- Decent-sized restaurant with tables spaced far enough apart to make for a comfortable dine-in experience; was very busy on a Friday evening during dinner, but the space didn't feel cramped - Service was a bit hit or miss; our waitress was very attentive at first--checking in several times and eager to take our order--but after we ordered, it was hard to get her attention and follow-up was limited - Food was good, though not particularly memorable--the large salad was fresh and nicely dressed (just be sure to toss it well, as the dressing settles at the bottom); the kid's spaghetti and meatball came out hot with a pleasantly tangy sauce--served with a warm, toasted garlic knot; the pizza had a thicker crust and was generously loaded with toppings, but the bottom was a bit too charred, and there wasn't quite enough sauce toward the edges, leaving parts of the crust a little dry read more

See all

THE FOOD ---------------- = Carnivori Pizza - Was OK. 16" was cut tavern style and more than enough for our family of 4. Lots of haphazardly spread pepperoni, sausage, meatballs and bacon toppings and the toppings DEFINITELY made it better. Not enough tomato sauce IMO and undercarriage and crust was a litttttle too "doughy" and thick for my taste. Lots of black ashiness from the oven on the bottom of the pizza too. + Anthony's Classic Italian Salad - The large was plentttttty of salad for our family. Made up of romaine, there were lots olives, tomatoes cut into 8ths and 1 whole egg cut into quarter slices. All of the dressing was on the bottom, so mix it well if you want to taste that Italian dressing! + Kids Spaghetti and Meatballs - Just enough to feed 2 toddlers. Sauce was tangy. Meatball was solid. = Menu consisted of plenty to choose from - starters, roasted wings, salad, pasta and quite a few specialty pizza pies. Pizza pies were a bit on the pricier side though, especially the specialty 16" at $27.99. THE SERVICE ------------------- + All of our food came out very blazingly fast after we ordered, so we didn't have to wait long to stuff our faces. = Waitress was cordial, but not overly friendly to us like she was to a neighboring table of, I guess, more chatty adults. THE SURROUNDINGS ------------------------------- + Located in the Fair Lawn Promenade directly off Route 4 in Fair Lawn, so very easy to find off of the highway. + Plenty of parking spaces at the strip mall. + Big bar towards the front of the restaurant with TVs scattered inside. = Restaurant is mid-size, but feels on the smaller side during peak dining times on weekends when it's jam-packed. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS ------------------------------------- = Was super busy at 6 PM on a Friday evening, but only waited about 5 minutes for a table. When we left at 7:30 PM, a few parties were waiting to be seated, so their wait might have been a bit longer. read more

See all

Came for happy hour, was empty but started to get filled up and loud as we were leaving. I live so close and never have been. I let my husband choose so he wanted to go here. I ordered the wings 5 for $5 (buffalo style) the wings were un-eatable slimy, they were so gross, I couldn't get them down. The $2.00 off the alcohol was a joke when one nice drink cost $12.00. So $10.00 for a good drink. (I had the Italian Lemonade it was good not strong but ok. My husband had the meatballs and hot peppers sandwich and he was happy with it and ate the whole thing (that was off the regular menu). The shining star of the night was our waitress (bartender) Melany... bright, bubbly and just so nice to talk to!! I hate writing bad reviews but the public needs to know that this was just gross. I would not recommend to anyone for happy hour but wouldn't go back because now I have this bad taste in my mouth (no pun intended). read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Happy hour menu - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

We usually love this location for it's convenient pick up and the quality of it's food, but lately it's been going downhill. The last order we made was for a 16in meatball and ricotta. The first thing I noticed was the crust seemed rather thin. It really had the texture of a regular oven pie, not what we are used to from the coal oven. The other issue was that it was a full inch smaller than it should have been. Now while it might not seem like a big deal, when you pay nearly $30 for a pizza, you should get what you pay for. That one inch difference amounts to Anthony's overcharging about $4 a pie. Not sure we'll be back. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - 15 inch pie - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

The service is not good. Sat down and waited 15 minutes before anyone even came up to us. A worker grabbed her door dash delivery in front of us. read more

