Going with a 5 on the take out. First time at Uncle's and it was a most pleasant awakening! We can only comment on what we ordered which was minimal but happy to share our findings. We went with a shrimp parm hero and a prosciutto and mozz hero (normally a panini but we subbed). Shrimp parm hero (purely an amazing Italian America creation) was perfection. Snappy breaded shrimp, delicious sauce, and the star...the BREAD! It's what's happening! Not sure if it's semolina but these soft and chew-some sesame seeded hero buns are perfection. Prosciutto hero was equally as inspiring. Always willing to pay the dough for quality and that is what was delivered. Can't wait to try the pizza and move on down the menu. read more

Great tasting pizza and pinwheels for great prize! Will definitely go back again. Overall great experience. read more

Cuisine: 6 Service: 6 Decor: 7 Value: 6 Overall: 6 A decent local pizzeria and Italian restaurant under new ownership/management. Nothing outstanding, but serviceable. Chicken parm was probably the best dish we ordered, along with the free, very chewy garlic knots. The regular slice was not bad, but the grandma slice and eggplant parm were just okay. read more

See all

The food is very good. The menu offers all of the highlights of an Italian Pizzeria. I had the chicken parm with angel hair pasta. All good. The pizza is good as well. But the service is just weird. It was about 28 degrees outside and we sat in the dining room (versus the pizza area in front.) We had to keep our hats and coats on because there was no heat in the room. Finally we asked if they'd turn it on. They did. Kinda. For a little while. Then it was off again. The garlic knots came out and were very good. But no plates. I asked if they bring out plates with apps. The server answered, "no". Okayyyy? No napkins with the chicken wings. (We asked and she did bring them). No silverware. (We asked. She brought it.) The evening went kind of like that. Weird. The server was a sweet girl, but completely unaware of what to do. And she's not that new. We had her a few weeks prior when she added an extra slice of pizza onto our bill (we ordered one slice, got one slice, was charged for two slices.) Yikes! How are you guys gonna make it during the busy season??! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - New menu - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

This is a great place to grab lunch or dinner. The food is delicious, and the service is good.

Quite a few Karens in the review section here so let me balance it a bit. This place was perfectly fine. Stopped in the area to charge our car and was a bit peckish. A no frills spot with someone continuously making and baking pizza. A bit toasty hot in there, and for some reason they only had bottled Winter IPA (it's middle of summer)... Otherwise service was quick and pizza was good ! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - Sicilian's Sicilian and Spicy Buffalo slices - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Great atmosphere, but greater food. Uncle Joe does everything simple and right to the key. I stopped in for a nice chicken roll and was Impressed by their selection of pizzas and salads. After waiting 10 minutes for my chicken roll to bake, it came out a little cold but that's okay. The chicken cutlet and mozzarella cheese worked perfectly together. Their marinara sauce was probably the best I had in a while haha a lot of places make their sauce too sour or less savory but this one was actually pretty good. The flake on the roll was delicious. Well moneys worth read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Buyer beware. If you order on line on their website, they will not honor daily specials. ( Wednesday special of 18 inch pie for $13 ) was billed at $21 online. When asked about the special, they "clarified" that it was only for phoned in orders, not applicable to their website. read more

Beautiful upgrade to our fav pizza spot in the Hamptons. Went with a group of 8 and ordered All the salads, a pie of grandma slice, eggplant parm platter with spaghetti (best), buffalo wings (awesome), garlic knots which I didn't get to try because I had pasta. Was super happy with everything. We ate in the back room which was stunning for events and large parties. Wish I took more pics of the room and food but we were hungry and attacked it when it came out. For 8 people it was $120 + tip which I thought was super reasonable for a sit down part of a slice restaurant Looking forward to our next visit read more

See all

We were extremely satisfied and full on Wednesday night before Thanksgiving (11/26/25). There were 10 of us and were able to eat in the beautiful private dining room. Due to the sheer number of us, we had quite a variety of food and drinks, and everything was superb, right down to the service. There was a great variety of appetizers.. the calamari and bruschetta were my favorites. Don't remember formal names, but the Seafood pasta was loaded with/various seafoods and delicious. Shrimp scampi and boulanise also a hit! We were so impressed, that the day after Thanksgiving we ordered takeout pizzas for the gang for lunch. They were also spot on, loaded with/goodies. The meat lovers was especially good. We will definitely be back . read more

