Great food. Great atmosphere. Always enjoy my time spent here. Excellent value. Looking forward to my next visit

Was a real successful restaurant with a great menu that decided they could make more money by raising the prices a lot and paring down the menu. Food is good, not exceptional. Few tables in basement with neat atmosphere. Upstairs in main restaurant very crowded. Family dining at steakhouse prices. read more

We'll start off by saying the food was great and the ambiance was fine. That said, the customer service attitude of the staff was the worst we've seen. We ordered takeout before the dinner rush and were promised a 20 minute ready time. We arrived on time but the order wasn't complete. We decided to have some drinks while we waited. The server wasn't happy we sat at her table and reinforced that displeasure each time she stopped including when she dropped off the bill prematurely. When our wait for the food was up to 45 minutes, we asked the server about it. She responded she had nothing to do with takeout. My daughter-in-law approached the manager about the wait and was rebuffed and essentially mocked. Customer sevice is a relatively simple golden rule concept re-enforced by "do I want people to spend money in my store?" We won't be back. read more

The Prime Rib was a special and it was excellent, the creamed corn was also very good.

The food here is just great. Hands down. The service is good too. Love the steak tips in cream sauce. Everything is always fresh and so yummy. read more

Best restaurant in town. My wife and I's "go to" for great food and drinks! Make sure and try dining in the cellar. We love it!

This is an outstanding atmosphere and a gorgeous format that I am thrilled to have access to here in Cicero. As a resident, I'm proud to support the local art and the fun speak easy bar in the basement as well as a great dining experience. Being the second time I've dined here, I arrived shortly afternoon opening so the wait was not 1-2 hours. Even with call ahead seating, I knew better, so if you go arrive between 4:30-5 for the best experience. The appetizers and bread were fab. The signature horseradish tomato soup is to die for. Last time we dined I played it safe with the filet, super awesome quality cut of meat made to perfection. The side of creamed corn was pretty good as well. This time I had the 10 west pasta and added shrimp. Nothing to write home about, a little blah, I needed to add salt and pepper but it wasn't bad. My husband gave a good not great review for the ribs. Mother in law says the pork tenderloin medallions were quite good. I really like this place but unfortunately it just can't keep up with the demand so meals are slow to arrive to the table, even being one of the first tables seated we were here over 1 1/2 hours and weren't lounging. I just don't feel its worth coming at my preferred time for dinner around 7ish since I know it isn't quite worth that wait. Hopefully it will continue to evolve to fill that much needed hole here in Cicero. read more

10 West - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

My husband and I had a last minute date night away and sat in the downstairs bar area. We have always sat upstairs and it was such a cool, cozy environment! We enjoyed everything from the Crab Stuffed Mushrooms, Tomato Horseradish Soup, the bread we used to sop up the sauce from the mushrooms (swoon), my bleu cheese topped filet and his ribeye, the Brussel sprouts and the touch of creamed corn were absolutely heaven! Angie was top notch and on the spot with service! We had to have the bread pudding and tiramisu. Hands down best desserts! Thank you to the 10 West Team for knocking it out of the park for us once again! read more

It was busy Saturday night so we sat at the bar. Get the cream corn and order extra its delicious! Also ask Michael to make you an Irish coffee its the best you've ever had, trust me! The steak isnt great but everything else we had was amazing read more

It has always been a treat to dine at 10W, and I always look forward to coming here when I'm in the area. The wine, the food, and the interior space are all worth prioritizing a trip to Cicero. Any review sub five conflicts with my every experience. The Filet and Tomato Horseradish Soup are my favorites. read more

We have been here many times but the stakes stakes were tough. The server was matter of fact and the manager was even worse. We will never go back. read more

A not so hidden gem. Wait can be long but go for a seat in the bar. The server was awesome. It was my birthday and he hooked me up with a great gin martini. Food was great. The tomato horseradish soup a must. Wife had chicken. It was great. A definite repeat. read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants anywhere. It's obvious they use fresh ingredients and take care with details. I've had the chicken and noodles, which was amazing, we've had burgers that taste like the meat was freshly ground and the salads are insanely crisp. The model is just serve really good quality food and don't try to be cute. It works perfectly and I've never had a bad experience here. Their only problem is being too busy, which isn't a problem for them but certainly is for you if you get their a bit late. Totally worth the wait, though. read more

This has become one of my family's favorite spots since it opened. I never would have thought that there'd be a local, lovely steakhouse in Cicero, and I was ridiculously impressed. Albeit, I didn't have the highest expectations for the place before going there, but I thought that it was a sweet little spot. I liked the feeling of the place. I reminded me of BJ's, if you've ever been there. It was like, a cross between a tavern and a restaurant, but it also had some nice natural lighting. I ordered the Filet Mignon with the sweet potato fries. It came with a salad, which I thought had a lil too much cheese on it. The veggies made me happy regardless though. The steak was cooked perfectly to my liking, and the 6oz was a great serving size. I don't eat a lot of red meat, but I figured when in Rome... the fries were really tasty as well. But I rarely meet fries that I don't like. It's really good to call ahead and reserve, I heard that the place can fill up quickly! I would definitely recommend snagging some steak or pork chops at this spot though! read more

