It was fabulous! We got 2 lobster dinners 2 lb each. It came everything! And it was delicious…read more All of the fish looked awesome. We will be back for sure.

The Hamptons are a challenging place to run a business. Seasonal, workers shortages etc . This…read morestore was run so well for a long , long time. Now it has lost its charm and sense of what good quality is. I don't know who bought it but it is no longer clean and delivering what a high quality fish store could. The service is below past standard and just the presentation is less appealing. Please up your game. I miss the old Stuart's.

Beautiful cuts of steak that are expensive! Friendly staff…read more Long lines and not worth dealing with Hamptons traffic in the summer on weekends. I would recommend going on a weekday

My wife had the SalmonPoke Bowl and got violently ill with food poisoning within minutes. I called…read morethem to let them know. They were cold as ice, not the least bit concerned or apologetic and basically couldn't care less.

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are…read morecheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers. His blarney is a hallmark, as are his prepared seafoods, including lobster salad, both a house made coleslaw and potato salad that is light and flavorful plus one of the finest tuna fish salads that's made with just the lightest touch of mayo. It's so good I freeze it for the winter months when Mike is closed. With a couple of hours notice, Mike will also custom prepare steamed lobsters, one of the best lobster rolls on the East End or shellfish platters that are to die for. This is definitely a place to come for seafood and english sports on the telly.

So I needed a 4lb salmon to make gravlax and The Seafood Shop was amazing. We picked out the lucky…read moresalmon, I examined it closely, it was fresh and organic and a good price. The young man who trimmed it gave me a piece exactly 4lbs and packaged it in a heavy duty disposable tray that I will be able to cook in and throw away. So, in summation: service treats you like a valued new friend; checkout staff are knowledgeable and helpful; store doesn't smell of seafood, truly a testament to the freshness of their products. It is a sham that they have removed the fresh vegetables from the store, but I understand. In addition, all customers were given a big slice of their homemade jalapeño cheese cornbread. Not to be missed. I'll be back.

Absolutely terrible customer service. They did not pick up the phone, hung up once we finally…read moreestablished contact, and failed to meet a delivery time by 3 hours.

Omg what isn't good here! This place looks small and the parking car be tight. The guacamole, tuna…read moreand chicken salad are amazing. Also got fresh mozzarella that's room temperature which makes it great to serve right away with their amazing produce. The chicken wontons were excellent with a spicy sauce. The dot cake and campfire cookies are amazing! This store is quality!

Overrated to say the least. I was so excited to stop by Round Swamp Farm with the number of…read moreinfluencers that fave about it. I tried the chicken salad and it was honestly pretty bland. My friend had the turkey sandwich and it was nothing special. Someone else had an Asian chicken salad which they said was pretty flavorful. We all split the chicken tenders and I will just say- not worth the price. The workers were great and I loved the vibes of the place. A lot of great options for prepared foods. Overall just did not live up to my expectations!

Cute and convenient market in the heart of the Hamptons! They have a very convenient market that…read morecaters to your food, groceries and household items. They have a natural juice stand inside where you can also get fresh matcha green tea, and other natural juices. The variety of foods is incredible and they carry lots of delicious baked goods, and other prepared foods. FYI, bathrooms are upstairs. It took me a few minutes to find the bathroom until I asked and had to go up the stairs. The bathroom is not very clean but it is what it is. Not what you would expect from the area (Easy Hampton). The service is ok they are working very hard so they treat you like they don't have time for your questions..I was a brand new customer and even asking where the restroom was made me feel a bit unwelcome maybe they only cater to the "regulars"!

I went there to get some fried chicken, I've had it before and it was very good. Only this time I…read moregot just one fried chicken thigh. Well it was $6.00,, SIX DOLLARS!! for one thigh! seriously!!! I purchased it but was not pleased. It was very good as usual but not worth six dollars. It's not that I can't afford it, but at these prices I won't be back soon. And I'm telling everyone I know about this. They should be ashamed! They'll go out of business at this rate, especially in the winter when there's not enough people here to support them.

I have driven by this place many times but did not realize they had a small restaurant because it…read moreis very small and tucked well back on the property. They proprietor Marie was superbly friendly - the place is quite quiet and secluded - there was one other customer while I was there. I ordered the Oysters and the Hot (Butter) Lobster Roll - the oysters were super fresh and delicious and the Lobster roll was all big chunks of lobster and the best I've had in New York! Absolutely perfect! This place is clearly all about the quality and freshness of the food - it's not the place you'd go for a date but it is certainly one of the best quiet eating spots here! I can't believe it took me 15 years to find it. Will certainly be back! Highly recommend A+

Not what you would expect, but what we should always look for and support when visiting this area…read more Authentic is an understatement. Oysters, steamers and Lobsters as fresh as can be and prepared at the moment, in front of your eyes.

