My family and I stopped in here on a Friday for lunch. We are greeted the door by a man and he was behind the counter and he also made the pizza. The pizza we got was a large cheese and I got the eight dollar giant, slice and fountain soda. The girls cheese pizza was $16. The pizza was ready in about 11 minutes. We see it ourselves, and he brought it to us. Eat the pizza in the back corner. It's a very small area to eat and died in. But it was comfortable and we enjoyed our food. read more

See all

On our way back from a trip to Rough River Dam State Park (see my review), I called 8th Street Pizza to order for dine in. We were about 10 or so miles away. When we arrived, the pizza was ready and it was as good as previous reviews stated. There were 3 very friendly and professional female staff members. The restaurant isn't very large, but it is clean and stylishly decorated. See photos. read more

See all

8th street pizza is a downtown new Albany Indiana pizzeria that sits as the name suggests on the corner of 8th street. My family and I made the trip from Lousiville to dine at Thai establishment. It is smallish on the inside. You walk up and order at the counter. They have a small sitting kitchen bar in front of the counter for people to eat real quick or wait for there order. They also have about 3-4 small tables in a lobby area. So obviously you can dine In but the place is more geared for takeout orders. Being we made the 25 min trip from Lousiville and we are a family of 6 we commandeered the tables In the lobby and dined in. We got a 16 inch New York style pepperoni pizza to share and I personally grabbed a ham and cheese calzone with my wife getting a Cesar salad as well. Pretty reasonably priced. While order cost under $35 so not bad at all. There was a bit of a wait but the worker was very upfront and told us before we even paid "there may be a long wait tonight especially on the calzone". Which I'm ok with. I don't mind long waits as long as it communicated. So props to them for having service integrity and keeping us informed. The pizza was covered in pepperonis. It is thin we crusted which I guess makes it the New York style. The pieces we're New York style large. But they were still a decent slice. The slices were covered too to bottom with pepperonis too. My kids all loved it. I tried a slice and I will say it was pretty tasty. I was was nervous about all the pepperonis (I like pepperoni but too much is overkill for me) but it was really good and maintained and overall good flavor. My wife said her Cesar salad was good and deceptively large. She kept saying "I feel like someone keeps putting more in this bowl where I'm not looking. My calazone was just ok. Decent size portion, good breading and cheese and a nice sauce. The ham pieces they skimp a bit. They put the little ham blocks in it that you would find on a cheap salad bar platter. So that was my complaint on it. It wasn't bad but the ham made it seem cheap and generic. Would much rather prefer some baker and Cooked ham traditionally found in ham and cheese calzone. That said we still had a good experience here. As I stated the kids loved the pizza and want to come back. I'd be very willing to come back. I'd probably just stick with pizza or inquire about the type of ingredients used in the other calzone toppings. read more

See all

First time at 8th Street Pizza and it will not be the last. When you first walk in you are thrown into a smell that just makes your mouth water. The staff was friendly and helpful. The pizza was excellent! I definitely recommend getting the garlic butter (it's not homemade but it is amazing). read more

8th Street Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza with Banana Peppers - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Pizza is more of an afterthought. Very strange place, more of a very small intimate bar. You might love it, but not my thing. We were looking for 8th St., Pizza and there isn't a sign out front anywhere that says that. It's part of a brewery, but there is a sign over the kitchen. Anyway, just OK. read more

Score! Another great pizza place near me. 8th Street Pizza has been around for a while and has been on my 'intending to try' list much longer than it should have been. Not only do they have great food; they have a great mission. From their website: "8th Street Pizza, located at 411 E Spring Street in New Albany, Indiana, is the area's only pay-it-forward pizzeria serving Floyd, Harrison, and Clark counties since 2016." I love that one of the options on the menu is to be able to purchase a slice for someone who may be hungry, but can't afford food. I have been doing quite a bit of carry out lately, and I have to tell you that the breadsticks almost didn't make it home. The tantalizing aroma of garlic had me wanting to reach in the box and start dinner early. But pictures must be taken, so I fought the urge to munch. They were worth the wait! So soft and so garlicky. And the marinara that accompanied them was very good, too. Not that they needed it because they are tasty all by themselves. Next up was a sausage, mushroom & onion calzone. The adjective that came to mind with the first bite was 'pillowy'. I don't know that I have ever had bread that soft and light before. The fillings were tasty, but that bread... I can't speak to their dine in service, but everyone I have encountered behind the counter has been friendly. If you are in, or close to, New Albany, do yourself a favor and give 8th Street a try. read more

See all

8th Street Pizza puts a lot of effort into giving back to the community and acting as a resource for those in need. I really admire that and gave an extra star because of it. I wasn't a huge fan of the pizza, unfortunately. The style is a hand-tossed, thinnish crust with a good portion of toppings! The sauce was pretty thin to the point of missing and the pepperoni had an overwhelming sausage smell and flavor. It was decent pizza. Service was fine. It took a minute to get someone to recognize that I was there for carryout, but quick once they did. The store is spotless! Great mission. Good service. Alright pizza. read more

