JULY 2026 Penguin was here…read more Got 2 Pizzas. 1 Sweet Honey Garlic 1 white with cheese Brocoli and tomatoes. BOTH DELICIOUS! 2 Drinks

Hidden jem in the Village of Lewiston...speciality slices of pizza for under $5. Fast friendly…read moreservice, appreciated the variety still left at 7 at night Cute sitting area inside and picnic tables outside when it's not rainy. Would stop again , for something else besides pizza, perhaps a calzone if hungry.

Brought my wife to Niagara Falls, had a problem with our rental car and the guy at the rental…read morecompany said "I'm pretty picky about my Pizza" - I knew that he knew. So to Broadway Pizza for lunch. He said the Dill pizza is becoming a thing around here and they have a good one. Walked into a true Pizza place. Line of locals waiting to order. The lady and her husband were taking the orders each local she hit with small talk. Great variety of pizza cheese, white, mushroom & pepperoni, Dill and half a dozen others. You could pick your own topping of you wanted but with this selection come on ... Tables and wooden chairs your typical pizzeria- you are not here for the furniture. Excellent place. Oh and they were making Stromboli's as well - maybe next time.

This place may not look like much but the pizza is terrific. Lots of options by the slice,…read moreincluding a pickle and ranch slice that was awesome, as well as full pies, rolls and calzones. The owner is super friendly, too

Been in & out of Town recently, but decided to try this long time little Italy sensation…read more.. I wasn't disappointed and am so glad they have the same recipe and everything... Everything was super good as ALWAYS... Am told they will be opening a full bar shortly !?! im in ! ... I suggest them to everyone to try to stop by & Support your local businesses

While visiting Niagara Falls, I was craving an authentic New York-style pizza experience. Yelp led…read moreme to Goodfellas Pizzeria, and it did not disappoint. The pizza lived up to the hype. The crust was crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted. For a medium pizza, it was huge, probably like 16 inch. But what truly surprised me were the wings. They were massive! I've never seen wings that big before. Where do your chickens come from with wings that large?!?! And they were just as delicious as they were impressive. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, with a perfect balance of sauce and spice. On top of that, super meaty! Like some reviewers have mentioned this place is in a sketch looking part of town. It's not a super busy to high traffic place. We were the only diners here, but plenty to pick-up orders. If you're in Niagara Falls (the US side) and craving a taste of New York, I highly recommend checking out Goodfellas Pizzeria.

Joseph Martelli Niagara Falls, NY Review of Buzzy's pizza-Their food is really good and they make…read morethe best old fashioned pizza by far from any other pizza place. If you like that type of pizza you have got to try it

Craving local, Buzzy's was recommended by our hotel. Did not disappoint! Soup - good. Pizza - good…read more Calzone - good. Diet Coke - good. The lovely lady who served us was very helpful. She recommended the wings and/or pizza without hesitation! She was very attentive and made sure the soda glass was never empty. We sat outside and totally enjoyed the great weather and the amount of people coming in to pick up their takeout orders! Place was great!

Picked up their 1/2 tray pepperoni and 20 Wings half mild/half hot for $27.50 (tax in). It's a very…read moresmall place with only a couple of small tables inside. It looks pretty uninviting, but the guy at the counter was friendly and served me with a smile. It took them 25 minutes to cook it up. The pizza is pretty good, the crust a little plain but with lots of small size pepperoni it made it nice and spicy. The hot wings were good and crispy, covered with a good amount of Frank's hot sauce. The mild wings weren't as tasty, with only a tiny bit of butter and Frank's. This place is cash only.

GIANT BURRITOS…read more Let me start out by saying my father has been long time friends with the owner, but this review would be five stars regardless. Locally owned hidden treasure is what I'd call Piro's. Tucked away on Buffalo Avenue right off the LaSalle Expressway, if you blink you'd might just miss it. The menu is nothing fancy, it has your basics; Pizza, Wings, Subs, ect.. I always come for their Giant Burritos, stuffed with Chicken or Steak, or opt for the Stinger, which has both. You won't go hungry when you order one of these hunkers. This past time I ordered their Poppers that come (6) six to an order. Had a good kick to them, cheddar cheese oozing out as you bite. The breading was light and it hit the right spot. I've also tried their Pizza Logs, you can't go wrong. Left over Pizza from Piro's is the best.

Mike & staff were very accommodating / Prices were fair & The products were of the highest quality…read more I highly recommend this FINE LOCAL PIZZERIA for anyone in Niagara Falls NY (716) 215-6465 ... Ask for a "Test Slice" ... You won't be disappointed!

Great people, great pizza, great price. What more could you want? The $5 lunch special was perfect…read moreafter a stroll around Niagara.

We absolutely loved Mario's while staying in Niagara Falls. We dined here twice while on our trip…read more(usually against our rules unless it leaves a lasting impression on us!) Mario's is a cute little spot you may dine in or carry out, located on one of the main drags in Niagara. The delicious slices were served up quickly with a smile, both times. ;) I love the cheese, but the authentic pepperoni had me wanting that meat! You must try Mario's, it's amazing!

Big slices of NY style pizza. Fast pies. Excellent ambience and service. Best pizza experience in…read morethis tourist zone. Walk up and enjoy.

Our friends invited us to have dinner with them here tonight. We started out with Chef salads. They…read morestill make the best salad. Their Italian dressing is the best I've ever had . Still one of my top three pizzas in the area. The cup and char pepperoni has great flavor and is made special for them in Wisconsin. The thin NY style crust,the sauce and cheese are spot on. Nothing has changed inside for over twenty years.. clean but could use some updating. Service was great.

Intense old NY style, dim lights and lovely service, great food comes out insanely fast…read more I was offered a nice booth, bread and butter as an appetizer, water in a pitcher. Ordered calamari and pizza. Food came so fast and had a special place to rest which was great presentation. The pizza was real saucy due to my request of extra sauce. I dont recommend extra sauce because the crust is thin style. The pizza tasted great but it was hard to hold because of my choice. Good prices. Im happy. I was not a fan of the mushrooms being big and still juicy.