Excellent pizza!! Reg pizza place bur we visited with family who apparently sit in on Fridays…read more They took bottles of wine and had a great night! The owner and staff are amazing and treat people like family! Pizza was great-we tried eggplant, vodka sauce and sausage, pineapple and bacon and regular. All great and the garlic knots were the best!

Excellent Pizza As a person who spends part of the week in Mattituck and part in Brooklyn This…read morepizza can hold its own in Brooklyn The best slice for miles around

My friends have been telling us how great this place and we just never got the chance to…read morego......how silly!! We finally went and can't wait to return!! The pizza was amazing and our main dishes were delicious too! ( eggplant parm ......not your average dish) The service was excellent too! We live 45 mins away but we will def be back!!

The first part of our dinner was one of the strangest experiences I've had in a restaurant…read more We sat down near a chalkboard with the day's specials and looked at the menu, which included another page of specials as well as a long list of pasta dishes and proteins. Our server came over and told us that two of the items on the chalkboard - including one we had planned to order - had been sold out already. This was at 6 pm on a weekend night. So we went back to looking at the menu. Within seconds, our server showed up again - the steak had been 86ed. We went back to looking at the menu. Our server returned to our table a couple of minutes later and told us how he liked to rank the restaurant's dishes, then telling us about his top three in minute detail. We were pretty sure what we wanted at this point. But our server came back one more time to tell us that the salad from the specials menu - again, a dish we planned to order - was gone. At this point I began to wonder if we would be allowed to pick our own food for the meal. Anyway, we settled on another dish and beckoned our server over for his fourth (and first invited) visit to our table. We ordered. The food came in a reasonable amount of time. The pasta and pizza were good, the salad dressed with something a bit too acidic. We ate, paid, and left, still somewhat in disbelief. Maybe if this place had fewer items on the menu, they'd be able to stock more ingredients for each one. As things stand, it's a rather frustrating venue (albeit one with a clearly devoted following). P.S. The noise level in the restaurant is high - we were practically shouting to hear each other at various points during our dinner.

had a very nice waiter. I ordered a blackberry margarita and it was delicious. Food came out at a…read moregood time and was also very delicious. Very nice of them to box the food also for leftovers. Highly recommend this place. very nice inside too!

This place is a model of disorganization, and I will surely never return.. It's not hard to handle…read moresix customers, in the span of 5 minutes but somehow these people find a way to make it is difficult as they can.

Had dinner here on Saturday…read more Ambiance is nice and lively and service is friendly. Food is just okay. The pizza was average and the crust undercooked, the pasta was also undercooked and needed seasoning. Prices are really high considering the quantity and quality. I doubt we will return.

Party of five and no one was disappointed with the food, service or accommodations…read more Seating available outside, inside and at the bar. Servers are friendly and accommodating. The food was fab. Try the Cioppino filled with clams, mussels, shrimp, bass, calamari, cherry tomato broth, spicy calabrian salsa, grilled house ciabatta.

This is our go-to delivery service after a day of wine tasting in the North Fork. Huge pies, easy…read moreand on time delivery, tons of topping choices. Yummy!

Nope... This is NY after all, your pizza hast to…read morebe-on-point. while the flavors were good, the crust was garbage. it was like biting into a slice of bread. Pizza crust should thin-ish and slightly crispy. not be like biting into a pastry or a slice of wet bread... and no, i did not get a sicilian. which is supposed to be thick-ish.

We've eaten here a few times and I felt the need to leave a glowing review. Every time the servers…read moreare attentive and friendly. The food is always on par. For appetizer we shared Frutta Di Mare appetizer. The fish salad was extremely fresh, light and tasty. Before our entrees, we received tasty house salads. For entrees we had the Flounder Oreganata and Veal Tuscano. The portions were perfect with even enough to take home leftovers.

7/20/25 We have been here many times since my last review,…read morebut I decided it was time to give them another review. I opted for the flounder franchise which was very fresh and flavorful served with a side of spaghetti and garlic and oil. Hubby opted for the cavatelli bolognese. We both enjoyed our dinner very much.

Amazing best pizza on the north fork…read more Best Diablo pizza in New York Best fungi pizza in New York Best arugula pizza in New York

Best oven brick pizza I've had and you must also try the Cesar salad, it was delicious! The…read moreservice by Nabelle was very personable and attentive. We felt very welcomed and felt like my husband and I were amongst family. He also provided some recommendations since we were in town for the 4th of July holiday.

Ample parking but it always seems to get packed. This is a very popular place. My girlfriend and…read moreI volunteer at the Custer Observatory across the street, and the parking lot is always full. We finally made it a point to come out early and find out what the buzz was about. First, the building is beautiful and the grounds look very well maintained. The staff is friendly and the bar was very well attended to, judging from the crowd around it. The menu has a nice selection of items, and we focused on some sandwiches, a salad, and an appetizer. I have to say, the marinated brisket burger was better than I expected. Nicely fatty and very flavorful. I ordered it with bacon, just because. My better half ordered the French dip, and she tried to finish it, but couldn't. Half was packed to go. All in all, it was a great dining experience and we'll make it a point to be back for sure.

When you get off the Orient Point Ferry, Sophie's Restaurant is the ideal spot for lunch or dinner…read more It's an old converted house with a dining room and a nice bar. It is worth stopping, go slow because you might just drive by it without realizing it. The food is excellent. We had the chicken sandwich and the clam strips. The staff is sweet and nice. Parking not an issue.