This had been a favorite place of ours last year. The food and service was special. But there is new ownership, the menu offerings more limited and less interesting. Oddly you can only order the pizza as shown on the menu. At least according to the waitress. I asked for a chefs special loaded pie. They can't do that. There bar now has only limited offerings. I asked for a bloody-mary, they don't have that , and only have a choice of 5 drinks. So I asked for a classic negroni which was on the menu, and was brought a glass of beer Since I couldn't get a pie I wanted I ordered 3 slices. The waitress brought my slices long before my wife's meal came to the table My pizza slices looked like they had been sitting for some time. Far from anything special My wife's eggplant-parm was Meh Sadly, I won't be back read more

Ordered a large pie with two toppings, mushroom and onions. Was overcharged, when I showed that Slice Price was lower they said we will give you a discount next time, WTF. Overall pie had skimpy toppings and undercooked doughy taste. No bueno ! Will not be going back. read more

Uncle Joe's is known for having no cheese on their pizza so we paid for extra cheese. We got the driest pizza I've ever seen. We called to let them know we must have picked up the wrong order. The woman on the phone tried to convince us they put extra cheese and then didn't even want to come up with any solution. Last time ever ordering from Uncle Joe's. If this is extra cheese you can imagine how their regular pizza is. read more

See all

Thank you Uncle Joes for lunch today. Glove wearing and friendly. Easy in and out. Worth a quick ride over from nearby towns. Always reliable and still has customers now and doing take out. read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

I had an amazing experience at Uncle joe's and Daphne G was a great attendant and was very kind and helpful. The food was great.

Great Pizza! Just tried the Miller Place Soft Opening, had a few slices, really good. Owner brought over a plate of " Italian Donuts " , avoid if you're on a diet, because you can't have just one. Full opening Monday, back room sitting area, dinner menu looks great, new local spot is going to get busy! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - Italian Donuts! - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

We ordered 2 pizzas for delivery on a Saturday night. They arrived early and super fresh. Crust was still crispy. Pizza was delicious. We got the margarita and the prosciutto with hot honey and arugula. The latter was everyone's favorite. We would definitely order from here again. read more

Quogue elementary school chamber choir visited Uncle joe's this afternoon and the service was beyond excellent! Thank you to our Waitress Isabella who took great care of the kids and Teachers! Looking forward to visiting this place next year! Happy Holidays! read more

Not horrible but.... Ordered 2 pies late. I know, I know, dick move, but we were starving and I asked if it was ok first. I arrived 10 minutes early so I didn't keep them waiting. Paid my bill and threw a $10 in the tip jar since they were very sweet about making food so late. As they were almost boxing up the pies I asked for pepper flakes and cheese to go. One of the counter girls, obviously new, asked for here to get them. A more seasoned employee came over apologizing for the additional charges. .75 a small plastic container. .50 for garlic powder. .75 for cheese filled halfway. I'm talking really small containers. My buddy asked if the charge for condiments if we ate there. No, she said. So if we eat there the cheese was free but to go is .75 cents. I paid for that, but I gotta say that's obscene. It's the equivalent of getting a cheeseburger and fries to go and paying extra for ketchup. The goodwill gained by making us a pie at 9:35pm when they close at 10pm was completely lost. In fact now I was extremely annoyed. I let the young lady know how I felt, that it wasn't her and asked she tell the owner. Still bothered this morning I told the story a few times and the people listening said it was crazy too and will stay away. Stop gouging your customers... I know I'm a tourist, but there plenty of places to anting our money. Oh!!! The pizza? Meh. Not stretched by hand. Too much corn meal on the bottom. Not grande cheese. Give it a 5, on par with dominos. Won't ever be back. read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza was great! The food was all delicious. The sauce tasted homemade and every dish was served very hot. The fettuccini was one of the best I ever had. Our waitress, Isabella was attentive, pleasant and wanted to please. We will be back soon! read more

