Def punching above their weight. Plain slice, deep dish, & buffalo chicken slice are all fire here, I wld still avoid all of Scarsdale if possible, tho. read more

Many good pizza options to choose from with adequate seating. I went there today for lunch with my wife. For a Saturday afternoon, they were crowded with families enjoying their pizza. I had a regular slice and a grandma slice. Both were delicious and I would definitely eat there again whenever I'm in the area. read more

Amore Pizza - Regular slice and grandma marinara slice - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

This place is great. I was in the area and was looking for food. I'm glad I stopped here. They had a lot of pizza and roll options available. I ordered the spinach and feta roll with sauce. It was delicious and fresh. I'll definitely come back here again. read more

See all

Amore pizza is good. My son loved the ziti slices when he lived here. They have good salads too. The people who work there are very friendly, and the service is fast. The ambience is casual and friendly. Parking is free and easy in the parking lot right outside. read more

Good people and great pizza. We are just outside their delivery area, so I generally only go for lunch. Well priced as well.

This review is pizza only. I was passing through the area on an empty stomach, making my way home. I decided for a slice and stopped in for a quick one to go. The pizza isn't bad. Not quite my taste, but not bad. read more

Amore Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

This pizza is freaking delicious. I don't understand why it doesn't have 5 stars. I always judge a place by its cheese pizza-- and it does not disappoint. We also really love the Italian Farmer pizza. Delicious. This is our go-to pizza spot. read more

Good quality, fresh food at Amore Pizza in Scarsdale. Their pizza is always great and the fresh foods are delicious. The service is fast and friendly. If you are hungry for some great takeout and in the Scarsdale area, try Amore Pizza. read more

Been a customer for many years, and for good reason. The pizza is always fantastic, served hot and fresh. My family and I get order it often, and it's our go-to place for pizza. Their other dishes are great too. We've had their food catered a number of times for family events, and everyone on each occasion loves the food. Chicken dishes, pasta, salads, all great! Good serving sizes too. People there are very friendly and know me by name. The place is always spotless. read more

I'm surprised by the average reviews. Their Grandma pizza is outstanding. You have to ask for the marinara Grandma if you want tomato sauce. If you order a regular Sicilian-Grandma there will be no tomato sauce at all. That's also a good pizza if you're in the mood for it. They only take 15 min to make a pie so I order and go over early so I can get it hot out of the oven. read more

Amore Pizza - Grandma: olives/onions - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Great food. quick delivery. Great garlic knots. Salads. wraps. meals. chicken franchase my favorite. read more

BEST PIZZA IN WESTCHESTER!!! The pizza is great, the staff is friendly and they are good for sit down dinner. They have reasonable prices and large portions. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED read more

Granted it's late night and with that being said. This is not the spot for late night slice. The spot looks like a nice spot to sit and eat but the the slice was soggy( the top layer of the pizza dough and below the cheese). It's the best way I can describe the dough. The sauce didn't stand out like some other spots. Took two bites and I was done. read more

Amore Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

This place has great specialty pizza and their eggplant roll is out of this world. I picked up a regular pie and it's always sloppy. Greasy, undercooked, and just blah read more

Worth a try. Great slice not thin as you see frequently in pizza places nowadays. They have a selection of ice cream bars which was nice. Spacious place with polite staff. What I did not like was the refrigerated ziti slice looking super old. Pasta cooks quick those type of slices should be fresh. read more

Amore Pizza - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Absolutely great cheesesteaks and pizza. I love the different varieties of pizza but the square pizza is what I love the most.

Let me tell you how good the pizza is at Amore pizza: I just went in there, 20 minutes before closing, and asked for a slice of cold pizza. Well I asked them not to heat it, it wasn't exactly cold. Eating a slice from this place, even at room temperature, is like a slice of heaven. The cheese the crust this delicious sweet sauce holds up even when it's not piping hot out of the oven. Multó bene!! read more

Always great food and friendly service. Italian classics make for a neighborhood mainstay.

I love this place! We had food catered from here twice and it was delicious and easy. They come set up and the trays with burners and leave you all the tools you need to host. The meatballs are delicious, the baked ziti is incredible snd the garlic knots melt in your mouth. read more

Amore Pizza - Baked Ziti, Meatballs, Chicken Parmigiana, Antipasto Salad, Garlic Knots, Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Excellent food and superb service by the one and only Felicity! She was so accommodating, friendly and funny! Will definitely stop stop again when in the area read more

If you're in the mood for a calzone, head right over to Amore Pizza. Their cheese calzone is large and oozing with mozzarella and ricotta. It's really cheesy! It's great paired with marinara sauce. I also recommend their cheese slice topped with sausage. They put a lot of sausage which I really appreciated. My friend ordered fettuccini carbonara and enjoyed it. It looked really creamy- what could be bad? The service was also good. read more

The food was great. Great quality, easy, and fast. Definitely recommend the Tomato slice or the Sicilian.

Great food. Best pizza around. Service is friendly and they work fast. Inside reminds me of an old-school pizzeria that I grew up on.

