Used to be a family favorite but now it's a dump and you guessed it....short staffed. Oh, and if you have a good allergy, you are penalized. $4 extra to get a gf crust. Im pretty sure that is a form of prejudice and discrimination!! Figure it out your pie. read more

I hadn't been to Your Pie in forever so it was good to go back! When we went in it was pretty crowded but it was ok. At first we wanted to go outside but it was a too hot summer day! Loll than we chose to go inside where it was way cooler. we sat down than we got are drinks I got lemonade my brother did and my mom got coke. After we went back to are seats. And we waited for the pizza it was pretty good but not as good as Nyc pizza or Antico's pizza. Hahah loll After we ate are pizza we got ice cream it was ok I chose to eat it later though. Overall I would go here every once in a while. read more

See all

Worst experience ever! Cauliflower crust was covered in flour. Even after shaking it off it was still covered (see pic). I didn't want to complain but we couldn't enjoy the pizza b/c of the gritty flour aftertaste. But we really felt they needed to know so they don't mess up someone else's pizza. After bringing it to their attention one guy said the other person 'shouldn't have used flour b/c they have a special pan for cauliflower crusts'. The other young man/teen who made the pizza was lackadaisical and said "sorry, I should've used less flour". So now we're out $16.00 & all we receive is a shoulder shrug & a simple sorry. I think you should do more & have a better response when you royally mess up a simple order. I've never been one to write reviews but this was very disappointing. The pizza could've been great but they ruined it. They could've offered a discount for future visit or remake it. Next time I'll speak up right away b/c it doesn't seem like they cared that we didn't enjoy the pizza. read more

Your Pie - Flour covering the bottom of cauliflower crust pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

Not bad for the price. The pizza was okay but they are stingy with the toppings. I did like that it was thin crust .

Tried this place out for lunch today on the recommendation of a friend. The service is kind, the execution is terrible. While doing the build your own salad (lots of options for this as well as build your own pizza!), i noticed the romaine mix in the well is pretty brown- its only ~11:30am and they open at 11. The employee noticed something off about the cheese he was about to grab so he asks a manager about it and the manager went back and forth with another cheese container located elsewhere in the well about one being vegan but doesn't seem to make up his mind which is which. The employee is disturbed by this and i'm sure he hopes no one asks for vegan cheese today. I couldn't see the different from where i was standing but idk. I ordered 2 build your own salads and a pasta dish & pizza directly off the menu. The salads were left to sit while the pizza and pasta cooked (about 15 minutes). The salads were mixed with the same instrument (idk if it was a gloved hand or utensil) because I got some onion and salad dressing from my coworker's salad in mine. I don't have any allergies, but I also didn't order jalapeno honey mustard or onion, and what if I did have an allergy? Salads are inconsistent in size and pretty small for $8. The pasta dish (Mia's Marinara Meatball) was made incorrectly and the meat was left out entirely. The amount of toppings is a bit stingy (even cheese and sauce, there was a good 2.5" of crust left uncovered) on both pizza and salad. The cook time on the pizza also seems inconsistent, though I only saw about 4 go in and out (one was dropped and had to be remade, RIP their lunch). This place has been open a few months and I expected better trained staff, especially when the person who seems in charge (maybe he wasn't, he just had a different outfit on than the other dude) doesn't know what they're doing. I'll give it another go for pizza. They do have a small selection of beers on tap and the gelato looked good, but I am not impressed. read more

I had the opportunity to attend the grand opening for this Your Pie and I was blown away! I've eaten at a variety of Your Pie locations but the aura and the atmosphere of this location wows you from the moment you walk in. The pizza was phenomenal and the staff was happy and friendly. I also enjoyed the variety of craft beers and wine. Everyone was thrilled and management was really on top of everything. I will be attending this Your Pie whenever I am in the Smyrna area. read more

Your Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

See all

I usually love Your Pie and support them but the service on 2 occasions was not good. 2 managers just watching 1 employee do all the work. Food was slow & quality was rushed. Hopefully this gets the owner and they can fix these issues. read more

Your Pie on Atlanta rd is clean, has outdoor seating, Gelato and great tasting pizza. Can't go wrong with a build your own pizza restaurant.

This is a great place! I like being able to make my own pizza (setup is like Subway) and the wood-fired pizza always comes out perfectly (not charred like Antico). They also have beer and wine. Patio is a big plus. read more

Been hearing about this place for awhile, so I decided to try it tonight. The place was clean, and the staff very friendly. The concept is pretty basic, create your own pizza, but they have some specialities. I tried their Lineage pizza, with sausage, pepperoni, and all kinds of veggies. I really enjoyed getting the pizza in abt 5 min., and really enjoyed it. The thin crust was really good, and I'm not one who typically likes super thin crust. I can't wait to go back and try something else.. read more

I've been here 3 times. The front staff are not pleasant nor are they knowledgable about what's going. And although the pizza is good, the service is super slow. The toppings are right there, I'm telling you what I want why isn't taking them so long just to out the toppings on. I personally think the workers are misplaced or there are not enough workers. And 2 of the 3 times that I've been here the manager or owner whoever he is seems a little childish and not really helping. And both times they were clearly behind. If they don't get some retraining people will stop coming. There is a competitor very close by with the same pizza making model. I will not waste my lunch period here for the sake of time and definitely wouldn't recommend it to my colleagues for the same reason. read more

