Went this past Saturday night (March 2, 2024) with another couple and felt compelled to update my recommendation. This was our fourth time back and it did not measure up to our expectations. It was a little crowded outside and so we were seated inside at a table. The service was just okay and I think that had to do with not having enough staff. At one point, my wife ordered a second drink and didn't receive it until we were ready for the check much later. The bartender was kind and did her best but should not have been put in the position of having to fill drink orders for the entire restaurant and take care of the bar as well as the inside tables. That all said, I can forgive less than stellar service when the meal is amazing. I wouldn't have even written this if it was just an isolated thing. However, that was simply not the case. We ordered three burgers and a pasta carbonara with chicken. The burgers were mostly tasteless and bland except for the parts that were burned. The buns were also burned. If that's the best you can do with a burger, you probably shouldn't be in the business of making burgers. The pasta carbonara was on a whole other level of disappointment. First, it tasted metallic. It was inedible. Second, the chicken came late, was also flavorless, and dry to the point of being inedible. Thankfully, the bartender comped the chicken off the bill. I think she also comped a percentage off the food, which was nice of her to do, but doesn't make up for how bad it all was. I'm not sure if I'll be back to see if things improve. read more

Alligator Reef Club - Burned burger bun - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

I was in town visiting some friends and we decided to have brunch here. There was plenty street parking. When we arrive, I was mesmerized by the decor, making me feel like I was somewhere on the water and the keys. Service was fast and the attentive. Food was delicious and love their bottomless mimosa. read more

See all

I've been to ARC multiple times but my last visit wasn't very good. My group showed up after Happy Hour and the place was dead - maybe it's just not busy Thursday nights? There was only one waitress in the restaurant. We sat ourselves outside and we waited a bit for the waitress since no one knew we were sitting out there. Service was meh but I was happy with the food and the fire pit :) read more

This was my first time coming here, but it definitely will not be my last. Brunch was AMAZING!!! The flavors were all on point. Staff was friendly and service was fast. The place was very clean and nicely decorated. The meals were all unique with their own spin on some classics. I had the Superfood power bowl, which I was not expecting to come out with alot of Kale and looking like a salad. But I took the first bite and I was hooked! It was delicious! It felt like a very healthy breakfast and I really enjoyed it alot. Then I took a taste of my friend's Cajun Shrimp with Crispy Polenta cakes and promptly decided I would be coming back for that the next morning for Sunday brunch. Definitely do yourself a favor and ask for a side of the candied bacon as well! read more

See all

There's a smell that just doesn't sit right. Bleach? Toilet cleaner? Burns the nostrils

Let's talk about this little gem. Are you looking for a quaint spot to take a date, or maybe a girls night out? Look no further. This place, although small packs the perfect punch for romance or for a nice night out for a few drinks. The food is delicious and the display was just as amazing as you can see in the picture! If you are in town and you have the opportunity to stop by, do it. This one may not be for the kids though, due to the limited room and unique menu let's keep this one reserved for the adults, trust me you won't regret it. read more

Alligator Reef Club - Alligator Reef - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Good vibes & live music. Love that if u miss happy hr 4-6, it's again 9-11. Majority of their cocktails are on happy hr. There are also a few bites. I didn't enjoy the mahi tacos but the shrimp ones are tasty. My friend really enjoyed her poke bowl. Pretty decent portions. The Capri spritz & cherry good thyme are nice cocktails. The other few cocktails (watermelon one & both margs) were a bit too sweet for me. Service is friendly & attentive. Outdoor seating area is nice. read more

See all

It was the perfect day for an outdoor lunch in downtown Melbourne, and I finally got to check out Alligator Reef Club--a place I'd been meaning to visit for a while. As soon as I walked in, I knew I'd be coming back! The décor, both indoors and outdoors, creates such a welcoming and cozy vibe. The staff was incredible, with Sam going above and beyond to ensure everything was exactly how I liked it. I sampled a variety of dishes and already have a list of what to try next time--LOL! The combination of top-notch service, atmosphere, and mouthwatering food made for an amazing experience. Can't wait to return! read more