AMAZING VEGAN PIZZA!!! I have been searching high and low for vegan pizza delivery (I think more places need to get on board with dairy/diet restrictions). This hit the spot. Wonderful crust. Cheese tastes like Daiya cheese and then I added the crunchy pepperonis on half. 10/10 recommend. Thank you 8th street! read more

8th Street Pizza - Vegan pizza (I added pepperoni to half since I'm dairy free and not vegan!) (: - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

First time at 8th St pizza. I have to say, I am impressed! Not just the pizza, but the mission. Feeding those who need it most. Ordered a nice sampling of items for dinner for the family. Calzone, cheese sticks, Neapolitan, BYO 16" with bacon and sausage. The restaurant is spotless. The staff are super friendly. Calzone, BYO and cheese bread were fantastic and I would highly recommend. Plenty of toppings on the pizza and the bacon was plentiful and well cooked! The Neapolitan just didn't deliver the flavor I was expecting. Still a quality product, just a bit bland IMO. $56 + tip. Give it a try if you're in the area. You'll like it! read more

See all

I had been wanting to try this for a while and finally made it happen. I made an online order for carryout and it was quick and easy. My pizza and breadsticks were already done by the time I got there. The crush was phenomenal and breadsticks so good. I ordered a pepperoni pizza which did not disappoint! read more

Just moved to the area and decided to try a local spot. I'm definitely NOT disappointed. This is probably the best pizza I've had in the area. Thin crust but not crunchy. Ingredients were fresh. Perfect amount of sauce-cheese-toppings ratio. This will be my new go to spit for pizza. I ordered through grubhub and got it within 25 minutes. read more

8th Street Pizza - Grilled chicken, basil, and half with green olives - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Not a bad pizza joint. Definitely no-frillls for sure. Had an order of the garlic breadsticks (curiously addictive despite their somewhat diminutive size) and an All-The-Meats 12" pie. The pizza was good, better than average, although a little too greasy for a person sans a gall bladder. Overall, I give them a 9.5 out of 10. read more

Tried this place for the first time this evening, and I must say that the pizza is very good. I really enjoyed the tangy sauce, and the pepperoni's were large and delicious. I don't know much about the history of this eatery, but I definitely plan on visiting the place in person one day soon. I had this delivered to my home tonight, but I look forward to trying some of their other offerings. The price point was pretty much on par with similar offerings in the area, and their toppings did honestly stand out as great quality. I've since learned about their charitable givings, which is absolutely great! Another reason to support this business. read more

This is a wonderful mission with great food and although I count Jeff Minton as a personal friend, this is an OBJECTIVE 5 star review for some truly great pizza! I have not had it in a while, only because we are lazy and default to having door delivery so often, but a return trip is on my to-do list for 2022! Stop in today! You won't be disappointed! read more

This place is not for me. The food is fine but not my style. Be sure and join the text club for coupons. We used the free bread sticks with purchase. I bought a large all meat. While everything tasted okay the bread sticks were very small and the 1 tiny garlic butter wasn't enough to dip 1/2 of them. On the pizza the pepperoni was good but the other 3 meats were ground up too fine and all melted together into 1 flavor. The crust was too thick on the outside with to much edge but too thin in the center. The cheese level was pretty good, but on a meat pizza I like to get a good size chunk of each meat and be able to distinguish it from the rest of the pizza. read more

8th Street Pizza - Small bread sticks and tiny dip - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

What is better than eating good food from good people on a great mission? When it is good pizza! Tried their pizza for the first time last night as part of a fundraiser for Let Us Learn - well what a pleasant surprise. I was expecting frozen cardboard crust and sweet sauce typical of Southern Indiana. Instead I was presented with a chewy edge and crisp under crust topped with perfect sauce, cheese, pesto and roasted veggies. The dining room is a cafeteria style mishmash of old restaurant tables and there was a homeless guy bathing in the bathroom - so if these things bother you, they do offer DoorDash delivery and carry out. read more

8th Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

This was such good pizza. I haven't been in before but I will definitely be back. The guy running it was super nice and helpful. My kids said this was "the best pizza ever". read more

Nothing I could find to impress as far as taste. I found it better than Domino's or Pizza Hut...more on the level with Marco's. I did add a star for the concept and mission. I did get a deal on the delivery fee from Door Dash and my 12 inch Pepperoni pizza came piping hot and delivered straight to me at work. Although I liked it there wasn't anything outstanding that would gravitate me to order from here specifically except the humanitarian vibe. read more

Excellent delivery pizza! Crust, sauce, toppings--all fab! Highly recommend-- also heard they are charitable. read more

