I was pleasantly surprised by the pizza I ordered here. They hand toss the dough and the toppings were fresh. It is not artisan pizza but it is better than a pizza you would order from a national corporate chain. If you sign up for their rewards program, you get a free pie on your birthday. I would like to try their gelato the next time around. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

They need to hire more employees . Came for lunch and they only have one guy working. He's taking orders and making pizzas and there's a line of people. If you want a business to run well you have to have employees to run it and not had customers waiting over 30 minutes for a pizza. read more

Wow! New owners, new look...terrific product and service! This place got a deservedly bad wrap in the last year or so of its previous ownership. But, wow have things turned around. The renovations have opened the place up...it's got a more comfortable feel and the big wall the separated the dining area from the ordering line is gone. Folks may not like the "pick your own" ingredients line that Your Pie was known for, but the see through kitchen is great and makes for a terrific look. The pizza tasted fresher and the crust was fantastic. It looks like the menu has some new pizza offerings, plus a variety of salads, sandwiches, pastas and wings. Not so broad a menu to do too much poorly. There's a similarity in product, just diversity in offerings. I'd recommend the new ownership update their Yelp photos to celebrate their new investment. Congratulations! read more

Always a great experience at your pie Milton. We got seated quickly and our server was great! The drink sizes are very big. Side salad and pizza to share for 2. BBQ chicken is an all time fav and was made to perfection. They are also great with customization. I don't eat pork so removing bacon was easy. Food came out fresh and quickly! Parking here is a little weird as they do a curbside pick up and delivery as well. read more

Your Pie - GREEK SIDE SALAD - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

My team went for lunch. Great vibes and staff was amazing! Highly recommend and pizza was fantastic!

The completely blew it. every part of the order was wrong. Two chicken melts had zero chicken. None The pizza was soggy. Everything was cold. It was a pick up order that we were told would be ready in 10 minutes and were given a number for the table. after 20 we ask whats going on and the order was just sitting in the warmer. Should be a complete refund. read more

Excellent service! They always greet me whenever I come inside. The employees are always so nice and friendly. They are usually pretty fast when it comes to the food, but there have been a few times where I've had to wait, but I can't complain too much because when that happens it's pretty packed. One time my pizza came out burnt but they already had another one in the oven for me! Have I mentioned that their food is delicious? Some of the best Pizza I've had, their bacon and brie pizza is to die for ! read more

Maddie was so friendly and outgoing and had great recommendations about the menu selection. We got a pizza and a Craft beer and we're very happy. read more

This was the worst pizza I ever had. I got home and opened the box and all the crust was burnt. I called to see what they could do and they said nothing except write a review They did not offer to fix it or anything ! I used to come to this store before new ownership and it was great Now I won't go back Very slow service too!! read more

Happy to say they done fixed themselves, quick service and that drew fellow made sure I had a very enjoyable pizza eating experience. Pizza was yet again bussin they get 5 BIG BOOMS for that one. read more

Visited on a week night it was steady but lots of tables available. The create your own pizza option is awesome 8.99$ for anything you want on it! There are also free dipping sauces(marina/ ranch /etc.) while it's an order at the counter type restaurant I was asked during the course of my meal 3x if I needed anything. Awesome service and food! read more

Your Pie - 10" VEGGIE PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

For the second time in 3 weeks tried the peach and prosciutto pizza and was roundly disappointed. I know peaches are scarce this year but the pizza they're selling (for a premium) vs what they advertise (a lot) is a rip off. If you can't sell what you advertise, don't sell it. read more

Your Pie - See this? This is what they advertise. - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

If your craving for pizza and fast service, this would be the place to go! You get to choose your base, sauce and toppings (custom pizza) or order from their menu which has decent options as well. Cannot beat the price and portions are helpful! They also have a bar area plus they serve gelato!! Even more reasons to go check them out. Decent place for pizza if you do not prefer fast food chains. read more

Your Pie - Custom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

Good pizza and service. I recommend their food. Very nice people and a good menu variety.

