Cancel

Open app

Search

Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown

4.2 (43 reviews)
Open 11:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

Order Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown Takeout or Delivery

Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown Photos

Business Info

ANDY’S PIZZA - GEORGETOWN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Pizza
Camilla Y.

We casually stumbled on this place after always wanting to check out the Old Town Alexandria location. Tried the pepperoni and margherita pizza slices. They were great and came out fast. Service was super friendly. Given how popular the place was, we were surprised how clean it was. Great addition to the Georgetown area.

Saha S.

We came here after watching a movie in Georgetown, and it really hit the spot. The slices were a bit thin but very crispy. They also had big jugs of lemonade which were very flavorful.

Michael O.

I've been to this location a number of times and the pizza is great in terms of consistency. I just ordered the chicken wings and it was a disappointment. There were a couple of wings that were undercooked and I didn't eat them. Make sure to ask when to place the order to ask them to make it crispy otherwise what I got is probably the default. Also when this place gets packed it's hard to maneuver since it's a narrow area. This is not an issue when it's empty but definitely will impact your experience especially if sitting on the high tables.

Half chicken half pepperoni
chelsea d.

It wasn't great it wasn't bad . The customer service was good the vibe was cool too . Unfortunately my first pizza came out burnt but did they remade our order! Unfortunately it is a bit of wait but it would prob be really good for a late night option.

Two slices plus a coke deal and a side ceasar salad.
Tyler E.

If you crave pizza and you're on a budget oh boy is this place for you. A singe slice of pizza is around $4.50 or you can get two slices and a coke or two slices and a miller lite for like $10 to $11 bucks. I went with the two slices plus a coke deal and grabbed a ceasar salad from the fridge which was $9. The pizza is pre made and the staff will quickly heat it up after you order so the wait is almost non existent. The inside is small but the ambiance is very nice. I could see myself studying in here, which many people were.

EriCKa C.

Best pizza Best service Coolest ambiance Greet lunch staple in Georgetown Andy is wanting with this restaurant. I'm so happy to have a place that's close to my job. !!!

Burnt dry and stingy cheese pizza
Ciara B.

I drove 30 minutes to Andy's last night only to open a burnt $25 box of pizza (taped shut). I called immediately and explained the issue. I even offered to send a photo, but Maria told me they could remake it and said she'd leave a note for the day shift. I called back the next day to confirm, only to be told Maria isn't a manager and they needed to "check with the manager." Then another girl got on the phone questioning me like I didn't know what burnt pizza with thin, burnt cheese looks like. The replacement pizza was never made, and the customer service today was terrible. I'm visiting the area, and this was not a good experience and definitely not a good representation of the restaurant. I didn't eat this charcoal pizza, and I definitely won't be returning. Save yourself the trouble and don't go here. Rude and unreasonable. The entire pizza was burnt. It tastes like dollar pizza in New York no the $1 in NYC is better than this!

Buffalo Crispy Chicken Slice
Eliza O.

Very good spot with reasonable prices. I loved the variety of pizza slices and the location is great. It gets packed quickly, but the pizza and service make up for it!

Jamie B.

Andy's is hands down my favorite pizza spot in the DMV, the customer service is always excellent and of course the pizza is delicious. I especially love they have great deals if you just want 2 slices and a beer. The restaurant is always clean. Highly recommend!

See all

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Best pizza in Georgetown by far. Georgetown has been needing an Andy's location and we finally have one!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown

Review Highlights - Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown

Andy's is hands down my favorite pizza spot in the DMV, the customer service is always excellent and of course the pizza is delicious.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 38,772 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Timber Pizza - Petworth

Timber Pizza - Petworth

4.5(626 reviews)
3.3 miPetworth
$$

Cute little place that was all decorated for the season…read more This was our first time here & we had heard a good buzz about the place so we were excited to try it out & hankering for some good pizza. We arrived 20 minutes to closing, not realizing their hours, but they were open & it's pizza & cooks fast. Yet it was abundantly clear they were hoping no one walked in & we were told they were closing so we asked if we could order and they hesitated. We were about to leave when they said yes. We were a party of three & ordered three pizzas to share & try. They were decent and the other two really liked the dough but I actually did not care for it. They staff cleaned around us including at our table & had their music going. Then they sat on the counter and watched us, lol. Not a fun experience & we would not have bothered them had we known. If you are open then you are open, otherwise close up early. No real desire to go back!

Was so hungry the last time we went in, we forgot to take pictures of the pizza…read more This pizza is so yummy but their salads are also so good you almost forget you're eating a salad. They usually rotate a seasonal selection of salads so you know what you're getting is fresh and in season. For pizza, it's always so hard to just choose one or two kinds. But no matter what you decide on, you won't be disappointed. Personally, I'm a one pizza per person kinda gal, but these are for sure shareable and the ambiance is very relaxed and the staff is very nice and willing to make recommendations. A great staple in this area!

