I had seafood pasta but it was a little bit too rich for me. But it was delicious. Ambience was great with friends celebrating my birthday with me. I always loved Andria's but I miss the old Andria's. It was great for couples. But the food is still great. The staff make the place more charming. It's a must go place at least once in your lifetime. read more

Great steakhouse for special occasions if you don't feel like driving all the way to STL for Ruth's Chris. Hubby & I have came here twice and we loved it both times. Service is great which was as expected it would be, food is delightful, and the vibes give off romantic classy vibes. Recommend this place for a fancy date night, anniversary, and any other private celebrations. read more

Wonderful service, but way overpriced. The noise level in there is also too much. The lady at the podium that takes reservations stopped at other tables asking how their meal was, but never asked us and that is a huge peeve of mine. Waitress and other staff members were amazing though! We will not be back unfortunately. read more

Let's call this 3.5 stars. The experience we had on 4/30/22 could best be described as "uneven". Starting with the highs, the food was outstanding. I would give them a 5 for that except for one issue I'll outline below. We drove over 40 miles to try this place for the first time after hearing a lot about it. If I lived closer I'd say I'd come back from time to time. But I can get as good or better closer to my home in St Charles county so it will be rare for me to make this drive again. I liked the atmosphere and the setting too. Here's the uneven part. It started with the drink orders. I asked for a bourbon list. I was told they don't have one but I could go look at the bar to see what they have. I did that. The selection is lacking for this price range. I have a better bourbon selection at home. So I asked for a Sazerac which should be a staple at a fine restaurant. The bartender didn't even know what it was or what was in it. And they don't even have absinthe to make it. Ok, I settled for a Manhattan. It was ok. He generally struck me as not a top notch bar tender. Moving on to the meal. As I said the food was great. The salads, the rolls and the sides all were A+ At our table we ordered one rib eye, medium rare, one fillet medium and the daily special tenderloin kabob, well done. They came out as follows: rib eye, medium well, fillet very rare and kabob medium at most. The fillet was so rare that it had to be sent back to be finished. This is a steak house, people, they should be able to get this detail right. My only other quibble with the food is there were no croutons on any of the salads. A house made, really great crouton would perfectly top a great salad. A miss in my opinion. Overall the service was about as good as it seems you can typically get in this post-pandemic world. Water was always full although for some odd reason every time they filled my wife's they filled it all the way to the very brim, making it impossible to take an initial drink without dribbling. Our waitress was occasionally MIA although I'm not grading too harshly for that. The real knocks on this place were the mediocre bar service and steak temps. That's enough to make it not worth the drive too often. If you live close by though and haven't tried it, do so. You will have a delicious meal, eventually. read more

I have dined here many years ago, before Yelp and it was good back then. Hubby had been craving prime rib for like forever so he suggested Andria's. I never argue when I get to eat so I said sure! We were there right when they opened so we were the first diners of the evening. We were seated at a booth in the back. I had forgotten what a lovely restaurant this is. It's a bit fancy and romantic without being overly fussy. We weren't dressed properly for this place, I had on shorts, but they didn't turn us away. I would definitely dress up a little bit next time. But, we were so early I don't think it mattered that much. We had our little guy with us who loves shrimp. We ordered the garlic Shrimp appetizer. He ate every piece and said it was great! They brought out a basket of rolls and they were hot, straight from the oven! He was wanting a hamburger, but it wasn't on the menu, so I asked and they were kind enough to make him one. Now that's wonderful service! It was huge and he loved it! My salad was excellent, with lots of different types of lettuce, red onions, croutons and tomatoes. I had the small filet and as I savored the amazing taste, it brought back memories of when I was here before. Their steaks have a distinct taste because they use their special sauce. I love it. Hubby of course got the prime rib and thank goodness he ordered the small, because it was huge! It was cooked perfectly and he enjoyed every bite! Our server was attentive and friendly. We couldn't have asked for a more wonderful dining experience! I was so happy hubby was craving prime rib! The desserts sounded amazing, but we were all too full. Maybe next time! read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Filet - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

