Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    76 Main

    4.6 (41 reviews)
    PriceyHotels
    Open Open 24 hours
    Updated over 3 months ago

    76 Main Photos

    Recommended Reviews - 76 Main

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Sitting Area
    Marynda P.

    We loved our stay at 76 Main! Upon checking, we were told that they upgraded our room without a charge. This was a nice surprise as we were there to celebrate my husband's birthday. Everything is lovely beginning with the outside to the foyer to the sitting room to our room. You will find fresh baked goodies throughout the day and evening in the foyer. The sitting room was a great area to sit and read or just have a chat. There was a mixer that evening. Everything you would want to have in your favorite cocktail is beautiful displayed in the kitchen to add in your own spirits. (BYOB) We stopped at the package store just down the way and purchased Rose and whiskey. Our room was spacious with a king bed, chair, dresser, and side tables. Soft robes are provided as well as high end toiletries. Hangers and wall hooks are provided for hanging your clothes as there is not a closet. The bathroom was small with not much counter space. However, this was not a problem for us. We hope to return soon!

    Jenna H.

    My husband and I decided to stay at 76 Main the week after labor day for a little "babymoon". We booked about three weeks prior to our stay and had to move rooms which was not a big deal at all and the housekeeping made it as painless as possible by allowing us to leave our luggage in the current room and then moved it to the new one while we were out for the day. The location of the inn is perfect - it is just steps from town but still far enough away to ensure a quiet nights rest. We were told that there was limited parking, which was the case - but that it was not a big deal as busses ran cheap to all of the beaches and they would provide us with beach chairs and towels. Sounded like a plan to us! However when we arrived (as I mentioned the week after labor day) we found out that the busses had stopped running to all but one beach... felt mislead by inn management who obviously did not know what they were talking about. They did follow through with great beach chairs, towels, and an umbrella though which was appreciated. Not wanting to take cabs back and forth every day - we took the bus to the same beach every day. The inn was beautiful - you could tell recently tastefully renovated. I loved the back patio area where you could enjoy coffee , a nice book, or drink in the afternoon. Our first room was a deluxe king at the bottom of the stairs. This room had AC which made it very comfortable, and faced bushes which made it nice and quiet. The linen on the bed was incredible! I need to find out where it is from so I can also buy it. The inn is kind enough to provide water in the rooms and i pads to help you with your trip - nice touch. One piece of advice as to be expected in almost all Nantucket Inn's is that the bathrooms are tiny. Not just small but uber tiny. The stall shower we had in our deluxe king room was not pregnant friendly. I was uncomfortable showering every day and I think more water ended up out of the stall than in... Other gripes about the room include a very hard knotted rug under the bed. It hurt our feet just to step on it - rude awakening for a preggo who is up frequently through the night. A nice pair of slippers would have been appreciated to help ease the pain. The main light in our room would not turn on. When we asked management they told us it did not work due to an upstairs leak... The room was beautiful though, with a comfy bed, and actually quite spacious for Nantucket standards. The second half of the week we were upstairs in a queen room, number 8 which was lovely as well with the exception of the temp. There was no AC in this room and the windows were forced shut so that we could not open them... strange. There was no way to manage the temperature in the room and it became very hot overnight. Not wanting to wake anyone up I told Katie the next day - she fixed it as best she could. Family tip - they have guest houses removed from the main inn, which are great for families and come with a mini fridge. Breakfast was ok each morning - they had the same types of muffins, scones, cereal, and juice - which were tasty. Some mornings the breakfast was not out in time for when they advertised, which was annoying as we paid for it, and had some early morning tours - lighthouse and boat trip that we were counting on a quick breakfast for. For coffee they had k-cups... huge disappointment - this is what we have at home. I would much prefer a fresh brewed cup then out of a cup that I get at home on a weekday. Also disappointing was there was not the standard afternoon coffee, tea, and snack that every other inn I have ever stayed at offers. Overall the management seemed tired and over the summer season, which was quite a disappointment for our only trip this year. Katie was ok, and was really trying. But the male manager seemed awkward and non-chalant about everything. Based on our experience and number of choices on the island we will most likely not be back.

    reading room (through bathroom on backside of house)
    Jacqueline L.

    stayed in this well designed boutique hotel at the top of main street while some other friends stayed at the sister location, 21 broad (a little closer to town + offers more rooms). we actually preferred being a bit off. was quiet vs. other which was next door to a popular late night bar. we were able to visit each location which was nice. just a quick five minute walk from one to the other. both have common areas with stuff like games, a record player, outdoor courtyards with lounges + modern fire-pits. our location offered beach chairs + towels that they let us share with our friends. the staff flip-flopped from each location too so wherever we were they new us. the managers, daniel + corrine were spectacular along with everyone else. always friendly, offered suggestions for restaurants, assisted with transportation, and/or whatever we needed (even before we booked). would recommend suite 15 on the third floor. because it is a renovated house, you can hear everything going on. didn't bother us though. small reading room off the bathroom was cute + sunny in the afternoons along with a cushioned window bench that over looked main street. only a few sugfestions to make the stay even better... #1 change plastic curtain on already xsmall shower to glass door (although skylight was another nice touch, extremely needed), add a soap dish for the sink counter, fox ice machine on second floor (was fine going to the kitchen, but closed at 10pm). other then that, a wonderful place to stay. would highly recommend it!