My first visit to this restaurant was lunch with a coworker. He has 1 hour for lunch, I was off for the remainder of the day. We arrived there at 1:00pm....We ordered 2 salads and a small pizza to split. We looked as it was being made and the person making the capese salad obviously had not done it before. He was asking the others how to make it while we are there. I have had it in Italy and other authentic bistros in the US, I saw he was doing it incorrectly. But at this point, we are here to try it out. The owner/mgr/son came over to assist him in making it. We then went to pay and to split the tab. The cashier split it correctly based on the receipt but he told us it all went on my card...Fine, I would get cash from my coworker. I looked at the receipt and it showed it was split. The owner came over and said to the cashier, we don't use that code and it didn't split it, and don't do this or that in front of us, etc...I said but the receipt shows it did split it and in all this time its now 1:25pm. So we finally sit down and my co worker needs more dressing. A waiter said he would get it. After a few minutes we saw him making new pizzas!!! So I got up to get a condiment and asked the owner/mgr/son was the additional dressing coming? as the guy who was to bring it was now making new pizzas and seemingly forgot. Now I am one keen on excellent customer service and especially in new eateries but time is of essence with the time it spent to get to a simple request for dressing. (Its now 1:35 pm) The owner/mgr/son came over and brought it and offered a "snide" remark "I didn't realize that when he said he was bringing it back that he had to 'drop everything' to bring it right then." I kept my peace but I thought, 1. This place is new, 2. I am new to trying this place, 3. This is the owner/mgr/son and if he does not feel being responsive to new or existing customers is paramount then why would anyone return? The waiter/employee was not dropping everything, but just following through on what was requested by a customer. If you are new to the area and you appear not to want to champion good customer service and follow through, then what is the point? Also for a new crew in training, you should have a prep meeting to get your staff up to speed on how to prepare the menu items before lunch time and not to chastise them in front of customers. Having good food is only one component of a successful restaurant. read more

I loved it! Especially the gluten free crust with olive oil and then my toppings. My 4 year old son and 2 year old niece looooved their pizzas too! My whole family went! All of us, with our different taste were satisfied. Would definitely recommend and will definitely go again! read more

Technically, it was a pizza. The crust wasn't good, the ingredients were ok. The pizza was small. Everything about it was average at best. We were disappointed. I can make a pizza on my own that tastes better. If you're going to spend $20+ on pizza might as well go to real pizzeria down the street with bigger pizzas, better ingredients, and better crust. Much better options in Smyrna. read more

First time at YOUR PIES Richard the Mgr greeted us at the door and explain the concept and walked us through the menu. The pizza was amazing and the crew was very friendly and answered any questions. I love a clean restaurant so you know I'll be back ! read more

Good service, they are trying really hard. Food needs a lot of work.

I was able to dine at Your Pie Smyrna during the soft opening which was an event where all proceeds from the entrees went to charity. They have make your own pizzas, paninis, and salads. All three entrees are the same price of $7.99 but if you make it a combo it is about $4 more. They also serve gelato and have beer on tap. I have eaten at a few other chains with the customizable personal pizza but their crust is the best I have had. I had the 10 inch pizza and made it a combo with a drink and gelato. I tried the cookies and cream which did not disappoint. Pizzas cook quickly so I think they will do well with the lunch crowd or those looking for a quick bite. I work nearby so and will be telling others. It is great for families but also for anyone looking for a tasty fast casual meal option. The staff was friendly as well so I was sold. There are lots of toppings so I will be back to try something different and grab a beer. read more

See all

Pro: tasty pizza. Nice, fresh ingredients with good choices. Happy place with friendly employees. Nice location. Cons: slowwww. Don't come here if you're limited on time. Took 25 min to get my pie. Also, they wear disposable gloves, but I saw some of the workers scratch their heads and faces without changing their gloves. Just because you're wearing gloves does not mean your hands are clean! Managers, you should be teaching your teams to charge gloves after each prep. How long are these employees going without a glove change? If you go here to eat, just ask food prep folks to change their gloves/wash hands before they touch your food. I was thinking of Subway where they change gloves after each sandwich prep and was shocked to see these folks scratching, writing, scratching, adjusting their hats, writing again, adjusting their pants, making pizzas, scratching, writing, etc with same gloves. read more

The BEST customer service ever. Everything about this pizza is amazing and the experience in general is absolutely marvelous. You will not be disappointed at all by choosing Your Pie if you are wanting pizza! My husband and I are in town from Tampa and we were taken away by the customer service and care of this establishment! read more

OMG this was my first time trying this place , and I was so confused on what to order but the young man helped me choose and I must say I enjoyed the pizza (the NAT ) which was absolutely amazing. It was fresh and my wife enjoyed the fresh salad .thanks to the staff that was so friendly at assisting us . Special thanks to Richie / rich (not sure of the name exactly) for your recommendation, and for taking your your time in assistance. I will return . read more

After regularly going to the Your Pie in Buckhead, I was so excited to hear that one opened on Atl rd. I was greeted by a lovely young lady (Bonnie) who was happy to accommodate my gluten free needs. The pizza was even better than in Buckhead and came out at just the right time. The crust is perfect, crunchy on the outside and doughy on the inside. The manager (Richard) was also a delight, he even came to our table to greet us. All in all, my sons and I were very pleased with our experience here. I would recommend this place to all my friends. read more