So in two days I came two times. I have not been disappointed. I am from California and I'm somewhat lucky to be that far away because I would be here at least three times a week. I had the key lime the first day and it was amazing. The next day I had the rumbleberry and it was outstanding. My wife and I have decided to order pies for special occasions and get together. These would definitely all consumed rather than those pies you get at the store. (6 stars)!!! read more

Very disappointing. Coconut cream pie did not taste homemade and the whipped cream on top not only tasted bad but the serving was enormous. Will not recommend. read more

Okay, this place was adorable. The group I was with almost missed the turn to get to the restaurant which is tucked right next to a laundromat. It's a little bit of a hole in the wall, complete with floral wallpaper and cute old ladies working there, but don't let that stop you from bringing a group of your friends or family there! For lunch, I had a slice of their pot pie and a dinner roll which I swear was so dense, heavy, warm and delicious! And really, trust me on this because I am a pastry and pie person through and through, the pie here is probably the best you can get anywhere. I had a slice of their pumpkin pie topped with homemade whipped cream and it was a **joygasm** in my mouth! I also had a taste of the American Apple Pie with cinnamon drizzle and mmm..... The menu is huge with about 20 different pies you can order in advance (for pies that you'd like to try on the spot the menu looked like it had around 10 choices, really large selection) with choices such as Country Custard, Bumble Berry, Tollhouse Cookie Pie, Key Lime, Chess... I sure hope I can come back before I leave! P.S.: The local customers are so cute. One was actually knocking on the window just to say hello. :-) read more

A Slice of Pie - The sweet ladies who work at the counter - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

Delicious but just too expensive. We used to get all our birthday pies there when it was located in 6th street. Can't afford it now.

Each slice of pie is a meal in its self. We usually take our slices home and we with snack on it throughout the week. Delicious!

I go the cherry raspberry and my husband got the Boston cream. Both were absolutely amazing! So glad the slices were large because I wanted a whole pie after just a bite. read more

Amazing food! Delicious and large portions were a welcomed treat. A slice of pie was about a quarter of pie. The crust was flaky and flavorful. Yum! read more

A Slice of Pie - Four Berry Pie! Yum! - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

We stopped here both on our way to and from Branson. It's kind of hard to find since it's tucked at the back of the property behind a laundrymat. On our way down I had the 1/2 slice of Turtle Cheesecake (order 1/2 slices of the cakes and full slices of the pies - trust me on this one). It came with homemade whipped cream and was so rich that after having this at 5:00 p.m., I didn't eat anymore that evening! It's so sweet that if you're a diabetic, I recommend that you don't go to the laundrymat next door! But seriously, they do have sugar free items available. I also tried a few bites of the Apple Walnut cake which had cream cheese frosting and was also very rich. On the way back home we split a slice of Strawberry Rhubarb pie which was very good. It's only 5 minutes off I-44 and well worth the detour. read more

Great place to get little piece of heaven when visiting my son at his school in Rolla!!

Best pie and cheesecake in the entire world. Seriously? Amazing. I've been going to this place since I was a kid. Turtle Cheesecake with homemade whipped cream? You can't get better than this. Almost everytime I came back to St. Louis I had to stop here. The few times I brought a friend back some cheesecake I would hear, "Cheesecake Factory don't have crap on this!" I've always paid cash here. I am not even sure they accept debit/cc. The ladies here are so friendly and make you feel right at home. I must do before leaving Rolla. read more

Best place ever!!! I come here for dessert every time I'm in rolla. Make sure you bring cash as it's CASH ONLY. Also half of a slice is way too much for one person- don't be fooled! read more

I want to add I did not know they had delivery. My one piece of pie wasn't as perfect as the original owners. I welcome The idea of of learning more about their menu read more

Visited A Slice of Pie for the first time today. Very good, generous slice of amazing Apple Pie with ice cream. Great location. read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

Delectable, mouth watering, must have, can I get some please! This place is a must stop for everyone who travels through this area. It is a once in a lifetime experience that must be repeated when the opportunity presents itself. I have never had so many pie options, and always scrumptious and sinfully delicious. I have tried their fruity pies such as raspberry and rhubarb and peach; all amazing experiences that leave you savoring each bite. The crust is homemade and you just crack it off and eat it alone. The fruit is NOT out of a can, and is wonderful. I have also had their cheesecake, peanutbutter delight, and a few others. BUT...my favorite hands down is the french silk. Oh my heavens! Each time I get this pie, I take a bite, close my eyes, moan and am so thankful to be alive. This pie is an amazing blend of delicious chocolate, pie crust, and homemade whipped cream on top. Heavenly and perfection! Can't wait to visit this place again. Warning: Cash only! Also, they will sell whole pies/half/full slice/ and half slice. All HUGE portions. read more

See all

A bit pricy but very tasty. Large variety and you can order for holidays or a special occasion. A whole pie will set you back +/- $35.