Photos
Timber Pizza - Petworth - Bar

Bar

Timber Pizza - Petworth
Timber Pizza - Petworth

See all

Tatiana Pizza - Unique jumbo slice

Tatiana Pizza

4.4(109 reviews)
1.1 mi

Pizza.slices were fantastic. Bigger than NY and the flavor was so good…read more Customer was great too. 32 or 34 inch pizza was super impressive as well.

We chose this spot because it was just a very short walk from the Hilton DC where we were staying…read morefor National Police Week. When we first walked in, the cashier immediately apologized for the long wait times, thanked everyone for their patience, and let us know they were incredibly short staffed with only two people working. Because the tiny interior was already packed, we decided to leave and do some sightseeing first. However, seeing how good the pizza looked we knew we had to come back later that afternoon. There's no negative details in my review. Nothing but positive things and a small recommendation. 1. Staff and Service I really appreciated the cashier's honesty about running behind right off the bat. That allowed us to make an informed choice rather than get frustrated by a long wait. More businesses could learn from this! 2. Restaurant's Layout The inside is a bit tight and busy, but it's located in a smaller older building, so they have no other options. Since they can't expand the inside adding an outdoor pub height counter for eating, a bench or some seating out front would be a great way to give waiting patrons a place to sit. Also a place to eat. 3. The Pizza -The Veggie Pizza: My nephew and I both ordered this, and the slices were massive you'll see in my pics! They were honestly the largest slices I have ever seen! I love pizza and have eaten it in New York and Chicago, and my slice here held its own. It was loaded with a huge variety of vegetables. I requested to put mine through the oven twice to get the veggies warm and cooked because I noticed my nephew's slice looked like a warm salad on crust. So happy I did because it was delicious! The jalapeños were intensely spicy which is on me, since I'm a bit of a lightweight with spice! -The Meat Options: My son got the pepperoni and thought it was really good, and my husband got a supreme slice which he also said was good . 4. Price and pizza size- they're more expensive than a typical slice, but once you see those big ole slices in my pics you'll understand why. They can't even fit on a plate. They had to serve them to you in an actual pizza box! After reading my long review you're trying to find out if I would go back huh? Absolutely! If I ever in the area or stay at the Hilton DC again, I would definitely walk right on over and get a slice. You can feed a family of three on one slice! Adult and two small children!

Photos
Tatiana Pizza - Size of pizza/prices

Size of pizza/prices

Tatiana Pizza - Toppings on top of toppings!

Toppings on top of toppings!

Tatiana Pizza - Made a normal slice from my gargantuan slice

See all

Made a normal slice from my gargantuan slice

Grazie Nonna - Green Goodness

Grazie Nonna

4.2(793 reviews)
1.5 miDowntown
$$

We celebrated a friend's birthday at Grazie Nonna, and it couldn't have been a better choice! From…read morethe moment we sat down, we had such a wonderful experience. Our server (I believe his name was Anthony) was fantastic. He was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, answered all of our questions, and even suggested cocktails based on what we liked. His recommendations for both drinks and food were spot on. He was patient while our group made decisions, attentive throughout the meal, and made the entire experience feel effortless. The food was outstanding. The Caesar salad was honestly one of the best I've had in a long time; fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We had to try the famous Drunken Love pizza, and it absolutely lived up to the hype! We also shared several pasta dishes, with the Cacio e Pepe being the clear favorite at our table. Of course, we couldn't skip dessert. We ordered the cannoli brownie, tiramisu, and cheesecake, and every single one was delicious. The tiramisu was the unanimous winner, but the cannoli brownie deserves a mention! It is incredibly rich and packed with flavor in every bite. Between the amazing food, excellent service, and fun atmosphere, Grazie Nonna made our birthday celebration one to remember. I'll definitely be back and can't wait to try more of the menu!

Really wanted to like this place, but unfortunately our experience was disappointing…read more My wife and I ordered the chicken Alfredo to share. The Alfredo came out, but the dishes were missing the chicken. It took a few minutes to get our waitress's attention, and she let us know the chicken had been forgotten and put the order in. We decided to wait rather than eat the pasta without the chicken, figuring it would only take a couple of minutes. Instead, it took about 10-15 minutes for the chicken to arrive, and by then our Alfredo was ice cold. The waitress apologized and put in a new order of pasta, but that also took quite a while. When it finally arrived, it came without the chicken, while the original chicken that had arrived late was now cold as well. At that point we didn't even eat the meal. The waitress said the replacement pasta was "on the house," which was a strange thing to point out since it was replacing a meal that was prepared incorrectly. To make matters worse, when the bill arrived, we were still charged for the original Alfredo and the added chicken. Unfortunately, this experience left us frustrated, and we left without enjoying the meal we came for.

Photos
Grazie Nonna - View from the pizza bar

View from the pizza bar

Grazie Nonna - Drunken love

Drunken love

Grazie Nonna - Vodka sauce pasta with chicken

See all

Vodka sauce pasta with chicken

Andy’s Pizza - Georgetown - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...