Annamaria's Deli is on Point!! It reminds me of the must go to sandwich shop in Rome Italy called "All'Antico Vinaio" restaurant... it's a neighborhood hood sandwich shop that also sells limited Italian groceries too. There's many sandwich styles to choose from and I had the Anna Maria and it was excellent. The fresh meat cut for your sandwich is piled on and the other ingredients speak for themselves as the flavors keep you wanting more. I asked if I could change the hot pepper spread for the sweet "No Problem ". The service is top notch! I don't think you can get any closer to the taste of a sandwich in Italy so this is the next best thing. Make sure to stop by and find out what's your new favorite sandwich! read more

See all

The Annamaria and Anthony sandwiches were delicious. The ratio of good quality bread to protein is balanced. Will surely try other items next time. read more

See all

This is hands down a place you need to try if you want an Italian sandwich, I've had 3 different sandwiches from this Italian deli and I have not been disappointed yet. In fact I've been impressed. The guys that work behind the counter are friendly and make a mean sandwich, they keep the line moving and the food tasting good. The Anna Maria is a must try. The tuna salad with the spicy peppers is good too. read more

Annamaria's Deli - Tuna salad with the hot peppers - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

YUM! My friends and I stopped at this deli before going to a Giants game and it was such a good stop! They have a variety of breads and preset sandwich options plus the ability to make your own. The focaccia and ciabatta breads were yummy and they are so generous with loading up the sandwich. Everything was delicious and prices ranged from $15-17 which was great! The guys working were nice and the service was fast. The deli itself was very cute and it seemed like a popular stop. read more

Annamaria's Deli - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Wow, this was such a cool little deli. The staff were friendly and the ingredients were all fresh. They had a variety of bread to choose from and a huge menu of sandwiches. I ordered the Lidia and my copilot ordered the Napoli. We both ordered them just how they make it and we ate them on the flight home a few hours later. My sandwich was delicious and massive. Both of us only ate half of it and brought the other half home with us. My copilot had the focaccia bread and it definitely got soggy by the time he ate it but that's not their fault. The oil/balsamic is so delicious that it's a must, just know it might get soggy the longer you wait. We will definitely be back! read more

Annamaria's Deli - The Lidia - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Hands down one of the best sandwiches i ever had. Bread was amazing and fresh, chicken cutlet was perfect. You will not be disappointed, give it a try . read more

Great place right up the block from my house. I usually get food Togo, and have never had a sandwich I didn't like. They have so many options, and you can customize the sandwich with toppings of your liking. I love the olive tapenade they make. So fresh and delicious. read more

If you want a sandwich loaded with meat then you need to come here! Ordered an Annamaria and Patsy with mortadella added, Louie, and a Napoli. All were great, but my Patsy was the fave. Salami and mortadella added, fresh mozz, marinated artichoke pieces and olive spread. Can't beat pricing either as mine was $11 and could only eat half. My only suggestion is to ask for oil and balsamic to be put on the side if you plan on eating them later so the bread doesn't get soggy or arugula wilted. The Louie was a bit confusing as we were expecting real roasted chicken breast more like a grilled cutlet and it comes prepared more like deli sliced Turkey. Otherwise overall enjoyed! It was our first time ordering and I seriously want to try the Nonna and one of the Italian tunas. read more

See all

Food is high quality and delicious. It would be helpful if the services would allow you to order drinks

Really good Italian sandwiches, we got the lidia and a ham and cheese sandwiches; very fresh ingredients, nice ambiance, and really good costumer service; you can make your own sandwich too. read more

Annamaria's Deli - LIDIA - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Everything was absolutely amazing from the service to the food! Have been a few times and everything was top notch! Five stars!!

As I was leaving work, I'm thinking.... I could go for a good Deli sammich. I use my trusty Yelp app and I find Annamaria's. Small Italian Deli on the corner with street parking. Inside is very old school with a menu right to the point. Everything was ran like a well oiled machine as one person takes the order and another is immediately making up the sandwich. I got the Annamaria (cappicola, sopressata, salami, provolone, fresh mozz, arugula and hot peppers) and I got my wife the Nina (Roasted chicken breast, provolone, sweet peppers and arugula). Both sandwiches were phenomenal. We all know that the bread can make or break a sandwich and this Italian bread was EXCELLENT. The hot peppers complimented the fresh mozz amazingly. Both came with a balsamic glaze. It works, especially on the Annamaria; giving that little sweetness behind that spicy kick from the peppers. The Nina was MASSIVE. To the point that I was lucky enough to steal some of my wife's as she couldn't come close to finishing it. Great, old school, local Italian Deli that I look forward to trying more from their menu. read more

See all

Very good food very tasty!! if you wanna hot meal on a dish or a nice sandwich check them out! They're pretty quick with making your sandwich as they make them right in front of you and you could either take it to go or eat it right at the counter the guys usually are very nice respectful and give you a nice portion place is very clean read more

