Their grandma pies are legendary. We order them for work all the time and they always deliver

Ordered takeout - meat lovers and a grandma pie, we thought the meat combo was a bit salty but is to be expected when you're getting pepperoni and sausage. The grandma was good for that order. Second time ordered just grandma and the cheese had an odd smell and did not taste like mozzarella, tasted very old. The 4 adults tried it and then ended up throwing it out. We had to physically remove it from the house and put it into the trash it was that off-putting. Would not reorder. read more

Considering I received a small bowl of romaine lettuce chopped with 3 tiny slices of Parmesan it's awful that they charge $17.95 for this The pizza tasted like it was made this morning and heated up The crust was like cardboard Very disappointing read more

This is a restaurant, but I ordered quite frequently from but today I don't have any cash on me and all I want is a slice of pizza and they said no we have $10 minimum on credit cards. Now typically if this was my first time there I would understand that but I frequent them several times a month but not anymore. read more

Last Friday I was out late shopping and Google'd pizza and Al Dente popped up. I drove over there and although it was late, there were some really good looking sausage slices. I got one to go and while I was eating, I was thinking this is a really good slice. I wanted to get another, but it was now 10pm so they were closing. Went home and told my wife about this spot we need to try out. Fast forward to last night and it the pouring rain we took a 20+ minute ride out to Rye. Ordered a large pie over the phone for pick-up. The box felt light, but I put it on my backseat and drove him. Man what a terrible pie. It was thin, lacked cheese and was much smaller than what I remember last week's sausage slice to be like. This Al Dente pie was reminiscent of a Brooklyn "dollar slice". Pure garbage. never going back. read more

We ordered takeout and the pizza was bland and soggy. The pictures make it look better. Would not recommend.

Our favorite pizza in Rye. Yummy, fresh and deliver is always super quick. They also have great healthy salads and delicious penne a la vodka. Highly recommend. read more

We had a party of 10 out of towners looking for a local Italian place, and called about a reservations. She said don't worry, we'll seat you. We arrived and the table was set up, so a great first impression. The place is small, so we took up half the seating, but it looked like most of their business is take out, so no worries. The server was very busy handling both pickups and table service, but she wasn't phased, and was happy taking care of us. We ordered a couple salads, several pizzas and a couple bottles of wine, and had a blast. No complaints about the food. Overall a great experience. Bonus - there is an ice cream place across the street. read more

Good pizza, salad and the garlic knots! Also if you're like me and enjoy ranch with your pizza, they have good, thick and flavorful ranch ;)

Worst pizza I've ever had. Got a barbecue chicken slice. Cheese was awful and chicken was dry

I'd give zero stars if I could! Stay far, far away from this establishment. Went in 11/9/2022 afternoon for a single Sicilian slice. Noticed he had a fresh pie right from the oven. I pointed to it and said I'll have one of those. The man behind the counter said it wasn't cut yet and wouldn't budge on his stance. And proceeded to warm up a very old and tired slice that was not in full view of the customer. I got violently sick from this slice. It was not even edible! I could only stomach half the slice because it was loaded with salt. As if to cover up rancid cheese. The people who run this pizzeria are very dubious! I won't be back! read more

Nice pizza and reasonably priced, unlike most of the places downtown. Plenty of toppings and a nice, dry crust. Recommended.

I order from this place at least 5+ times a month. Consistently delicious. Order arrives on time and hot. Everything is perfectly cooked. Never a disappointment. Always totally satisfied. I'll keep ordering every chance I get. Love, love, love this place!!! read more

From Frank S. Owner Sorry for Your experience but like I told your husband with his review for The same issue, Please listen to anyone reading back your order because we could of fix the problem from the start. That's why we read it back. We gave you a $50 discount which I thought was Extremely generous for one dish. As for the 35-40 min deliver for a new pasta is because you live in Connecticut which is a 30 minute ride to get to you. I'm wondering how the rest of the food was , you never mentioned anything about the rest of the order? Sorry for the inconvenience. We are gonna keep putting a great product out for great people. Thanks again for your input. My answer: Thank you for your offer Frank. I do wish to point out that we 1) confirmed that we would be in your delivery radius. 2) Discussed IF a request to alter a dish COULD be accommodated and that it WOULD be accommodated before we proceeded with the order. They read back the removal of the ingredient. The rest of the order could not and will not salvage my opinion of the rudeness and lack of professionalism in resolving the issues at the time the order was placed. I wish your business well and hope that your staff learns from this and actually represents you better in the future. read more