Surprised at the prices. A whole pie was over $30 and a slice was around $8. Wife and I got two bowls of potato soup and two slices of pie and it came to over $40. Pies were good but the soup tasted like something that was pulled out of a freezer and lacked much flavor. read more

So glad we discovered this on Yelp on the way home from Branson. Delicious homemade pies ( without the work at home) Good chicken salad sandwich as well. read more

In one word, AMAZING!! The strawberry crumb pie was unbelievably good. The best pie I have ever had! The two young lady's working were a delight. (Libby and Caroline) All around great experience! If you are in Rolla, you have to stop here!! read more

See all

The Pies doesn't taste the same. I don't think the same lady is baking the Pies. I hear alot of locals talk about how Slice of Pie has changed. read more

Slice of pie takes a huge slice from your wallet, each slice is 6.95, whether it's a high cost ingredient pie like pecan or low cost like cream pies. They were out of cream pies the day we went. We opted for the peach, which was just ok. We also shared a Rubin sandwich. The food is good, but not worth the cost in my option. No great experience or value found here. read more

This place is a hidden gem! Stumbled upon it one day out exploring Rolla and oh man! They have some awesome pies! The inside is like made to look like a cute 1940s home kitchen! The pies did not disappoint! If you like pie, and ever in Rolla. Give this place a try! They take cash only, no debit or credit cards. Be sure to have cash on you! read more

See all

Hands down the best pie I have EVER eaten! I wish I didn't live so far away. 10 out of 5 stars...ha ha but seriously it's that good!!!!!

a classic! you can't stop by rolla without getting a slice. the new location is huge and such a great upgrade.

Glad we stopped! Definitely worth it and holy cow! One slice will make you crave a nap! Great staff and I've never had better pie. read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

In town with the lady checking out some wineries. Locals said we should give this place a try. Definite small town charm. Small shop with a varied selection of pies. I went for the chocolate cream pie and the lady went for one of the fruit pies. For me pie has to have an amazing crust and this did. The lady said hers was excellent too. My chocolate pie was good. The filling reminded me of the pies my grandma use to make and it really sent me back. If I had one complaint it would be the whipped topping was 3 times as thick as the pie and really wasn't my thing. The Lady's said she really liked her pie too. Worth the stop. Oh and Cash or Check only. No cards. The Good Lots of Pies. 1 whole slice is a meal. Great crust. Small town charm. The Bad Wasn't a fan of the 3 mile tall whipped cream but didn't ruin it for me. Dining room is tight. The Ugly Nada this place was fun. read more

In town with my daughters for Volley Ball and a college visit. Found this place for a evening treat and so glad we did. Monthly special of the Mud Pie was delicious. Rich and velvety with so much chocolate made this one a favorite for my little one. My oldest ordered the Pecan Pie. Growing up on pecan Pie around the holidays, there is a pretty high bar here to achieve. Nothing more to say but simply amazing. My daughter even said it is the BEST pecan Pie that she has ever tried. Thought about rating the place only 4 stars simply because they don't accept credit. We almost couldn't order our Pie but found some extra cash hidden in the car for such emergencies. But since the pies were awesome, I'll stick with the 5 stars. Thanks for a great treat for me and my girls. read more

We went here for lunch. We had the bacon quiche and chicken salad sandwich. They were both really good. We also ordered the blackberry crumble and chess. I ordered the half slice and it was huge. Great place to eat lunch. read more

Found this Slice of Pie on Yelp. I tried the bacon quiche it was very good, had a croissant with it very tasty, also had a slice of banana cream pie, it was actually a double size so you can split it or order a half slice, which is probably an actual normal piece of pie. Didn't care for all the whipped cream on top because it didn't have any flavor to it, but the actual pie was okay. I would choose a different pie next time. read more

Delicate pastries, baked goods & beautiful French breads. Soups, sandwiches and salads available. Delish and quick. Dine in or take out. Staff is incredibly friendly and the food is good quality. read more

Excellent pie!!! Prices are a bit high but the pie is delicious and portions are good.

Fantastic atmosphere and customer service. Good prices and the absolute best pies! 10/10 would recommend

Hidden Gem! We were recently on a road trip from Michigan to Oklahoma and stopped here based on a recommendation, and was not disappointed. It's just a little hole in the wall of an establishment off the beaten path of the highway, but what they lack in size they more than make up with flavor. They have a big selection of favorites that are always in the menu, but they also have a rotating selection. I went with the French Silk, which the proprietor described as "the sweetest pie they have". I have to agree it was over the top sweet, but every bite was heaven. read more

Perfect place for my 600th review! It had been a while since I had been to A Slice of Pie in Rolla, MO but it still looks exactly the same as my last visit. On any given day they have 30+ different varieties of mostly pies, some cheesecakes, and some cakes. They have whole pies, slices, 1/2 slices, mini pies, etc. They have warm pies, frozen pies, ice cream, whipped cream, etc. They do have a food menu as well but I've never tried the food. Why would I when the dessert options are so appealing? I had lunch with three other family members in Rolla on Friday and we made a last minute decision to stop for pie afterwards. We got 2 Bumbleberry slices with vanilla ice cream, one key lime slice, and one toll house slice. They were all completely different and unique but each one was better than the next. The key lime was frozen and very tart and creamy! The toll house was like a giant warm chocolate chip cookie with whipped cream on top! I'm not much of a fruit pie eater but the Bumblueberry was excellent and so was the crust! Thank goodness I don't get to Rolla, MO that often. This place is crazy good. If you are in Rolla it's a must see. Absolutely do not miss it. I would have rather just eaten this than lunch! It's only an hour and a half from St. Louis. Too good! read more