Nice place, good pizza and a fun place to go with friends. I had a lunch meeting here the other day and we enjoyed the good service, and a great sausage pizza. It was nicely cooked with a thin crust and the right amount of char on it. We ordered iced teas with it, no alcohol because it was a work day, but everything was good and our waiter was quick to refill our glasses. Glasses. She was extremely pleasant and checked in with us often. This was a good place to go on a rainy day and enjoy some time out. I think it's a good place for groups who want to get together for pizza. I'm not usually a chain fan but this was pretty good. read more

Been here many times and the food is great. This location is one of the better spots for this franchise, I've been to a few and this is my favorite. Our bartender Mel is always on top of her game and Nick the manager has this team working and servicing great here. Always recommend read more

Fun active place with bar and good service. Clean and the food is good. The place is a little noisy but again that's because it's always hopping! read more

We have Anthony's in Florida, and I'm guessing that's where they reign from. Lots of dolphins football memorabilia around the shop. A little piece of my home state here in Jersey. I Joined the rewards program, and my free 12 inch personal pizza with sign up was going to expire today. Couldn't seem to place my order for pick up, so I headed over to dine in for lunch on a Saturday. Not full at all. Lots of football games playing on the TVs. Service was friendly and attentive. I ordered the traditional pizza that works with the sign up reward. None of the pizzas worked with the redemption qualifications online, so I think you do need to come in to the restaurant to use the coupon. I ordered a glass of the California Pinot Noir . It was good. Pizza arrived not too long after, piping hot and smelling like freshly baked bread. For a simple traditional pizza it was exactly what you want. Light flakey crust with lots of gooey mozzarella and a tasty Pomodoro sauce. I ate three slices, and saved room for dessert. Got recommendations from the server and went with the tiramisu. She had suggested the chocolate cake, but I wasn't in a chocolate mood. Next time. The tiramisu was exactly what I was craving. It was a good meal. They have happy hour Sunday through Friday from 3:30 to 6 PM. This is so close I will definitely come back. read more

See all

They gave us DAY OLD PIZZA!!! We just had the worst carry out experience ever. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. I know what day old pizza looks and tastes like and that's EXACTLY what they gave us. The cheese was reheated and peeling off the crust. The blobs of sauce were fresh but the crust was stale and gross. We have been local Anthony fans for years and usually go to the Clifton location. Never had an issue with eat in or carry out. We recently moved closer to the fair lawn location and thought to give them a shot. Literally never ever again are we going back here. I would rather drive further for the other location and avoid this experience ever again. Check your carry out before you walk out the door. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Day old pizza given for carry out! It was disgusting! - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

Finally made it back, yikes, also took pics of the food for the 1st time in like 10 times I've been here lol.. LOVE THIS PLACE, their pizza is THE BEST, the wings TO DIE FOR! Went with my little brother, twin sister and her bf, we ordered a Carnivori Square large pizza and a "Traditional which was free" plus Arugula, Prosciutto and Onions! Delicious (this is my go to one! Yummyyy ).. Also loveeeeee their wings as stated on my previous review, we ordered the order of 20 wings, and mixed 10 Dry Rub, and 10 Original wings! Jay/Jason was our server, 10 Stars service!! Very good customer service skills, and super friendly !! The ambiance is always good, music is not low but is not crazy loud you can definitely enjoy it and talk .. Recommend this place! WORTHY OF ANYTHING! read more

See all

Love this place! Food is great. Service is wonderful. Atmosphere is casual and fun! We ordered wings for a football party. Lots of them. We were a bit disappointed this time because they were very dry and a bit overcooked. They also did not include and blue cheese or other dressing. This was definitely a one off bad day because normally they are great! read more

One star cause we were constantly being updated on our delivery. I appreciated that. If you like a thin, really thin pizza with no frills then this is for you. Honestly, save yourself some money and slather some sauce on a pita with cheese and burn it yourself. Over priced and will not be ordering again. Where or where can I get an authentic pizza in Bergen County?? read more

Great service and great food! Came in last week with my wife and we had the meatballs! And shared a pie! Absolutely delicious!

