MY STEAK AND CHEESE WAS DELICIOUS!!! It might have been a little heavy on American cheese but it was super flavorful and creamy in every single bite. Honestly- the best steak and cheese I have had in a long time. Don't second guess it- make an order. Footnote: we did take out. Easy to order, easy to pick up. read more

Zerio's - Steak and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Their eggplant parm grinder is 10000/10 the best around. It normally comes with prov cheese but I get mozz instead. This place has a big selection of other cold subs, hot subs, paninis and pizzas as well. Their staff is always helpful and friendly, the place is always clean. They do a great job on everything. The best sandwich place around!!! read more

Can't believe I haven't ever rated Zerio's. I have been coming here for 20 plus years, honestly since they first opened their doors. Every time I have ordered here whether it was a tuna grinder, cheesesteak, chicken cutlet, salad, soups (omg don't get me started on the soups), or pizza everything has been fresh and flavorful. Probably the best deli, in my opinion, in central CT. If you've never tried them, you should. Thanks Zerio's! read more

We ordered a small pepperoni pizza and it was just enough! Haven't been here in a while and forgot how good the pizza is. The crust reminds me of a Chuck E. Cheese style crispiness. Order was completed quick for pickup. Service was friendly upon pickup read more

See all

Great restaurant. Great customer service. Affordable prices. While on vacation we ordered out several times. They stay open late and the prices were affordable. I recommend. read more

Zerios pizza is one of my favorite spots to grab pizza when in cromwell. The Pizza is delicious and always fresh! I ordered a small pepperoni pizza on my last visit and I wish I had gotten a large it was so good! I have been coming here for a while and will continue to. Staff is friendly and helpful. read more

See all

Food was ok. This is basically a take-out place so if you expect service when you sit down, don't. You will have to flag down the help multiple times, then go up to pay your own bill. read more

The lobster roll is very good. Their Italian options are good as well. The wings were a little dry. Neat restaurant and great customer service. read more

Wow. To be honest, I didn't have any crazy expectations. But this pizza really blew me away. We got the BBQ and buffalo pizza (half & half) and the ratios were so on point. The thing that stuck out to us the most was the SAUCE! Omg. SOO good on both pizzas. But really, everything. The flavor was on point. Will absolutely be coming back. read more

Zerio's - Buffalo Chicken and BBQ Chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

They say some of the best eats any where in the world are your mom and pop shops. Folks, this is it for Cromwell. Great service, excellent quality. Highly recommend. read more

Food is very good and fair price . Service is always good . The restaurant is clean and upbeat place.

Ok, so, since my last review I've haunted by the inclination give Zerios another try. Remembering they offer a white clam pizza, today was the day that I decided to follow that inclination. For once, I actually called in my order ahead of time; so, there was no wait time. Immediately, the aroma struck me as it filled the air around me with hints of garlic and cheese. So compelling was this scent that I opened the box as soon as entered my car. The folks at Zerios get an "A" for presentation. I won't even try to describe my pizzas appearance; I couldn't fully do it justice. I'll simply say "beautiful", and point you to the picture. Now, I've had some great white clam pizza in my time; and yes, some bad white clam pizza, too. But this, was...just ok. The garlic was well proportioned and cheese was plentiful, as were the clams. The texture, however, was a bit on the dry side, and that made all the difference. At just under twenty bucks, before tip, ghis was by all means a fair price, for a fair meal. read more

Zerio's - White Clam Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Right when we walked in we were greated very nicely. Staff was very friendly. There was a free sample of pizza on the counter as well. I ate two separate days. Day was was the buffalo chicken panini. The chicken was slightly dry but still really great and would definitely recommend. The sauce in there is a delight. The chefs salad was pretty good. Loved the ham roll ups on the salad. The house dressing was great. Just wish there was more. Not enough to cover the whole salad for my liking. I 100% would definitely come back. Was a great value read more

See all

An unassuming little spot with great food and customer service. I thought their pizza was great and their sandwiches looked delicious. read more

Awesome place great people great food I would eat here at least 4 days a week if I could ; read more

Best buffalo chicken wing and meatball calzone is to die for... great atmosphere and friendly.. love getting dinner here... keep the good food coming to my belly... service is always good, friendly and welcoming... read more

I'm so happy my best friend showed me Zerio's. We recently came here for lunch and split the Southwest Smoked Turkey Panini, as well as Buffalo Chicken Pasta Salad. I love a good panini and anything buffalo, and both items did not disappoint. Honestly, my food was pretty amazing - all the flavors of the panini was downright delicious and that pasta was creamy with just enough kick. The portions are huge - the reason for us splitting - and the price was fair. They also offer complimentary slices of cheese pizza, which was much appreciated while waiting for our order. I'm already planning on returning and trying other paninis! read more

Zerio's - Southwest Smoked Turkey Panini and Buffalo Chicken Pasta Salad - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

I've never eaten here in person, but we regularly do takeout. Their pizza is good, a bit of a thicker crust and the tomato sauce is a little sweeter than other places around. We really enjoy it for a change of pace. My husband usually gets some wings and I get some chicken soup. I absolutely love their chicken soup! It's flavorful and doesn't skimp on the chicken. No tiny chunks substantial strips with all the other flavorful components. We've never been let down by Zerio's. Our next takeout order we'll have to venture out a bit and try some of their other offerings. read more

