Pie is delicious. The only thing wrong with this place is the price is a little too high.

This location is NOT closed!!! It is being remodeled and they are in a temporary space a few stores to the right in same strip mall. A sign in the door points you to the short-term quarters. We had a banana cream pie slice that was excellent! Yummy! read more

See all

The pie and brownie were excellent. But the service was terrible. The two kids were confused, couldn't run credit card orders, and appeared overwhelmed and under trained. read more

Picked up quiche for our breakfast. It was the best I've ever had!!!! Highly recommend. Also took some pie for our lunch. Blackberry crumble was fabulous. They were out of several I wanted to try (and no indication on the board that it wasn't available ). That was frustrating to ask for 3 or so flavors from the list and be told they were out. The gal Waiting on me wasn't overly helpful or encouraging but quality of good outweighed the ordering challenges. read more

I really want to love this place but I just can't. I keep coming back but think this last time will be the final. The food is homemade, that's for sure. I can't speak on the pie behalf but for the pot pie it was a large slice. Although there was not much filling, I can could the pieces of chicken and relatively dry. Now I can live with that but not at the expense of paying $22 for 2 slices! Seems like highway robbery for something that was just mediocre at best. Could have been and older pot pie but again, not for that price! read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

We were coming through Rolla so we thought that we would stop at this place. The website said they opened at 9 which was perfect timing for us but there was no one visible in the store. After walking about a bit trying to figure out what was going on, someone came out from the back and opened the door. We were kind of disappointed that they were out of several things and it seemed to be taking a bit to get our 4 slices of pie. When my husband went to make the coffee he ordered, the Coffee of the Month was empty. We asked about it was was told, there wasn't any. I commented that we had seemed to have come at the wrong time. It was then that the girl at the counter responded that they don't actually open until 10. Everything became clear. We were early and they let us in anyway because the website still had the wrong time listed and that was why they were out of items they normally have- the items weren't ready. I was impressed by this. The pies were delicious and huge slices. Maybe a little higher than I thought necessary -39.00 for 4 pieces. BUT, I tasted no preservatives, everything was fresh and luscious. Pieces filled the entire go boxes and whipped cream in the French Silk was piled high with enough to share on my Bumbleberry . We also had the Quiche, whiccame with a huge Yeast roll, very high quality ingredients, the Sam can be said of the Cherry Crumb. The fruit pies did not have any of that nasty canned jell that most places use now instead of real fruit. I highly recommend this place. read more

AMAZING PIES!! Been there several times when we pass through the area. Owners are so sweet. Definitely stop, you won't regret it.

A bright spot on a long road trip. I sure hope a future road trip crosses its path. Got the fresh strawberry and banana creme pie, both excellent choices. read more

4.5 stars-Wonderfully friendly down home style bakery and lunch stop. Learned of Slice of Pie before going on this trip to the area and they reviewers were spot on. Pretty little college town halfway between St Louis and Springfield. First thing you see when walking in is a six or eight foot case practically filled to the edges with pies of many types and two different sizes. The young lady at the counter could not have been friendlier or more helpful. More on that later. Specials now are fresh Strawberry and Millionaire pie-a cream, fruit, and nuts concoction. These pies are gorgeous and it will most likely make it a difficult decision what to choose-both for right away and to take home:). American & Dutch Apple, Country Custard, Blackberry Cream, Peach, Peanut Butter Lust, etc. Cream Pies such as Chocolate Silk, Lemon, Coconut, etc. Quiche, Cakes, two different types of Pot Pies, Brownies. Menu is so appealing. We chose to go ahead and have lunch here also. I chose the Chicken Mushroom Pot Pie but unlike the photo I saw online this was a quarter slice of a full 10" pie! Much larger I think then the six-inch mini pie in the picture. Heated to a piping hot and served covering the plate. The filling was spectacular. Meaty, herby, mushrooms, corn, green beans, etc. Absolutely delicious. Loved it. The unfortunate part was that due to either how it was stored or heated, the top crust was not crisp and the edge crust was too dry for my taste. But as a whole it was still a delight. Served with a large, soft, fresh, made roll. Sooo goood. DW chose a chicken salad sandwich-the only one on the menu. Mayoee(?) chicken mix with purple grapes, mandarin oranges, almonds, etc. Served on a croissant looking roll that was quite sweet, surprisingly. The roll was dry. The salad not real flavorful. Served with chips. Could have been better. After much questioning and debate we chose to take the young staff members recommendation and pick the one she said was fresh today-Blackberry Crumble (over the Chocolate Cream and French Silk) Served with real fresh whipped cream. They offer not only two sizes of whole pies but also two sizes of slices, whole and half. The whole is a quarter pie, similar to my pot pie and the half is an eighth of a pie. We went half slice and it was plenty big enough for two-or a hearty eater. The mound of whipped cream on top was a sight to behold. Interestingly, they sprinkle more of the crumb topping over the cream. Detracted a bit imo. The pie was served slightly warm. The crust here was outstanding. Buttery and baked perfectly. The filling was generous and with a nice blackberry flavor. Not really strong, but nice. We also chose to take an eight-inch toll house pie with us for future enjoyment on our road trip. This was a good meal in a quality establishment. Wish I lived closer to try more often. But my mid-section says good that I don't Tip-on Tuesday they do half slice half price deal. read more