Definitely the worst location I've been to yet and I've been to at least three or four. The food was not fresh at all. The salad was completely wilted, and I hadn't even realize it until I left. It's literally an edible. The pasta I ordered was barely edible. The best I can say about this location is they were fairly friendly. Will NOT be back. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

Make your own pizza.They have wheat and white base, a number of cheese and vegetables along with meats. You can choose from 10" inch pizza or salad or panini for the entree. You can make it a meal combo with gelato..yummy!!!!! They also carry local brewed beer on tap. The pizzas are thin based like NY style I think which for 7.99$ is little high. Make your own pizza joint and a fun place to eat and drink beer. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

We go back several years ordering from this location. Recently, they changed their M.O. Firstly, I had to order more than we wanted just to get it delivered. Admittedly it was a small order but they tacked on $6 for a delivery charge. I added another $2 just for good will. The total soft cost was $8, a 30%+ gratuity on a $25 quick order for this repeat customer residing about a mile+ nearby. Some 45" later I received a regular size pizza with a total of 7 pepperoni slices to scantily top the entire 14" pizza. In addition, the second pizza, the 10" size had about 60% of it covered in cheese. I took photos. It appears they didn't like nor want our small order, but instead were spiteful, trying to irritate us since we ordered lightly. They succeeded! I recommend our good neighbors should try some more established pizza parlors nearby. This is not a very enticing way to do business with an upscale customer, delivering nearby in a high end neighborhood. In fact, we'll share this experience with our homeowners association. I'm not inclined to do business here again. Certainly, we'll save our large orders for the more humble family pizza businesses who appreciate our business regardless of the size of the order and the coerced tip. read more

Great new spot! Lots of options and delicious! Friendly staff and clean environment. I grabbed a pizza and split a Caesar salad. Both were fresh and tasty! Gluten free options, but really lots of options to give you a choice on your pizza ! Or lots of options if you just want to order off the menu. I did a veggie pizza with feta and pesto! Gelato is a must so save room! read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

The restaurant was being run by children. We ordered 2 salads, a Caesar and a caprese and their signature Philly cheese steak pizza. The spinach in the caprese salad was rotten. The lettuce in the Caesar salad was old and it two croutons and rationed shreds of cheese in it. The pizza was worse. Here is the picture of the advertised Philly steak, pizza and what we got. There was a sprinkling of steak instead of a generous helping as shown on the advertisement. read more

See all

The staff here steps up their game in March and did not disappoint. I came here for "Pi Day" - March 14 of every year Your Pie sells pizza for $3.14 all day. These places get slammed. I planned to arrive when they opened and I'm glad I did - I quickly got in and got my pizza as the line started snaking out the door. They had extra staff on hand to deal with the load. My pizza turned out just as I had ordered. read more

Your Pie - $3.14 pizzas on pi day! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

It's really an exceptional experience and restaurant. The staff, the food quality, the costs and the atmosphere couldn't be better. The owner of this franchise should be proud of all things this location. We will make this a regular experience for our family of five. Nice work!! read more

This is one of the better places we have gone for getting a custom pizza for $10. We actually come here about once a week. I wanted to bring up a manager that we think there's a fantastic job. His name is Jamie Rhodes. Every time we have gone in there he's asking customers how we are doing, guides, his employees, us and gives us wonderful service. He seems to really care about his job takes pride in it. One of the disappointments is that when we came in here the last time, we usually have a very good beer selection to go with our pizza. We heard there was new management, so we hope they will continue the practice of having some wonderful craft beers going forward. Regardless, the food is great and the service is great and we will continue to come back. read more

They have a drive through at this location. The inside was empty around lunch on a Saturday. They have white and wheat pizza pizza crust. Many, many toppings included in the price of $8.99 it's a little bigger than a personal pan. I also had cookies and creme Gelato it came free for my birthday sign up on the app. The staff was young people and they were all friendly and courtesy. read more

Your Pie - a group of people preparing food - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

My 13 year old says this is worthy of 5 stars, and he is super picky! We placed our order online and picked it up in store which was very convenient and easy. I was pretty impressed with the quality of the crust and toppings. I will definitely be back again! read more

Your Pie - Pizza with all the meats - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Im not going to lie, when I first visited YourPie I was skeptical. Many of the other reviews had listed the staff as rude and disrespectful. However, today I received service equivalent to nothing I have received in my 57 years on this god forsaken planet. Walking into the restaurant, I accidentally slipped on a Starbucks cup left outside. As I was falling, a brilliant young man dashed to my aid and saved me from my fall, possibly preventing serious injuries I could have suffered. This was a start, but it continued. After receiving my pizza, which was fabulous for freezer food, I was confronted by the young lad. The best part of the day was not him doing anything out of the ordinary, but he was genuinely interested in talking with me about my 4 divorced wives. We had a long chat, shared some laughs, and I continued on with my day. I decided to leave a review for the young man, who I believe was named Caleb Bucket. Just wanted to tell my story and help this young man receive some recognition for his actions, and with that, he has once again given me hope for the future generations of AMERICA. -J. Tom read more