I'm currently obsessed with this pizza, hence the fact that I ordered delivery two days later and will likely order again this week. I'll add that this time I ordered half a caprese and half a square margherita. I wasn't sure how this was going to turn out, and sort of hoped that it would be exactly half an round caprese and half a thin crust rectangle shaped margherita, since there was no disclaimer noted otherwise. It turned out to be a rounded and thicker crust margherita to match the caprese, which was a small disappointment; still delicious, but not the same. Also, I unknowingly didn't specify spicy or sweet peppers for Paulie's pizza, and it defaulted to spicy whole green jalapeños, which are HOT. read more

Well staffed, clean, and they make the pizzas great! Perfect for happy hour, a date, or a family dinner read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

I try this place for the first time after years of driving by. I seat inside, table for two. Nice atmosphere and Clean. The girl who helped us was very nice and courteous. I had the eggplant Marino I think that was the name, very tasty and perfect portion for two, I also had a pizza with mushrooms,onion & sausage, small size is 6 slices, enough for two people. Prices are good, I don't know about alcoholic drinks since I don't drink. I will definitely will try this place one more time, I wanna try a few things on the menu. read more

We ordered pizza and wings for pick up tonight. After the 5 minute drive home, our pizza was a little cool, but still tasty. We got the eggplant Marino. It was good, but a little sweet for me. The wings were perfection as always. The salty wings, caramelized onions and seasoned focaccia marry so well together. I probably wouldn't order the eggplant pizza again, just personally not a fav. We normally get the Paulie's Pie and it's always delicious. We'll definitely be ordering/coming in again. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Eggplant Marino - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

Food is consistently good. Dan is an excellent manager and Tina keeps the bar very entertained and never waiting for a refill.

So I received a comment from the restaurant Asking me to Share my contact information with them. I did and guess what no one even got in touch with me. Why bother asking if you're not going to follow up. Add poor customer service to my review Picked up margarita pie. Very disappointing especially for what they charge. Pie not hot No basil except one large droopy piece. Known for crispy even burnt crust- this was read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Disappointing Margarita pie - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

I'm really not a big fan of chains and I love Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. That should tell you everything in a nutshell right there. Their pizzas are well done and thin crust. You don't get that as an option. That's just how they do it. If it's not for you then don't come here. You've been warned!! So don't come crying to yelp about it after. I LOVE thin crust and well done pizzas so it's not super surprising why I like this place so much. But besides the pizza their wings and salads are good too. I like the dry rub wings a lot. Their arugula burrata salad is also amazing but anything with burrata is an automatic home run for me. My only complaint is their pizzas are on the small side. Even if you order a large. They're smaller than your average pizzeria and for the same price. Still, good pizza is good pizza. read more

See all

Food has gone in the wrong direction in my opinion. Just ordered from there and not very appetizing. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Who would put a burnt meatball like this in someone's order? - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

I can't believe i forgot to take a picture of my cauliflower pizza. I joined my cousin, Mary C. here for lunch, because it was the closest location with a parking lot. The day before was National Pizza Day, so we were celebrating a day late. It's a clean, typical "Italian" chain restaurant, specializing in coal fired pizza. We were seated quickly by our friendly waitress and our drink orders were immediately filled. For an appetizer, we got the wings, and for our pizza, we split a large cauliflower pie. The wings are decent. They seem to be baked, with a simple seasoning of salt and pepper, but topped with lightly caramelized onions. I wouldn't go out of the way for them. The large cauliflower pie was very filling. It has a creamy sauce, instead of a tomato based one, and the roasted cauliflower on top was great and garlicky. It's probably good for at least 4. We took most of it home. Prices were good too, the cauliflower is the most expensive pizza and it was only a little over $20 for a large. A fine choice for slightly different pizza. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wings - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

Great food and great service. I had the Italian margarita, the eggplant appetizer and the cauliflower pizza. Everything was delicious!! The margarita was amazing. My server was Michael P. He was awesome!! He knows the menu and is one of those servers that reads your mind. He asked me if I wanted something literally moments before I could ask him (water, napkins, 2nd drink). He saw my pizza vision and clearly loves pizza. We basically created a custom cauliflower pizza that included some white sauce, marinara, and sausage. Definitely coming back. read more

Always consistent. Good sangria, great service. Always go back to the chicken wings. They are oven roasted in an iron skillet with onions on top. They come out crispy and very tasty. My go to is always the morning Italian salad with grilled chicken. Their salads are always cold and fresh This place could become very busy so try and go off hours. read more

Service not the best if you try to order for takeout. The food is good and family friendly. If you go on the weekends prepare to wait to be seated read more

Even, though it is a franchise, the pizza is quite good. They have great garlic knots too and good-size salads.

