White's Market is a small, rustic market…read more If you need to do a large grocery run, need to feed lots of people, and aren't ready to spend $100+, I'd recommend taking a longer drive off the island so that you won't feel the sticker shock. If you need to pick up a few staples or items that you need for your home cooked lunch or dinner in your summer/rental home, this is the most convenient marketplace for extra goods in Barnegat Light. Purchases here support a local business of the island, which is a nice mental reframe. There's not a large variety of different packaged items, but it does the job when you're in a pinch. They also have household goods, snacks, and produce. There is a butcher in the back of the market as well as pastries and bagels tucked away (I heard they're delicious, but unfortunately I could not have any as I'm gluten free). They also have a mini fridge in the back which hoagies to go as well as cheese. If you want a sandwich made fresh for you or cold cuts to go, they do that too! They also have free tootsie rolls by the butcher which I thought was a cute touch. Note: they are no longer "Cash Only" and accept credit card as payment! Grab a free local newspaper (The Sandpaper - haha so cute) here as well if you want to know high/low tides within the next week.

Classic! You must experience White's. The staff is fabulous. They're so friendly and competent. The…read moredeli is awesome! I love it here. The corn is the best on the island They even have vegan ice cream!

Such great food and customer service here. Enjoyed my sandwich on semolina very much! Always return…read morehere. They're the best.

Still five stars the steak quality is second to none. It's one of those butcher shops that you…read morecan't give up. It's always great never service without a smile and the shop is super clean.

Absolutely the best food, service and is extremely clean. I would highly recommend this place. You…read morewill be amazed by all the yummy food. Both raw and premade foods. desserts are fabulous, too!

Food excellent. Everything fresh and delicious. Just a bit hectic at times. However. no reflection…read moreon food.

I don't think there is a type of meat they can't get. While visiting friends in AZ they served us a…read moreBBQ'd Tri steak. A delicious cut of meat. Can't find around here. Went into Okies and he special ordered it for me. It is sooooo good. But they have lots of other ready to eat salads (try the chicken salad)... delish. And the people are so friendly and helpful.

The German Butcher has a much better selection and much more professional helpful staff Okies is…read moreoverrated overpriced. I won't be going back very disappointed in the service and the attitude of the staff they give off a snotty vibe.

My family has been coming to Neptune Market for years, so this was a disappointing visit. We…read morestopped in for a quick breakfast, but what should have been a simple order ended up taking nearly an hour. All I ordered was a pork roll, egg, and cheese on a Kaiser roll with a hash brown patty. I understand they were very busy, but the wait still felt excessive for such a basic breakfast sandwich. I was also surprised to find out that after 11:00 a.m. they stop serving pancakes and omelets, even though breakfast sandwiches are still available. It would have been nice if the full breakfast menu was offered a little longer. The biggest issue for me, however, was food handling. I watched employees place dirty register receipts directly on top of prepared sandwiches, including an egg and cheese that sat with the receipt on it for several minutes. Thermal receipts aren't something I want touching my food, and it completely turned me off. I also noticed several employees with long hair and facial hair working without hairnets or beard nets, which didn't inspire confidence in the kitchen's sanitation practices. Neptune Market has always been a family favorite because the food is tasty and reasonably priced, so it's disappointing to leave this review. I hope they can improve their food handling practices and kitchen hygiene because I'd love to see them get back to the standards that kept us coming back for so many years.

Great food and counter service for breakfast and lunch! My "go to" place in Harvey Cedars!read more

Ordered my Thanksgiving Turkey and they did not disappoint!! The bird was amazing!! 25# clean,…read morethank you!!

What an operation! This place was packed when I came and probably because they have a good product…read more The meat we get from here is always fresh and they do a good job of getting you in and out quickly. It is also a little pricier than the supermarket but you pay for quality. It is kind of hidden so make sure you know where you are going when coming. I would make sure to order in advance especially if you have a big item. They also have eggs and other stuff if you are interested. Overall, they do a good job and we love the product.

This was a cute spot to stop at on the strip. They have parking and a nice little dining area on…read morethe inside. They make fresh lobster rolls, with different flavors. My cousin and I stopped in to spit a sandwich. We got turkey, with bacon, lettuce, tomato and onions on it. It was a big sandwich for two people. They did not skimp out on the meat. We also got an order of fries, which they brought to the table as well. They were good and crispy.

Food was good, portions small, very pricey for the portions. I wouldn't recommend it for dinner…read more Lunch yes. It was tasty. We spent over $200.00 for 11 people. We ended up making burgers because it wasn't enough for dinner. FYI ticktock videos are fake size.

Greeted by the owner, very nice, beautiful meats and they sell lunch too! And their soups are…read morefantastic. Had the chicken pot pie soup, wow delicious hearty vegetables lots of chicken.

I got an amazing bone-in ribeye and bought a #4 hero while I waited. Also picked up a container of…read moreBrandt beef tallow which I used to make grilled broccoli rabe. Highly recommend!

Just moved to the area. Great fresh seafood and Pies! Now I go once a week for fresh seafood.read more

It's the best for everything! Love this place for years! Seafood, produce, plants and flowers, you…read morename it. And delicious homemade Cole slaw!

Came here to get bagels for the house of people I was staying with, and walked in right when it…read moreopened. It's your standard deli, you can get sandwhiches and other things that you need. Nicer service than I'm used to in New York. The bagels were all pretty old, except for the Sesame and Poppy ones. Not really great.

Got breakfast sammies here on a "Shoulder Season" Fridy and the place was bare bones…read more Hardly any produce is carried here. Don't reply on them for groceries or supplies but the breakfast sandwiches were fresh and so delicious - eaten out at the picnic tables. Glad they are still here but wish they carried lettuce, tomato and cukes.