Yes! the food is great but, the last 3 times I've been there the order was wrong and 1 of those times I had a 10" hair on my hamburger. So, yes the food is very good but...... read more

Best sandwiches and fries I have ever had anywhere. I also always get their homemade sweet cherry tea! They have so many options here, everyone can find something they like. Everything always tastes very fresh. Me and my father drive almost an hour every other weekend to come to this place and eat lunch. It's worth it. I can't find one thing to complain about. If you're in the area, stop by. You won't regret it. read more

I went and had lunch there with family that recommended it. They were a bit short handed but were very apologetic so that was forgivable. They were definitely hustling behind the counter to keep up. I split the whole Al Capone and an order of fries with my sis and we were not disappointed. I loved how the meat and cheese was grilled and the bread was toasted, warm and so good! Some jalapeños might of been a tasty addition. My bro-in-law had a bowl of vegetable soup and said it was really good. While I was just visiting from AZ i'll definitely go back next time I'm in town! Thanks guys!! read more

We have been there a few times and I have personally have had the Al Capone, Cheesy Italian Beef, Philly Cheesy Steak and the BLT. Highly recommend all of them! read more

I ordered sandwiches and a salad from a.s.s. for a forestry workshop. I heard rave reviews from everyone in attendance. People have come to expect crappy subs from subway and Jimmy John's at work meetings. They were blown away by real chunks of steak, caramelized onions, brie, homemade pickles, and other details that made these assorted subs brilliant. I will go out of my way for more of these subs. read more

Yum! This is one of our favorite places, the staff is so good to kids and families!

These sandwiches are seriously delicious. The Al Capone is a favorite - definitely worth all the fat and calories in this Italian meats! I get something different every time and I've never been anything but satisfied. read more

A favorite of mine for several years. Still haven't explored the whole menu. I crave the Capone regularly, and go for the specials while they're available. I've never been disappointed with a sandwich. read more

Not sure what I am missing, but I am not overly impressed with this place. It is definitely dumpy looking. That could be overlooked if the food were amazing. Sandwiches and salads are ok, but often give me a stomach ache. Not sure why? Soups are often creamy and rich. Would like to see some lighter varieties. All in all I would prefer a sandwich from Subway. read more

Yankee Doodle was delic! The fries are thin, crispy, and have an awesome seasoning on them!

Mmm! This place is delicious. If you're in the area you should definitely stop in. I always get the California :). Ask for them to put extra seasoning on your fries. :) read more

I can't believe I didn't right a review already for my absolute favorite sub shop. The bread is always fantastic and all the meats are delicious. Used to go with the Al Capone now I'm all about the capicola but I've never had anything bad. It's so good. read more

My husband and I have passed this place numerous times and have always seen a lot of cars and commented that we needed to try it...OMG!!! So glad we finally did!!! Amazing subs! Seriously the best around. We had the Capone and it was absolutely delicious. The meat is fresh and sliced a bit on the thicker side so you really taste all of the layers. The sub was warm and toasty with fresh bread and fresh vegetables. We also had the fries, which were crispy and delicious! We can't wait to go back to try more of the subs on the list! The quality of the ingredients makes the subs truly special. read more

Our kids beg to come here on the weekends. Sandwiches are so good and big that we often split them. Menu is selection is great. Only negative is the staff isn't the most friendly or welcoming. read more

Great sandwiches are worth the wait! ASS has great subs, soups, cakes, and fries, but you will not obtain this wonderful food over a 30 minute lunch break unless you call ahead. We love sub shop, and wish they had longer hours. This is actually worth a little drive, too - our friends from the near north suburbs always wanted to eat here when visiting Algonquin! read more

This place is really good. It's definitely a hole in the wall but one of my favorites. The Al Capone is their signature sandwich and is what I usually get, I've tried a few other things on the menu and have never been disappointed. The food is 5 star quality, my only reason for giving it 4 stars instead is that it's a little bit on the expensive side and I think that the sandwiches have gotten a little bit smaller. If you haven't been here, it's definitely worth trying. read more

The #23 is awesome! Love this place, a little pricey but I'd rather eat here once a week than eat garbage 5x a week!

What can I say that has not been said before? Delicious, hearty, original, and creative subs. Maybe a tiny bit pricey, but you get for what you pay for. FANTASTIC! read more

Stumbled across this place today on a lunch-time drive. What a great find. Excellent food, help wanted sign in the window (which is needed) and a new favorite of mine. Been looking for a good sandwich place and finally found one. read more

Hands down the best kept secret for subs in the burbs!! I have been a loyal customer of the Sub Shop ever since I can remember. I have ordered the Yankee Doodle almost exclusively for the past 20 years. While I have tried a few others, the irony is I would never order a ham sandwich from any other sub place....I don't really like ham. There is something about the honey mustard that keeps me coming back! They have the delightful plastic cheese for their cheese fries, just what I want out of cheese fries. The fries have a seasoning mix on them and oooft, they are quite moreish. As an added bonus, they now serve my favourite brand Great Lakes potato chips, made in the lovely city of Traverse City! Eat here. You won't be sorry. read more

Great subs. My favorite is the greek sub, HUGE. Great cheese fries.

