The best garlic knots in town! This vodka sauce is a perfect shade of pink & rich & delicious. This place is super underrated! It's clean & the staff is so friendly. I will now be coming here instead of all the other overpriced pizza places in the neighborhood. read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

I was trying a new Italian pizza spot in Queens The cashier/teller was extremely rude and racist. Would not recommend only because they have no water drain read more

Alessio Pizzeria - This is gross - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I recently gave into my pizza craving and tried Alessio's. I heard good things for the past few years but was skeptical- not anymore! Both slices were tasty and not greasy like some pizza can be. It's a bit of a hole in the wall but don't let that stop you. Even the cashier was nice I'll definitely be back soon! read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Great spot for pizza Pros: + Large variety of food + Hole in the wall for sure + Delicious margarita pizza + Huge slices Cons: - Difficulty to find parking IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC read more

Alessio Pizzeria - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Delicious food people would love y to o come back for more with good service and with family and friends and family

Pure definition of " Hole-in-the-wall"!!! Amazing! There is a older man that helped us and I'm sure he was the owner. He was a one man show and absolutely amazing. The pizza was soooooo good. Exactly what you expect with NY style pizza. Nice big slices, foldable and plenty of toppings. Wish they would have had garlic knots but they were cooking when I was there. Darn, guess I'll have to go back!!! A few tables and crowded as they are right by where you order but that's the be expected. Overall, I can't wait to come back! read more

Alessio Pizzeria - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Love their pizza . Always crispy and love their sauce and cheese. Pizza is always consistently good

Good big slices!!! I like it saucy!! Pizzerias always have fast service! I had a regular slice but they had many choices. I don't usually eat an entire slice cause I feel it gets cold and ehhh. This slice never got cold nom nom nom. read more

Great pizza, fast, friendly service and reasonably priced. We just happened to be in the area and glad we stopped. read more

We ordered from here since we were visiting my mother at LIJ. My father suggested pizza and this is the place he wanted. I was suggesting Iaverone since we have all been there for dinner several times. I'm such a brat when I go home because I don't want any gourmet pizza; I want that classic NY style slice. Thin, orange grease, and crispy crust. Of course I browsed through all the Yelp reviews and pictures. Everything looked decent. Since we were visiting my mom, we were unsure of the delivery options to hospital rooms so we called ahead to place the order. We ordered pizza and garlic knots. They told us the usual 20 minute wait. My dad opted to pick up the order- he is very old school and does not use any delivery apps or opt for delivery since everything he orders, he figures he can drive to. In my opinion, I did not like the pizza. I hate excess tomato sauce and this pizza was full of it. The bread of the pizza was too thick for my taste. I was starving so I ate what I could but became exhausted trying to get all the excess sauce off. My parents did not complain but I don't think they are as snobby as me regarding the particulars. I did not think it tasted bad; I just wish there was less sauce. The garlic knots were good though. read more

They overcharge! I spent $15 on 2 silicians, a bottle of dr pepper, and order of garlic knots. It came cold and didnt even taste good. I would never order from them again. Just trying to rip off your customers! Order from luigis or umbertos instead. read more

Straight and simple pizza place, no fancy gimmicks to pull you in. The crust was great, crunchy on the inside, doughy in the center, just how I like it. I ordered a chicken bacon ranch and a buffalo chicken pizza and those came out to $8.60. Even though they were speciality pizzas that was a bit pricey. My chicken bacon ranch was great but the buffalo chicken wasn't spicy to any degree. Luckily I ordered my slices to go and had my bottle of Frank's to douse on it. Gotta get a kick! I don't like the fact you cannot see the pizza being made. Most pizza places all the work is being done in front of you so you can see it's clean, but here there is a separate back room where this happens. I'd like a little more view of it to ensure the health code and public safety is being respected! read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Yummms - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Had food delivered. Pizza. Yummers!!! Had cheese, half garlic, half pepperoni. Very fresh. Ordered again.