Personally, I would give No Stars. My wife and I went there tonight (first time for me) to get three slices of pizza. First off, my wife is short and she couldn't see the selection on the top shelf. We she asked about the selection in one spot with at least two different types, she was told only one. This guy had to answer the phone, so Mr. Personality from the back took over. Inside of a few minutes, he argued and gave us snide/rude comments at least three times. Even I being taller, I couldn't see what was going on behind the counter and they gave us four slices, instead of the three we ordered, so when we were charged over $22, my wife questioned why? I asked the cashier how much are slices? His answer "I don't know..." and he turned and walked away. My wife opened the box and we saw four slices instead of three, we told them they made a mistake. This turned out to be Mr. Personality from the back's third snide/rude comment. We got money back for the extra slice, but walked out of there fuming...NEVER AGAIN!!! And they weren't even busy, so that could not be an excuse for their icky and totally unprofessional behavior... read more

Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant - the menu - Pizza Near Me - Rye, New York

Solid pizza joint - NYC caliber. They don't get too fancy. All ratios of pizza cheese crust are correct. Staff is nice and fairly pretty priced. We eat here at least once a week read more

This last year I have ordered several times from Al Dente. I find their Buffalo Chicken pizza with the blue cheese and celery to be excellent. However on 10/29/2023 I ordered a small plain pizza, an italian combo wedge and a chicken cutlet sandwich. I would be embarrassed to serve this food on this day. Pizza was tasteless, literally. The chicken was so thin and dry I actually thought it was the remnants of the breading in the grease of the pan. Lastly the italian combo was the worst assortment of cold cuts I ever observed on any sandwich where I thought I bought it from a dirty bodega in a run down city. Disgraceful to call this Italian food. read more

I ordered take out pizzas and they came out great and definitely one of top pizzeria in Rye! They were meat lovers for myself and margarita for my wife. read more

Menu, referred to be cashier, has old prices. Charged $40 for a pie with 5 toppings. Absurd

We LOVE Al Dente! During the whole pandemic we tried to keep our food ordering to a minimum but usually ordered here once a week. We always get the Grandma pie. My dad loves a good pizza and when my parents come for dinner they always request it - definitely a favorite of our family's. Their avocado salad with grilled chicken is really good also! Nothing bad to say about this place :) read more

Horrific food and even worse customer service. They Got a dish in our order wrong and we could barely get someone on the phone to discuss. We were told at first that the manager was "too busy." When we finally got him on the phone he was rude, aggressive and unapologetic. My food arrived not as advertised and was cold. Will never be eating here again, as there are much more deserving (not to mention tasty) restaurants during these trying times. If you misguidedly choose to eat at this establishment, Do yourself a favor and never order their $18 baked ziti. A 5 year old could do a better job. read more

Walked in on a whim as I had been shopping in the area. Old school Pizza joints have sort of been over shadowed by wood fired, fancier joints. One bite of Al Dente and I morphed back to being 12 again, biking up to our local pizza shop never disappointed with what a dollar would get us. At Al Dente, the crust was flavorful, chewy where it embraced just the right amount of sauce. The staff was welcoming, friendly in a natural, yet highly sarcastic, local sort of way. I not only got a great slice and a satisfied belly but made new friends along the way. If you are in the area, definitely stop by you won't be disappointed read more

I live in the Bronx. Some of the best slices in the state... I've had some of the best NY has to offer.. but let me tell you something about this.. Classic walk in, display is full of specialty slices. The cheese was as generic looking as can be but FAR from it. Came back the same day and had a margherita slice with some Garlic Knots. Once again. Amazing. If you want a Pizza night or a slice that is just gonna turn your day around, THIS IS IT. Kudos. You've won a lifetime customer Al Dente read more

Anyone who knows Rye and knows Italian food knows that Sunrise pizza is a Rye Institution. Unfortunately my grandson did NOT know this and picked up a pie and salads from here and brought them to our home. It was so awful we had to throw it out! Sugary sauce and soggy crust.... salads with MOLD ON THE TOMATOES!!!! Nobody I know goes here and now I know why. Disgusting. read more

Grandma pizza pretty good, stuffed mushrooms are one of the bests I've ever tried. 9/10 for the shrooms and 8/10 for the pizza. read more

Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant - Stuffed Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Rye, New York

I agree the food is good but the customer service side of the business is beyond horrible. I have been ordering from here several times a week for the last year. Tonight, I placed an order online and then called a minute later to make a change, they claimed Monday is a slow night and order is already made up (2 minutes after it was ordered) and there is nothing they can do. Then they gave me a list of issues with online orders versus over the phone (really, this is your business and you set it up this way). I agreed to just accept the order. Well, it is now over a hour since the discussion about a really slow night and I still don't have the food. I just called and they claimed it got super busy right after I called and only have 2 delivery people. They seem to have an excuse for everything. I would have given it a negative star review if that was an option. Never again. read more