Big fan of Annamaria's Deli! Their sandwiches here are reasonably priced, very fresh and delicious, and good size! I've had the Annamaria and Hot Roast Beef sandwich here. The Annamaria sandwich was so good; one of the best "Italian" sandwiches I've had. The Hot Roast Beef was really good too. I appreciated that the roast beef was cut fresh on the spot. The beef au jus/gravy was solid, but there was more fat than preferred on the roast beef so it made the sandwich a little too chewy for my liking. Staff was super friendly and the sandwiches were wrapped in high-quality wrapping paper (which is not a given at many sandwich shops). If they could add a solid standing hot sandwich menu, I think it could elevate this deli even further! Can't wait to go back! read more

I go every week and I love the sandwiches and the pasta. Everything I ordered is amazing. From the sandwiches, pasta, chicken cutlets, meatballs, sausage peppers and onions, it's all amazing. The guys are great and very friendly. I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!!!!!! read more

Absolutely delicious. My first time here I asked for their recommendations on 3 sandwiches. The men behind the counter were super super friendly and helpful. He even told me which breads to try out with which sandwiches. Everything was perfect, the cold cuts all sliced impossibly thin, the fresh mozzarella deliciously made, the fresh bread toasty, really there are no complaints here. Also, their prices are so fair for the quality of sandwiches you're getting. They also offer some prepared foods like chicken cutlets, meatballs and a ton of other options. I'll definitely stop in for sandwiches again but also fresh bread and meatballs. This is a perfect hidden gem of an Italian delicatessen. read more

See all

I ordered takeout for lunch. The sandwich was amazing. The bread was fresh and soft. The sandwich tasted delicious. It was filling just the one half. I will be ordering again. I feel they can expand their menu. I did order a side of balsamic but it didn't taste that good and was very oily. read more

Annamaria's Deli - ANNAMARIA - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

This place is AWESOME!!! It's the cutest little sandwich shop and the vibe inside is really cool with all the meats and New Jersey feel/ decor they did. It feels really authentic!! The service was super fast, and probably the fastest I've ever had a sandwich prepared and it was REALLY good too. I would definitely come back!!! read more

See all

A word of advice... don't walk in and ask out loud why they have so many Italian soccer scarves but not your team's - AS Roma. (The very cool crew behind the counter raised their eyebrows, started to speak Italian and I'm pretty sure they were goofing on me. And I don't blame them.) Another word of advice... if you dig Italian food (and who doesn't?!) - you need to make your way here. The last biz that was here was tired and rundown and now you walk in and it's vibrant, clean, smells amazing, they have Italian music playing in the background, the shelves and fridges stocked with all sorts of imports. And the food? We tried a few of their specialty sandwiches (they automatically got another star from me for not offering mayo) on top of their meatballs, breads, pasta and veggies. A knockout on every level. The sandwiches were expertly assembled (there's more than a few places that fail on this front and there's an art to it) and tasted phenomenal. Reasonably priced (for the quality of goods). Awesome staff behind the counter (even if our squadre di calcio don't align). North Jersey didn't realize it but we actually needed one more Italian deli. read more

Annamaria's Deli - How I imagine heaven might look (with the fragrance of fresh basil wafting everywhere)... - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

10/10 will order from here again. This sandwich was well packed and delivered fresh! They have so many sandwiches to choose from and all are very reasonably priced for the size sandwich you get! Perfect Grubhub ordering/delivery and eating experience! read more

Annamaria's Deli - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

I have passed by this small shop too many times so today I dropped in to check it out. It is small cozy shop and very clean and orderly presentation of all their products. I asked for the best seller and informed the roast beef is very popular. It was so delicious! It had a lot of thinly sliced RB, mootz , and pepoers . I really enjoyed it. I also got some sausage and peppers to go with it. Can't wait try this dish ! read more

Amazing Italian sandwiches! Highly recommend the ciabatta bread option for your sandwich!

Best sandwiches around. I ordered a party platter of various sandwiches and it felt like each one was better than the next. they might've made us wait a little when we arrived to pick up our order but it was well worth it. Next time I want sandwiches again, I will be ordering from here! read more

Annamaria's Deli - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Oh man, this spot is just SO GOOD. My husband and I have hit up Annamaria's Deli multiple times for lunch when we are working remote and it is just the highlight of the day. I've yet to have a bad sandwich from here. All of their ingredients are so fresh and many of them are imported from Italy. Some of the sandwiches I've had are the Annamaria, Louie, Funzy, Nonna, and the really super delicious Tommaso - which uses imported Italian tuna. All of these sandwiches were to die for, and the best part? They definitely do NOT skimp on the meat or cheese! Just order the Annamaria and you will know what I'm talking about. It is piled high! The wheat bread they use is especially delicious too - nice and crunchy and holds the sandwich together well - no meats and cheeses falling all over the plate in a goopy mess. The flavors of everything are just so so good. The prices are right. My husband always picks up the food and says they are quick, efficient, and friendly. Whenever we get a chance we try to order from Annamaria's Deli, it's simply the right thing to do. read more

having every sandwich they make, and making my way down the list... . walked out with 3 today. . the roast beef , smfh. I wish my grandmother was alive to share a sandwich with. The roast beef is a must! I grew up having a roast beef hero at least once a week from the same spot for over 40 years... that spot changed hands and new owners don't roast anything g in house anymore... losers. . this sandwich would put a smile on her face, easily. . I found my new roast beef spot, hope they stick around for 40years! read more