The buffalo chicken pizza was good and the kids enjoyed their plain slice of heaven. Its a little shop with good food. Eat up! read more

Alessio Pizzeria - What's left of my slice. - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

The service has been much better since I've been back. I'd give 4 stars. Food is really good

I was in the area and was in the mood for pizza. Stumbled upon this place and eyeballed the ziti slice and a pepperoni. I usually like my pizza well done so requested it a little crispy. I like when the pepperoni starts to bubble. Took a bite first from the pepperoni and noticed right away the crust was almost paper thin, almost too thin. It was still decent but nothing great. The ziti slice was certainly better because when you add carbs to carbs, how can you mess that up? There wasn't a lot of cheese on the ziti slice which is how I prefer it. May stop by again if I'm in the area. read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Solid buffalo pizza slice, I also enjoyed the chicken bacon ranch slice, and chicken marsala slice! read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I have been going here for a long time now (just about everyday during lunch) and always used my credit card. One day I show up and they started charging $2 service fee for purchases under $10. Now I understand that they would want cash if I was purchasing like a 2 or 3 dollars worth of stuff, but my usual purchase is $7. it is the price of 2 slices and 1 bottled drink. I think they should accept credit on 5 or more with no charge. I own a business myself and know credit card companies only charge .17 cents + .0325 percent of total purchase per transaction. That only equates to less than a dollar for anything under 10 dollars, which means they are making a profit for swiping your card. Very unhappy with the direction they went in. read more

I wanted a slice of pizza and looked up the reviews from this location lace. I am so disappointed. There was hair baked into my slice. I was to far away to go back and make a formal complaint but that is completely in Sanitary. The place looked clean in the beginning it I will not be coming here ever again. read more

See all

4.5 As far as pizzerias go... 5 stars for basic regular slice: exquisite crispy crust with the right amount of cheese on top of a tangy flavorful tomato sauce. There's even the right amount of oiliness!!! 5 stars for grandma slice: sauce is different from basic regular slice, and the combo of basil and garlic and cheese are just right 4 stars for margarita: cross between regular and grandma, but crust could be bettery 4 stars buffalo chicken: not enough buffalo but chicken and creamy sauce is yummy 4.5 stars for rolls: sausage, chicken rolls offer nice crust to filling ratio, and fillings are nicely seasoned and mixed with sauce or cheese 4.5 stars garlic knots: just the right amount of garlic and parsley, and butta on top of a crispy and chewy knot of goodness 4 stars salad pizza: needs better crust and salad mix 5 stars grilled chicken salad: mouthwatering tender grilled chicken slices adorn a bed of crispy lettuce, tomato and cucumber with some olives and mozzarella thrown in. A zesty Italian dressing isn't overwhelmingly oily and delivers just the right amount of tang. Other menu items are solid. From soups to appetizers to pasta and heroes, you will get a satisfying meal that tastes home made. The food isn't cheap, but I guess it's smart to take advantage of prime location on the intersection of two major roads with strip mall parking. Kids in this neighborhood are lucky to have this pizzeria be a part of their childhood memories. read more

Just moved to the neighborhood and loving this place already! Very good pizza for neighborhood pizzeria, even my kids love them!

Went to this place a couple of times for lunch when I go for my Dr.'s appt. and I love their bread. I guess I always come here when I'm starving coz I thought the food was decent. I came in today with my kids at 8PM (they closed at 9PM) and asked if they were still open and the manager/owner immediately said yes! We waited 35mins for our food. Saying that the food is tasteless is a compliment because it was awful and tasteless. Awful because the alfredo sauce should be called oil and butter sauce on an uncooked cream. My 7 years old had to put so much salt on his food to be able to add a flavor to it. While we were eating the manager or whoever the guy in charged started sweeping the floor and you can see dusk going all over the place I bet some went on our food. Where I'm from, it is rude to broom or sweep floors when people are eating because you are putting dirt on peoples food. That's not even the worst part! He brought out his mop and the chemical he was using was so overwhelming I had to tell him to please wait until we leave because the smell is too much. He stopped but left the chemical there. I know people are smarter than that to just do stuff like this. I can literally taste the chemicals and had no choice but to just wrap everything up. We left at 8:45pm and stayed 10mins our bill was $56 for 2 tasteless pasta and small pizza. I should've just spent it at Vacarros OR Ciros. I WILL NEVER EVER COME BACK to this place and please save your money and actually enjoy it somewhere else. Some staff are Rude and unprofessional not to mention that the food is so bad! read more

Horrible - don't ever order from here - rude, Food sucks, and not worth your time. If you want food id rather come over and cook for you than waste your money on them read more

Excellent white and spinach pinwheel. Regular and chicken bacon slices were very good also. Fresh tasty ingredients. I look forward to trying other dishes here. read more

Alessio Pizzeria - Lots of tables. - Pizza Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Place has amazing food great price am amazing staff this is probably the best pizza place in Nassau figures it across the street from NYC go visit today read more