We are visiting the Hamptons with family and ordered three pizzas from this restaurant earlier in the week One margarita a second with meatball and onions and another with pepperoni . We enjoyed the pizza which we requested to be cooked extra crispy . The pizza crust was good but different than any pizza I've had before . I felt neutral about the crust but all the ingredients were great I would order for them again . In addition the delivery driver was very friendly read more

I ordered by phone and had to repeat myself 6 times, I asked if there was an issue with the phone, the girl said she couldn't hear me. Finally was told 25 minutes my pie would be ready. I got to restaurant 20 minutes later, I was handed my pie and asked if I could look at it as there seemed to be confusion when I ordered it. It was wrong, I said I repeated myself 6 times, how could they get it wrong? By the way, music was blasting, no wonder she couldn't hear me! I decided to keep the pie, instead of waiting for new one. I was never offered an apology and/ or discounted price! I was ignored by one person completely as she walked away while I was talking! I finally said, "is anyone going to even apologize?" And the girl's answer was, "I don't even know who took your order!" To add insult to injury the pie wasn't even warm!! I've stayed with Uncle Joe's as I have gone to his place for over 40 years, but never again!! read more

A pretty forgettable night to be honest. We walked in at 7:20 pm for my birthday last night (Wednesday). We asked if we could sit for a meal, they told us that we could but kitchen would close in 20 minutes. They also offered us to do takeout. This should have been warning enough for the night coming. We ordered mozzarella sticks and calamari as starters. They were both delicious. I would recommend. Our son had 2 nice slices of cheese pizza. He enjoyed. I ordered shrimp parm with penne alla vodka. It tasted odd at first, not like any penne alla vodka I've ever had. It took a moment then realized it was well seasoned with garlic. It is rare for me to send food back, and this was still edible. So I continued. My fiancée's meal on the other hand was not edible. She didn't have the heart to send it back. She ordered a Ziti Al Forno. We never could figure out what was wrong with it. It tasted like something in the pasta had turned. We didn't really have the option to send any dishes back anyway, with the kitchen already closed. It's safe to say that I would not recommend. It's a real shame. read more

Sorry uncle Joe, i know you for years and i know how much you care for your place, but this time i have to say something; i order fry calamari with spicy marinara , the girl told me they di nit have "spicy marinara" on my arrival i show her how to do it, just adding some chili flakes from the dispenser on the table! Tye calamari was horrible!!! Totally overcooked and hard like a rock ( all you need is to keep them on milk one night !!) my son is here from Italy with the desire for pizza and once at home he ask me: dad is this tomato and bread cake? The place look great after the renovation , but where is the girl that was there for years? She was great!! The rest of the young staff need to be train, need to know how to answer the phone and interact with the clients !! Any way the marinara sauce is still the best! Good luck uncle Joe Evviva la Sicilia read more

Great service! Great food! The pepperoni and margarita pizza are so good I will definitely be back!

Pizza is very nice with the cornmeal crust. The little zeppole is tasty. Very short wait for food

Welcome to my review of Uncle Joe's in Hampton Bays. I will start by dying that I have read the prior reviews and will now give you my straight up review. Upon entering through the parking lot entrance, the restaurant is a very warm and friendly place with a rustic ambiance of brick and stone. They have a nice private dining room on the highway side. We were met by uncle Joe who was very nice, personable and great to talk with. We were talking about Italy and our roots. We received a nice basket of bread and a marinated zucchini to start. For dinner, we started with the fried Calamari with tomatoe sauce which was nice and tender, and a nice portion. Rings only (I like tentacles too). The main entrees were.... Chicken Florentine, 3 nice cutlets cooked to perfection, Veal Rollatine.... outstanding and I had the linguini pescatore which was amazing. It was a very nice portion of linguini with a lobster tail, shrimp, calamari and scungilli. This dish was so delicious and tasty. Jean Marie, our waitress was just amazing and took great care of us, and our night talking with uncle Joe was just the best. I highly recommend Uncle Joes!!!!! read more

See all

I hate shi**ing on a business, but: Pizza is a D to D- Chicken Parm is a C to C+ House salad was an A They also forgot that I ordered pizza. Overall this place was pretty terrible. read more