See all

Alligator Reef Club, 529 E. New Haven Ave., Melbourne, FL. 32901 2.5 Stars Located in the brightly refurbished one-time carbuncle at 529 E. New Haven Ave., Melbourne, FL. is where one will find a new entrant in the growing field of eateries aptly named Alligator Reef Club. The estiment may be new on the scene, but the owners are not. The owners, very well known to the Big Boy, are well-established veterans of the local restaurant scene. Darlene is our oniduro today and she did not leave us hanging long. Darlene possessed a charming demeanor and seemed genuinely delighted we walked in the door. Taking a seat at our table, I began to take in the complete remodel of this longtime Melbourne haunt. The place is bright, open and exudes an extremely welcoming atmosphere with a succinct ocean vibe. Well done! Keeping it simple today, I placed an order for their Tuna tacos and a Key West Sunrise Burger (because who doesn't want an egg on their burger?) Tuna tacos are one of those dishes I crave on a regular basis. As these were advertised to be served on the grilled flour tortillas with the traditional cabbage as well as their take on the sushi staple wakame (seaweed salad) and topped with a Balsamic ponzu sauce I was looking forward to the sample. The Key West Burger certainly read well on the menu comprising as it did of an Espresso rubbed blend of ground beef short rib, brisket, and chuck and including candied peppered bacon. That was about as far as I got on the description as the drool began to pool on my menu. Again, knowing the owners as I do, and looking at the fare offered, I was really looking forward to chowing down on this grub. Unfortunately, the line cook must not have cared about the quality of the protein he was slinging as my tacos smelled a bit like the infamous red tide dead fish. To say it was foul would be a gross understatement. My second even commented from across the table that they could smell it. I have to say it again. If your fish smells like fish, it's not good. I know for a fact that if either of the owners knew about this, the cook would have been unceremoniously tossed out on his tuckus (along with the tuna). While the Key West Sunrise Burger was not advertised as "smashed", it came that way. I still don't know why this is a thing. In my humble gastronomical opinion, it ruins a perfectly good burger. Fighting through for the purpose of this review, I found it to be edible, but nowhere near as succulent as the menu leads one to believe. The décor and Darlene saved this place for sure. While the food wasn't spectacular and cost over $60 while not being worth $10, the vibe is great, the drinks looked interesting and I know the entrepreneurs in charge will get this right, however, until further Big Boy notice, I say, "skip it." read more

See all

We came here specifically for the outdoor seating w/ live music and the drinks. Both of those were as expected. We enjoyed a seat on the patio overlooking the lawn and had the blackberry mule and the espresso martini. The mule was mine and was delicious enough to get 2! It was refreshing, cute, and not overly sweet. We ordered the bruschetta as an app. The bread was good but it was mostly just diced tomatoes. Nothing special. Then we each ordered the tacos.The tortillas were good. I was satisfied with the fair price so can't complain. This is a good spot to just come hangout and enjoy some good drinks and music. read more

Alligator Reef Club - BlackBerry mule - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

Another great alligator reef experience. Quick drop in for drinks and apps! First time sitting at the inside bar, because it was too hot outside. The inside bar is the cutest with a gear selection of liquors, wines and beers! read more

See all

Yummy food with a kick! Loved the Jerked chicken and Brussels sprouts friendly attentive staff Skylar Very cool vibe outside patio perfect Must try when downtown Melbourne Fl read more

Alligator Reef Club - Patio area with fire pit - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

Food is Delicious! Service is Great! You can eat outside or inside...both are great (depending on weather of course)...Enjoy!!!

This place was super good! Came here on a Sunday night. Walked in and they told us we can take a seat anywhere inside or outside. We chose to sit outside. Patio seating is awesome and they have heater stands around the patio in case it's cold. The food was amazing, I got the Jerk Chicken entree. Had perfect flavoring, the rice and chicken. Asparagus tasted kinda weird, but it was okay. My friend got the Alligator Death Rolls and said they were amazing. While we were sitting outside, I got a water and their cups are not glass so the wind easily blew over my water and it got everywhere. Haha. It shocked me but we laughed like "how did that happen.." Our server was also super kind and attentive. I would love to come here again. read more

We were in a party of four service was excellent, staff are quite friendly and attentative to your needs, the menu and drink are nice, there needs to be a more variety of Ses foods, especially local area fish, No fish and chips offered, in Florida a variety of seafood menu is a must. Outside set up is nice, we were out on a Sunday, a very gorgeous day. Prices should be a bit lower, a party of four with three well drinks ran me , $133.00, seems like Miami prices. Overall Very Nice. read more

See all

Such a fun little local spot. Had mimosas and brunch. Loved the ambiance. Food was terrific. read more

Alligator Reef Club - Sunday mimosas - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

Burger was delicious! I loved the vibe and ambiance of the place. Was definitely a good time for a Friday night! Breeze was a great waitress to us tonight. Very friendly and did a great job of explaining the different menu options. Definitely will be coming back again soon! read more

See all

Beautiful restaurant with major FL keys vibes!!! Beautiful outdoor seating with tons of shade. Excellent drink menu - I ordered the key west margarita and it was amazing . My lunch was the chicken sandwich which I seriously loved. The fries that's accompanied the dish were truffle fries . Legit cleaned my plate. Glad this restaurant is here !!! At night time on the weekends they have live music . They also have games to play outside as well -such as Jenga. Our server was excellent too- extremely friendly and great service. Excited to come back and try more food read more

Amazing Service & Delish Food Pretty outdoor patio when weather is nice wonderful drinks made with fresh juice

The food and the friendly staff was amazing the drinks were all smashing, can't recommend this places to people if your looking for a good vibe spot with friends and family! read more