Nastiest pizza ever didn't even wanna change my slice when I asked after taking one bite. The spanish dude can't even speak English. I asked for manager and a pizza maker came out and started talking Rudley cause I didn't like the slice. There's so many pizzerias around way better such as ivarones in lake success center and then Luigis. Way more friendly staff and people that actually like their job. Wish I can leave 0 stars. read more

I was in a real bind and they came through! I had a business lunch scheduled for approximately 50 people today and due to a series of miscommunications my caterer was unable to meet my time deadline. I called Allessio the second they opened and placed the order for ten pies and a salad . Not only did they not question the 1.5 hour lead-time they delivered exactly on time and everyone said the pizza was delicious. The favorite was the White Pizza with Broccoli and Spinach... I definitely will use them again and this time I promise to give them more time! read more

Our office will curently not order from here again- They incorrectly took our $50+ order, and refused to bring the item that was not given. We tipped their delivery guy generously. We order multiple times a week. And $50+ each order. The person on the phone was rude, unhelpful, referred to my as "honey", & "sweety" multiple times, after asking him not to. He also explained his mistake, was not worth his drivers time, despite our multiple orders, and generous tipping- With so many options of italian food here, why waste our time, and money with poor customer service. read more

Good pizza and buffalo wings. Also tried their Caesar chicken wrap and chicken roll. Good food and okay pricing. Parking is terrible to find at lunch time though read more

They refused to bring the food that they forgot in the delivery. We order from them 4-5 times a week. DONT ORDER FROM THEM! Really bad customer service read more

Supposedly owned by the same people of Umberto's, there is no similar connection with the pizza. A great quick stop for an average slice, the slices are better on some days than others, ranging from good to Tombstone frozen pizza. They seem to always have pan pizzas ready made, which offers a little bit a variety from your traditional slice. read more

I'm updating my past review after stopping in a few times since the last review. First off, after trying a few other pizza places in the surrouding area, Alessio has the BEST tasting pizza hands down! Also, I'm finding a friendlier atmosphere these days. This combo definitely makes for repeat business. Maybe the owner read some of the reviews & made some adjustments? Not sure but whatever it might be, I hope it continues cause I will keep going back for more! read more

This is our favorite italian place because the pizza, from vegetable to penne pasta pizzas and their pasta dishes are incredible and delightfully delectable! Price is well worth the meal! read more

If you want an authentic, freshly made pizza that could really hit the spot then this is the place. An old school kind of pizzeria that gives the slice with the right sauce, thickness of dough with the right price. We ordered the original, pepperoni, margarita ,grandma and garlic knots. All to our satisfaction after trying many various others, all being the most popular in Nassau county. This is by far the best and our go to place from now on. Consistency of the dough and sauce being an issue we found with most reputable pizzerias on Long Island. This place doesn't disappoint after all these years. Also, staff are friendly and accommodating. If you want to customize your orders it's never an issue and they won't get pricey as some of the other places. Alex and Enriques are so good to all their customers you'd feel like you're in that Cheers Bar! Must go! read more

Entrees are pretty good for a pizza joint. Its the better choice in this neighborhood for Italian take out or delivery. We have had all the chicken entrees and its always good. Delivery is usually thirty minutes to forty five minutes. Oh and pizza is good too. read more

Totally underestimated this place... From a self appointed pizza connosouir - this pizza was SO good! Their regular is solid and tastes like real NY pizza - good crust (not gummy or gooey), perfect sauce/cheese ratio, and the pizza folds perfectly for one handed eating. comparable to Umberto's. Will return for sure. read more

One of my favorite pizzeria's in my neighborhood. Affordable, great service and amazing food! Def. recommend this place for food!!

I'm a very hard person to impress when it comes to food. My expectations are very high but I'm also practical when it comes to knowing what types of places I'm ordering from. I ordered delivery for myself. The girl in the phone was polite. My order was semi detailed, picky and weird. Everything came out exactly how I ordered it. The delivery was super fast, I questioned if it was my food or my friend who was supposed to come by at the door when the bell rang. The food was very fresh. Even the hero bread was fresh and soft. Coming from someone with OCD and who's hard to impress, this place just got it all right. Food was just spot on excellent. 5 Stars read more

When I was a kid, the boss used to give me the leftover pizzas for free! Absolutely love the joint. The people that work there are quiet, but are very receptive to conversation! read more

The best pizza, mainly because of the sauce I think. Amazing pastas and salads too. Highly recommend