Alfy's Pizza, or should I say, how to put yourself out of business. I grew up with Alfy's there was one in our area as a kid decades ago. It closed and became Pietro's and that location eventually became Pizza Haven. Anyone that remember the latter, knows they have been gone for decades as well. That said, my memories of both were positive and since we road-tripped to Portland for Pietro's it was only fitting we road trip here as well As always we checked the website ahead of time to decide what we would have and although some places don't publish pricing online this business does. We checked the menu in restaurant as we always do, because sometimes they don't update the website and prices have changed, but the prices matched. We placed our order and was shocked to see the prices were 20% to 25% higher. The pizza was about 15% higher and they added an 8% service fee for each order. When I asked the guy about the prices, he got mad, he said he was unaware about the price increase but said the 8% was explained on a sign, that he was unable to find. Since we had driven more than an hour, without a backup plan, we ordered a smaller pizza to offset the costs, but it gets worse! We ordered the Royal Alfy, which is supposed to be a loaded pizza. There was so little meat on this pizza it was criminal. I don't think there was a piece of sausage for each piece of pizza and I didn't detect many other meat toppings at all. It tasted like a veggie pizza, which is not what we paid for and with the inflated prices, we overpaid for that! In review of the website, since we planned this trip last summer, they have two locations that are temporarily closed. Sorry, not possible, you can't have a location without revenue for an extended period and hope to reopen. It clearly takes cash flow you do not have!!! After this amount of time unless you have a documented remodel, which you don't, those locations are not opening and the way you are cheating the community, it won't be long before the remaining locations close and based on your low Yelp score, It's clear you either don't care, don't listen or don't understand that without a community, you have no business. That was officially the longest drive for the worst pizza. I'll come back under one condition, to help you lock the door when you lose your lease. Karma is coming and you will regret not being a better business. read more

I don't know how this place gets such low ratings. I completely disagree. It isn't often that I get their pizza as I like to come in and get there all you can eat salad bar. The salad bar is about you'd expect from an old school pizza joint, but everything has always seemed fresh and tasty. I've never had any problems with the staff though some are not the friendliest. I'd say if you remember God Fathers, Round Table, pizza haven, Pietro's pizza or any of the other old school pizza chains this is as close as your going to get and to me, for my old school pizza place fix this is it! read more

Been going here since I was young dude and the quality never misses. Wish they still had the Nintendo 64's there haha.

We recently visited here for lunch.... Service was great, food was on point , have previously hosted birthday parties and baby showers here and never had any issues. Prices are really good for lunch too!! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Garlic chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

See all

Very surprised this place is still open. Pizza is mid. Customer service lacks any kinda great experience. We have too many pizza places in Monroe and this one can go bye bye. read more

Friday deal, two medium pizzas for $15 in total! Server super nice and wait time was quick. Came here for The nostalgia and it didn't disappoint! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Ham and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

See all

One of the last Alfy's left and we love making the drive. They still have Nintendo 64 games and my husband and I always get a few games in while they bake our pizzas. The pizza recipe is consistent with what I remember from my childhood. They have a nice banquet room in the back to rent as well, definitely a gathering place for families. With that being said, please make sure your kids understand how dangerous it is to run in here. A lady almost dropped a pizza on a kid because two kids were roughhousing and running through the middle of the entryway/ordering area. The staff is always pleasant too, be sure to stop by! read more

The pizza was good and the salad bar was fresh. The staff was friendly. I will come back again.

The manager & staff of this establishment and thieves. We rented the banquet room and I signed 2 receipts & when my cc statement came they had apparently adjusted my total after me signing because they said they forgot some charges. Mind you they tried charging me double when I billed out and we never got the banquet room discount. When speaking with the manager he pretty much called me a liar even though I have receipts to prove what I was originally charge. DO NOT TRUST THEM ...PAY CASH ! read more

What happened to Alfys pizza in monroe? No more half price pizza and no more Greek pizza.

Immediate service, perfect pizza crust and sauce. Salad bar is well stocked and clean. Cold beer. Very enjoyable with our two grandchildren.