    Bedroom Suite

    See all

    Photo of Mandi R.
    106
    16
    6

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - 76 Main

    Brass Lantern Inn

    Brass Lantern Inn

    (35 reviews)

    $$

    We had a wonderful stay at the Brass Lantern Inn for our 20th Anniversary. We stayed in the Brandt…read morePoint room. Our room was ready by 1pm on check in day and check in was a breeze. Brant Point is located on the top floor (3rd floor) of the Inn. The stairs leading to this room are VERY steep so please keep this in mind when booking. You will have to carry your bags too. The room itself is tastefully decorated and the bathroom is newly renovated. The view is good but not great. You can see the harbor but a few other homes & trees obstruct a lot of the view. The bathroom is fantastic! We loved the rain shower head and the LED mirror. It has ample room and plenty of storage. They provide an iron, ironing board and hairdryer in the room along with basic toiletries. Breakfast is served daily. You must sign up via text the evening before. They provide you with a link and you make your selections from there. You can take the tray back to your room, eat in the dining room or on the patio. Coffee, hot tea , water and fruit are available all day in the dining room. Fresh baked cookies are also put out in the late afternoon. The Inn is centrally located and all the shops and restaurants are within walking distance. We really enjoyed strolling the beautiful streets of Nantucket. It is also very close to the ferry and Whaling Museum. You can rent bikes and Jeeps near by too. We walked to Brandt Point lighthouse - it was not far at all. We enjoyed our time in Nantucket and would definitely recommend The Brass Lantern Inn. It was our first time staying at a bed and breakfast and we couldn't have been more pleased! The grounds are nice, the rooms are clean and well appointed! We highly recommend getting a Jeep to explore the whole island and all of the lighthouses! Madaket Beach was an amazing place to catch the beautiful sunset!

    This was our first trip to Nantucket and we loved staying here! It was walkable to restaurants and…read moreshops. The room was so cute and clean. The breakfast scones and muffins in the morning were such a nice touch! The staff were kind and welcoming. Overall, this was a great experience.

    Blue Iris

    Blue Iris

    (5 reviews)

    Had a wonderful stay at Blue Iris. The staff--specifically Casita and Maria, were so kind and…read morehospitable. We went during the summer so prices were steep, but this is a quaint hotel tucked in downtown making it accessible to shops, restaurants and the beach (via bike).

    Stayed here for 4 nights in August and we booked 2 rooms, one for me and one for my parents. Rate…read morewas between 700-800 per night for the rooms. We were extremely disappointed with this hotel, both the product as well as the service quality. For 750 pre tax, we expected a higher quality level, namely: -the rooms were old and my parents room (terrace king) had a smell. The rooms were dingy and the bathrooms were extremely dated. The terrace room went for a premium and the terrace was dirty to the point they never went out there (ground floor) -the lobby was tiny and not a place to spend more than 2 mins. It's full of luggage that is being stored and very uninviting -the rooms are marketed as breakfast included when you book but you have to choose between a croissant and oats and you can pour yourself some coffee that is on a warmer -most of the time, the front desk person is actually hanging out in the kitchen and they come out after you make your presence known. -outside of the croissant and coffee program, there is no food, cafe, or restaurant. You'll need to walk over to sister ships / faraway which has lots of offerings -in general I'd say the service quality is very low. They run extremely lean on staffing (maid plus 1 desk person) and the front desk folks are really only focused on checking you in. And the overhead saved by having a skeleton crew working does not get passed on the customer. -I called several times in advance of arrival and most of those calls were never answered, the phone just rings. I did catch a front desk clerk over the phone at some point and asked for some recs. She said she'd email and never did. I ran into her upon check out and she commented, "oh hey sorry I never emailed you those recs". So there is no concierge service -Between no lobby to relax in for a few moments, no restaurant, no reasonable breakfast though breakfast was advertised, no staff, and lousy rooms I dont see how this hotel charges more than $300-400 per night. It's a place to sleep and spend no time otherwise. At every turn, the hotel was a major let down. It was a damper on our trip. I believe the hotel requires complete operational revamp or major price reduction/50 percent. The value you get for the price point is completely upside down. Hope this helps someone to avoid the mistake we made staying there.

    76 Main - hotels - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...