The most delicious pizza pie one could ask for in the area. The service was prompt and menu detailed enough to eliminate possible questions. The ambiance was in keeping with a boutique pizza restaurant. You will enjoy this caloric splurge... go indulge! read more

484 New York Pizza - Pizza slices - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

My wife and I are from out of the state. We stopped in to try something from the area thats not a chain. The place is small inside, but cozy. The lady taking orders was nice. The food was made as we ordered came out pretty quick. The pizza was cooked to perfection. If we come back to the area, we definitely will be stopping in here again. read more

484 New York Pizza - Extra Large pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon. - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

Best Calzone & Giant Pizza around! This is our 'go to' place either for a quick dinner or if we're entertaining a large group. Great customer service, quality is always amazing! A must try, if you haven't! read more

Great food and service!! Love smelling the pizza's being made. Always clean. Tables cleaned promptly.

Exceptional customer service; good price and very good food. I.e., pizza! ! You can't go wrong by ordering from this establishment.

There was only one man working the whole store so it took 15 minutes to even get our order taken. The worker was very nice but definitely overworked since he had to answer phone calls, make pizzas, and take orders. We got 2 pizza slices and 1 12 inch pizza, and the whole pizza looked way fresher than the two slices. The slices looked like they were premade cheese slices with the toppings thrown on and reheated in the oven. The 12 inch pizza was hot and delicious but soooo greasy. read more

484 New York Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

I have traveled for business to this area for 19 years and never knew this was here. I am happy I have finally discovered it! Ordered a steak sub and Greek salad. Salad was fresh and delicious. Sub was hot, fresh and very good. I will be back next time I am in the area !! read more

If I would've known yesterday was National Pizza Day I just might've grabbed a slice from here. We walked in just to order some mozzarella sticks because he blamed me for eating his cheese bites (smh). The woman taking our order was okay, not too talkative after she found out that's all we wanted. The mozzarella sticks are just frozen to fried, not homemade here and their "marinara sauce" was simply a good spaghetti sauce. But, marinara has more of a tomato paste and less of the tomato sauce. There were a few slices of pizza and a few garlic knots in the warmer that didn't grab my attention, but we already had food so that wasn't the mission. They also had Jamaican patties advertised on the window and being that this place is Italian that made me hesitant. read more

See all

Great little mom and pop pizza shop, literally. Had the Meat Lovers pizza with mushrooms, onions and Jalapeños and a Greek salad. It was great, everything looked and tasted fresh. They provide great service and food for a decent price. If you looking for pizza, this is the place! read more

The Antipasto Salad was actually pretty good, but WHY would you idiots send a Salad to a customer in a Hotel room without a Fork or Napkins!!!!!!!!!!! The Pizza was so very bad. Any frozen pizza at the grocery store would have been better. But I was hungry, so I ended up eating half of it. read more

Driving through Florida headed to Atlanta and this was a delicious quick stop for a box of cheese pizza, was impressed with the food, courtesy and customer service of the staff. Highly recommend read more

I think different people cook there, so the food tastes different every take out onothing like New York style picture food is also overpriced. read more

I've been going here for years, an the pizza was always great but since the owners hired employees to run the place, the pizza just hasn't been the same, lacks the quality I was so used to. read more

Great!!!! We love visiting different pizza places while traveling and we have found a jewel here. Exit 341. In a shopping center just across from Cracker Barrell and Don Garlits museum. The little shopping center looks dated but don't let that stop you! The prices were good and reasonable. They have a variety of beverages including beer and wine. We ordered a medium pizza and Italian sub sandwich. This was enough to feed our family of four (2 adults and 2 kids) for lunch. The pizza was awesome. The crust was cooked perfectly throughout the dough with golden crusts on top and just enough crunch on the bottom. The ingredients tasted fresh and toppings appropriate. The pizza is made after ordering. This did not take very long and was hot. The sub was equally great. Bread was toasted. Sub was filled with plenty of meats and toppings. Portion sizes are on the larger side. My youngest is a picky eater and never finishes his food but he had no problem eating his half of the sandwich. Inside was clean. Restroom was clean. Staff was pleasant. read more