See all

They have some of the best pie I've ever had! You must try the strawberry one with cool whip! Fire... I'm hoping to find some sugar free samples on the menu in the future! read more

Could use some help with quality control I think some of the things had to be better than my choice I ordered a brownie with ice cream it came out so hard you literally couldn't bite it. When they replaced it with a new one they said that one had been setting on the self to long and the microwave made it hard . New was better but not great still microwaved so when it cooled down was super hard also. I am sure some of the fresh stuff was better I just choose properly. Not sure I would give them a second chance. read more

I'm going to preface this review by saying that the pies were DELICIOUS. The slices were huge, the crust was crunchy, and the filling was plentiful. My cherry-raspberry pie was both tart and sweet and my brother loved his chocolate pie. Upon walking into Slice of Pie, you will immediately transported to your Granny's kitchen. From the wallpaper to the place mats, everything makes you feel like you're eating dessert at Granny's. With that said, I would like to point out a few service issues that the picky, criticizing side of me noticed. My brother and I came in on a Saturday night and they were out of most of their pies. They still had a few appealing choices left. We ordered full slices of pie ( which are only 70 cents more than 1/2 slices!) and waters and sat down to wait......and wait we did. We waited and waited for both the pie and the water. The pie came and I reminded her that we still needed water. They also failed to mention until we had already waited for at least 10-15 minutes that they were out of the pie my brother wanted. When everything finally came, my cup had a hole so I got water all over my pants. Even though Slice of pie is a replica of Granny's kitchen, it's not Granny's who is serving you. I wanted an advice- giving 60 yr. old woman. Instead I got a bunch of bleach-blonde, sweatpants and sandal wearing girls. They were clearing off the tables and started throwing their tips at each other from across the room. It was kind of weird... They also ignored us as we left. The place is small and a friendly "Good-bye!" or "Thanks for coming in!" would have been nice instead of them standing at the counter watching us walk away. As mentioned at the beginning, the pie was definitely wroth it. Slice of Pie came highly recommended by Missouri S&T students and I'm glad I had the opportunity to try a slice. I just wasn't a huge fan of who was working there that night. I wanted Granny, darn it! read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

Delicious, fresh pies. Good variety. Helpful staff. Very satisfying desserts. Now I'm hungry. read more

TERRIFIC Boston Cream Pie! The very BEST! Getting pretty expensive, though.... BUT! Really big serving - for me, it's like a "double".

We tried four pies on our visit: Strawberry rhubarb- flaky crust, soft, tender, well combined flavors for the inside filling. The purée filling had no bite or bitter component, and was sweet with a nice aftertaste. Cherry crumble- overloaded crumble with a thin layer of cherry filling. In a full piece, there were only three cherry pieces and the crumble was thick to the point it needed to be cut off the cake. 97% dough to 3% filling made us sad and left us wanting more. French silk- thick creamy texture with the flavor of a hot cup of milk chocolate with whip cream. Atop of a delicious filling was a three inch thick layer of fresh prepared whipping cream whipped cream. Peanut butter swirl- sweet and salty, a cheesecake texture which is frozen with a heavy peanut butter flavor and small chopped peanuts evenly dispersed through the pie. Dripping with flavor, the top has rich drizzle of chocolate. Alas, the final part of this review includes notice to the public that unsanitary conditions were present in the face of a pandemic. No employees with masks, of count we observed 5 employees, then an older man came out and without using hand cleansers or washing took a cup, got a drink, and was profusely sweating with soaked clothes. It seemed out of place to not even wear a mask to box pies or treat customers with this level of respect. read more

See all

Yummy delicious pie! There are so many options to choose from. The only reason I give this four stars is because I feel like the Oreo cheesecake pie that I had could have been a little better. I want to try the apple pie the next time we go. read more

We saw the sign from the street and my husband swiftly pulled a u-turn for us to try this place. His favorite food is pie, and let me tell you, this pie is TOP NOTCH!!!!!!!! First, the staff are all so so so wonderful. And the pie was beyonddddddd measure! read more