This is my first restaurant review but felt compelled to do so after how excellent the staff and my pizza was tonight @9pm. I have traveled the country with my job and 8th Street Pizza is definitely in my top 2. I also want to give a shout-out to the lady and gentleman working tonight. They were both very kind, respectful, and well mannered (something you rarely find anymore). As a business owner, they are a huge asset to your restaurant. Keep doing what y'all are doing here. You've hit a home run! - Christopher read more

8th Street Pizza - Deluxe pizza & Pepperoni Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

8th Street Pizza gives back not only to the community that needs a bite to eat and don't have any money, but also with fantastic flavors. The pizza and breadsticks rock and look forward to supporting this local business and the community. read more

8th Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Pizza was super tasty! I ordered online which was an easy process. It didn't take long to have them ready and I got a text letting me know so. read more

We had 8th Street pizza for the first time yesterday and it was Delicious ! If you order here , please be patient, I assure you ,it is worth the wait ! We had to wait a bit but the fella making pizza was on his own ( Zero help !) And he had the dough a flyin'! Like a pizza makin' machine I tell ya! Great pizza , super fresh of course. And,, if you have a job somewhere , making pizza or whatever , go to work! read more

Good pizza, GREAT mission. Not my go to pizza place, but I definitely wouldn't say no. I'll be back to support the mission and eat some quality pizza! Staff was very friendly and attentive. If you're not familiar with their mission, it's a pay what you can concept to help feed the less fortunate. Give it a shot! 5 stars for the food and concept combo. read more

See all

This is the best pizza we have had in a long time! Ordered the all meat pizza and it was delicious! The service was good

Great food and a discount for people that live at breakwater apartments. It takes a while sometimes, so call first.

We were in New Albany as a day trip from our visit to Louisville. We stumbled upon this place as a few of the restaurants were closed due to COVID. We had a Hawaiian and Caesar salad and it was great. Nice touch that we could have a beer and wine as well. Clean dining area and friendly service. read more

8th Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Found this place looking for a new pizza place since so many places have closed due to COVID. Amazing! Quick service, clean eating area and fantastic pizza! $14.00 for the BYO pizza is a steal and it is well worth the trip if you are in Louisville/Kentucky area. I highly recommend. read more

First time ordering and had it delivered. Excellent pizza!!! No shortage on toppings and great flavors. Will definitely order again! read more

8th Street Pizza - BYO Classic - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Amazing food and service! Only complaint is paper straws, the service was over the top though!

Their dough is like no other. They forgot one of my fillings for the Calzone, but the dough and cheese mixture will definitely have me come back sometime. And the inside is cute giving a nice stop in a pleasant town. The staff were quite polite and made the food within a reasonable amount of time. Wish they gave a little bit more marinara for the Calzone. Still one of the best places for a Calzone in New Albany! read more

Pizza was absolutely delicious. The dough was so soft and perfect. Highly recommend trying this place

Always great and so convenient! They have a great variety of toppings and extras. We have never been disappointed.

I stop them on my lunch break traveling between clients friendly staff and my pizza was ready and absolutely no time at all and this is nothing like your typical Domino's Pizza Hut kind of pizza this is just like you would get it if you were in New York. We'll take a bite and the cheese just strings. This pizza is absolutely amazing I haven't happy to this good in a long time. I recommend this place to anybody that is looking for a homemade New York style pizza. read more

8th Street Pizza - The best pizza I've had in a long time. - Pizza Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

All of the food I have had from here has been good!! The pizza a was great!! The bread sticks were good!!

We had lunch here today and really enjoyed it! The staff was very friendly. The service was fast. And the pizza was delicious! We bought pizza by the slice and the slices were huge! Would definitely come back again! read more

Wonderful pizza and very satisfying salads. Fresh and carefully prepared with a generous hand, 8th Street Pizza has become my "go to" pizzeria. Thank you. read more

My friend and I, who has Tourette's syndrome were kicked out of the restaurant and threatened to be called on by the police. The owner did not display his best judgment and acted irrationally! I highly do not recommend this business! Unacceptable! He post things such as helping certain people in the community and is discriminatory against a individual with Tourette's syndrome and threatens to call the police, how contradictory is that!I do not recommend this business! How could someone who says he does so much to help individuals like my friend,threaten to kick us out, which he did, and call the police yet he says he tries to help individuals like this! Do not recommend this establishment! Two face!!! Even worse, the other man that he had kicked out of his restaurant who was an innocent bystander, was homeless! He says he is helping the community, Putting on a front to help his business! read more

Awesome pizza! They help those that need some help with a meal. Great idea and great food and service at a fair price! We'll be back!

Order was correct-food was super quality with all ingredients evenly spaced, perfect amount of sauce/cheese. Perfectly baked. Arrived 15 minutes ahead of time at my door (I'm in a hotel mind you). Bravo! read more