We went to Andria's because in the past we had some of the best steaks ever. This time since it was for one of our birthdays we splurged a little more because we were expecting great quality food. We were very disappointed. I had lobster and steak and was extremely disappointed. The lobster had to be microwaved and tough as hell. I have had better lobster on a $10 buffet line. The waitress was gone for long periods of time and was not very attentive when she did show up. This place used to be nice and have great food. Save your time and money and go to any other higher priced place to get your streak. read more

So you'll have to excuse this post since I didn't order a steak of any sort. My hubby commented that the rib eye tasted really good. It's definitely better to order with the sauce being cooked with. He ordered his rib eye with a baked potato; he made a comment that the sides and the options were basic. I ordered the shrimp which had a jalapeño bread crumb. It was good. Not the best because it was kind of greasy. It wasn't overdone though thankfully. I didn't taste any kick from the jalapeño that I thought I would sadly. The fries I ordered with it was so salty I couldn't even eat it without brushing them off with my fingers. Don't get me wrong I like my fries salted but I felt like I was just eating pure salt. Thank you for doing the main thing well- the meat (according to my hubby). I wish the sides could be done better with a little more finesse. read more

We've been dining here for around 35 years. It's always been delicious. They have the best prime rib I've ever eaten, and, I find myself comparing others to theirs. Since we live a couple hours away, we don't get to dine here often, but it's always a treat when we do. If we're in the area for a show, Andria's is a must. On the most recent visit, we brought friends with us, so they could enjoy Andria's as well. It was their first time, and they enjoyed it very much. One had shrimp, one had salmon, one had noodles and one of us had prime rib. We all had salads and shared an order of toasted ravioli. It was all delicious and service was great, as well. read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Prime rib, baked potato, asparagus. - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

Delicious food and great customer service. Perfect for special occasions. Our waitress even heard us mention a birthday and brought us a delicious little piece of cake to share. read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Complimentary cake for my husband's birthday! We didn't even mention it, our waitress just overheard and surprised us! - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

See all

It was awesome. this was the smaller, 14 oz prime rib.... it's as I remembered. It was butter soft and no kidding, really pulled away with a fork. My husband and sister in law both ordered 16oz sirloins and they both loved theirs as they both remarked how perfectly grilled as they to ordered. After such large pieces of meat we each ordered dessert which is a bit of a departure for us... we generally don't order desserts or just order 1 and share. Well we got a slice of cheesecake, a Heath bar caramel cake, and a Fudge brownie a la carte...mine. It was also the best! The place is so close to home and yet we don't make it here very often. The steaks are so good I don't think we can stick to our diets if we come too often. Although it is a little pricier than other chain steak houses, it is definitely better and the serving sizes are larger. It's definitely worth every bit. The only downside I'm going to add was that the service was a little disappointing. Others might disagree...and there's a good reason. We were served our food about at the same time as the two tables that came quite a bit after us.... they probably thought the service was great. read more

See all

Great prime rib. kabobs are awesome Generous cocktails Good options on the wine list at reasonable prices. Have been going for special occasions for many years. Rose is outstanding read more

I don't know what else anyone can say about Andrias that could be more honest than this is the steak joint in our area. Not sure if it's world renowned but it's famous around here for first dates and anniversary dinners just a class act and don't forget to take a bottle of steak sauce home with you so you can always have a good reminder of your best steak you can remember read more

Overpriced! No complaints about the taste of the food. It was just so over priced. It was ridiculous.