I've eaten at this establishment for a while now. I've never been disappointed until today. As you may know the prices of their delicious pies are quite pricey but usually worth it as an adult. I have three kids and spending $21 on dessert for them is not feasible nor do I want them hopped up on that much sugar. So when they are with me I opt in for the pie sampler for $20 which has 6 slices of their pies (about a 1/4 of the size of their full slice). So they get their three and I get a slice, my husband does and one left over for midnight snack or work the next day. If it's just me, I have no problem splurging on myself (the perks of being a grown adult who works). However I went today and placed my order over the phone for curbside pick up (thank you COVID-19). I ordered my sampler as usual and let everyone pick their slices. Now, before I could add their cakes as an option but today I was told no, so I had to order a FULL SLICE on the side. I ordered our flavors, 2- chocolate cream, 1 key lime, 1 peach crumb, I peanut butter swirl and 1 coconut cream.. The gentleman who took my order over the phone brought the pie out to my car and said thank you.. he was polite however he brought our items not in a bag but just in the styrofoam containers.. which normally they come in a bag for easy transport. now, I don't know if it depends on who's working.. but our slices today were very slim and two slices weren't even accurate slices as they just fell apart and were more like... a tablespoon of pie.. (the peanut butter swirl was the worst) so in total I spent over $30 for a very disappointing sampler of pies. Now they were gone in about 3 bites each which normally would be a food average size dessert. Today was just a huge disappointment. I would say go for the pie as it is good and tasty.. but I would highly recommend you stay away from the sampler option as it was a huge waste of money for me and my family today. read more

A Slice of Pie - Left to right: peach crumb, two chocolate cream, one key lime, one peanut butter swirl, one coconut cream - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

The cherry crumb pie was served warm and the pb lust was a delicious ratio of peanut butter and chocolate. Reminds me of a pb cup. It took a few minutes to order as the young lady was a little overwhelmed with how busy it was at 2:30pm. The dining area had not been cleaned from previous customers but there were a couple tables left for us to sit at. Ordered coffee too but it took about 10 minutes until it was served to us. Wish they had music or something to help the ambiance, it was silently awkward and you could hear everyone's conversations. read more

A Slice of Pie - Cherry crumb and PB lust - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

If you're looking for a "slice of pie" this place would be hard to beat. However, if your craving chicken pot pie, I highly recommend getting a Marie Calendars from the freezer section of your nearest grocery store. I love pot pie for the crispy, flakey crust and delicious savory filling, but what we were served wouldn't rate well even as family leftovers from 3 days ago. The pot pies were obviously not fresh. Then they were microwaved (badly) and served to me and my 2 young sons. The crust was soggy, and the filling was still cold in spots and molten lava in others. I had to warn my kids to be careful, but they still got burned because the cold spots fooled them into thinking it wasn't that hot. I don't know what the owner is thinking even having this on the menu. I feel he'd be much better off sticking to what they're good at which is the fruit pies. read more

Where else can you order a fifth of a homemade pie? So many DELICIOUS options! A MUST stop!!

Pro - Tollhouse pie with fresh made whip cream!!! Highly recommend! - Open evenings read more

Our friends bought a cherry pie for a birthday. It was $42 and there were barely any cherries in the pie. It was overcooked and the filling was only about a half an inch deep. And the taste was horrible. Wasted money. This place used to be great but I think they've definitely gone downhill read more

Excellent pies! The servings are huge, so plan on getting at least two desserts out of each one and taking one home. Staff were very pleasant and quick. Wish we lived closer... read more

We have tried this pie several times and are always disappointed. French silk is too sweet, quiches are so cheesy they give you indigestion, all other pies are too sweet, too. Not to mention they are incredibly overpriced. I just don't understand the good reputation for this place. We don't go there anymore after so many disappointments. read more

I've been coming here for years, and I don't intend on stopping anytime soon. If you're in Rolla and looking for something to do, THIS is it. This place always has the most kind workers and the most delicious pie. Oh you don't like fruit pie? Guess what? They have other pies too. The chocolate silk pie is my wife's favorite, but I'm an apple pie kinda guy. My grandkids really like the coconut cream pie as well. Keep doin what y'all are doing!! read more

A friend brought me a pie from Slice of Pie. I have had their pies in the past (mostly pre fire) and were very good. This cherry crumb she brought was very dry, no cherry's (just fillings) and crumbs on top no flavor. After she told me the price she paid of $40.00 I thought she was kidding. Not sure if I will go back myself in the future. I know things have gone up but $40 for a pie WOW read more

People are nice, store clean. I like my apple pie with a little bit of a crunch left in the apple. Theirs is mushy

I went to the Saint Robert location and was charged over $8.00 per slice for apple pie. This is well over the price listed on the webpage.