We have visited Anthony's 4 times this summer. All meals ( wings, pizza, salad, and broccoli rabe) were consistently very good. Service is excellent. A very nice outdoor bar with sports tv's on all walls. Perfect for a weekend date. read more

I really liked it there, been to the one in Fairlawn, promenade. Always lots of customers there, pizza delish, loved the wings and the waitresses, and waiters. read more

I placed an order for a pizza and 2 sandwiches at 11:40 and was told that it would be ready for pickup in 25 minutes, at 12:05. At 12:15 my order was still not ready. I was told that it was late because they decided to make fresh foccia bread which seems strange since this is peak lunch hour and I guess they only had old bread (from yesterday?). The order finally came out and I left. I was very disappointed with the pizza. Normally I would say I want the pizza well done when ordering and they would always tell me that is the only way they make the pizza. I opened the box and aside from not being well done there was almost no tomato sauce on the pizza. I ate part of one slice and left the rest; it was not worth eating. This is the second time I have had to wait more than 15 minutes past the quoted pickup time. They used to be really good but something has happened; can't accurately quote a delivery time and this time the pizza was very disappointing. read more

Great pizza as always! Been to the one in Clifton too! Will definitely come back! Love Anthony's!!!!!!!!

This place is A-OK in my books. Its exactly what you expect out of this chain. Good pizza and drinks! I had their pumpkin beer with their sugar cinnamon rim- delish. Their eggplant marino pizza was good. I love how they have an outdoor seating at the bar which is where we took our two seats. Its a great place to sit on a nice night out. Its located in a cute new promenade. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Eggplant Marino - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

Fantastic food and friendly service. The margarita pizza was delicious and very fresh. Perfect! The Italian margaritas made by Juan B. (Our server bartender) were outstanding. read more

Excellent! My co workers and I decided to come here and grab a quick bite and boy was i happy we choose this place. I got their Coal oven Chicken sandwich, extremely flavorful, it won't disappoint. We all shared the Margherita Pizza it was sensational, well done, just how i like it. I had to come again for a second time, this time I went to a different location and the taste was consistent, yummy like the first time. This is a good place to come to with family during the evenings and during lunch hours to grab a quick tasty bite with your colleagues. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

The Margherita Pizza is always very good made with plum tomato sauce, grated Romano cheese and fresh mozzarella. Eggplant Marino has a very tasty sauce loaded onto very thinly sliced eggplant garnished with Romano cheese and basil. Great for take out! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

This is my first time dining here! The bartender Stefania was fabulous! Very attentive and informative! Had a great lunch! My sister and I split the caprese pizza, it was delicious !! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Caprese pizza - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

Best brick oven pizza in NJ great family friendly place the staff is is the best try the mushrooms and sausage pizza

Sitting outside. The waiter is very kind and attentive. The pizza is delicious. However, they only serve pizza or sandwiches (so nothing that takes long) no one else is here... why does it take 10 mins for drinks?? Also, only Cheesecake for dessert. Came here for my daughters bday and she loves chocolate but no luck :/ read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza is consistently good. You're either gonna like this type of pizza or not. It's "well done" in more ways than one. Sometimes I'll admit it is a little overdone where it's all crunch and very black around the edges. But for the most part it's been perfect. I'm a huge fan of the personal pizza with mushrooms. They make this to perfection. Their sauce is so simple but you can really taste the freshness of the tomatoes and enjoy the simplicity of it. Great lunch menu to take out and really great atmosphere for a nice, yet casual, dinner. It's more of an upscale sports bar, if anything. read more

Service is great! Love the outdoor indoor eating they have great for the summer time! Pizza was phenomenal, better than I expected They don't have garlic powder which is odd for a pizzeria but they have garlic cloves which honestly took my pizza from 0 to 100 would come back again for sure ! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Bar area - Italian Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey