Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    A Love For Cakes

    4.5 (44 reviews)
    PriceyBakeries, Desserts

    A Love For Cakes Photos

    You might also consider

    More like A Love For Cakes

    Recommended Reviews - A Love For Cakes

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Cake

    I ordered a 2 tier cake within a weeks notice and Sabine really executed not only with the appearance but with the taste of the cake as well. The guests absolutely loved how the cake tested. They also provide a cake testing box with a generous amount of different flavors of cake and buttercreams/fillings of your choice. It really helped us narrow down the flavor. I highly recommend A Love For Cakes. We cannot wait to order again! :)

    Custom cake
    Katrina B.

    WE LOVED OUR WEDDING CAKE! We showed them a picture of a wedding cake design from Pinterest and, no joke, it was an exact replica. We couldn't have been happier and we received so many compliments on how it turned out. On top of the beautiful aesthetic, the cake tastes delicious! We had a chocolate cake with a coffee buttercream and it was a dream. We finished the entire cake completely. Thank you Sabine and Gia for the perfection!

    My husbands 50th birthday Popeye cake!!

    I HIGHLY recommend A Love For Cakes very nice very professional they create the most amazing cake ever I submitted a photo of a Popeye cake I want that made for my husband's 50th birthday and they totally nailed it I was be on ecstatic of how great it came out my husband absolutely loved it thank you so much again to all the staff at A Love For Cakes

    a cake decorated with musical notes
    Christina P.

    Loved, loved, loved the cake I bought for my son's birthday. I was extremely happy with how the cake came out and let me tell you the flavor was delicious! Definitely would recommend to anyone looking for a custom cake! Thank you so much!!

    a wedding cake

    They create magic! I ran some ideas for a baby shower cake with Sabine and sent some photos. What she created exceeded my expectations. Everyone loved the cake. It tasted delicious too!

    Cake
    Tiffany F.

    Thank you Sabine!! Thank you for making the most delicious cake for my wedding! The flavors and the cake were so amazing! Also, it exceeded my expectations, I was just blown away with how beautiful the cake was.. wow Sabine did a great job! I will be posting more picture soon!! Thank you Sabine, we loved the cake.

    40th anniversary cake
    C H.

    Omg I cannot explain how wonderful this place is. I came here after exploring different bakeries for my parents 40th anniversary. Some of the quotes I received from the other bakeries were ridiculous. I emailed them first and spoke with Lisa. I gave her my ideas of what I wanted and she was so patient and kind. I then met Sabine at the bakery to order the cake and she helped me narrow down my choices and flavors. I ended up with a 2 tier cake. The top layer was chocolate and buttercream. The bottom layer was almond cake with fresh raspberries. Both so delicious. And it was not super sweet which I liked and so did everyone else. Sabine and her staff are amazing. Thank you for such a beautiful cake. I will be using them again for all my future events. Look at this beautiful cake :)

    Sesame Street cake

    We ordered a Sesame Street themed two tiered cake. The design of the cake was great and the characters was on point. But the cake inside was so dry. Some sort of sweet liquid or syrup was poured on top of the cakes to try to keep it moist. The cake was also crumbly. I was told the cakes would be made a day before but I don't think that's what they did. It had to be a couple days old. How can you do that to someone? I was so embarrassed. It was my baby's first birthday. I did the rookie mistake of not cake tasting beforehand. The fondant was also terrible. It was very sweet and the outside was very powdery. I ordered from here based on the reviews, I don't know what went wrong. I had a horrible experience. It was not worth the money at all.

    Our Minecraft cake

    They did a great job with my son's birthday cake. I sent a picture from pinterest and they replicated it perfectly. This was the third cake I've gotten from here. The first 2 were for my daughter's 1st birthday and they did an equally great job. We are very happy.

    David H.

    This will likely be my go to place for any cakes in the future. I contacted them a day or so before New Year's Day & told them I needed a cake for my wife's birthday on January 5th. I showed them a few pictures of what I was looking for & they sent me over a form to fill out. I believe I was texting directly with the owner (not sure) but they responded fairly quick. They even delivered the cake. Cake cake out nice & my wife looooved the chocolate. She's saving the ribbon as a memory. I will absolutely recommend this place for anyone who needs a cake & will be back in the future. Thank a million.

    Ann S.

    Ordered cupcakes from Sabine for a bridal shower. We communicated mostly via email and Sabine always responded in a timely manner. The cupcakes looked exactly what I wanted and they were a huge hit! Thank you Sabine, will definitely order from you again!

    Jessica H.

    Sabine is great! She made an Indian-style cake for my father-in-law's 70th birthday, and it was perfect! I would highly recommend A Love for Cakes!

    Just amazing.  The detail was out if this world.  The flavors and quality if the cake itself were also outstanding.

    Cake and decor we above my expectations. Absolutely amazing. My guests enjoyed it as well and the cake was delicious. They also delivered it to a location in Manhattan and left a tube if icing in case we needed to add anything to it.

    This cake looks nothing like what i asked for

    See all

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Gin L.
    25
    16
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - A Love For Cakes

    Is this establishment closed permanently?

    Yes. There is a Chinese restaurant there now called "Noodle Valley".

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Bakeri - Behind the counter

    Bakeri

    4.3(16 reviews)
    0.9 miRidgewood

    I always love to go to bakeries when I am in different neighborhoods. Today's stop is Bakeri in…read moreRidgewood, NY. By the time I walked in around 11:45, all their scones were gone. :( So I made do with a scrumptious cinnamon bun! :) The cinnamon bun was fantastic and so loaded with cinnamon. Taking a bite into it was like cinnamon bun heaven. The server was cheerful and was recommending different things to me in lieu of selling out the scones. It's a very small place with a couple of seats inside and more so outside. I will make sure I get there early enough for the scones! I've been told they sell out around 11AM.

    I'm giving 1 star only because I genuinely love your products…read more The problem isn't the quality of the baked goods, it's the location and the overall customer experience. For a bakery that generates this much interest, the setup feels strangely unfinished. There's nowhere comfortable to sit, nowhere practical to wait when there's a line, product availability is often disappointing, and on top of that the shop closes at 3PM. For many people, that means arriving only to discover limited options or a closed storefront. What makes this especially confusing is that this location is in Ridgewood, a neighborhood already full of strong food and coffee options. Opening a highly anticipated bakery should bring something new and enjoyable to the community. Instead, it feels like customers are expected to adapt to a business model that prioritizes operational convenience over the actual customer experience. Maybe from a business perspective this investment makes sense. But from a customer perspective, the excitement of finally having this bakery in the neighborhood quickly turns into frustration. I wanted to become a regular customer, but every visit feels unnecessarily inconvenient. The products deserve better than the experience surrounding them.

    Photos
    Bakeri
    Bakeri
    Bakeri - Coffee and granola

    See all

    Coffee and granola

    A Love For Cakes - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...