I understand some people have bad experiences at any restaurant so I discount random ones that talk about a bad employee. Every restaurant has a few bad apples. You gotta excuse all restaurant reviews for the covid years 2020-21 as well. Times were tough. More importantly: How's the food? The service is something you have to judge after a few times. I've been here a few times now for our monthly meetings on Tuesday night. The pizza is okay. Not fantastic but I've had much worse at other places. We get a discount on pizza when we have meetings as does any regular group. I've had the parmesan wings before and they were delicious! I recommend them highly. I like the salad bar. They have lettuce and spinach. I have never noticed bad lettuce in the bowls. They have a ton of goodies to put on your salad. You can have a one time plate or a all-you-can eat plate. It comes with free garlic bread. It's under warm lights so it can get hard after a while. The little ones might like the games they have inside. There are some free old style computer monitors that have some games on them. Some of the monitors dont work though. There's plenty of comfortable seating. I like this place for a family outing or a group meeting. There is a large separate room that can be divided in two sections for smaller groups. Give it a try. The employees have always been friendly. I'm sure you'll like it! I'll take some pics next time I go. read more

Fresh food, deliciously prepared pizza and clean facilities! With excellent service and a beautifully kept salad bar! But... Four stars due to staffing. They could use another employee during their busy hours. read more

Been coming here a long time, friendly staff and the pizza seems to always come out pretty good!!

If I could do zero stars I would. Here's how the experience went for us. Keep in mind, we've ordered from Alfys in Monroe on and off for over 8 years now at the same house. 6:30 order pizza. Was told it was not busy, so it would be 30 mins. COOL! 8:00 rolls around, no pizza. I call back. They tell me there is a system issue screwing up the tickets making delivery difficult, driver had to return to alfys for address verification. But he is back out. Ok...stuff happens. 8:30 call from the driver with the address ave vs dr. cannot find the house. I give him the correct address. am told I am out of delivery zone, as he continually repeats my address incorrectly. I give him the entire address, surrounding directions, cross street etc. Okay hes on his way again. 9:00 he calls, repeats a COMPLETELY Different address not even close to mine, takes 5 minutes to find the ticket that he says he finally found. I repeat no, this is my address. again with directions, etc. He sounded completely out of it, impaired in some way. But said i'll get yours out to you ahead of my other deliveries. 9:30 rolls around, still no pizza. We call the number of the driver for a 3rd conversation where he says I'm off the clock. We say seriously? We've been waiting OVER 3 HOURS WITH NO PIZZA! He says well We're closed. Go F*** yourself. After shock and what just happened arguing with him, he says it again and hangs up. I immediately called Alfys in Monroe vs his cell and a man answers. He says, we're closed you will have to call tomorrow. I said well I would like to make a complaint about one of your drivers. He says Yep. You dont like the way I treated you, go F*** yourself too! I reply with excuse me? And again he repeated it followed with, we dont want you as a customer. I can honestly say I'm shocked. This is the most HORRIBLE customer service situation I have ever had. What the heck is wrong with people. I ordered pizza as a treat for my kids . They were excited about it after a long drive, and yet nothing comes and we are talked to like that? I will be going to Alfys myself tomorrow to have someone make this right as we prepaid. and I will NEVER order from this establishment again. I would rather drive myself than give them a cent of my money. read more

Love the salad bar here, it's always a treat! Highly disappointed in the way my sister was treated!!!! Garlic bread is part of the salad bar. Purposely made us wait 35 min to get the garlic bread out. It was a disgusting display of customer service. Alfys has struggled enough now this guy is making it worse. Sad! read more

So the woman behind the counter is very friendly making a not that great food a favorite but the older man behind the counter is the complete opposite very unfriendly. The pizza toppings are delicious but the crust is mediocre ( albeit better than the cardboard box dough of Dominos thin crust). The salad bar is a plus & you can play Minecraft on Nintendo video games inside parlor. read more

Alfy's has THE BEST blue cheese dressing hands down !! The pizza is really good but honestly it's just a vessel so I can get as much blue cheese down my throat as possible in one sitting. Fucking amazing. read more