The day I had a slice of Boston cream pie... I think my whole life changed! lol. okay, well it was REAAAALLY GOOD. We've also tried the chocolate cream pie, strawberry cheese cake and their apple pie... all are delicious! All the employees are always nice. Definitely definitely recommend. Worth every penny! read more

See all

While the food is great, the price is still too steep. I just can't see paying these prices for Pie. The only reason I was able to even have a slice of pie from them is because a friend of mine paid. read more

Absurdly good desert all around, I've had the brownie a couple times and lemon meringue a couple as well. Every time is as good as the last and the slices are always huge read more

A Slice of Pie - Brownie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

Not too bad of a spot. You receive very nice portions and they have good variety to chose from. If you have a little one I highly recommend you only ordering 1slice because the portions are shareable. read more

Simply amazing! I was in Rolla for a month for school, and my friend told me A Slice of Pie was a must visit! While it is a small shop that is easy to miss (it's hidden between a few buildings), A Slice of Pie is bursting with life and homeyness. As soon as you walk inside, you'll see a huge amount of pies they have in their display case that look absolutely drool-worthy! I opted for a slice of french silk pie for myself and grabbed a piece of apple pie for my friend. To my surprise, the grand total came out to be about $15 for 2 slices of pie. However, my shock wore off after I saw how much pie you were getting for each slice! They were huge! Each slice of pie is easily 2-3 portions depending on how much you want to eat! One bite of my pie was all I needed to tell me that I would be coming back for more pie! The french silk pie was absolutely delicious: smooth, decadent, and chocolatey! This pie definitely hit the spot for all of my chocolate cravings! The crust was also amazing: flaky and melt in your mouth! Overall, I was very impressed with A Slice of Pie! It definitely lived up to the hype! I would recommend stopping by here if you are ever in Rolla or driving thru! Just remember: cash only! So make sure you grab a few bills before you head out here! read more

They offer a wide variety of pies and you can order a whole, half or a slice. They are very large pies and taste amazing! The coconut cream pie is huge and is one of the best I have had. My favorite is the Boston cream pie. One slice lasts me about 2-3 sittings as it is very large. I highly recommend this place! read more

The owners of Slice of Pie couldn't have been more lovely and the pies couldn't have been more delicious. read more

A Slice of Pie - The delightful owners in their new location. - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

I heard about this from some locals, and it was worth it. It's a bit hard to find, as it's kind of in an alley, but the pie was absolutely perfect. read more

I don't know why I thought I'd be first to review A Slice of Pie, what with it having the best pie in the world and all, but for some reason, I thought I'd be first to the punch. Silly, silly Julia. When traveling through Missouri with my husband and his family, we've been known to make major detours just to stop at A Slice of Pie. On our Route 66 trip, Justin and I made sure to stop by and refuel at this homey little spot in Rolla. Maybe not the smartest thing to do when you're the driver on a road trip, 'cause I guarantee you'll want a nap after savoring one of the huge slices of whatever tickles your fancy that day. My favorite so far is the cinnamon-y peach pie with vanilla sauce and Justin loved (but couldn't finish) the chocolate cream pie he had on our last visit. That thing was like, 6" high!! I'm pretty sure the smallest slice offered is a quarter of a pie, and these ain't no teensy pies here, folks. Come hungry--and even though the place is small, maybe come with a group so you can get a sampling of their offerings. Your big belly will thank you. read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

We are from IL on a trip to Branson. Had to swing by here based on reviews both going down AND coming back! LOL It's a strange place to find but our trusty GPS found it buried behind a laundromat. Seriously good stuff! Makes me wanna slap my grandma! We tried the turtle cheesecake and apple walnut cake with cream cheese icing on the first trip. VERY good. The only tiny flaw was they used granulated sugar in the icing vs. powdered and so it was a little grainy. Otherwise perfect. The cake was absolutely jammed with apples and nuts. A whole cake would probably be pretty heavy! The second time around I had strawberry rhubarb. The mark of a great baked pie to me is always the crust. This was very good, perfectly browned and flaky. It cried for a pinch of salt though. The filling was the perfect mix of sweet berries and tart rhubarb and left me wanting more. Much more! If I lived near Rolla, I would prob weigh 200 lbs pretty quickly. If you are within 75 miles of this place, make the trip! A whole fruit pie is $19.95 and a whole slice is $4.95. The cakes are $43.95 for a whole and $23.95 for a half cake, $4.95 for a slice. read more

Roadfood and Yelp! trumpeted this place and we had been anticipating it for hundreds of miles, but honestly, it was kind of disappointing. The crust had a great texture-- it was still crisp with a little bit of flakiness to it. But it didn't taste buttery (my wife diagnoses it as a shortening- or oil- based crust; my palate is not so discriminating as to be sure). More importantly, and more lamentably, the fillings were way too sweet. "Bumbleberry" tasted like the sugary fruit mash at the bottom of a cup of Dannon yogurt. "Peach" had a little more promise (though it was still to sweet) but all of that promise was extinguished by a cinnamon syrup that had been poured over the whole slice. I suppose that was to make up for the fact that they hadn't finished oversweetening the filling. Don't make a big production out of coming here, or if you do, get used to disappointment. read more