Went back to give Baby Moon another try. We had a much better time. The staff were friendly. Danielle did a great job. The parking lot was full but the restaurant was only at half capacity. The crowd broke a bit geriatric at 6:30 in the offseason. We were started off with tasty garlic knots and bruschetta. We drank a perfectly fine carafe of the house Chianti. Four of us split a very good large chopped salad. 3 of us had pasta. My friend and I shared pastas. One was a really good orecchiette with sausages and broccoli rabe. We tried bucatini with clams, pesto, olive oil and garlic. It's an unusual combination. It grew on us over the course of the meal. My wife ordered a frankenpasta by adding an ingredient or two to something on the menu. My buddy barely put a dent in his veal parmigiana. Portions were really big. Our experience shows that restaurants deserve a second chance. We will put Baby Moon into our rotation. read more

Baby Moon Restaurant - Jurassic pork chop - Italian Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

Experience/Food: First off, I thought that this place was a disappointment considering we were in the Hamptons on a trip with some friends. I expect better and high quality for a restaurant in this area of West Hampton especially for Italian food. I had the penne alla vodka and I thought that it was decent but the flavoring was a little weak for vodka sauce and bland I felt. I got bored of eating my meal about half way through. My friend Jack said nothing stood out to him, he also got the vodka pasta. My friend Josh got the Cesar salad with grilled chicken. He thought it was a very tasty salad, good salad dressing and portions, but the croutons were a little burnt, he said. My friend Thomas got the chicken parm for dinner, he said the cheese was very fresh as well as the sauce but the chicken was a little tough. My friend James got the veal Parmesan, he thought it was really good. My friend got the veal piccata he said it was great. My friend Curbs consumed his veal piccata really fast because of how delicious it was to him. My friend Alex got the chicken francese but it took him a while to get it, it was mid for the price but it was good. Overall almost everyone thought the food was decently good. Service: The service was decently fast for everyone except for my food which was a little slower than the rest which was the penne alla vodka and also my friend Alex's food which was the chicken francese. Ambience: quiet warm ambience outside with heaters on a nice windy noon. Nice chill location near a decently busy road. read more

See all

Reliable good Italian food, wonderful owner and most staff... Very busy in the summer.... They can handle a crowd.. One warning.. super angry woman on the phone for take out.. told me off, called me rude and hung up... Meanwhile she asked me for my order.. and began talking to someone else not once but twice.. will spare the details. Just know going into anywhere in the Hamptons in July/ August people are working super hard to accommodate and may be at their limit or more. They won't miss my order. If you don't want to sit at a restaurant .. take out here is usually fast and excellent. Everything is homemade.. no fake meatballs, premade chicken, premade sauce.. All made here and good. Pizza a bit bland, so opt for a specialty slice with toppings. Hero's are always super good here. read more

My family has been coming here for 40 years and the food has been consistently good. It's a great place for the family and kids. Last night we came with just the adults & had a great time sitting outdoors. We started with grilled calamari with pesto, very tender & flavorful My honey had the seafood fettuccine fra diabolo. He loved it. I had to bolognese over gluten free pasta (best gluten free pasta I've ever had!!), my brother had salmon & bowtie marinara, my sister had shrimp fr diabolo and baked clams to start. We all enjoyed what we had! Ever seat in the house was full, the service was great, we quickly received our food. We brought two bottles of wine & paid the $25 corkage fee. The new remodel is very nice, great wide area for outdoor seating. The weather was great & we had a great time as always! read more

See all

Baby Moon has been around for over 50 years now and it was pretty busy even after 8:30 on a Thursday when we came here, so they must be doing something right. The mini pizzas are actually really big compared to personal pies at some other places I've been to. I had plenty to bring home for another full meal. The prosciutto and arugula tasted pretty fresh. My one comment would be that some people might want a bit more cheese on their mini pizzas than mine had. Baby Moon has a big menu nowadays so I look forward to trying some other things there in the future. read more

Baby Moon Restaurant - Prosciutto and arugula pizza - Italian Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

My husband's family has been ordering pizza from this establishment on and off for over 35 years. Consistently good. Today on our long drive, we decided dine in - large location with a lovely large outside patio and sparkly inviting string lights everywhere. Our waiter was delightful and friendly. Food was pretty good - free bruschetta and garlic knots to start, we ordered a small mini pizza to share and baked eggplant. The eggplant was very tasty but could have come out a little warmer and gooier. Pizza was also good but needed more cheese. We will probably continue to order from here but will try other things, i would get the baked eggplant parm again! read more

See all

This place has been a family favorite for DECADES. We came here every summer, at least once, often more. But I hadn't been back for years, and then my brother treated us to dinner. There was a lovely welcome appetizer of bruschetta and garlic knots! Worth puffy allergy face! Both were yummy. They have gluten-free options! Woohoo!!! Both pasta or unbreaded versions of some things. I had the gluten-free version of eggplant parmigiana, since I hadn't had that in AGES. It was delicious, came with a side of gluten-free pasta, and the portion was enormous. The leftovers provided two more meals for me! The sauce was very good. I don't remember if I like their pizza. Maybe? I know that I've had it. We also had a nice bottle of wine. Service was flawless. The place was packed, but not overly noisy. Tables are well-spaced. It's a nice, unpretentious restaurant. Casual, but well done. read more