Lemme tell you this - place is legit! Absolutely amazing. The sandwiches are huge and you can just look at the ingredients and tell that this is quality. I am shocked that I never stopped by here before but I will come here regularly. I placed my order thru an app but they didn't get the order. The guy just said "I will make it now" and boom...in 2 minutes I had my sandwich. I showed him my receipt and he was like "ok no problem". He could not have been nicer or more charming. I looked around the small store while I waited and they have some nice goodies too! I was so impressed with the food and service. This is hugely insulting to them but allow me to make a comparison. Think of a large chain that gives you footlongs for $5-$7. And then imagine a real quality sandwich made with love for the same price in the same time - which one would you choose? If you have to debate this.... I love small neighborhood places and this spot is perfect for a quick sammy grab. read more

I can't believe I didn't review this yet. Absolutely fantastic deli! Honestly, one of the best. The portions, the taste, the quality, the service, the prices, you just can't go wrong here. If you're in the area, and you're in the mood for a sandwich, particularly in Italian sandwich, this is the place. What you get you would imagine would be something you're splurging for as a treat, but they don't make you splurge! The pricing is beyond reasonable, especially considering what you get. Personally, I like their Annamaria sandwich, and their broccoli rabe is fantastic. Do not miss the spot! Go and enjoy, and you're welcome! read more

Stopped by as I was traveling on business. Had the roast beef which was so good and brought home the annamaria. Absolutely delicious! Only wish they had a location in PA. read more

Annamaria's Deli - ANNAMARIA on ciabatta - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

I just devoured a roast pork with provolone. peppers, onions, mushrooms and au jus (gravy) on a fresh semolina roll. It was amazing. Sometimes, the bread makes the sandwich, but in this case, all of the components of the sandwich made it terrific! read more

I've been getting sandwiches here since they opened in 2020. Some of my favorites are the Napoli, chock full of prosciutto & soppressata, Filomena when I'm watching my heart health, roast beef with au jus. Very few places make Italian sandwiches this good. Trust me, I'm not even Italian. It's all in the bread and quality ingredients. They have a selection of bread to choose for your sandwich. I used to get my Italian sandwiches from other places around this area but Annamaria's has the best prices and quality. Try them once and you'll never go to any other place for your Italian sandwiches. read more

I haven't eaten here in maybe a year because I live four hours away, but whenever I drive to NYC I stop here. They're in East Rutherford and when the Giants or Jets play at home I remember their sandwiches. Recommend Patsy, Massimo, and Alfredo pasta shells. read more

Annamaria's Deli - Porchetta, mozzarella, arugula and crema di balsamico on ciabatta - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Some of the best meatballs I've ever had. I usually only eat half a sandwich and take the other half home but not this time!! That meatball sub was gone!! Excellent service read more

What a great addition to the area! Annamaria's took over the spot previously occupied by Rosario and Franks deli. They did a nice remodel and added a counter with a few stools to eat-in. Nice selection of Italian sandwiches made on Brooklyn bread. A few hot specials also. Will be back soon to try some other sandwiches. read more

Annamaria's Deli - Benevento- Italian tuna, fresh mutz and aragula - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Fab sandwiches. Everything authentic about this gem of a sandwich shop. I try to load up when im this far south on route 17

One of the best old Italian deli's in the area. Great fresh Italian meats,cheeses, pasta and breads.The sandwich selection is top notch and all delicious.Amo questo posto!! read more

Very nice and fresh deli. Reasonably priced specialty shop right in a neighborhood with a great view. read more

Annamaria's Deli - Napoli sandwich. Full and tasty - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

I am eating a Zia and lord have mercy this is one of the best sandwiches I had in a long long time. You can legit be from any place in the world and find a panini or sandwich or anything that suits you, definitely a must go. Also all the other Italian stuffs they have are pretty damn good ! read more

Sandwiches were delicious. Ready on time. Would highly recommend Quick and helpful service

Such a special local find. Based on location and size you may not think much of annamarie's but you would be missing a delightful opportunity for flavorful food. DEFINITELY A MUST STOP in town. The sandwiches on the board all sound so delicious, it's hard to narrow it down. The combos of meat and cheese are endless. All the toppings and sides are FRESH. I tried the Katherina on rustico bread and was not disappointed. The peppers and artichoke combo was perfect. Not to mention the big slices of smokey mozz, which had a nice strong flavor. I can't wait to try each and every sandwich. The stuffed peppers in the case looked amazing so i will definitely be trying those next as well. The shop is also full of italian kitchen essentials like fresh pasta, sauces, olive oil, various jared and prepared vegetables, and sweet treats. read more

Annamaria's Deli - All the italian specialties you need - Delis Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

One of the best in North Jersey, no doubt. Amazing bread and fresh ingredients. Amazing special sandwiches with great combinations. I don't live close but regularly find myself coming out of my way to come here read more