Amici's Pizza & Pasta is hands down the best pizza in the area. It's our go-to spot when we want great flavor and quality ingredients. Their pizza leans more toward a traditional New York style than most places around here, and you can definitely taste the difference. Consistently solid and always hits the mark. read more

Decided to give Amici's a shot and it was definitely delicious. We're usually in the area for Cherry's but my daughter is obsessed with pizza so we decided to grab a small from Amici's and now we're hooked! The first pizza we got was just a cheese then we came back for a half cheese half pepperoni. It was so good. The sauce they use is so good and the crust is perfect honestly it's at the top five pizzas I've enjoyed. Definitely will be ordering from here again! read more

See all

I'm a huge fan of this local gem. This place is located in Park Square. There is no indoor seating, but there are tables outside as well as an entire park to enjoy. We often meet up with friends, get pizzas, and all hang out outside because it's a beautiful area to do that in. They do also deliver, and you don't have to use a delivery app, which is rare these days. The owner is always super nice and efficient too. I've only ever had pizza and calzones here. They're so good, I don't know if I'd ever try anything else. If you get onions or green peppers on your pizza, they are sautéed here, and I love that touch. The meatballs are great! This is a great place with delicious food in a prime location. Winner all around! read more

Amici's Pizza & Pasta - Calzone with Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

See all

Amici's never disappoints! We love to get their meatballs and meat pizza well done. That's our go to order, however we have had several other pizza's and side items that have always beat the local competition!! read more

Food is always hot and fresh and they're so friendly! Fast, and they do amazing work!

Great NY style pizza in Lithia I always order the Greek Pizza which is meatless but also tastes great w added sausage Nice well cooked bottom read more

Pizza and service is great! Right around the corner from my house. My kids love walking over for a slice of pizza.

I'm Italian, from Bklyn, NY. I've loved this place since they opened years ago and the best thing about them is consistency! The food is made perfectly like home! At least once a week we have pizza and calzone, sometimes Rapini. Ihave been sick with bronchitis on and off for months and the most soothing thing I have experienced is the Italian Wedding Soup. I always think about sending a thank you note, but I really want everyone to know that you will love this food!!! read more

We are lucky to have good pizza so close to home. The pies and Stromboli are excellent. Never tried the sandwiches. read more

Friendly staff and good pizza!! We are regulars. It's a take our place only but they have tables outside if you want to eat there. Not fancy but a solid choice and one of the owners is usually present. read more

I completely agree with the person that said they have the best cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza in the entire Tampa Bay area. Don't sleep on the Supreme either. It is delicious. read more

In a land of make-believe pizza joints with cardboard flavor and marketing hype, this little takeout oasis does a nice job with true NYC flavor 'za and solid other italian entrees. Chicken Marsala is very good and consistent. The staff are on point, owner is friendly and hard-working, and for FishHawk or nearby the location is easy. On a nice day tables outside are a good option, or steps away at Park Square. Standout in this area and very good! read more

After a long weekend trip, we returned home and wanted something yummy. We decided on pizza and pasta and wanted to give Amici a try. Boooooyyyyy have we been sleeping on this place. We ordered Alfredo pasta with chicken and shrimp and it did NOT disappoint. The portion sizes were generous, great prices, friendly customer service and delicious food! They have earned themselves new customers! read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza and was sold a day old cheese pizza they had pepperoni added to it and reheated. Terrible and shamefull. Will not be back or recommend.. read more

This is 1 of 2 family friendly spots in this lot. It's located in Park Square which is an open air space for families to take in the fresh air and friendly neighborhood. There is no dining room, however there are numerous tables and benches outside to sit and enjoy your food. Additionally, you can grab this TO GO! The ingredients are fresh and delicious! read more

Recently moved into the area. Can't eat pizza as much as when I was younger, but like to have it every 3-4 weeks. Tried a place down the block a few weeks ago. I was really disappointed. I usually order a large pizza, have a couple of slices and freeze the rest. The pizza I got at this other place was terrible. Crust was saturated with grease. Choked down a couple of slices and threw the rest of the pizza away. Tried Amici's last night. My niece was visiting. We both found the pizza to be first class, excellent crust, great pizza. Solid positive recommendation for this pizzeria. read more

Located within the FishHawk development at its "Town Center," this well-established NY pizza takeout joint hit the spot for lunch one afternoon with its pizza special: two large cheese slices with a canned drink for $5.99. Hard to beat! And, very, very good. Served hot with tables available nearby at the nice community park, or take it home in a box. I took mine home and lathered it with Boscoli's Italian Olive Salad. Wow! read more

The food was good and had a great staff. I think the problem I have is behind the scenes. Turns out the staff don't get their tips. The tips go to the house. That is ridiculous!!! Tips should go to those who provide service, not to the owners to "supply" a party for Christmas. Please bring cash for your servers, these kids work hard only to be treated terribly. Better yet, get fired... yep, some get fired if they inform others that the tip doesn't go to them. Even if the owner has a suspicion you told someone, you're cut. Still trying to find out if that's legal? Whoever runs/manages this place apparently doesn't know how to treat their workers. Or even how to treat people with respect or reward for hard work. Sooo overall, I'd give this restaurant no stars. Do NOT give these people business or allow the owners to steal your server's tip. read more