Tried this place twice over a two week visit. I had four different slices of pizza and they were all great. I especially enjoyed the Sicilian. read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Not a bad place! We came here in the midst of COVID-19 and had to wear a mask to enter. We ordered two slices of pizza and two penne a la vodka dishes, part of a dinner deal. Be aware that the pizza special is only good until 4pm on weekdays, and this fact is only written on a piece of paper taped inside, not anywhere outside. However, despite the false advertising, the pizza was perfectly well-done and flavorful and we were able to eat for two nights with the penne a la vodka, which was a little creamier than I prefer, but still was a good dinner choice. I would come here again in the future if in the mood for Italian. read more

My first time visiting this spot. Initially, I wanted some bagels, however, the store was closed for the day. Uncle Joes did not disappoint! I only had garlic knots. And they sure will leave strong garlic breath for you! And you can taste the garlic bits. They were so soft! If I come visit Hampton Bays again. Will definitely come by! read more

Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour - The cute pizza clock! - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

This place has GOT TO BE KIDDING! I Was once my go to place on the way out to Montauk. Now apparently it has been sold and Everything Uncle Joe is gone. The prices were so ridiculous I had to laugh. I didnt bother ordering anything as I could see the place had been ruined. If you Loved Uncle Joes... Run from it now! You have been warned read more

Best pizza in town, the chicken parm was outstanding, great service and the wine room is spectacular!!!!

I specifically asked if I could get a Sausage Parm Hero when I got home I saw I had a Sausage and Peppers Parm I called to see if I brought back the Sausage and peppers and in the meantime could they make me the Sausage Parm I'd originally ordered I was told the sausage Parm comes with peppers I asked if they could just leave of the peppers and again was told it comes with the Peppers, I was graciously offered a refund by the concerned staff I spoke with but wasn't offered the Easy fix Sausage Parm This won't deter me from going back but it's not but I feel compelled to document the experience read more

By far the best southern Italian restaurant on the East End. Besides a large array of pizzas the menu features all the fav red sauce Italian dishes. We started with terrific Caesar salads, sparkling and fresh, then Chicken Francese and Chicken Marsala both fantastic, perfectly prepared and such large portions we took half of each home for dinner the next night. Amazingly, they do mixed drinks well. The Negronis were top notch. Our waitress, well informed about everything, could not have been nicer or more attentive. We'll be back, for sure! read more

First week I've eaten here since the new owners. Beautiful reno. That saying in the last few days I've tried it twice and have been disappointed both times. First time ordered spaghetti bolognese, garlic knots. Garlics knots were good. Bolognese was just ok, kind of bland. $40 for one order of Bolognese, 6 garlic knots and two sodas. Second visit ordered 2 Greek salads with chicken. First bite into the chicken in my salad- it didn't seem cooked enough, but the rest was fine. Neither salad arrived with with feta, as advertised. Asked for feta and what came was bland. Rosemary bread was good. Two salads with chicken and two sodas, $58. Mediocre service. Waitress seemed new or not trained enough. Im sad....wanted to love this place as much as I did old Uncle Joes. read more

Been going to Uncle Joes forever. Came in with my wife and ordered two slices on a Saturday at 6 pm. No customers were there. Pizza looked like it was sitting out for days. They reheated the pizza which tasted dry, hard and we ended up throwing it out after one bite. If I were Uncle Joes I would take my name off the business. Shame they renovated very nicely but should have a real pizza maker. read more

If I could leave zero stars I would. I ordered online and selected delivery. 30 minutes later they tell me that my order was for pickup and try to make me pay extra. DO NOT ORDER ONLINE AT THIS PLACE, THEIR SERVICE SUCKS!!! read more

I have eaten twice at Uncle Joe's. The food is always great and the new renovations have made the place look amazing. The staff is very friendly. If you last visited before they decorated for Christmas, you are missing out. The backroom is warm and cozy with the new decorations. I love what the new owners are doing with the place. I'll be back again soon. read more

Food and service was excellent and I am definitely going to go back again especially for the grandma pie!