Yes, yes, YESSSSSSS. I'm a serious Andria's fan. You get what you pay for. Andria's is not cheap. But the food is worth it. This is where I go when I want Prime Rib. Give it a shot... and be hungry when you get there! read more

My husband and I had our first date at this restaurant. We loved it. Tonight was our 10th wedding anniversary so we chose to eat here as it was a sentimental place. My husband had made a reservation and told them it was our anniversary. They acknowledged us and told us Happy anniversary. The dining room was not crowded, they were not at a peak level of business. I ordered the Beef Romanoff. My first bite was from the middle and it was cold - like from the refrigerator cold. I kindly sent it back. No problem just heat it up please. It was brought back to the table but by then my husband was done eating so I asked them to box it up. They boxed up my entire entree portion. We were charged full price - again, no problem. We tipped generously. The people behind us were also celebrating their wedding anniversary. They received a cake as we were leaving. I also talked to a friend that celebrates their anniversary and they were also given a cake. When we got home I realized there is NO WAY they boxed up my entire portion. The styrofoam container is soo small. We were agreeable about the food being served subpar. We were agreeable about being charged full price. What did we do to deserve being treated badly? read more

Andria's Steakhouse - The clear lid is supposedly my entire entree I wasn't able to eat with the rest of my party because it was served cold. - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

This is our favorite steak house. Great food. Great service. Try to go every couple in months. Make sure you try their filet!

I just had an amazing dinner experience with my BFF at Andria's! It was worth crossing the Mississippi River, most definitely! I love that the restaurant is close to the stores in O'Fallon / Fairview Heights, but that it's set back off the interstate just a bit, hidden behind a veil of trees and greenery. It's an oasis after the hustle and bustle of shopping at the mall. Upon arrival we were immediately seated by the hostess. Hot bread and butter appeared in the blink of an eye, along with ice water. At that point, we looked around and the ambiance is quiet, classy, a bit old fashioned, but nice inside the home turned restaurant. We asked the hostess if we could sit outside because the weather was simply superb today, and she said while they currently weren't seating out there, she would check. Within a couple minutes, we were whisked outdoors to the patio to a cloth covered table set with china! It was amazing out there! If you can finagle it and the weather's nice - go for it! There's relaxing recorded music piped outside (acoustic guitar during our meal), and at our September visit the serenading music of cicadas. It was a perfect outdoor dining experience! Wait it gets better... The meal was awesome. The house salad was delicious - fresh greens, mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, olives, red onion, and their house balsamic. BFF and I both had the deliciously tender ribeyes with their house marinade. I had one of the best baked potatoes I've ever had - perfectly baked and oh so fluffy; and the bestie had the crispy and tasty fried zucchini. We split dessert - the lemon berry mascarpone cake, which was amzaeballs!!! It had real blueberries in the cake, and this light lemon flavor. The middle filling of mascarpone was just the right touch of decadence, along with the drizzle of red berry sauce. We were tempted to lick the plate, but some how we maintained our composure. While the Yelp page says it's a classy joint - and it is - attire is all over the place. Some people were dressy. We were in jeans, tennis shoes, and comfy casual. The servers and hostess made us feel completely welcome. Service was actually very, very excellent - especially considering the fact we were unexpectedly outside. It would have been easy to ignore or infrequently check on us. The servers were really perfectly attentive. This restaurant just became one of my favorite steak houses!!! read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Ribeye & baked potato. Steak had fantastic flavor & the potato was the fluffiest-amazing good dinner! Excellent service! - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

See all

We have been going here for the prime rib since 1981. We ordered our meat medium rare and seared. The service and prime rib were always excellent. Salad and baked potatoes were very good always. The prime rib is best tasting and flavorful beating other restaurants in both bị states. Keep up the good food! read more

Andrias is the best steak house by all means in the St Louis area. We have been enjoying dinners there for years. Special occasions, holidays, or like last night on 2-21-23 just went to have a great meal. The food the wine it's all top shelf. The staff is the greatest. Larry, Maureen, Max and Rebecca, always are so welcoming and friendly. The entire staff of servers and helpers are first class all the way. If you have not tried Andria's please do, you will have a great dining experience. Jim and Karen Greenwald Granite City, Illinois read more

My wife and I went here for our 10th wedding anniversary and it was perfect! We both ordered the filets and they were so good! This might have been the best cut of steak I have ever had. The service was very friendly. The waitress was very attentive and kind. I look forward to returning soon! Until then, I frequently use their steak sauce. It's great to marinate beef in. read more