This was my first time at 10 West in Cicero, IN. We called ahead to put our name on a list, but the wait was still almost an hour-a very popular place. We shared a delicious, but small appetizer-Cheese Crostini with tomato horseradish soup dip-excellent! Two of us had very good fish tacos, which unexpectedly included no side. I ordered sweet potato fries as a side-very ordinary. Two ordered the Cuban Press which was okay, but not really pressed enough. Another ordered a steak sandwich which again was okay. There were, also, only four beers on tap. All in all, an okay meal. We did love the ambience in the bar in the basement. read more

Have driven by many times but never stopped because the line to get in stretched down the block. With Covid, and slow reopening we went there tonight to celebrate my husband's birthday. All the food was amazing. All made in house - the fresh baked bread was to die for! The tomato horseradish soup was tasty - the horseradish gives it a little kick. I had the walleye w/ braised cabbage. Fish was perfectly cooked w/ just the right amount of crispy edges. Braised cabbage was a great sweet/ sour combo that is so hard to find. And to top it off chef made sugar cream pie - the State Pie of Indiana!! Oh boy - our server was Chamron - so delightful, full of info about the menu & very conscious of new standards for service in the Age of Covid. We will definitely be back! This is a local gem not to be missed!! read more

This place is so good!! From my salad to my dessert it was amazing!! Service is spot on!! I got the Walley with grilled asparagus... delish!! I highly recommend 10 West!!! read more

Great food here. My wife had her work Christmas party here, and we split fried ravioli and grilled cheese appetizers. I had the walleye with asparagus and creamed corn, and my wife had the tenderloin. We split the brownie sundae for dessert, which was tasty. read more

My wife and I ate dinner here Thursday night. Catfish was good, but needed to cook a little longer. Key Lime pie was excellent. Carrot Cake was very good, but The Boathouse and Swan Dive's is better, unfortunately, their serving size is pretty small at the Boathouse. 10 West served a much larger portion of Carrot Cake read more

We had a great first experience! The hub and I went here for an impromptu date night. We asked to be seated in the Cellar. We started with the spinach artichoke dip and it was delicious! I ordered the Bacon wrapped pork tenderloin with a Ceasar salad. The hub had the schnitzel with a house salad. We Loved both our entrees. Both salads had some of the best house made Croutons we have ever had. For dessert we ordered House made Key Lime pie and Salted Carmel Pecan cheesecake. Both were Devine! Our server Trey was great he was personable, attentive and professional. We will definitely add this to the date night rotation.. read more

Every experience has been wonderful. Call ahead seating is an absolute must during any evening. Hostesses are attentive and friendly. Service is prompt, yet appropriately timed. I cannot get enough of the tuna appetizer. Thin slices of sesame crusted tuna sitting over crispy grain wafers; tangy and sweet sauce, but give it some wasabi for a kick. The cedar plank salmon is perfectly cooked, paired nicely with sweet creamed corn like I've never had! It's a custard consistency with large kernels that lend great texture. It's soon to be a favorite. My husband gets filet or steaks, which are melt-in-your-mouth juicy. Oh let's back up, how could I forget the bread!? This bread is cut in slices and fanned out, then coated in melted garlic butter, served with more butter. It's perfect just the way it is. Overall, a top notch restaurant in the heart of the sweet little town of Cicero, Indiana. The atmosphere is that of upscale restaurant with the benefit of being so close to home. I look forward to dining for many years to come, thank you! read more

We went here for my birthday dinner. The crab stuffed mushrooms and grilled cheese crustini were phenomenal. The horseradish tomato soup was a nice kicked up touch with the grilled cheese. I had the 10 West pasta which was good but it was hard to live up to those appetizers. My drink was not fantastic; pink coconut, but otherwise it was a very nice atmosphere to celebrate my birthday. Nice without being stuffy, still family friendly without being loud. Would go back sometime but still personally would probably save it for a date night and not take my younger children. read more

Fantastic food and atmosphere!! We love this place so much!!! Their surf and turf specials are mouth watering!!

10 West is my favorite place to eat. I love the atmosphere, the delicious food (especially the creamed corn) and the friendliness of the staff. I have ordered the prime rib combo most of the time, and love their house (Green Goddess) dressing. Cicero, Indiana has Morse Lake nearby, and it is a favorite for Noblesville, Cicero, and TIpton residents. read more

10 West - View of first floor restaurant from table - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

The best chicken and noodles in Indiana, in my opinion. The taste was better than my Mom's! Sorry, Mom.

