Sofia's is a little pizzeria that's tucked into this quiet street corner among a few other eateries on Harrison Ave. We've ordered for takeout several times and even dined in on occasion. They remodeled a few years ago and the white tiled dining room is pretty spacious and comfortable now. When we recently ordered several large pies for the office, they delivered a 1/2 hr earlier than expected and the pies were still pretty hot. There were 3 large cheese pies, 1 pepperoni and 1 veggie, but the clear favorite was the chicken bacon ranch pie drizzled with ranch dressing because that disappeared quickly. C'mon, who can refuse bacon? Plus they do a slightly thicker crust than other pizzerias in the neighborhood, they generously pile on the cheese almost as thick as the crust and the number of pepperoni per slice was a lot. The wedge/hero sandwiches are alright, but nothing spectacular. I do want to try the pasta meals though, when we order-in during late night shifts at the office. read more

See all

Everything excellent food was amazing It's hidden gem in Harrison . Calamari soup and chicken was awesome Thank you Claudia !! read more

See all

This is a great place! I came here for a birthday party; we took over the entire restaurant. I tried their salad and mozzarella cheese sticks. Their pizza and chicken tenders looked great, too. I loved the friendly staff and the newly renovated inside of this place. I'll definitely stop back to try their pizza. read more

Went with a couple of good friends of mine to dinner, we were greeted as soon as we walked in by Claudia the owner . We ate Calamari Antipasto salad and Chicken Scarp and Chicken Parm wedge Food was Great Portions were Big and Service was Excellent. After Dinner was Over Claudia came out to to ask how everything was. Great Place! Franco read more

My new fave is firehouse pasta. You can switch out cavettelli for other pasta. I do Rigatoni...more surface area to soak up all the deliciousness! read more

The best Pizza in Harrison and probably all of Westchester! Same owners and staff for 40 years. They just did a beautiful renovation, without raising prices 25-30 percent, like the other restaurants in the neighborhood. Try it, you'll love it! read more

last night we ordered Chicken Scarpariello, pasta on side,, and an order of meatballs for take-out. The chicken dish was nothing like we are used to, made in a watery white sauce, which when packed had soaked the bag, paper plates. The meatballs were the worst......absolutely tasteless, dry, no seasoning - all bread. all of this sitting in my fridge....hoping to doctor it up. cost: $34 ! The marinara sauce was bitter, as though directly out of a can. We will not return. We ordered from them only bc of the convenience of walking down the street. There are quite a few excellent Italian restaurants in Harrison, from now on I'll drive gladly. Questioning f they've changed the cook. read more

My good friends are regular customers at this restaurants and I can certainly see why they like this restaurant so much. It is the kind of place that you would walk by and see as another pizza place but once you give it a try you are hooked. The seafood pasta dishes are delicious and the cheesecake is the best! The owner and the staff were so attentive and certainly going back! read more

Welcome back Vic!!! Best Pizza Best Pasta Vic and his crew take great pride in their restaurant- place is always spotless and pizza and pasta is as good as you will find anywhere... Best Veal Parmigiana around as well Prices are very reasonable as well - The restaurant is one of my favorites for sure read more

This used to be the best pizzeria in Harrison. Recently this was sold to new owners and the prices have sky rocketed. I understand inflation but $28 for grilled chicken and broccoli rabe is absurd. It's a shame because my family and I have gone here for 10+ years. Sorry to say but we'll be going elsewhere read more

The pizza here is ok. Don't order cannolis. We have ordered them on two separate occasions and both times they were HOLLOW. Just a bit of cream on the ends. Once is a mistake, twice is purposeful. Tried to support small business, but if they cut corners like this, no thanks. read more

What a neighborhood gem... right in downtown Harrison. The food is delicious, the portions enormous, the price very reasonable. Having said this our friend Henry Angelo is just the BEST, most friendly and greatest waiter anywhere ! TREAT YOURSELF as soon as possible. read more

Plain slice.. overcooked.. tasted like a slice I could find in Pennsylvania. So much hype, sad results. I'll give it a 5.6 out of 10. - respected pizza and cheesesteak reviewer. read more

So disappointed in the new expensive menu. Was my favorite family spot. Such a shame.

Very disappointed with the large sausage pizza that I ordered..Pizza was soggy and undercooked will not return

There are about 5 pizza places in Harrison. Sofia is best, since they have a great crust, fresh always hot pizza, gluten free options, and they don't burn there pizza like some other places in Harrison. My family always get the meals as well, which are flavorful and always delicious. And of course gent service is the best part of this place. The waitresses are awesome and always so friendly. Nothing to complain about here! read more

Average pizza joint. Prices seem fair some dishes not cooked properly. Wait staff very at tentative and friendly. Pizza guys seem annoyed anytime u ask for anything.. read more

Sofia's turned me into an Italian food lover. The house bread is AMAZING. Seriously, try it. We've been there several times now and there hasn't been a meal that wasn't just what we were craving. Even their basic house dressing is just right. Veal or chicken francese, penne and vodka sauce, classic garlic and olive oil over penne, shrimp parmigiana, meatball wedge, pizza. You name it, it is delicious. End your dinner with coffee and classic Italian desserts. Can't go wrong here. If you have a little one, they even give them some pizza dough to play with so you can enjoy your meal. Amazing family feeling. read more