Lithia/FishHawk has a glut of pizza places. There are at least 10 spots to get a pizza picked up or delivered, and most of them are pretty forgettable. Amici's, however, is Extremely Good. Classic NY style, super thin, not especially greasy. Excellent pizza, all around. Apparently they do other Italian stuff too, but I will go to my grave never ordering anything else from a place like this. Get pizza or get out. Just a walkup counter, no tables inside although since it's in Park Square, there's plenty of outdoor seating as long as some hugeass group isn't bogarting all the chairs. They serve beer and wine too, but you're also allowed to BYOB so its really your choice. PS is on the resurgence! Anyway, great pizza. read more

I ordered an eggplant parm sandwich today. I found one slither of eggplant, and the rest was nothing but soggy breadcrumbs, sauce and a sprinkle of mozzarella cheese. I had to throw it out rather than eat it. The owner /cook tells me he makes it lasagne style. There isn't any soggy breadcrumbs with a microscopic slice of eggplant in it. The worst I've ever eaten, and I'm an Italian from Brooklyn NY.Eggplant Pharm. one star for it be available on time. read more

I am very upset that this establishment refuses to use any COVID practices. No employee from cashiers to cooks wear any masks and they are in a very small space.. I used to go regularly and pick up a pizza to eat outside. When I came this past weekend, not one employee had a mask on, not even dangling from their chin like the time before. No sanitizer in sight and they go from handling money/credit cards and cash register to giving you a paper plate/plastic ware to eat. Please take your responsibility as a restaurant seriously and help your customers stay safe! read more

My husband & I took a wrong turn & just happened to find this place so we stopped in to get a bite to eat. The service was really good. It was a pleasant environment. Italian music playing in the background. Restaurant was clean and decorated really cute. The food was great! I especially loved the Italian cheesecake my husband ordered. One of the best I have ever eaten. read more

I have only had their spaghetti and meat sauce, but I have ordered it a lot. I absolutely love it. The sauce is incredible, probably one of the best I've ever had. I highly recommend. read more

This little gem of a pizza place is in the Park Square in Fishhawk Ranch. Parking is plentiful and when coming here you can get your food to go or sit outside at the numerous tables. We ordered a chicken parm dinner with salad and two 14" cauliflower crust pizzas. One with sausage, sautéed onions and peppers. The other with pepperoni. The chicken parm was very good, fresh and the sauce was tasty with perfectly cooked pasta. The cauliflower crust pizza, a great option for carb control and diabetics, was very good as well. The toppings were fresh and full of flavor. We would definitely come back and look forward to trying other items on their plentiful menu. Come check it out and help out a small business in the local area. You won't be disappointed. read more

Such a great experience tonight at Amici's during their tree lighting ceremony. The margarita pizza was great and Peggy and Fran made it feel like being home for Christmas. It's clear that this is a true family-owned business who cared about the details! We will visit every time we're in town. 10/10 reccomend. read more

Great people, food and wine. Nice local place to enjoy Italian food. Take out and delivery with outside seating. read more

Amici's Pizza & Pasta - outside - Pizza Near Me - Lithia, Florida

Maybe tonight was a bad night, but the pizza was just above average, I expected more based on the reviews. Loved the garlic knots and the Italian "Knot-chos" but as for the pie itself... it was tasty, but just "ok." That being said, it was good enough to give them a second try in the future. read more

Holy crap! This is some damn great pizza!! I just moved into the area and ordered from Amici's for the first time as we are so exhausted from the move. I couldn't be happier. You would be hard pressed to find a better NY Style pizza in New York much less in Florida!! I got the meat lovers which has pepperoni, sausage, and ham. What a delight. The crust is thin as a whisper and everything is just delicious. Absolutely will order again. read more

Counter service with tables outside. I lived near NY and it's average NY pizza. Tangy sauce. Salad was fresh and house dressing excellent. Margarita pizza had sauce...not a big fan. Around $13 for a personal pie. Not special enough to return. read more

Just moved to the area and have ordered pizza, pasta and sandwiches from here a few times. Been great each time. People are super nice. Food is always great. Walking distance from our house which is super convenient. So happy that we found this place. read more

Absolutely the best pizza around. John and sal really have it together. Hang outside at Park square and fishhawk and enjoy your pizza. Beer and wine as well along with other Italian specialties. read more

Just tried this pizza tonight. It's a hidden gem at Park Square in Fishhawk. John the owner is very friendly and his pizza is amazingly good! Will definitely go back! read more

Love this place. Service is good. Food is great. Probably the best kept secret in Fishhawk. Try the fried ravioli.

Exceptional Italian food with a small bill at the end. :) Pizza is good but their entrees are exceptional.

This place is great! Great food to grab and hang at the splash pad with! My kids love it and the staff is always great!

This is the best pizza in town! The local chains are ok and the other small pizza shops are good, but this is the best pizza! Order a large to get that perfect crust, smaller size will be a little thicker crust. I used to go to NY and would bring back pizza and bagels for my NYer wife. Our recent trip to NY and a few of their pizza joints left me wanting Amici's pizza. They also offer a number of other very good dishes. For lunch, two slices and a soda (or beer) hits the spot! read more

Sorry to say a great disappointment! I have to say this IS Not NY Pizza. I can't wait to find someone you can actually cook Italian. I may have to open my own place. read more

Good pizza, good service, great location. More of a carryout place, but they have some outdoor seating. Pizza is good, but nothing special. It's perfect to grab a quick pizza or sub or if you want to eat outside on a nice evening. Mozarella sticks were really good. I'll definitely go again. read more

Best pizza around. Philly cheesesteak was great. Caprese was outstanding as well. If you don't like this pizza, you don't know great pizza.

This is my go to Pizza place. We moved here from Philadelphia and my husband is a New Yorker, and he absolutely loves their pizza. Eggplant pizza yum yum read more