Cold food . Missing items. Delivery by door dash not known until check out. I tried to call our DoorDash driver to address the issue, no answer. I tried calling the restaurant to address the issue, no answer. I don't believe I've ever had pizza this disgusting ever. I order regular brownies they just gave me what they had. No salad or no chips which are clearly on the receipt. First time and last time eating at this place. Save your money and taste buds! read more

See all

The whole place is only run by high schoolers which would be fine if every other meal wasn't completely butchered. For example today I ordered a margherita pizza with mushrooms and red onion... I received only tomato and pizza sauce. The service is fine usually but there is the occasional instance when I'm ignored trying to pick up an online order. The only reason we were going back was because when they listen to our order it's good, but I don't think we'll be going back again. read more

Probably the worst Your Pie location I've been to. Bunch of kids working. Pizza had tiny portions of toppings. Went back to order cheese sticks and was told to come back to the counter for them. Not sure how I was supposed to know when they were done so I kept getting up to check. Waited for the bathroom and a girl who worked there was in for over 10 minutes. read more

I've been visiting this location for over a year. I guess they recently did some new hires but this one young lady names Alexis is not customer friendly at all. Twice I came to the location where one time she was cashing me out she didn't smile, say thank you nothing, and then went back to talking and laughing with her coworkers. No personality what so ever. The next visit I went for my lunch which I have down several times, she didn't speak, didn't say welcome just said what do I want - in reference to my order. So that was twice she failed at the opportunity to treat me like a guest. The rest of the staff was friendly and younger kids but they smiled. I have not been back since. read more

Easy parking. Clean inside. Courteous and fast service. Reasonable prices. Great custom pizzas. I take the kids here all the time. Simply put... 5 stars. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Great made to order fresh food and cooked fast! Good service and clean store.Chopped

We typically like your pie salads, but when you order online for pickup, and your salad is missing key ingredients (meat), it's quite disappointing. read more

I like this place, I have a high bar on pizza on this place is decent but it's "my pie", I get everything I want and nothing I don't.

I come into your pie and I order my pasta and I go and sit down and wait. While no workers are present in the front, the pasta takes a disturbing amount of time to cook and I'm concerned. When it comes out, as expected, it's burn with black charred spots everywhere. The overweight white lady gives a bland excuse claiming that "their oven is on really low temperature" and when I go up again to say that it's really burnt and if there was any way this could be resolved, she lies and gives me another excuse to say that it's perfectly normal. I've had this pasta 4 times already and never before has it been this terrible done. If you're going to mess up a customer's food, don't lie to their face two times with bad excuses. read more

Your Pie - Pesto NAT PASTA - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Nice homey feel...we are well taken care of when we come here and the food is very fresh & yummy.

I can't give enough props to Jacob and Emily. Jacob you always listen to our feedback and open to any and all suggestions. Emily you make you patrons feel so welcomed and like they have been your friend forever. I wish the bar area could be a bit bigger but it has allowed those of us that come in on Thursday Pint Night to get to make new friends. The beer varieties are fabulous and enjoy supporting so many of our local breweries. As far as food goes, you can't complain as you are the one that is responsible for your own pizza slide from sliding into the oven. I know they have great looking salads, I haven't eaten one though. I would suggest this place to anyone and Jacob keep up the great work in running this awesome pizzeria and selecting such great staff. read more

Double Pepperoni??? I don't think so. Pizza was nothing special. There are better options out there. I cannot recommend this place. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Man I'll tell you what this place was aweosme. Back home I go to blaze but it's tough there for allergen pizzas. My wife has a severe dairy allergy and Ainsley at Your Pie made my wife's allergen friendly pizza in a special area in the back. Also- they were kind the entire time. Often times restaurants treat you like a bother when you bring up allergies. Your Pie is fantastic. read more

When you have two teenage daughters and they are super picky about what pizza they eat, this place hit the bull's-eye! Great service, very clean spot, you choose the sauce, cheese, toppings, etc. Fast, easy and moderately priced. From the time you finalize "your pie" it's about 7 minutes until you are sitting down enjoying it. Good spot, bravo! read more

I've been to MOD several times and was well impressed. I thought perhaps Your Pie would provide a similar experience. I was disappointed. I ordered three pies. The ingredients are chopped into tiny chunks. The garlic is not fresh. I asked the preparer to add more onions and and she just added like 5 slivers. Same with other ingredients. By the the time I got to the Oregano, I figured her out. When she just sprinkled a bit on only ONE-HALF of the pies, I didn't say anything. I am not coming back. Since the ingredients were tiny, my guests asked what were the ingredients. Then, when I got the pies they were COLD. This was last Saturday. read more