This place has great pizza but the service left something to be desired. The ambiance is welcoming and well thought out and the beer selection is good but lacks your standard Coors and Budweiser products for the people that don't like craft or import beer. Out server didn't know the the menu, was rude, dismissive and not very attentive but the food made up for it. The mozzarella sticks were good and just needed a little salt. The salad was well out together and tasty. The pizza was amazing and you could task the quality ingredients. I would try this place again hoping for better service. read more

We came here for lunch on a busy Saturday afternoon. The place was suits and clean and fairly busy. Our server was attentive despite having several tables and our food arrived promptly. He had the chicken fettuccine Alfredo which looked delicious and he was quite pleased with it. I had the Cobb salad which was very substantial and meat heavy. I forgot to order the dressing on the side so my salad arrived at the table already dressed. Next time, I would probably order a different salad (more vegetables less meat) and dressing on the side. All in all, a great experience and I'm looking forward to my next visit. read more

It was our first time here and we were excited because we had heard great things. The waitress was sweet but we felt rushed into ordering. I asked her about the pizza that goes in the special oven, Napoleon style, I told her we were excited to try it. I ordered a margarita, garlic knots and the Italian sandwich. Once we received our food we were surprised to see the sandwich comes with something like "mini garlic knots". The menu does not state this, so we didn't know it came with it. I found it weird that the waitress would not tell us we are ordering an appetizer of something that comes with our sandwich. I would have ordered the bruschetta instead had I known. In addition, we enjoyed the pizza but it was not what we thought. Since it was our first time here we just thought it was their version of Napoleon style. Once the check came I noticed she had rung us up for the regular pizza. I inquired and she said she thought I wanted the other one. I told her that's specifically why I asked her about the STG. She awkwardly said, I don't know what you want me to do. The food was good, although I wouldn't get the garlic knots again, they were like deep fried donuts in garlic sauce. The Italian sandwich was very flavorful but I would substitute the spinach for fresh basil! I recommend this restaurant, I just wish the waitress would be more attentive. You would think if they have two different pizzas with the same name she would clarify with the customer which type they want. In addition, it would be nice to explain that the appetizer we ordered is very similar to the side that comes with the sandwich. I would have had an opportunity to try another dish on their menu. read more

See all

My husband and daughter dinner place every Wednesday for the past 2 plus years. They often go before church service, but if they can't make it before, they definitely go after. They love the thin crust pizza and the fact that they were able to their own toppings; the pizza sizes are definitely a plus. We don't like to waste foods, so the sizes are reasonable enough to where they can finished their foods and were filled for the rest of the night. read more

fast service on curbside pick up or dine in! the Demarco is always the choice! Best Pie Money can Buy! They now have the option for smaller sizes too! read more

Fantastic food with a great atmosphere. Pizza is amazing. Salads are fantastic. Garlic knots are the best I've ever had.

Great pizza great waiting staff!!! Ambience was awesome!!! It was Friday night rush and everything was still amazing!! Thank you

Love their food. And their service is great as well. Their spaghetti and meatballs are awesome.

If you like great pizza and environment, this is the place. I recommend the chicken pizza for those who trying to get away from pepperoni. And the service is great even with a large work crowd or just your family. read more

How about zero stars!!! We can ordered at Broken Arrow Brewing and waited an hour... no pizza. Totally crap service!!! They even made another delivery while we waited and the guy said he'd "check on it" ... still nothing. They had our name, order, and number... nothing. What total CRAP service!! read more

We stopped by on Mothers Day. Great server who was nice and on top of her game. The food took over an hour to get after we ordered... The server kept apologizing for the excessive wait. We waited but the couple next to us just left after an hour of waiting on their food. Once the food did arrive it was very good. It appears they we just very short staffed in the kitchen. read more

We were in from out of town visiting friends in Broken Arrow and had a fantastic order placed for carry out. It was ready when we got there. They had a carry out special for the Mayweather fight and it saved us big money. The pizza was super tasty and yes when we return to Broken Arrow we are stopping in to eat here. The staff was super friendly and awesome. So thank you to them. We enjoyed the 4 large pizzas we ordered! Respectfully, Bryan Moore Oklahoma read more

We come to this particular Andolinis because it has consistently good food, it is fresh and hot and is on time. The people at this location CARE. In today's crazy environment, that no longer seems to be the goal, so we appreciate Broken Arrow Andolinis. read more

Very tasty, but ridiculously overpriced. Get the Marzano sauce on whatever pizza you get.

Great pizza, but only come when you are hungry. Unique selection of Pizza. Wait staff hilarious.