We've come here several times, and I get that "covid" has been an issue, but we have shown up without reservations several times. Had no idea that reservations were mandatory. The hostess didn't even try! Don't waste your time! Porter's in Collinsville is worth the drive!! read more

Andria's is a nice, old school steak house. We don't have many places like it on the IL side of the river. However, for how much you pay for the food, I would rather drive across the river to get better quality food. The pros: - They make their ranch in house, and it's delicious! - The pepper steak sauce is awesome. My husband ordered this on special and I wish I would had done the same. It did wonders for the steak. The cons: - Slow service. Our server did apologize, but it was suuuper slow. - Slightly over cooked steaks all around. - I think it's over priced. The steak isn't bad by any means, I just think there are better places to get a good steak dinner, even in Illinois, especially considering how much you pay here. read more

Good food and good ambiance!!! Quaint surroundings! Will definitely go back!!! Very friendly staff and in a beautiful surroundings!!!

Located in an old farmhouse in Fairview Heights, Illinois this restaurant is a hidden gem. We have eaten at Andria's approximately seven or eight times now. Every time the food has been excellent. I highly recommend any of the steaks or the salmon. The steaks are huge and always cooked to perfection. The fried ravioli are very good and I highly recommend them as an appetizer. The service has been very good to outstanding for all of our visits. read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

See all

We had a fabulous time at your lovely restaurant! We had a family gathering and a continued birthday celebration for my husband's 95 year year old uncle.....the food was yummy and a special time was had by all read more

Great settling. We are inside but I would come back and eat outside in fall or spring. The turnover was excellent. Highly recommend. The salads were pretty good but not super memorable. The steaks were very good. The sauce is excellent we bought some and use it at home. Our server was new I think, I hope. She was awkward and not what we expected of the venue and prices. She wasn't very familiar with the menu, or wine. read more

Apparently this is suppose to be a top of the line restaurant for steak. I've had much better. Over priced steak dinner with outback steak house quality/taste. The twice backed potato was gross. Idk how you mess up a baked potato but they sure did. Staff was nice. But that didn't cover up the nasty/ mediocre food served read more

I've heard lovely stories about Andrias steakhouse and have always looked forward to trying it for myself. That's the most disappointing birthday meal I have ever eaten. The food was cold and bland the broccoli was not palatable by any means. The ribeye was served rare which is usually fine by me but it was my husbands and he prefers medium rare, I could barely chew the tough meat. I had the salmon with dill sauce and it was okay but also served cold. I have no idea what the fuss is about and we will not be back nor will we tell anyone else to go to this restaurant. read more

Great atmosphere, excellent food, and even better service!! My first time and it exceeded my expectations! Can't wait to come back!! Worth every penny! I devoured my entree and didn't even get a photo! Prime rib is amazing! read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Clam Chowder Soup - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

See all

Wow. If you haven't had the pleasure ...,, you are missing out. What a gem. Great food great outdoor seating , and even better service. Rose read more

I must say I was ready to be blown away by this place based on the reviews, but I wasn't. The food was fine, but it was just a regular fillet, salad and veggies. I liked the old house. But we were treated by the hostess like we were second class citizens and we must have got lost on our way to the local burger joint. We probably wouldn't go back. read more

We took our daughter and son in law there to celebrate and was totally disappointed. Waitress messed up the order and when she delivered the correct steak, it was served on a plate of grease. This told me that it wasn't grilled , just out in a pan with oil and fried. Very upsetting that you spend over $300 on a meal for your family to say they will take it home and feed it to their dog. Waitress never came back to ask how about the meal, just dropped bill off. Discussed with hostess and expected a call from the owner and that never happened. If you want an excellent steak with phenomenal service, take the drive to Popeyes Chophouse in st. Rose, Il. Your puppy WON'T be eating steak that night!! read more