Sofia's is a staple in Harrison (my home town) I have been coming to Sofia's since I was a baby! This is a restaurant that actually cares about serving quality food at a fair price. They make a delicious tomato sauce, meatballs, sausage, etc. I love love love coming here, and will continue to do so! read more

This place is head and shoulders above the average pizzeria. Food is really high quality. I had squid ink pasta with shrimp and it was excellent. Pizza also excellent. Tre leches cheese cake was out of this world. read more

I am very picky about pizza; this was the first place I got pizza from in Harrison when I moved here and I haven't felt the need to try anywhere else because I like Sofia's so much! Never eaten in, just done take out/delivery. Prices are reasonable, delivery is fast, food arrives nice and hot. No complaints! read more

Just had their focaccia on a whim and it was delightful. Super fresh tasting and the people running the place are personable and engaging. I'm new to the area & will come back often! read more

Literally the best pizza in America, and all their dishes are incredible. Every time I'm in the area I make sure to stop here at least twice. Alessandro and the staff do a top-notch job. read more

For the people who are looking to eat legit pizza come here, but be aware that you will get hooked on the Buffalo chicken pie for the rest of the night. Never drink and get tipsy it will lead you to eating 5 slices of pizza for the night. So stay away people if you don't want to get fat. Changed my mind go to this place and get a legit pie of Buffalo chicken or pepperoni and sausage pizza. The guy in the front when I first moved to the area is no longer there, they replaced him with another person who is really nice, attentive, and knows how to make a legit pie. So come on down to this place, we order a pie once a month here. Best spot to go too within the area, don't go anywhere else. read more

Great old school Italian red sauce and pizza place. Rating should really be more of a 3.5 but I have a soft spot for the Chicken Scarp so I round up. The place can be a little inconsistent but it usually ranges from ok to great so its worth a chance. read more

Sofia’s Pizzeria & Restaurant - Scarp! Hot or sweet, I recommend hot. - Italian Near Me - Harrison, New York

Sofia's is my go to spot! I eat there regularly. I love their entrees! Chicken Parm is yum yum yum as is their File of Sole Oreganta! The atmosphere is friendly and causal and the prices are fair. Give this hometown gem a try!!! read more

The pasta primavera was like they opened a can of mixed vegetables and poured it over the pasta. Nothing in our order looked homemade. Their eggplant is not crispy, so if that's your liking this isn't the place for you. I think Sofia has stock in garlic. Waaaaaay too much Disappointed in our order. read more

Love their Chicken Sofia! It's my go-to every time I go there. The food here is cooked well. The pizza is amazing. The staff is friendly and always very attentive. The owner is really nice and seems to be beloved by many in the community. read more

I Showed Up Early..... I Had To Wait But You Know What ....You Cant Rush A Good Pizza. Excellent 18" Cheese Pie.

I think I've found the best pizza in Harrison. I know that's a bold statement to make... but I have to go with it. Try a slice of Sicilian and I promise you will have to agree with me. I'm also a huge fan of the Chicken Parm and the Penne Vodka. The owners are always welcoming and smiling. It's great every time! read more

This was my 1st time ordering from Sofia's. I had penne vodka delivered after reading raving reviews! The penne vodka was great, the best I've had in the area. I will definitely order from Sophia 's again, and recommend to others. read more

The food here is so good. Very authentic Italian food. The spicy calamari was awesome! And the eggplant parm was perfectly cooked. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants authentic Italian food. read more

I keep on giving them a chance and ordering because everyone raves about them but received burned pizza the last time so nomore I give up. Have yet to find a good pizza place in Harrison everything is just ok. Not great but decent. When you are Italian and have had amazing pizza from Italy and a few places pizza does not compare read more

Love the carbonara. Portions are huge too. The only reason I am giving them three stars is because I found hair in my food twice already. Now I can't bring myself to go back :( read more

We just went to Sofia's for the first time. The pizza was great. Kids also loved the chicken roll and hot dog roll. Our waiter was terrific. We'll be back soon! read more

I am doing an update just to include a picture which I normally include but didn't for this review. Pictures are always helpful in these reviews. read more

Sofia’s Pizzeria & Restaurant - Large plain pie and salads - Italian Near Me - Harrison, New York

Ok pizza, not the best by NY standards by far, but a nice traditional pizzeria that reminds me of all the summers spent at Grandma's.

Guy behind the counter is far from friendly. I ordered a chicken roll, it was cold and I felt like i was not allowed to sit. Very unwelcome feeling. read more

So I came to NY to visit my boyfriend, and he goes on and on and on about this place. So I couldn't wait to try it when I got here. The pizza was seriously top notch. And I am very picky about pizza. I got the white pizza, with tons of ricotta and mozzarella cheese. Amazing. Cheese on cheese on cheese!!! Being from the Midwest, good pizza is hard to come by, and this place is sooooo good compared. We're going to return to try the pasta which I heard is also very good. Garlic knots and cannoli topped off our meal. Both absolutely delicious! I will most definitely return whenever I'm visiting! read more

This is my favorite local place in Harrison. Everyone is so friendly and the pizza and dishes are great! A must try!