Andolini's is one of my top 5 Pizza Places in Oklahoma and it is because of their signature pies. We visited the location in Broken Arrow and it is right in the center of the beautiful downtown area. They have really put a lot of effort into making Main Street an attraction of its own. It's really gorgeous with the flower planters and decorations and the shops. When you walk in - you are greeted with a large beautiful brick oven that looks like it's either wood fire or coal fire. It's a very traditional classic looking oven and a good accent to the location. Ando's as I've heard it called is a wonderful spot for some very good pizza. We ordered the Demarco of Brooklyn (basically a Margherita style pie with cheese, tomatoes, and fresh basil, but with freshly made mozzarella slices and topped with pecorino and olive oil). It's a very large, very filling, 20-inch pie that could easily serve 3-4 adults. The crust is very good - airy, yeasty, crispy, and holds up well to the tomato sauce and mozzarella. It is my favorite Margherita style pizza pie in Oklahoma. We also ordered a gluten-free Margherita which was absolutely amazing as well. The crust was crispy with a soft fluffy top. It was flavored with garlic and was completely the opposite of what you would expect a gluten-free crust to be like. Normally, the gluten-free crusts I try are very similar to the box they serve the pizza in but crispier and drier. It is usually flavorless, but the pizzaiolos at Andolini's are masters of the crust craft and they deserve every bit of five stars for the pizza alone. I would definitely go back to Broken Arrow for the pizza alone, it is well worth it and you get some nice scenery from the downtown area. read more

See all

Great service terrific food! Timely and friendly staff ! We had pizza,salad , and meatballs. Very good!!

Fantastic experience here! The margherrita pizza was SO yummy!!! We learned that San marzano tomatoes are the reason it's so good so we asked for that sauce on our other pizzas... very glad we did! Ambiance was great, server was very patient and personable! Great place and would go back if in the area, since we love brick oven pizza! read more

mediocre pizza I don't know why everyone likes it. I gave it a shot because my husband used to work at it, he told me it was good we both rode up to eat and he even said it went down in quality. read more

This is the best environment with amazing food and great service. Along with the fun of The Rose District, this is the place to be!

Honestly... pretty terrible overall! We had high hopes and it did not at all meet those hopes. When we came in we literally waited and waited and nobody even acknowledged us for several minutes and I had finally go to the wait staff farther down (they were huddled together and talking) and ask them if we could sit inside. The two men making pizzas didn't even look up to acknowledge us or let the wait staff know someone was here?! The Good: Food wise... really good pepperoni pizza (only) and salads. The mozzarella medallions appetizer was very good overall as well. The Bad: The $29 margarita pizza had HUGE open spaces where there was nothing but red sauce and zero cheese. It lacked flavor and was overpriced for the minimum toppings, lack of flavor and quality (maybe 6 basil leaves torn apart on the entire pizza). There was also a huge burnt piece of cheese or something underneath the crust The chicken fettuccine Alfredo was utterly ATROCIOUS! The sauce tasted sour like the milk was bad in it and the chicken was literally BOILED with ZERO flavor and not even salt! For $152.00 with tip I have to say we will NEVER be back! read more

We're never disappointed! Andolini's is amazing! Even as vegans, their Vegan Pizza and Vegan Calzone were delicious! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Garlic Knots at Andolini's Broken Arrow! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

A buddy wanted to get caught up with me as I've been out of town for 18 months and wanted to know where a good pizza place was in BA. So I told him to meet me at Andolinis in the heart of the Rose Distict. We decided on mid afternoon to miss the lunch bunch and beat the dinner crowd. I got there first and was seated immediately. Limited parking on Main Street. Maybe there's more behind the building. We did a medium Hal/half with their combo and veggie pizza. service was good and the pizza came right out from the oven, hot and tasty. We added Greek salads and couldn't eat all of the generous serving of pizza. A nice atmosphere and a good beer selection. I highly recommend. You can't go wrong here. read more

They need to figure out a better system for the wait list on busy nights. The young girls at the front were just writing first names and approximate wait times. We had been waiting for about 20 minutes and watched as the girl seated some people that had came in after us. This happened more than once.. The food was good and it's awesome that they offer a gluten free pizza crust that isn't just a cauliflower crust. read more

Best pizza in town and I can always rely on them for a nice dinner for my family! You really can't beat their quality and the staff is always friendly and detail oriented. read more

Easily my number one pizza please. Incredible portions incredible quality incredible staff. You may end up waiting a minute. If you don't plan ahead. They have a really good lunch special and their chicken Alfredo was surprisingly amazing. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. No matter what's going on it's always a great time for Andolini's!!!