See all

Got a steak sandwich and Italian. The lady was super nice. Sandwiches were ready when we arrived. They are huge. Should have shared one. Lots of toppings and perfectly made. Right off the highway. Worth the stop. read more

We stayed the night across the road on our way to Tampa. We wanted to try something local and picked 484 New York Pizza. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone that loves pizza. Everything we got was excellent. read more

Sucks big time. I would be better off buying a frozen pizza from 7 11 and then warming it up in the motel microwave. Very disappointing. read more

Like Pizza and Food - Has Been Hot Meals - Extra Sauce and drinks like Sodas "!! Extra Breads Sticks "!!

Classic thin crust, big slices, plenty of herbs and seasonings on a table for customers to spice it up on their own.. good value for what you get. read more

Food was bland...we ordered fettuccine, Spaghetti meatball, and sausage sub. Wasn't worth the money we paid $31. Meatball doesn't taste fresh and sauce taste like from the can. Fettuccine too runny and bland. Doesn't seem like they even add seasoning to it. Our daughter only ate 20% of it and had to throw it out. Won't be going back... Disappointed. read more

Had a really great pizza here. I didn't really notice this place at first but after going to a nearby restaurant I spotted it and decided to go there. They also have sandwiches and other foods other than pizza but the pizza is the best around. They do have two tables if your looking to eat in but in my opinion I'd rather just take it out. read more

Great experience! We're new to Ocala and we're trying out some random new places here. It's at the first highway exit south of Ocala.. If you like thin crust pizza this is definitely the place for you! Great pizza. I loved the rolls too. The sub was very meaty.. the gyro could've been less crowded with veggies but it was still great. And the ziti was pretty good! I feel like the ziti tasted even better the next day warmed up! The area looked cute and the restaurant inside was clean and friendly. We ordered ahead on the phone and it was ready right when we showed up. The employees were so nice; I can't remember the name of the lady who was at the counter but she was really pleasant to talk to. I wish we could've eaten inside but because of COVID we took it home with us. read more

484 New York Pizza - Gyro, Garlic rolls, Italian sub, Baked Ziti, Small Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

Stopped in this area while heading to Port Canaveral for a cruise. Kids wanted chicken from the chain restaurant next door, we decided to give this pizza spot a try. They advertise pizza by the slice however once inside they advised no slices. We decided to order a small cheese and hamburger pizza. Let's just saw frozen pizza is clearly the better choice. This is nothing like NY pizza. Sauce lacked flavor, salt was needed and the cheese was very minimal. No more unplanned pizza stops for us unless it's recommended read more

We got a couple of slices one afternoon on our way home from shopping. I have to say that we weren't disappointed. Tasted like real NY pizza. We only had it that one time so I don't know if it's consistently good but give it a try and see what you think. read more

Best Fresh Pizza, Nice little mam and pap pizza restaurant. The pizza was really good! Well it was actually better than just good, it was awesome. They make hand tossed and stone oven pizza. The price was great for the quality rare taste. I will definitely be returing, especially to when i entertain to be able to show the super gigantic pizza hanging on the roof, If you haven't seen that its worth looking at. I'd highly recommend it! ANYWAYS, i think this place has been a good recommandation from my cousin! GOOD place to call in for to go. read more

I've driven by this place many times on the way to interstate 75 and have never had the time stop. Well I finally went today because I had a hankering for pizza. It was amazing. Best pizza I've tried in the Ocala area. The crust was thin and crispy and the toppings, pizza sauce and cheese were all delicious. Definitely like NY pizza. I would highly recommend this place. The staff was very friendly and it was ready when I arrived. Also, all of their desserts are homemade. read more

Stopped here on the way back from vacation. I saw they only had 1 slice of cheese pizza in their warmer, which looked pretty old. So I decided to order a pepperoni slice. They took the old slice of cheese and just put pepperoni on it lol. Employees were on their phones and barely paid any attention to us. Pizza sauce was not good at all- very artificial and paste-like read more

best pizza anywhere near here!! thank god for this place! price is worth every penny! I was so sick of the chains and then I found this place! well done 484 pizza!! keep it going!! read more