Giving a 1 star for monroe Alfys. The pizza though ok all the topping is in the middle of the pizza. And we did not get extra cheese we asked for. Salad bar could use better lettuce. And they should have togo boxes for salads. Hell they can even put my left over salad in the box for me as I leave. But to be made to throw away my salad that I paid good money for is ridiculous, and they would not even give me a small pizza box to put it in is ridiculous. I do not know any more. So I will go to the other pizza places. Done with Alfys. This not the first. But its the last. Maybe Alfys in snohomish is better? read more

Not bad not good. If you're looking for a quick meal this is the place. I will say that one thing I truly enjoy is the consistency in the pizza. I say this a lot in food reviews, but knowing I'll get the same taste and experience each time is very important to me. Could use a good clean inside but overall good food. read more

Alfy's wins with crust. Their crust is easily the best around. Easy ordering online and delicious pizza. See the photo. It tastes as good as it looks. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

OMFG I GOT FOOD poisoning the pizza sucks so much the cheese is not covering most of the pizza this place is trash

Really good pizza. It came hot. The cheese is delicious and the crust, I think, is the best crust I've had. Clean restaurant. Very nice place read more

Called in today for a Family sized Meat Eaters Wallop. It was without a doubt the worst pizza I have ever tried to eat. $30.00 and there was nothing on it. There was not any meat on it other than a light sprinkle of sausage and maybe a half dozen paper thin slices of pepperoni. And the cheese was so thinly sprinkled on it it did not even cover the crust. It had thick half cooked crust with very little red sauce. I have been eating Alfy's Pizza for years and and I have never had one like this. We tried a few slices and threw it out. I will never be back. read more

Haven't been here for a while. Ordered a family size and it's been reduced to what was a large a size and they charged me an 8% fee foR getting the original crust. I wasn't asked if I wanted that crust they just added it and the fee, no warning. read more

this location has been good for us. Lunch on Friday has half off. We meet friends for lunch and I can't beat the price!!! Kids love the games to play on. Pizza has been great each time. Servers up front are super friendly. We keep coming back b/c it's such a great price, but the food has been good as well. read more

It's Alfy's! This local chain has been an awesome place for family pizza night since i was a kid. Pizza, video arcade, beer! They have the best pizza sauce too. read more

I was in on January 25th to order a takeout pizza. I had a coupon I was using and the price just was not adding up to what the actual cost should have been. I was trying talk with the lady at the register and she wasn't understanding what I was worried about. She began to get very rude and upset and asked why I was arguing with her. I had just gotten off work and was in my work uniform being very friendly even with the attitude I was receiving. I decided to just pay what the charge was and I would take it up with the manager later. Fast forward a couple weeks I finally got a hold of the manager and explained the situation. She said she would look into it and get back to me the next day. 5 days went on with no call back. I decided to call again and spoke with the manager she said that she was still looking into it and would call me back in a couple days. It has been almost a month now with no follow up. I would not recommend this establishment. Take your money elsewhere. It's sad because I do like Alfys and rarely get it anymore as I don't live near one but was passing through and thought it sounded good. I grew up going to Alfys in Snohomish and getting it for lunch in high school when they had it delivered. But this experience left a bad taste and probably won't return. read more

We are usually very happy with alfys they are quick and efficient as well as yummy. Today we ordered a cookie with ice cream and when we opened the cookie it looked like something someone had broken up and spit back out very disappointed and the calzone we ordered was burnt the pizza and breadsticks were awesome and the delivery was quick but now they are closed and we are stuck with what we have! Be sure you check your ordered when you get a delivery we were not smart enough as usually everything is really good. Of course we will order again this is to remind people to check delivery orders as anything can happen! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

Super SLOW geez we ordered 2 cheese pizzas and they told us 25mins so we waited 15 and went to go pick it up and the ended up waiting another 25 minutes once we got there! Piss poor time judgment! Come on read more

The girl working on 2/25 at 8pm was soooooo rude! Restaurant is open until 9 but she was taking down salad bar at 8. When I asked her why she said because we decided to take it down. There was still a lot of stuff out and I asked if I could just get one plate. "Nope." That was her response. We walked right out. read more

