled both money transactions with multiple customers and FOOD with absolutely no regard to being sanitary, I cringe at the thought of eating this... or considering it edible. I'd question ever coming here again and for sure would NEVER suggest someone else to go here! read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - Gyro Sandwich??? Yeah right! - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

So we ordered lasagna this time around and a couple of salads. We were told it would be an hour. An hour and a half later we got our food. The lasagna temperature was tepid at best. I have had better service from them. They used to have employees that cared. Now it is I am sorry, because it something you're suppose to say. They delivery guy didn't even know which route he took to get to the house. He said he just followed his GPS? I don't know what they teach kids in school now days, but these are the people we are supposed to leave this country to? I really don't have a good feeling about this. These guys have no common sense. read more

Ordered a large extra cheese pizza, it arrived in a timely fashion, but when we opened the box we found the pizza uncut and the cheese all in one corner of the box! I called Yaghi's but they had already stopped answering the phone for the evening. I broke out the spatula and the knife and went to work restoring the pizza(pic attached) And took a picture. The pizza tasted not bad. Then I call this morning to make the manager aware. I spoke to Danielle. I explain the condition of the pizza, and her immediate response is to question why I didn't call it in as soon as I ordered the pizza? I answered that I called as soon as we opened the box, to which she quoted the time the pizza left the shop and the time it was delivered to my home (keep in mind she has yet to apologize for the quality of the pizza and her tone of voice is one an impatient mother takes with and insolent child) at this point I realized the person I was speaking with was not going to be of any assistance to me (the customer) or the business she is representing. I asked to for her to provide the General Managers information to which she responded "there is no general manager here" Then I for the owners email address, to which she responds "yahgis@att.net" I ask who to ask for? And to my dismay she responds "Danielle" at this point I realize the owner of this pizza shop has been scolding me and withholding her position in her own business while speaking to me the whole time in an aggressive and loud tone. The pizza is good here but, I cannot support a business owner that thinks it is okay to speak to people in such a degraded and dismissive way! read more

Yaghi's New York Pizzeria - After reconstruction the top left corner is where all the cheese pooled - Pizza Near Me - Pflugerville, Texas

I had heard that Yaghi's made a pretty authentic NY/NJ pizza so while I was in the area I stopped in and ordered the '2-slices and a can of soda' lunch special for $4.99. When checking out a promising pie I always order the plain cheese pizza the first time - this is my true test of the quality of the pie. I am happy to say it passed with room to spare! I'm a former Brooklyn boy who spent his 'wonder years' in north Jersey and I've been searching the Austin area for a pie that really reminded me of the the pies I relished as a young man. There are plenty of good pizza makers here in town but until today I hadn't really found what I was looking for. Yaghi's cheese pizza is the closest thing to a real Jersey pie I've had here and it's pretty much right on the mark. They claim to make their ingredients from scratch and it shows. The crust was medium-thin, quite foldable and actually had a fine taste all by itself - a good sign. The sauce seemed very fresh, slightly sweet with bits of tomato. Personally I would wish for a slightly 'wetter' pie but that's me. The mozzarella tasted fresh and good and had just that drop of grease when you folded the slice that told me this was the real deal. Took me right back to King Pizza in Paramus, my old favorite. The lunch deal is a nice deal and a great way to get your lunchtime pizza fix. There is one caveat though - although there's quite the variety of pies, calzones and all the usual suspects their prices are above my musician's pay grade. I understand that quality costs more and these are quality pies but I personally think their pricing is a tad excessive - although it's inline with Home Slice, East Side Pies and a host of others around town. I think they all ask too much for their pies but I'm older and I can't help but remember what things used to cost. Yaghi's pizza is the closest thing to the pies I remember and I know where to go now when I'm craving the real thing. They were friendly and courteous to me and I wish them well. read more

As a native north easterner I have high standards for pizza which are rarely met in Austin. This pizza reminds me of home. Crispy, thin crust, slightly greasy (but not overly so), savory, not too sweet sauce. This is as close as I've gotten to a New York slice in ATX. read more

Used to go to Yaghi's in Bee Cave and did not realize there was one close to my new home in Round Rock. To be honest, the location in Bee Cave was okay but nothing to brag about. Ordered yesterday from the Pflugerville location and found the service timely and the pizza terrific! I will definitely be back! read more

Ordered pizza and rolls two days ago. One pizza and four rolls were $50. Couldn't finish the slice. Their ovens are dirty and you can smell it while eating. Both hubby and I put the slices down and tossed everything we bought. Ovens need to be cleaned!!!! read more