We've been going there since it opened, about 20 years ago. Their pizza is quite good, the Margarita pie is my favorite. They also make awesome catered trays. I once used them when a few professional athletes were coming to my house to watch a game with my sons a week before Christmas. A HOF lineman was going to eat the entire large tray of wings by himself, he liked them so much - I had to remind him there were more of us who liked them too. The individual dinners are also excellent. A chicken parm dinner is always good and always enough for two people The service is always courteous, the orders are always accurate and timely. We don't eat in the restaurant often but it is our go-to place for takeout Italian, once a week. read more

Had the chicken salad and it was fresh and crispy, and the chicken was not dry. It took them about 5 minutes to make. My son got a sandwich from the Dunkin Donuts and ate it in amore restaurant with me--angry glares and stares of disdain from the folks who work there were muted, if there were even any.! That was nice of them to allow him to eat with me. Although I did not get pizza this visit, they have great pizza. I particularly like their specialty pies. The soda was cold. There was no free wifi. They had free newspapers! It's a no lose place to grab some good food! read more

My boyfriend with a severe nut allergy has gotten pizza here multiple times and always makes sure to ask about peanuts before eating it. However, he got the baked ziti slice which they said contained no nuts, and had an allergic reaction. They somehow managed to get pesto on his slice which he couldn't tell was on it until he started chewing(pesto has nuts) and had an allergic reaction. Thankfully he is ok, but will never be eating here again. Don't eat here if you have allergies. Most unprofessional situation to tell someone with a life threatening allergy that the food is safe. Bullshit. read more

Disgsuting , this is the second time something like this has happened - I order from this place and they bring me food that is barley cooked! I will be leaving a photo below to warn other people do not eat here!!! They don't fully cook there food or care about there customers the first time I made a complaint they were rude and didn't care I will never be spending my Money there ever again read more

Amore Pizza - Chicken tenders pink and not cooked 6 Chicken Tenders - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

I'm gonna have to disagree with Rick W. - Amore Pizza sucks. The tomato sauce and cheese are just not that tasty once you've had good pizza. I have had a few slices with toppings that are pretty good (chicken parm slice is good), but the plain is a real downer. If you're in this area looking for pizza, I would recommend Italian Village in the Golden Horseshoe, which is just a minute or two away. read more

I just ate an eggplant Halo had no flavored and was over price. A cheat to place is 54 gallons maybe the other food is better but do not order the eggplant read more

Nice environment and friendly service. Many different options on the menu but it isn't the best pizza in the area. read more

Amore Pizza - Amore Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

In our house Amore Pizza is known as "Pizza and Puppies". The kids like to go for a meal and then visit the pet shop next store. The food is very solid. Yes the layout is a bit wierd, and the parking isn't great. But the service is fast and friendly, the pizza is solid and the rest of the menu is pretty good. Just make sure you do the pizza part before the puppies. read more

No no no no no no no no no the pizza here is disgusting. Do not get suckered into this place they have fancy slices but none of them are good. My kids who have no sense of what is good won't even eat this pizza. read more

We had been ordering takeout from several local pizza places and always liked the salads at Amore but 2 weeks ago my daughter wanted chicken noodle soup and there was a fly in it. I thought she was joking but no, it had wings and was floating at the top of her soup. Done with Amore. read more

Pizza-- beautiful thin crust. Chicken Mars-hell yeah! Unique and delicious twist on the old dinner stand by. I was disappointed to not see a simple cheese and/or roni slice but the 2 specialties I got were good. read more

Great food st a great price the pizza was awesome and garlic nots to die for plus the wait staff very friendly I will definitely be back!!!!! read more

What can I say about Amore? This is my absolute favorite pizza restaurant. There is nothing they do not get right! They have an excellent sauce, delicious cheese, and wonderful toppings. I have been going there for years now and they never disappoint. I do prefer there delivery over their over the counter My recommendations are their chicken parm slices and their chicken rolls. read more

Amore...I have to ask, what happened??? You use to make the best Sicilian pies around. Now you cut the size, the cheese, the sauce and the taste. Pretty disappointing all around. Third time and three strikes and you are out! What were you thinking??? read more

As being a Scaradale native, I can honestly say Amore has lost it's way in the past several years. After the major renovations, the taste of the pizza diminished day by day. I will have to side with Italian Village on this one; which is down the street. Try there salad slice with a side of dressing. Never disappoints ! read more

I called and ordered take out from here tonight (and it was not the first time). I was told that our pizza and wings would be here in 40 minutes. After an hour my husband called to find out where our order was. He was told that someone else called and they thought it was a prank so the cancelled the whole order. They did not even offer to quickly deliver a replacement or give any reason as to why they did not call me back to confirm it was not a prank. We had to run out and get food for the kids. Will NEVER order from Amore again. read more

This is my "go to" pizza joint. I have loved this place for over 10 years! I recommend the chicken parmigiana pizza and their delicious home made salad dressing. read more