Alligator Reef Club - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

I am so glad this place is here, the atmosphere and the service are incredible, I would give those 5 stars. There was also live music on a Saturday night which was great, acoustic guitar and a great singer which really added to the ambiance. The food is good but nothing mind-blowing. My one gripe are the cocktails. Basically a very large glass of juice with some alcohol- waaaay too sweet. If they fixed the drinks and seasoned the food a little more, it would be 10 out of 10. Still- highly recommend checking this place out! Just skip the cocktails and get beer or wine. read more

This new offering in Downtown Melbourne has lots to offer. Craft cocktails, unique Key West inspired eats and a great outdoor patio venue. We stopped by after seeing Godspell at The Henegar Center and we're delighted. We ordered Fish tacos- delicious white flaky fish seasoned with fresh slaw and lime juice - TASTY! I ordered a pineapple Caipirinha- a little sweet but still yummy, Alligator "DeathRoll" ( egg roll filled w gator and veggies) and fresh crisp Broccolini ( a fave of mine). Flavors were bright and clean and each well plated. It's a busy place so plan accordingly. read more

See all

We just love everything about this relaxing little oasis. The deviled eggs! The brunches! The drinks... everything we have tried is so yummy! It's a go-to spot for us . Give it a try. read more

Very nice outdoor courtyard with lots of space even for large groups. Good happy hour menu!

An amazing menu with an atmosphere that is even better! I could not recommend this place enough if you're visiting downtown Melbourne! read more

See all

Great vibes. This is our go to place for weekend brunches. The outdoor space is so fun and relaxing with live DJ on the weekends. read more

Alligator Reef Club - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

Nice charming spot. Converted home into a restaurant. We had lunch and ate outside. Pleasant experience. read more

Great food, drinks and service! Just an all around FUN atmosphere. We were there for brunch and they had outdoor seating with a DJ playing fun music. It was perfect weather today but they also have beautiful indoor dining. SUPPORT LOCAL BUSINESSES read more

See all

First off I want to say that the service and ambiance is incredible. While I was enjoying my food the head chef took his time to greet me and ask me how the food was tasting. My server Kalii was awesome she gave me great recommendations on which items to try out for my first visit. I ate the Alligator "Death Roll" for my appetizer and that was very delicious, the tiger aioli was a great sauce to dip my rolls in ! For my entree I ordered the Reef Burger and that was cooked to perfection, I really enjoyed the "key chi" that was atop of the burger it was delicious and gave the burger a great unique taste that I definitely want to enjoy again. Overall I was very impressed with the diversity that the menu offers and was even more impressed to find out that the head chef makes all his sauces and items from scratch.I hardly give places a 5 star but this place definitely deserves it . read more

Alligator Reef Club - Reef Burger - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

We drank at the bar. The resturant is light and bright and filled with friendly bar staff. The drinks were very creative and cool.

We've tried the conch fritters in most restaurants we go to... these by far are the best we've ever had.... My cocktail was so good we stayed for a second ... I really recommend!! read more

The food is good, burger is my fav. Chill ambience and attentive service. It's a shame living at the Highline only feeling safe to go before dusk. Brevard need to clean up this riffraff that does not belong here. read more

Super nice place to go and have a really nice dinner and relax with a couple of drinks. The staff is really nice and efficient.

Went here for lunch today for a girls day. It was raining so we sat inside, so cute. I ordered the chicken tacos, they were amazing. My friend ordered the grilled watermelon salad, also amazing. The drinks are the best around. The staff is so friendly and helpful if you can't decide on what to order. The entire experience is over the top! We will be going back! read more

Loved this place! Attentive service! Excellent steaks! Innovative drink menus. Live music. Definitely recommend. read more

Alligator Reef Club - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

We went last night and we really enjoyed the ambiance. Very cute place we sat outside. We had cocktail and dinner. My Martini was perfect and a great size. I had a fresh Ceasars salad with nice firm shrimp. Pur waitress Lily was attentive, and the food came out in a timely manner. read more

Service was good. Waited an hour for food. When it arrived it was almost cold. Portions were very small and prices were very high. They need to only serve drinks with maybe a limited number of tapas. Outside patio very attractive however no one was out there. read more

A really good meal Wait, staff was very nice and we were very happy to see that they accommodated wheelchairs . read more

Alligator Reef Club - We were so happy good food , good drinks & handicap, assessable indoors - Bars Near Me - Melbourne, Florida

See all

We've been here twice and will return. I love the ambiance -- feels like we're on vacation. Twinkly lights, great decor, relaxed vibe, good live music. The cocktails we've tried were all quite good. The food is reasonably priced and while I wouldn't say it's the best, the whole package more than makes up for it. Service both visits was good -- attentive and friendly. read more

Very good, music, atmosphere, food, drinks . Definitely recommend it overall. Prices good also.