See all

Always delicious. I had the best lasagna I had eaten in a long time. The portion was big enough to have dinner the next night too. I will be back ! read more

We went a few times and the food was delicious. The service was excellent . We spoke with Carlos the manager was very friendly. One of our waitresses I believe Trixie was a sweetheart. Kept coming around making sure everything was great. I highly recommend! read more

Very rare, that a restaurant blows me away. This restaurant did just that. The food was incredible. The appetizers were on point. We had the baby eggplant, fried calamari, and the fried mozzarella. All of which were soooo good. Something as simple as the garlic knots, we had to order more. I'm from Brooklyn, so we know garlic knots, these were 10/10. As an entree, we got the vodka pasta, chicken parm's and the salmon. Cooked to perfection. The sauce is the best I've had on Long Island, by far. The service was so good and everyone was so friendly. The outdoor dining was perfect, and warm. We are already planning to go back next week lol. Would recommend this place to anyone who asked! Thank you for an amazing experience. read more

See all

Baby Moon is a Westhampton staple. Dine in or take out. The food is delicious and portions are gargantuan.

The Baby Moon Restaurant is one of the best local Italian eateries in Westhampton. They offer a diverse menu featuring classic Italian fare, including pizza, salads, ravioli, pasta, and seafood. The portions are generous, and the restaurant provides both indoor and outdoor dining options in a simple, casual atmosphere. The friendly, attentive staff ensures there is something to please every palate, and ample parking is available. read more

See all

Great service, huge portions, extensive menu. No wonder they have been around for 50 years! How about taking reservations?? read more

Everything was perfect. Outside ambiance lovely. GF exceptional. Italian gf is wonderful. Love the service and the food.

Go elsewhere - nothing redeeming. The service staff was rude and food not good. Also expensive for what you get. Could get better quality food from the freezer aisle at the local supermarket I generally don't feel compelled to leave reviews, but don't want others to waste their money read more

A warm greeting from Carlo and another wonderful dinner at Baby Moon. Our server Alex was cheerful and very attentive. We both enjoyed two of our go to favorites, hubby ordered the paccheri alla, mimmo, and I had the chicken Milanese that is topped with a chopped salad. Both dishes are consistently excellent! read more

Baby Moon Restaurant - Chicken Milanese With Chopped Salad On Top - Italian Near Me - Westhampton Beach, New York

See all

Always great. So attentive. I love the Bruschetta and garlic knots they serve when you sit down. The food is great and atmosphere either inside or out always fun. read more

Dining here for many years, and the food excellent quality of food has always been consistent. The portions are generous for the price. So nice to be able to dine outside on the patio, weather permitting. The lasagna is my favorite! Baby Moon has a lot of loyal patrons. Please be patient with the waitstaff when they are extremely busy. read more

See all

Ive been coming here since I was born. Baby Moon is a restaurant that our family has cherished for generations. The food is always great, and the service is super friendly. Much love to Jackie, Carlo, and the whole crew. read more

Service was fast and friendly. My wife is a vegetarian who loved the eggplant appetizer. Fried calamari was good. I had classic spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were among the best I've ever had at a restaurant. Prices were reasonable, especially for "The Hamptons". Perhaps we just hit it at the right time, but all of the other patrons were very nice as well. Place had a comfortable vibe. We will be back. read more

This restaurant was cute. I wasn't quite sure what to order, but luckily the outside was quite open and I was able to take a little stroll to investigate the orders of those around me. Finally, we decided upon ordering up some fried mozzarella, calamari, Caesar salad, and pizza. Food was fantastic, servers were slightly clumsy but it didn't take too much from the experience. Would definitely eat here again. read more

How is this place busy? Summer residents? Service was awful...unfriendly..Hates her job type of service! Food wasn't any better either! Worked here when I was a kid...boy has it changed...disappointing to say the least.. read more

Don't know wha has happened to this place, where we ate for years. We had a reservation, but that didn't seem to manner. When we got there, everything was confused.The outside seating was crowded, but we wanted to eat inside, and inside it was empty. When we said we didn't want to eat outside, this seemed to create a problem. We finally gave up waiting and left. We won't be back. read more

The food is a 2/5, the prices a 1/5, the ambience a 1/5, the service a 2/5. Order any pasta and it'll taste identical to barilla with jar sauce. Get the ravioli and I guarantee you'll think you had better ones at Trader Joe's. And for the joy of eating supermarket pasta you pay about 25 bucks a plate assuming there is no protein on there. But it gets better. If it's raining they're not exactly keen on helping you move inside. And when you do get inside whoever built the joint must have had a goal of making this a concert venue because you can't hear a thing; my theory is they have way too much tile action going on in here and noise bounces everywhere. There is a reason people get private chefs when coming here or they just drink their calories. read more