First time eating here and it was great. We started off with the chicken nachos and they were a little different but very good. For dinner I had the fish tacos and they were delicious also. Great service with no complaints. read more

My husband and I made our first trip to 10 West on a Friday night, as we're getting ready to move to Arcadia and have already heard good things about this restaurant. We arrived a little at 8 pm and were able to get a seat right away at a tall table in the bar. Michael took great care of us. The bread was wonderful with melted garlic butter. Bacon wrapped shrimp had a sweet glaze that was outstanding, they managed to keep the bacon a little crispy but did not over cook the shrimp. I had the fish tacos ... the fish was nicely cooked and seasoned, but I would have liked more of a true pico de gallo rather than the handful of chopped tomatoes and green onions thrown on top. His black and bleu steak was outstanding. We are thrilled to have a great dinner spot so near our new home and will definitely be going back. read more

10 West - Fish tacos - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

Love this place. Great food, great atmosphere. Perfect for a couples night out. Fish tacos are very tasty and even the cole slaw and desserts are homemade. So many different options on their menu. Worth the trip to Cicero. read more

10 West - Nice bar area and the downstairs is great for a totally different more subdued feeling. - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

The most consistent restaurant I have ever been to in terms of quality of food and service...and I'm a picky SOB!

This place is always a sure bet. It's the best steak on the far north side of Indy. The meat and produce always seem to be ultra tasty and fresh. Quality of the raw goods matter and they get it. The chef is a local celebrity for his craft, you won't be disappointed. Stick with the steak for your best bet but the specials are always incredible too. My wife is a vegetarian and likes the list of veggie sides, it works for her. Can be a wait on the weekend, that's a good thing. 5 stars from this meat eater! read more

10 West - The bar area. - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

See all

How can you not love this place! A very nice restaurant on a corner in a quaint central Indiana town. The food is fantastic and the wait staff is attentive. There's usually a slight to long wait so use their "call ahead" feature for seating. read more

First time at 10 West and loved it! Great ambience, but it's much more. The food and drinks were amazing. Started with the crab stuffed mushrooms which were a perfect appetizer. I enjoyed the special, stuffed blackened salmon with whipped sweet potatoes. Every thing was delicious and reasonably priced. I need to go back to try more of their extensive menu selections. read more

Fantastic food and great service! We were there on Wednesday night with my father, who needed some physical assistance. The staff went above and beyond my expectations. They found us the perfect table and helped get him in and out of the restaurant. And the food was amazing. Thanks for making this a comfortable evening! read more

Great place and food. Had awesome pork tacos and steak sliders. Our server was friendly and efficient. We called ahead on a Saturday for a table for three and still had a total wait time of almost 1 1/2 but we planned for a wait based on reviews. Part of the reason, I believe, was a very large party lingering at their table upstairs. Not everyone in our party was 21 so we sat upstairs in the side room which was really quiet - needs some candles or soft music maybe. It would be a great room for an event/function, but has less atmosphere than the main room and definitely downstairs (which I will definitely come back to sit in). read more

K.I.S.S. method perfected... Great Chef.. Great Vision... great people in the right spots at the right time.. and a Local Owner who happens to have a market/Meat shop 200 yards from the front door... Top 5 eats in all of Metro Indy... Just don't take my seat at the basement bar.... Your Welcome Enjoy!!!! read more

10 West - Burgers Near Me - Cicero, Indiana

My wife and I live in Atlanta GA and were visiting my parents from Noblesville. We decided to try this spot on the recommendation of friends and family. We were not disappointed! Service was great and the food was even better. Reasonably priced as well. read more

This was my first time and it didn't disappoint. We had a 30 min wait at 7pm on a Wednesday night however. Spinach artichoke dip was the best ive ever had. Walleye for dinner was great. Everything was hot and fresh. Cant wait to come back! read more

I like to eat out as well as the next person, probably because I need a break from cooking. How does a restaurant earn five stars from me? 1. The entrees have to better perpared than I could make. 2. Prompt and efficient service 3. Cleanliness 4. Atmosphere 5. Overall impact. I enjoyed a wilted salad and citrus glazed salmon, barbecued shrimp appetizer, and the house zinfadel. No complaints, only praise. Went on a Sunday afternoon, which is less crowded. read more

Just had a great meal with my wife at 10 West. Ambiance - great vibe in the restaurant. We were on the quieter side of the restaurant. The bar side seemed a bit louder but had a good energy. Decoration was woody and a little industrial but very cool. Food was very good. Had the chicken nachos. They were deconstructed so that was an interesting take but I would order them again. My with and I both ordered the ribeye special. It was a little thinner cut than I am used to for a ribeye but the chef cooked them to perfection (med-rare). Flavorful and juicy. The side of green beans corn bacon and redskin potatoes was great. Cream corn was not something I would have ordered but it was delicious. Carrot cake and cheesecake were excellent as well. Service was good. Our server took great care of us and fixed items that were not quite right immediately. Overall I would give our meal a 4.5 stars. Yelp doesn't give me that option so I chose 4. Will definitely go back again to try some other items. Thanks read more

Such a great local restaurant, in lovely downtown Cicero. Everything is prepared fresh. Great place to grab a drink, have a dinner date, or bring your family to share a meal! I've never left disappointed! I love the chicken and noodles! Their filets are cooked to perfection every time! If you've never been, you are missing out! Don't delay another day! read more