Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    American Pie Pizzeria

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order American Pie Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

    American Pie Pizzeria Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - American Pie Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Italian 3,114 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Dopo Argento

    Dopo Argento

    3.6
    (46 reviews)
    2.0 mi

    Refined Dining with Just a Few Misses at Dopo Argento, Southampton…read more Patrizia and I visited Dopo Argento in Southampton for a Sunday afternoon meal around 1 pm. The restaurant wasn't crowded, which made for a calm and enjoyable atmosphere. Starters: We ordered the sourdough bread service (not complimentary), which came with a hummus dip. The bread had a rustic, brick-oven style crust--crispy outside, soft inside--and paired nicely with our appetizer. We then split the Tuna Tartare, which was delicious, fresh, and beautifully prepared. That said, it was served on its own with no chips or crostini, so we ended up using the bread we had ordered. A small touch that would make a big difference. Mains: Patrizia had the Salmon Oreganata. The portion was generous and cooked very well, but it arrived solo on the plate without any sides. We both felt it would shine more with a vegetable or starch--something like spinach, asparagus, or potato. I chose the Paccheri Cacio e Pepe, which was excellent. The pasta was fresh, perfectly al dente, and the sauce had just the right balance of richness and peppery bite. Drinks & Service: We started with two cocktails, then shared a crisp bottle of Italian sparkling water with our meal. Service was warm, efficient, and attentive, adding to the experience. Dessert & Coffee: We finished with the Tiramisu, which was light, fluffy, and not overly sweet, alongside a cappuccino--a perfect close. Overall: Our total came to about $235 for two, and we left a generous tip for the excellent service. We chose to sit indoors since it was too humid outside, but both options are available. We're giving 4 stars because of minor blemishes--the salmon plated all alone, and the tuna tartare lacking an accompaniment. Still, the food was excellent, the vibe relaxed, and the service top-notch. Definitely worth a visit--check it out before the summer ends and see for yourself!.

    Was the worst!!! Worst service. Waiters are extremely rude. Manager sets the tone poorly…read more We got diarrhea on our vacation because of these damn people. I would never eat here ever again! With all these amazing restaurants in the Hamptons... Don't waste your time at this dump

    Photos
    Dopo Argento
    Tiramisu
    Tiramisu
    Dopo Argento

    See all

    75 Main

    75 Main

    2.9
    (567 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$$
    Gluten-free friendly
    Vegetarian friendly

    We were in town for a wedding in Hauppauge & decided to spend an afternoon shopping in Southhampton…read more& visit this popular restaurant in downtown. The vibe was incredible just as I had pictured it in my mind. We were greeted very warmly the moment we walked in. The menu was extensive so it was hard to choose between the entrees as everything looked so delicious. I decided on the 75 Main Chopped Salad. My husband chose the Main Prime Burger with fries & my daughter chose the Fusolini Alla Vodka Telefono. Each of us were completely intoxicated with every bite!! 10/10 all the way around!!!! We were hoping to see a celebrity or two dining alongside us (as this is one of the restaurants known for that) but no luck there. Nevertheless, it was an amazing lunch we will always remember enjoying together. If you get a chance to dine here I highly recommend it! Booking a reservation will make it it seamless. The hostesses even complimented me on my outfit as we were leaving & that made me feel fantastic!! I saw many people dressed casual, but we chose to dress up in case we ended up dining beside others who were the same. Parking was very convenient with two hour limits. We hope to come back again someday as there are so many wonderful places to shop & dine in this area alone. One could easily spend a long weekend here.

    The staff went way way out of their way to be customer centric...came by often, timed food delivery…read morewell and was helpful to lower music when it was too loud. The place was a little dim but frankly lighter than most. Seats were comfy but I sat on a couch. The food was very good. Calamari was perfectly cooked and crispy but not crumbly or oily. The aioli was delicious. The crispy shrimp appetizer was cooked just as perfectly and the sauce was stupendous. The wings were not saucy but not dry and bit soggy ... were just perfect. I got the kale salad and it was one of the best ever. The portion was generous and the chop was neither too rough nor too fine. The ingredients proportions were just right. The dressing was very tasty. I'd definitely come back and recommend to others.

    Photos
    75 Main
    75 Main
    Along the main road of beauty Southhampton

    See all

    Along the main road of beauty Southhampton
    The Plaza Café

    The Plaza Café

    4.5
    (126 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$$

    When you walk in to the restaurant with a mask on and everyone looks at your like you're weird…read morebecause there was no longer a mandate. Oops lol It was a quiet Friday evening and Plaza Café is conveniently located near my friend's house there in South Hampton. Being off season, there has been very little traffic and people on the streets. There were only 3 other parties in the restaurant when we walked in. This place is cute, private, has great good food, and service. Their menu is very small, but I was still having trouble deciding what I wanted to eat for dinner. Finally decided on the Tile fish....Yeah I know, I was like. Was told that they're like human beings because they eat just about anything in the sea. No idea if that's true or not, but I'll take it. The dish was light and full of flavor. Tried some of my friend's Salmon/Udon dish and I actually think his was the better choice. The salmon went very well with the udon. Noodles were kind of firm and juices full of flavor. Plenty of parking in their private lot. Looks like they may share it with businesses/hotel in the area. I'd eat here again. The décor and feel was okay, nothing amazing or memorable.

    This is one of my favorite places to come to when I'm in Southampton another place that absolutely…read moreloves Zev's my dog My husband and I ordered out food as we waited for a food all the employees were just going crazy over Zev. We ordered out octopus that was grilled to perfection I believe it was my favorite dish of the night, Fish tacos and fresh oysters that absolutely melted in our mouth's oh my God I can't wait to eat them again. What I really like about the take out order was it was packed very neatly and smartly and to top it all off they labeled All the foods what professionalism thank you.

    Photos
    Peacefull Dining at The Plaza.
    Peacefull Dining at The Plaza.
    Grilled Sword 'Chop' Tangine
    Grilled Sword 'Chop' Tangine
    Spring Appetizer:
Smoked Salmon 'Napoleon' with Chive-Creme Fraiche and Wasabi Tobiko

    See all

    Spring Appetizer: Smoked Salmon 'Napoleon' with Chive-Creme Fraiche and Wasabi Tobiko

    American Pie Pizzeria - italian - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...