Three strikes you're out. Strike one a few weeks ago: online ordering wasn't working. Strike two a couple weeks ago: online ordering worked until it failed at the order placement process. So I called to place a delivery order and after being on hold for six minutes gave up. Strike three tonight: online ordering worked! Delivery person was very friendly. However...food sucked. The pizza looked and felt like it had spent a bunch of time at room temperature. Almost all of it is in my garbage can now. Sorry Alfy's....I'm done. read more

I used to buy pizza from here every Friday when they were in Puyallup. I moved out of state but never forgot the delicious hand rolled crust. Came back twice for work and both times I got the royal Alfy's. It did NOT disappoint! The crust was form on the outside and soft on the inside. Toppings were perfect, cheese, sauce...ALL AMAZING! read more

UPDATED 8/8/08 It seems this Alfy's has gone a bit down hill. The salad bar isn't as good as it used to be, with the most basic of staples and always seems to have run out of something and replaced with whatever they have lying around. Pizza also seems not to be good as it used to be (can't place my finger why). read more

Went in just before 8pm on a Sunday. We weren't greeted until we spoke up. Placed my order for all you can eat salad bar and was told to go look at it becausethey were letting it runout and would not be refilling anything, also there was no regular ranch. It looked very low but I was in the mood for salad so I got it anyways. The lettuce was horrible, obviously well picked over since mostly really large pieces were left and bottom of the bag remnants. I picked thru and found enough to sort of make a salad although I would need a knife to cure the large pieces. I just didn't understand why they wouldn't refill anything more than an hour before closing. There were 3 people there already plus 3 more that came in after us for salad. If they are going to do that it should at least be discounted. The worker then shut the salad bar down completely at 8:20. We were then also told that we could only sit in one section, as the rest were closed. Half the TV'S were already turned off too. A family came in after us and the kids couldn't utilize the game stations. The service was horrible and it made us feel like an inconvenience. I won't be back. read more

This was my family's first time here and I Definitely won't be coming back. The service was okay. No one was at the register when we first walked in. Then they were on the phone while we stood there waiting to order. The employees are friendly and the prices are fair. They do not take American Express. They had lot if mini TVs with video games to play while waiting for your food. We were eating there and the pizza came out fairly quickly. Which was great because we were really hungry. However after the first bite I knew I would never come back. It tasted like pizza that's comes from the grocery store freezer. So gross!! read more

Alfy's Pizza - X large pepperoni, Sausage, mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

Can u give a minus star...wish i could. Simply the worst pizza ever!!!! I would not go back if i was paid. The pizza was tough, the sauce was disgusting, and it was luvk warm. Really people ??? read more

I thought the people we dealt with were very friendly - the pizza wasn't amazing, but it was good. The salad bar, again, not amazing, but pretty good. And we fed 6 adults and 5 kids with drinks and salads and 2 X-Large pizzas for $35. Um, seriously, $35. Again, not life changing quality of food, but the ambiance was great for a group, the people were friendly, the kids loved the free Xbox and N64 games, and it really deserves 5 stars on the value-meter (but Yelp isn't strictly value-meter, so it gets 4). Anyway - if you happen to be in Monroe and need to feed a small crowd, it's about as good an option as you've got. read more

Easily the best pizza on the Eastside.....Its always fresh, warm and checked and doubled checked for accuracy. They offer any of thier pizzas for take and bake at half price, have a buy one get one free special every Monday and Tuesday and have 5 gaming consoles set up in thier restaurant. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, Washington

See all

Scratch this one off my list... I decided to start checking out the pizza options in the area, including this one, found off Yelp (shameless plug). Got a small two topping pizza and it was only $7. That was the good part. I don't want to finish the 2/3 of it I didn't eat, for starters. I would accept $7 to do it, honestly. Place just feels kind of like a Pizza Hut about to go bankrupt. The pizza looked unappetizing and lacked any kind of real flavor. In short, I'm sure I've had better pizza at chuck e. cheese's. It has some small town charm, I'll give it that. But that might be another reason I don't desire to live in a small town. read more