I loved the pizza here. It was fresh and tasty! The dough was incredible! We also had the regular…read moreStromboli. I was looking for a meat lovers boli which I didn't see. I'm sure I could have added what I was looking for and they would have made it, but in a haste to order i just went with regular. The boli was fairly well stuffed and also delicious. There are only booths, no tables so being 8.5 months pregnant it wasn't the most comfortable seating arrangement, but typical for a pizza place so no biggie. The staff was so kind, attentive and personable. Lovely place all around!

Got pizza last night w/ crab soup. My wife compared prices and thought it was best price in the…read morearea, but more importantlythe best she had tasted. I would say there is no grocery store in this area which can provide the quantity and exquisite tast of the crab soup for the price! My wife said crab soup doesn't go w. pizza so I had the whole pint container, so she lost out on the best crab soup I have ever had and I am from MD! Ravens or not, supbowl, I will be back for the crab soup!

First time here as I met a local For lunch. Clean , friendly…read morewaitress , nice menu , and good food .

Nice little Italian joint nestled in the rolling hills of York County…read more We decided to order three pies. One 16-inch pep, one 16-inch bbq chicken and a sicilian pie with sausage. I called the order in and was told 20 minutes. Turned out closer to 30. The sicilian met expectations. Nice thick crust and a healthy amount of sausage (sliced, nit crumbled). The bbq chicken was a bit on the sweet side. There is no sauce under the cheese, just drizzled on top. I can't speak for the pep. I'd order from here again!

Takeout order. Very friendly voice, double checked my order. Quick service, 10 minutes for two…read moresamies and french fries. Not so good food. The chicken did not taste fresh, it kind of didn't taste like chicken. Very salty and not chopped chicken, but not cubed either. It's as if the cook was lazy and did a half assed job. The french fries were limp, soft and store bought. Aside from the shredded lettuce I don't think one ingredient was fresh. Be prepared to drink a ton of water afterward. Due to the amount of salt, you'll be thirsty and parched for hours.

The food here is amazing! And the price is great as well! Very friendly staff! Love getting my…read morelunch here

We are in the area for the Appalachian Trail. Found Fat Boys Pizza and Tacos. Easy online ordering,…read moreon time delivery service and great tasting pizza!!

Great homemade rolls. Subs were great. Meat was a little on the low side but still good…read more Will try the pizza next time in town.

I got an Italian sub. The bread was very good. The vegetables were very fresh and we enjoyed it.read more

Umm. Pizza burnt. Black on the bottom This is a continuous…read moreissue. Something is messed up. $17 for a small 2 topping pizza and it was burned. Called shop. No response or initiative to correct. You don't burn and item and not know it. They knew and sold it anyway.

"Wings" special @$11.99. $1.00 per each of these round and breaded, most likely dumped from a bag…read more"wings." Barely enough sauce for 5... Had to purchase a bottle of water and no side came with it. I should have asked more questions before ordering... The chicken subs ordered by my friends didn't have enough to fill the rolls. The orders came in 2 separate deliveries so that the shrimp and fries had to be changed for takeout but still didn't arrive in time. You can decide... we already did.

Service. Ordered $70+ of food that was given away to another person. Was told nothing then can do…read moreand we will have to sit and wait. Shitty customer service for mediocre food. Make it right because of your own dumbass mistakes.

Looking for a good classic slice of pizza or something unique like stuffed pizza - you have to stop…read morehere. From salads to submarines pizza and more this place knows how to make great food.

This place was amazing. The cashier went out of her way to describe the options since I had never…read morebeen there and was avoiding meat (due to Lent). So I purchased cheese fries and a slice of their specialty pizza. The cook delivered the food and it was phenomenal. Great small atmosphere tucked away in the middle of town. If you're in the area be sure to check it out, you won't regret it

great BBQ pie awesome atmosphere. quick service. if I lived around here I'd be back for more. enjoy!read more

The quality of food and service here hasn't gone downhill, it has swan-dived off a cliff into a…read moreflaming dumpster. Subs are inedible because the soggy buns fall apart due to how overdressed they are. They look full but it's mostly garnish and not nearly enough meat. You're basically eating a soggy salad in a bun. I can't tell you how many times we ordered food and the side was wrong or missing. You can get frozen pizzas better than what they put out. I don't trust their salads any more due to finding bugs in them which is proof that they don't wash anything first. Staff are loud and EXTREMELY RUDE. If I were starving on an island and someone offered me food from Brothers Pizzeria, I'd eat a mouthful of sand instead.

Top shelf pizza and wonderfully friendly proprietor and staff. Fantastic authentic pizza, perfectly…read moreseasoned and inventive varieties. Best pizza in Gettysburg to be sure, and a competitor that would hold its own anywhere.

Food was delicious- we ordered "to go" and the staff were very personable and friendly!! We ordered…read moremozzarella sticks, white pizza, and cheese pizza. Ingredients super fresh on the white pizza. Loved the crust. Can't wait to go back and try more items!!! A Must Stop when you are in Gettysburg!