Update: Read the other reviews, gave the pizza a shot. Went with a curveball, the "Vodkarita Pie". I'm not going to lie, very good slice. Also ordered the Cesar Salad, that was very good as well. Definitely get the pizza over the pasta here. Order came in a timely manner. Ordered a simple Pasta Primavera, vegetables were soft and mushy, scorching hot, and had little to no taste. read more

We ordered from Al Dente a ton in quarantine...their pasta dishes are very good and consistent- also very generous portions! Their other dishes have been underwhelming for us but if you are craving some carbs look no further! We've always had really positive experience with their takeout- it arrives hot, fresh and quickly. Will continue ordering them for futre. read more

Food is quite good if you eat in the restaurant. The take out service is not great. We order from them all the time and there is always something missing. When you pick up from them make sure your order is correct. I got take out last night and the pasta primavera had very little sauce. They don't give utensils unless you ask. I think they are quite busy and none of this is intentional. Still the best pizza and pasta place in rye read more

I was in White Plains on a business trip right before the pandemic and found this gem thru Yelp. The town of Rye is absolutely charming and this restaurant is in the most charming part of downtown Rye. I had the seafood pasta, chicken wings, and Caesar salad. All were excellent. I loved the small town vibe and the cozy ambiance of this place. read more

This is always my first stop when I visit New York. This little hidden gem is located in the town of Rye. Awesome selection of pizza, Italian dishes and salads. It's super casual, . Sunrise pizza around the corner has OK pizza, but they're very rude. The entire staff at Al Dente is very nice and they always make you feel welcome. read more

Al Dente Pizzeria & Restaurant - Huge selection of freshly made pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rye, New York

See all

The vodka slice is the best. Even my 7 years old is hooked. She will ask for it whenever we are in rye.

I took a shot in the dark when I originally ordered from this place because I work nearby but I can honestly say I've been pleasantly pleased with this place. My coworkers and I feel they are one of the best values for good old school Italian food. Excellent sandwiches and specialty pizza rolls. Their pizza by the slice is also very good. Considering that they are in Rye, the prices aren't too bad either. The service is very good here too. In the times that I've ordered from here, I've only experienced one mistake which they very generously corrected. In these times that kind of service is appreciated. read more

It's officially the 2nd worst pizza I've ever tasted in my life. Crust was stale, toppings were old and not seasoned. The first worst I've had was from Dominos in Port Chester . read more

Al Dente has by far and away the best food & pizzas around. Our favorites are penne vodka (daughters favorite) and chicken scarpello (husbands favorite) and my absolute favorite, the Sicilian Caprese hands down. We ordered, for Christmas, a six foot hero and a tray of Chicken Francese and Penne Vodka. All were delicious, with generous portions for a great price. I will be ordering for our Super Bowl Sunday get together. read more

Went to this place on a Saturday for lunch. Between two of us we split the lobster ravioli and the hot wings. Both were great options. The wings were just the right amount of crispy. The lobster sauce was delicious read more

Ordered from Al Dente this evening and this is about the 3rd time within the past 2 weeks. They have the most fresh, delicious pies & entrees. Delivery is ALWAYS on time and hot. The service is always amazing too. Thank you Al Dente for constantly going above & beyond to for your customers. We appreciate you & your hard work. read more

We tried three pies for delivery on Thanksgiving eve. Delivery took a long time, but we were warned, Best of the batch was a combo of sausage, pepper and onions, We also tried meatball, broccoli and pepperoni. The crust was thin and the sauce was on point, Toppings were fresh and savory, The large pies were only slightly bigger than the small. Better than most of the delivery pizza in this part of Westchester. It may become our new go-to, read more

Massive pizza slices and the cheese is on point. All the ingredients can be tasted rather than some pizza places in westchester

After living in Chicago on and off for almost 2 months I had my fill of deep dish pizza. Being back in New York I knew one of the things I craved was good ol' thin crust NY style Pizza. Though I was in Westchester county I figured I'd try my luck at a local pizza place instead of waiting to getting back to Manhattan or Brooklyn for my pizza fix. Small place, just a few tables, but the menu covers the basics plus more. From the front display you could see that they had at least 10 varieties of freshly made pizzas. Buffalo, classic Margherita, Ziti, Spinach, white, Chicken ranch and good old Sicilian pizza. I was pleased to see they even had gluten free pizza & pasta. Spying the menu they also had sandwiches & pasta entrees. I treated myself to a plain slice & the classic Margherita pizza. Let me just say that the pizza is fantastic. Sauce is not too sweet or acidic. The cheese was not overly oily. The crust was superb, crispy & not burnt. Staff was very friendly & attentive. Prices were more than reasonable. I look forward to visiting often and trying out more of their pizzas & entrees. Easily the best pizza in this small town. read more