Baby Moon restaurant has a great menu and fantastic food. Unfortunately the service help leaves so much to be desired that it soured our lunch experience. Why do servers look so "put out" at restaurants in general and at Baby Moon in particular. I felt like our friend and I were an inconvenience to our server who couldn't wait to get back to her conversation with co-workers at the bar. Do the owners of Baby Moon realize how much business they are losing with their "attitudes"? We came from Manhattan today on the recommendation of a good friend who lives in the area. Though the food is excellent I am not sure I'd ever revisit the establishment. Surely there are other restaurants that want our repeat business. read more

Carlo makes everyone feel welcome like family! We found the menu is wide ranging, and the food is incredible. If you love Italian, Baby Moon in Westhampton Beach is THE place to dine indoors or outdoors (weather permitting). read more

I wasn't sure what to expect when my father in law took us to Baby Moon since I'm an avid reader of Yelp and they didn't have great reviews. He said it was his favorite restaurant in WHB and so we all went. What I didn't expect was a lovely and totally delicious experience that made no sense based on the reviews that I'd read. The food was WONDERFUL- so fresh and delicious. Even my infant quietly ate up my baby eggplant appetizer (beautiful vibrant red sauce and delicate eggplants) and branzino (so so tender and juicy!) barely making a peep the whole time. Topped it off with a tiramisu at the end that was just delicious. The servers were patient and friendly with our somewhat crazy table and very accommodating. The atmosphere was lovely as well with a mix of families and dates around us. We didn't feel out of place with our baby there like a lot of restaurants would make us feel. Thoroughly enjoyed our experience and really looked forward to writing this review and giving them the credit they deserve. read more

Outstanding! We had dispaired of finding a GOOD Italian/ seafood restaurant in Westhampton. They are scarce on the ground. I had been put off by the name BabayMoon, thinking it sounded more Asian and maybe not what I was looking for... We had a wonderful dinner with very good and friendly service. Definitely give it a try:) read more

Very good food, large selection,also will make changes to dishes to suit. Very good prices, exuberant service. All around good restaurant to frequent. Highly recommended. read more

Large portions and reasonably priced. Nice to eat outside during warm days and evenings.

Every time we order a pie from here, it is fantastic. One of my fave pizzerias one the east end. Their pie is great and I love their sauce, it's not overtly sweet or acidic. The staff is pleasant, even when busy. We have never ate inside but I'm sure it's great as it's usually very packed out. Great place to grab a pie! read more

The food and service is consistently outstanding. We always enjoy the Bruschetta that the server greets you with. The Caesar Salad was a perfect size for 4 to share. read more

Love Babymoon! Everything is plentiful & delicious! Favorites are all of the salads, pasta w/shrimp clams pesto, chicken francese, and the gelato! The seasonal cocktail menus have something for everyone too! The newly-redone outdoor patio is beautiful & the perfect place for an afternoon lunch or date night dinner! Definitely recommended! read more

Went to Baby moon tonight. The dining area was very loud. Very bad acoustics. It sounded like everyone was screaming. Food was mediocre at best. Won't be coming here again. read more

Eat here quite often and have never had a bad meal. Sara is the best waitress ever. read more

The food is good, I have been going here since I was a kid. The same "old school" feel is great. The service is good, especially when they are so busy. Very hard working people. read more

The waitress was horrible and had no idea what she was doing. This restaurant is absolutely overpriced and garbage.

The best Italian restaurant around. Food, service and atmosphere perfect. Definitely going back.

Baby Moon benefits from being one of the only Italian restaurants in the area. Stop in on a summer weekend, and the dining room will be full, the phone will be ringing off the hook, and the line for takeout will extend out the door. It's not surprising though, as the food is usually good. The paccheri pasta with goat cheese and bread crumbs? Money. The linguini with clam sauce? Not bad. The pepperoni and mushroom pies have actual fresh mushrooms, as opposed to those slimy canned things that most pizza joints will offer. You also seemingly get an entire loaf of Italian bread with each pasta order. Gotta love Italians and their proper views on carbs (they are delicious, and should be consumed whenever possible). However, in case you were wondering, there's a reason there are no prices on the menu online. It's not cheap. Two pastas, a small pizza and a salad ran well over $100. Like I said about Tonino's, their pizza competition (I imagine), anytime a town has a "Beach" in its name, it's going to be expensive. If there's also a "Hampton," you're going to have a bad time. But unless you're cooking for yourself, your options are a bit limited, so suck it up. At least Baby Moon does takeout efficiently. They'll call your name out when your order's up, and send you on your way with a big cardboard box (instead of a bunch of bags) filled with your overpriced order so you can take it back and eat it at your overpriced beach house. And it'll taste good. read more

See all

Must be one of the worst restaurants I've eaten in in my life we had reservations, and they still made us wait an hour after they seated us they said that someone else wanted that table and we had to move. They put us on the table that was filthy with pasta on the seats and floor, we had a nasty waitress but after we ordered and the food came that was when it really got bad I ordered something very simple and standard shrimp parmesan. I don't know where they got the chef from but where in the world do they think it's OK to serve shrimp Parmesan with the tails still on the shrimp that's covered with cheese I really don't enjoy eating the tails I've never seen that in any restaurant in my life, I'm trying to think of something nice to say well the parking attendants were nice read more