Very busy even on a Monday. Go early or expect to wait, but if you are not in a rush, it is worth…read moreit. The service is very friendly and accommodating. The setting is casual and the food is excellent! Fresh and well made and with many menu options. A must stop in the east end!

Went to try a hot lobster roll and also sampled the calamari. The calamari was perfect - crispy,…read morenot too heavy of a batter, well salted, and piping hot. The tartar sauce and marinara paired well too. The lobster meat was chunked rather than shredded (which I prefer) and really piled on generously. It was disappointed that the meat was super dry and not tender. Kind of disappointing for a $36 lobster roll when you expect the chunks to melt in your mouth and be succulent. We did ask for a side of butter to dip the pieces in and it did improve it slightly. I needed to also salt the meat since it was cooked in unsalted butter. Bun was a tad too toasted but otherwise held up well and was both crispy and fluffy. Side of fries were well crisped and salted. Service was great - our waitress was attentive and quick to address our needs while managing a very busy bar. Food came out fast. Had no wait when opting to sit at the bar (2 people) though a table wait would have been about 15 minutes.

I bought a grilled chicken ceasar salad. The menu said shaved Parmesan . What I got was a pile of…read moreParmesan powder. Not the same . Also the chicken was cold and not freshly grilled. I understand having it pre-made for convenience, but they could have threw it on the grill and heated it up . Not sure if I'll go back

I first of all want to say, it takes a whole lot for me to write a negative review... and it pains…read moreme to have to say this, but this business is not what it used to be. I have been coming here for well over 5 years now, and I hate to admit that the service has been going down hill for quite some time.. the treatment I received this season is not as attentive, and the workers don't care about your experience there like they use to. I noticed the food quality and produce is the same- which is great; but the quality of the customer service has decreased tremendously. No one greets you when you go up to the back counter to order your take out food. I had to wait for the staff to be done talking with one another and laughing around while the staff poured the staff food. I had to address placing an order for myself - knowing I had been standing there for over 3 minutes with no one in-front of me on line, just waiting for the workers to finish their fun. It's fine to have a friendly work environment- but hi, hello- you are at work- and these are your customers. Loyal customers at that. 5 years coming here and I'm sad to say I won't be returning. I had asked for an iced coffee- which I order every morning I go there. And I asked for an iced latte for my partner. I remember there has been the same young girl making my latte.. and I get that you have to have milk in it/ but don't make the entire latte basically milk. And so this is over the third time ( 3RD TIME) we have gotten coffee from them and he hated his coffee, and complains about how milky it is. Me feeling horrible, I tell him to take it back to get and get an iced coffee instead of the latte- and so she tells him " you have to pay for it anyway since he ordered it" I looked at her and was so confused as to why she would tell us that we need to pay for something we asked for them to take back. Knowing the taste was too milky and not how a good latte should taste. It's the simple fact that the manager Deanna, she's been working there for years- she knows my face and I know her. This SAME exact situation happened last year where I came to her at the front register to ask her to make my latte over since it was incredibly milky. And she helped me just fine last year, I gave her back the entire latte - it's not like I drank more than two sips before handing it back to her. It's the simple fact that she tried to charge me for an item I returned back to them fully. And the fact that this has happened multiple times and I reminded her of it, and she still was saying that since I ordered it and they made it I have to pay for it... that is not how customer service works. I have worked in various fields of customer service my entire life & I am still dumbfounded by Deanna and this other young girl's words. All 3 of us were disappointed in something we had ordered. My other friend ordered a sandwich and a smoothie and he said his smoothie was not good, and way too watery. I've spent hundreds of dollars here over the years, easily- so for you to look at me and treat me with such disrespect is insulting and rude. I expected much more from a local family business that's been in my routine for years on end. All I asked for was an iced coffee instead of a latte and for the situation to be handled as it was is quite disappointing in terms of how this business is looking. I would consider the owner recommend a supervisor for matters like this because clearly there is a disconnect.

I know a guy who says the food here is great and the prices are just as great also so goread more

Amazing seafood. Everything is so fresh and great. It has an amazing vibe and it isn't like the…read moremodern day Hamptons, making it the best place. The service is great and the people are so nice.