Great take out food. I've been ordering on and off from Zerio's for about 10 years now and I wanted to give them a shout out for their great paninis and pizza. Recently I had the Buffalo chicken panini via Doordash. It was a generous size definetly enough for 2 meals. Super crunchy bread,delicious chicken and sauce/ blue cheese center. read more

Often give you a time that you're order will be ready and it's always later , then get an attitude when you ask why ,owners son is rude

Zerios was recommended to me by a Co-Worker for their Buffalo Chicken Soup that they have as a special on occasion. It's the best soup I've ever had and I'm sure to get it every time they have it! They make some amazing pizzas, salads and sandwiches too. Staff is extremely kind and the environment is great. I wish there was an option to give more than 5 stars! read more

Good for birthday parties, 3 pizzas (1 plain cheese, 1 margherita, 1 sausage mushroom) runs about $65. Can feed 7 adults and 4 kids. Cheers! read more

Zerio's - two pizzas on the counter - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

The antipasta salad was the worst I have ever had- all lettuce barely anything else- not worth the $12 for lettuce

I tried one of their panini sandwiches and was taken back how much was in the panini. I had the turkey and cheese and was pleasantly surprised and happy. Would definitely return to in the future. read more

Came for takeout and of course, had to order the paninis. They weren't kidding when they say thesr are HUGE. When I actually saw them in person I was blown away...how do you even make a slice of bread that big?!? I ordered the meatball & ricotta and the hubs ordered the buffalo chicken. Personally, I was obsessed with the meatball and the ricotta was so creamy. I made it my mission to finish it...but alas, I failed. This will definitely be on our go-to takeout list from now on! read more

Zerio's - paninis bigger than your head - Pizza Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

Every sandwich I have had here is good! My favorite is the Thanksgiving panini. I can normally get 3 lunches out of the sandwich since it so big! I also love their tuna Mac! Nice and creamy and Mmmmm good! My husband loves the chicken parm grinder. It's also large enough to get 2 meals out of it. Staff is friendly and efficient! read more

I generally love this place but today I ordered a loaded potato soup that was so bad, I think it may have been spoiled. It tasted sour but maybe it had a lot of sour cream but I couldn't eat it. I pulled out the potatoes and ate them cause I had to eat something but threw out the soup. I'm getting nauseous just thinking about it. Check the soup for spoilage or get rid of it. Terrible. But I do usually love this place. read more

Great food! The pizza is fantastic. So are the soup and sandwiches. Chicken salad is best ever!

My favorite restaurant in the Cromwell area! I've made countless orders and tried a variety of items on the menu, Zerio's doesn't miss! Really great food. read more

The staff is very friendly and fast! The food is absolutely delicious! I am a frequent customer,

We were on our way to New York and needed some sustenance to continue the ride. The paninis are GIANT. I would have split one if I had realized their size. We got a calzone as well and the amount of ricotta was amazing! Our daughter had an Italian on a roll and she was very impressed. She's 8, but is an aspiring foodie. Our son asked me to write down his roast beef ingredients because it was so delicious. We would definitely stop on our way through again! read more

I absolutely love this place! Everyone is hard working and polite and the food here is amazing! I always tip them because they deserve it! The place reminds me of Lil Italy! Oh and they are Always slam packed, so call ahead for your order. I'd give them 10 stars if I could! read more

Ordered takeout, cheese tortellini entrée. It was ok but I was very disappointed that it did not come with the salad as advertised. I had walked there and when I got home and opened my bag it only had the tortellini and a piece of garlic bread in it. I may try other items in future but will be sure to double check my order before I leave. read more

See all

Too much seasoning on the pizza! Everything else was great but the pizza its basically not eatable. I really wish the it was better

Excellent paninis! We've had the Buffalo chicken panini and the Reuben. They're souls are great too! read more

4.5 stars An excellent place to get some sandwiches! Stopped by here for lunch and it was absolutely PACKED. Zerio's is clearly a local favorite. Despite the high traffic, our food was prepared relatively quickly and neatly. The sandwiches were pretty average in terms of content, but the bread was really special. It was fluffy, but crunchy and just delicious overall! The portions are also pretty large. Service was friendly and quick. Food was solid overall. Price was pretty standard (~$10). Ambience was clean and pretty central being right off the highway. They also give you a free small slice of pizza while you wait, which was nice. I'd definitely return, but would just be mindful of the lunch traffic if you're in a rush! Check them out! read more

See all

With restaurants still in a state of flux we decided on an evening picnic. Called Zerio's places our takeout order. Order ready right on time. We took our food up to Pierson park and sat under the pavilion. Kid loved the panini and my pizza was excellent. The prosciutto grinder for the wife was not Parma which is what I think she was expecting but tasty none the less. read more

See all

Had a pretty good panini at Zerio's. Went in for Lunch and the place was packed. Clearly a local hot spot. As such, it took a bit longer than I would have liked to get our food, but the quality and taste were superb. I got the smoked turkey panini. A lot of the paninis are pre made so when you order, they just throw it on the press. They also usually have some pizza made up and you can take a slice and eat it for free while you wait for your food to come out. The inside is a bit small, and seating is limited, so get there early or go for a late lunch if you don't like the crowds. They have an abundance of deli meats, salads, and Italian dishes to choose from. My lunch cost about $12 for a panini, soda and bag of chips. I left stuffed....probably too stuffed! read more

We just moved up the street from here and LOVE their prepared dinners as well as their panini's. Last week I had the Thanksgiving panini. Try it! You will not be disappointed! read more

Fabulous everything- staff is nice. Tasty sandwiches and pizza. Typical deli with seating. Wish they delivered!!