See all

I have never heard of this place but after a recommendation by two people after dinner at Matts steakhouse almost half of our group decided to visit this place and indulge in dessert. I am not a big dessert person so kept it basic and ordered a slice of Dutch Apple pie. Now on to the review: 1. This place is tucked away and located next to a Laundromat and dry cleaners. Parking is limited which may be an issue during the day but around 8pm it wasn't an issue. At first glance it looked a "hot mess" from the outside. Upon entry you an instantly determine this place has been there for a while and elderly are involved in some way: cake display filled with storage of random items, paper dollie place mats, 70s mirror accent wall, clutter walkway/storage you pass by if going to the restroom (would recommend this be a staff only restroom due to the atmosphere leading to and inside), an older stale smell is noticeable immediately when you walk inside and the tables and chairs are dated. 2. The two ladies who took our orders or assisted were very friendly. You have an option to get a half slice of pie since the whole slices are large. They will suggest getting a whole slice for 80 cents more which is $5 and change. You can request the pie is warmed up and 1 scoop of ice cream is served in a large styrofoam cup... Way beyond one scoop. Only CASH and CHECKS accepted. 3. This place is opened until 10pm and while we were there the customers were rotating in and out the entire time. Everyone except us, ordered to go. Would highly recommend "to go" ordering at this location. 4. Everyone in the group was highly satisfied with their pies of various flavors. The Dutch Apple pie that I ordered was good. The apples tasted freshly peeled and not canned. The pie crust was tasty but the top crust was not as sweet as I'd like. Overall it was pretty good. read more

See all

I admit, I had high hopes. After reading the reviews, my mouth was watering in anticipation of the strawberry-rhubarb pie, but I was disappointed with how dry the crust was and how the filling didn't really seem to fill the pie at all. I thought that if a shop specialized in pie, the crust would be flaky, buttery, and all around delicious. But it wasn't. In fact, I've had better crusts come from a Pillsbury can. My fellow yelpers don't usually lead me astray, but this time they let me down. The teenage girls at the register seemed too preoccupied to acknowledge that I was standing there waiting to order, and I literally stood right in front of them for over 5 minutes before either of them even bothered to look at me. And they only take cash or checks. What business in 2015 doesn't take credit cards? read more

How can you go wrong?! My boyfriend and his family told me about this place so we had to stop on our way to our big Arkansas fishing trip! I've heard about the strawberry rhubarb pie and it did it disappoint. We also got an apple pie with their "secret" cinnamon sauce. Amazing. Best apple pie I have ever had!! The place is small and it was busy but if you're in the area, you have to stop! read more

I saw the commercial on tv for this place so I had to check it out. First of all, I got a slice for Egg Custard pie and a slice of Lemon Meringue and the GRAND TOTAL, you ready for this... $11.96 I said these pies have to be GOOD for that price. The Egg Custard was Nutmeg OVER KILL, and the Lemon was all right. I'll be getting my pies from the Grocery store read more

A Slice of Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rolla, Missouri

See all

A Slice of Pie is a dang slice of awesome for this middle of nowhere, unspectacular town. (Sorry Rolla-..ians?) As a big New York City kid out of my element in the quiet town of Rolla, finding this place was an awesome little food haven in a sea of chain restaurants and limited options for the palate. A Slice of Pie offers a number of pies, cheesecakes, (and other items I didn't pay attention to) fresh and ready to serve by the slice at any given moment. NOTE: The slices here are HUGE. Maybe I'm just used to stupidly small, fancy desserts in the city, where chefs fool you into believing that the size of dessert is inversely proportional to both its cost and quality. The slices here are towering, and easily share-able for two people. Unless you're me, and you ordered the coconut cream pie, then back off because all of this glorious deliciousness is mine, and mine alone. I appreciated the free refills on coffee and the overall friendly service. Just one downside: Do -not- use the bathroom here. It's pretty much a dark, dingy janitor's closet (complete with mop and bucket). I wish A Slice of Pie would overnight their treats to me in New York, because I'm almost tempted to go back just for more of their amazing, homemade, desserts. This is a must-visit spot if you are within an hour drive from here, and I -rarely- tell people to go out of their way for particular food places. This one is worth it! Thanks for all the memories~ read more

I've only had the pies so I can't speak to the savory foods, but the dessert pies are amazing! And the whipped cream is soooo thick and delicious. Not sure I can pick a favorite but definitely the peanut butter lust is a contender. read more

Stopped by today for three pies. Chocolate cream which was piled high with whipped cream and chocolate shavings, country custard which has a nutmeg eggnog flavor and a lemon meringue pie that was at least 5"-6" in height piled in meringue. Around $26-$29 per pie. And they are as homemade as homemade gets. If you want to make sure your flavor is in stock call ahead and have them put your order aside. Cash and checks only. No credit cards. I can't wait to dig into these pies! read more