Wow, this place used to be great but the last time I went it was not a good experience. I actually asked to return my side because it was prepared poorly read more

Six of us visited a few months ago, on our way home from St. Louis. The recommendation to eat here was a good one. I thought that the Lobster Turnover was particularly delicious. On the Salad, the Roquefort Dressing very creamy and flavorful. I had the Small Filet (8 oz), which was beautifully cooked and tender. The Baked Potato was large, flakey, and creamy -- hard to imagine how it could have been better. They served a good Iced Tea, which was refilled frequently by the wait staff without prompting (yay!). For desert, I had the Strawberry Rhubarb Crisp, served with ice cream. This was quite a treat, as our own rhubarb plant has been allowed to grow unhindered by picking for pie or crisp or any other such rhubarby delight for several years (until this Spring!). For a side, we had mixed veg, prepared to good level of doneness and with good flavor. My wife reports that her Sirloin was also quite good. I'm not much of a coffee person, but the Coffee here was (we all thought) nice, mellow, and flavorful, without the nasty burnt bitter taste that one often gets at many places that should know better. read more

The restaurant is closed, drive across town only to be extremely disappointed by poor communication

Our first visit. We wanted to like it, (went here on my birthday) but sadly Andria's didn't live up to the hype of the reviews we'd read. Hot Rolls= sorry you may try but this mouth can spot bread that's been "nuked" (microwaved for those not familiar with the term) a mile off! At least real butter. Appetizer: We wanted to try the lobster turnovers and were advised no we have bacon& Blu Cheese turnovers= Greasy and VERY salty (coming from someone who likes salty foods!) (Sidney street STL has/had amazing lobster turnovers) Salad= while the dressing is a wine vinaigrette style and tasty, not my fave and over all the salad was missing something, oh yes any sign of a pesky protein in the way of cheese or meat was missing. Side= We both skipped the spud and went for the fried zucchini, but before we did we asked the waiter "are those made in house or frozen?"...we were told made in house, well for anyone whos actually HAD homemade breaded/fried zucchini AND have had frozen these were very Obviously frozen with a factory batter! Steak=We both chose the "16oz" Ribeye (I buy lots of steaks and this was not even close, more like 10-12max) Char Grilled is good, but our steaks were not only lacking flavor in a big way but were tough ta boot! The steak in no way tasted like it had been in marinade or seasoned at all. While one would appreciate the touch of a little cake with a candle for a birthday this had to quite frankly be the sadest looking/tasting piece of cake right outta the freezer earlier in the day ever. Again sadly we left feeling like we had dropped north of a Benjamin for a meal on the level of the old Ponderosa Steak House. Some people in the area like it. To each his/her own! Needless to say we won't be rushing back! read more

Wow why'd it take so long to try this place.....? There's hope folks in the Ofallon / Belleville area! You can find a GREAT STEAK!!!!!! Andrea's does it all well - salads that are chilled and not wet, fantastic steaks, one of the best baked potatoes I've ever had, with good service from a prompt staff. My wife had a stroganoff kind've dish that rocked, and I did the small strip that was more than enough. No room for apps but next time for sure. IF YOU ARE IN THE MOOD FOR STEAK YOU NEED TO TRY ANDREA'S. read more

See all

I am an Andria's fan, but my last two trips were not up to par. Excellent service, salad, bread but my prime rib was gristly each time. The person with me said his was not, so maybe it was luck of the draw. Twice? I'm going back to the filet. read more

The salad with house dressing was EXCELLENT, the rolls perfect to sop up the dressing left on the salad plate, the filet mignon superb, and the fried zucchini a different and tasty side. The Bloody Mary though, was just okay. Bummer. read more

Andria's Steakhouse - Filet, to DIE for! - Steakhouses Near Me - O Fallon, Illinois

Always amazing. One of the few great places where they know how to cook a steak, pair a wine, and you can count on the consistency and knowledgeable staff. Never rushed or overwhelmed, you definitely are paying for quality! read more