We ordered the combination thin crust with basil (after cooking) and it was absolutely delicious. It was a 20" pie and fed three very hungry teenagers. Make sure you request no extra salt as sometimes they put some on as a type of garnish. As good as their pizza is I must say, their customer service is phenomenal. Last time we ordered takeaway, half the pizza was on the burnt side and they were incredible at rectifying the error, with the manager giving me his personal cell number. I highly recommend the Broken Arrow location. Fantastic food, great atmosphere and efficient takeaway without having to get out of your car! Delivery is done by Door Dash, and our pie was cold, but we warmed it up in the oven to be just like fresh and hot. I do not recommend delivery, but it comes through if you're tethered to the house. Better pricing on delivery through Andolini's web site too. Door Dash app is a spanking of an additional $5-$7 on "taxes". Thank you Mark and the Andolini's team for such a great pizza pie! Absolutely flavorful and very savory; in a league of its own for sure. read more

Large takeout order for a working lunch. Order was timely, staff was friendly and helpful, and the food was awesome!

Even if broken arrow is a little bit of a drive for you, swing out to main street and try the new Andolini's. I've visited all of them and this one is my favorite! The interior is very similar to the Cherry Street location except for no one is squeezing by your chair. This location is much more spacious with plenty of table, booth and bar seating. My husband and I are always looking for patios seating that isn't directly on the street or in the middle of the sidewalk. This Andolini's has a great off- the-sidewalk patio Area that's two tables deep and completely covered with an overhang. Great job guys and I haven't even started talking about the fantastic food! Of course Andolini's is known for their pizza but they carry so much more. Authentic items like, chicken Parmesan, mac & cheese (also offered gluten free), penne Pomodoro and sandwiches to name just a few. They also offer $5 kids meals and don't get me started on the unlimited pizza slices for $10! Just make the trip out here and support MainStreet, you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Great food and alternative to off the shelf pizza! Our guests enjoyed the feast as well. read more

Ordered what's become our favorite pizza from Andonlini's tonight for carry-out, The Peppa Pig. It never disappoints, and getting it to take back home was simple through the website. Initially I tried to order through the app, but that gives an error, but through an actual computer online is a pretty easy process. The pizza was ready a few minutes earlier than the time it said it would be which was great because I actually was able to get close parking. Got it home and enjoyed a couple slices from the comfort of our own home while trying to find something worth watching on tv. Even have a few slices left over for breakfast (yay!) read more

Do not order delivery from this place. Negative stars. The employees do not understand how to package food. I literally Just burned myself trying to get my food and it dropped out of cheap plastic bag and fell on the floor. Never never order from here!!!!!!!! read more

Our work group went for dinner on a Thursday night and it was busy. Try to beat the crowd but if you can't... they provide garlic knots while you wait. No request needed. The five top we had had all but one vote a 5/5! Pizza is delicious, bar is authentic, and even with the busy crowd we had our pizza in ten minutes! Voted best in Tulsa multiple years with the trophy case to prove it- if you need a pizza fix in Tulsa, GO HERE. Featured are the pizza rustica (right) and the roasted garlic (as is)(left). Split decision on which is better. I favor the rustica. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I'm currently sitting in the restaurant. I've been waiting an hour and a half for a pizza and 2 Stromboli's. This is the worst service I have ever gotten here. We've been trying to flag for our waitress for at least 40 minutes trying to at least get refills and another reason for why our food is still not here. *update: our waitress just told us our order was never put in and then keeping pushed back for to go orders. I will never come back again. read more

Terrible food and service I did not like the fact it was so expensive and the food was so gross so not recommend at all whatsoever and they took an hour to bring out my order read more

I ordered my pizza and meatballs from Andolini's online and had it delivered. The doordash deliverer couldn't find my house because her Google sent her out in the middle of nowhere so I called to tell them I didn't receive my order. They immediately started another order for me. Eventually the driver found my house and Andolini's cancelled the duplicate. Both the pizza and the meatballs were amazing. Good food, great service. read more

Great customer service!! Amazing pizza and pasta. The interior is pretty nice and clean. Would definitely visit again!

Service was incredible,food was delicious, and the establishment made me rather gay! My grandson had a gay time as well! The staff was incredibly diverse! I love this place and I like how it is run! Some employees should cut his hair! LOL!!!!! read more

Food was great. They have best gluten free pizza that you can get for the size and price. Went into the restaurant last week, had an issue, and the owner remedied the problem quickly. I ordered carry out last night and tried another one their pizzas. We will continue getting pizza from you guys. I do hope that next time we come in you will have a changing table in your bathroom for our baby. read more