The only good place to get a sandwich in the area. Cool place. Thank goodness in a sea of bland this place does not fall into that trap

Friendly staff, mom and pop shop, delicious!

BEST subs around! I love A.S.S. because they are unique and not a chain. We've been catering subs for our family parties for 19 years and always get compliments on the awesome taste and quality. Yes they are pricey, but well worth it. They are very accommodating and have opened early to allow me to pick up trays for my WI clients who appreciate how great the food is. My favorite is the Al Capone, but I've never had a bad sub here. Kudos A.S.S.! read more

oh my! Discovered this little gem with HUGE taste this w/e. Visited with 2 family member 2 times, so we enjoyed 6 different subs between us over the w/e. ALL were FABULOUS!! This subshop is extraordinary. The staff were so kind and professional and delightful. Trying to find an excuse to drive over NEXT w/e!! read more

What wasn't wrong?? My Philly steak tasted like extra virgin olive oil. Made with rough Italian beef--not even the right kind of meat. All of the veggies were on one side of the sandwich in a clump. Fries were not fully cooked and extra salty. Cheese for fries was cold. Idk how this place won awards!? read more

Best subs around. Very fresh and flavorful and not the same old JJ's or Subways. Everything I've tried here has been excellent. Their fries are also right up there with McDonalds and that's a compliment. Don't miss on your next trip on IL31 read more

I have never been here and wanted to try due to the high reviews. My husband ordered bbq grilled chicken sandwich and I opted for the chicken Florentine converted into a salad. Both chicken items were so dry you could not chew them . I had asked to omit mushrooms and they were placed on the side. I asked for my chicken to be placed on a bed of lettuce and I got this huge mound of spinach. The dressing given doesn't go with a spinach salad. The guy behind the counter looked mad like we were inconvencing him. Way overpriced for what you get. I hope I don't get sick. Also , I guess sides are seperate. Was not asked if we wanted fries or chips with the sandwich. Won't be going back there. I thought it was a family run business. read more

The subs are exceptional. There are a large amount of fillings in them and everything is very fresh. I found myself full after the first half of the Italian sub and had a readymade delicious mid-day stack to take with me. So much better than the conveyer belt stamped sandwiches at a chain sub shops. read more

Ordered catering for a bridal shower for 30 ladies and the sandwiches and salads were absolutely delicious. Very nicely served on trays all wrapped and ready to go. Picked up in the morning and everything was ready on time. Worth every penny and in my opinion a great value considering the size of the sandwiches and salads. More then ample portions. I will do it again for a party or event. Thanks Algonquin Sub Shop. read more

Best place to get a sub. A huge step up from bigger chain sub shops. Ingredients are always fresh. I have tried all their subs and honestly there is not one I didn't like. Not only are their subs amazing but their soups are tasty too. My favorite is the new England clam chowder, wow! After eating here, eating a sub anywhere else does not compare. Glad we found this place! read more

These subs are great! Awesome, homemade taste with fresh ingredients! The Yankee Doodle is the best...and get extra honey mustard!

This place is by far the home of my favorite sandwich (a submarine.) I have never had a bad sandwich, my favorite by far is the Monterey Chicken, be sure to get a side of french fries as the seasoning is a perfect compliment to the sub. Each time I drive by I must stop to grab a sub (even if I have just eaten) they are that good! read more

Can't say enough good stuff about this place! My personal favorite is the Al Copone, but I've had others and they're all good! Not your average sub, with lettuce, tomato, blah blah blah...they go out of their way to make the subs delicious. Calling ahead might be a good idea if you're short on time. Place is pretty popular! Highly recommended! read more

We were a little cautious to try this based on the exterior appearance. But with all the awards & word of mouth, we figured "why not". Glad we did!! Great subs, and very friendly staff. We will be back! read more

Its nice to see an independant sub shop like this. There are not to many in this area. Good food.

I'm so glad this place hasn't been on Diner's Drive-Ins and Dives because it's still my little secret. Ok, lots of people know about it but you don't have to wait in a line around the building! This is a family owned business with flat out good food! It may take an extra dollar and a few extra minutes to make your sub but it's well worth it for the quality product you get! My favorite is the Californian sub. They have a surprisingly large menu for a place that is so small so everyone is sure to find something. read more

if u love sandwiches u NEED to have the Al Capone!

I ordered the california sandwich. It was a chicken sandwich with cheddar, honey mustard, lettuce, tomato, etc. I dont know if they messed up or something because the sandwich was waaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyy too sweet. I dont know why the other reviews were saying the sandwiches are huge because the sandwich i had was kinda small. maybe around 8 inches at most. I liked the bread though and it was obviously fresh baked in house. I will defintely give this place another try because the other reviews suggested that their other sandwiches are terrific. definitely loved the bread so maybe their other choices are really good. Not the california though. read more

Sandwiches are very good. Fries are also very tasty. However it is very expensive for a sandwich. You will spend more than you expect on a sandwich. Also the wait for the food tends to be very long. You can call it in and it wont be ready twenty minutes later. Also, they don't want to fix their errors. One time when we got carryout they did not want to fix their mistake. The parking situation is less than ideal. read more