Hands down the best pizza in Ocala!! I am from NJ and my husband a transplant from Brooklyn, we are pizza lovers and order once a week. It took us a year and a half to finally find great pizza in Ocala. 484 NY Pizza is exactly like what we are used to from up north. We order it well done so the cheese is bubbly and the crust is crispy... it's perfectly delicious! If it was up to me, we would eat it every night for dinner! read more

Well the food was great. Took a long time for my booking order. BUT none of the workers wore a mask and for the lack of care to other I'm giving a one star. As a food service company you lack the compassion to care for others and keep them safe. read more

Made a pit stop on our way back home to Georgia and let me tell you way better than all them fast food restaurants in the area. But if your making a pit stop try and call in your order ahead of time because it does take long read more

484 New York Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

The ziti was super good if you love some carbs this is the place to go after a long day on the road

Tried calling in to order a pizza for pickup. It took so long for someone to that I was about to hang up. When the phone was answered, I stated that I was calling in an order for pickup. Before I could finish telling her that I was placing an order for pickup, she cut me off, told me I was breaking up, told me to call back (with an attitude) and hung up before I could attempt to reply. That left a bad enough taste in my mouth to not call back. Although I cannot comment on the quality of the food, my first impression of the service was not good. read more

Good Pizza. They somehow forgot the dressing for my Greek salad but everything was yum.

We came into town for an event for our family, we decided to try out 484 New York Pizza. The pizza was not good, the wings were burnt black with no sauce, their calzone had almost no ricotta cheese in it. We ordered food Saturday night, I had spoke with the manager on duty Sunday, i couldn't speak to them Saturday night because they were closed by the time we got the food to the hotel and tried it, only 10 minutes from the pizza shop. The Manager on duty Sunday was very polite and wanted to make sure we were satisfied, then I spoke to another manager that told me I would have to wait until Tuesday to speak to the owner Karem, the owner wasn't even wanting to hear it out and says our food is the best maybe you want some other crap food but not me ( her exact words), tells me I needed to bring the food back in to get a refund. They never told me that in any other conversation. We spent $160 to feed the family and the owners response was you should have ordered just a slice to see if you liked it then see if you wanted to feed your family from here????? Really I've never heard of anyone doing things like this, she's very unprofessional and doesn't care for her customer satisfaction she only wants your money no matter how bad their food was. DO NOT GO AND EAT HERE!! read more

Stopped by 484 New York Pizza to get four slices on the way to a family outing. They sell by the slice but have no pizza ready/prepared. I had to wait 20 minutes for a few slices. I'm not sure if this is how they operated all the time or I just got lucky. The pizza is mediocre, nothing special. Not worth the time. read more

Mybboyfriend and I eat there on a regular basis. We havennever had any bad service .THEOOWNERS ARE WONDERFUL! We've tried everything from pizza to hoagies to the pasta. Prices are good and food is alwaz the best!!!!!! read more

484 New York Pizza - Its the only selfie i have - Italian Near Me - Ocala, Florida

Never been here walked in the place is kinda small opted to order a gyro & a beer. Friendly counter staff. While the prepared it opted to use my DBPR app stands for department of businesses & professional regulation its something that I do first visit & then occasionally. Latest inspection was 6/21 other than one high priority which involved possible cross contamination they were fine all corrected same day. Well gyro was served folks 4 tiny strips of meat yet very tasty but way over priced. I'll return for pizza one day. Also they have a JUMBO pizza judging by the box by far the largest I've seen to date. This is my experience & my opinion. Not a place for gyros. read more

Best pizza I've had in a while...friendly staff and quick delivery! The pizza was excellent in the cheese and thin crust is the best pizza you can get in the area just passing through town. read more

We were traveling from Miami to the Panhandle and tried to stop at Zaxby's for lunch. It was so crowded and we wanted to eat with our pup, so we noticed right next door was a little pizza place with an outside table. We are so glad we did! They had FANTASTIC pizza and Jaime was so sweet. Loved the experience. Some of the best pizza crust and toppings I've had and I am a pizza aficionado!!! read more