Pizza I ordered was cut very unevenly. I called to get 1 remade and the lady had an attitude. Brought the pizza back and the lady cut her eyes. The guy making the pizza looked pissed. Everyone was getting warm welcomes except for me like I did something wrong. Large pizza isnt even a large any more mind you it's $25 after taxes. Shane on yall Anthony's. Not the same size like the slices they sell. Date is 3/22/2026. Here's a picture. I should've just went to vinzos or dough boyz. Never again will I waste my money here. They use to be so good. And I've been going here for almost 10yrs! read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza cut unevenly - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

Amazing service, staff is extremely friendly and welcoming. food is incredible look forward to patronising this establishment read more

Anthony's Pizza is the most similar to New York style pizza I have seen in Florida. I love it.

That manager needs to be fired! They are rude to their paying customers just trying to place an order. She REFUSED to give her name, my order came to approximately $41, I gave her a $50 and she gave me .27 change until I demanded my actual change. These people are scammers!! They cooked my pizza upside down, it was doughy (I have pics) and my sub barely had any meat on it! Based on what I saw, the health department needs to be called on this place, grease under the wheels they just mop around, dirty dishes, unclean counters and utensils.. ugh..Avoid this place like the plague!!!!! read more

Excellent food service and I would recommend any day of the week I love the Boss pizza and salad Caesar with a coke me and my client visits like three times a week read more

We ordered carryout, the order was ready on time. We ordered the special. Excellent NY style pizza!!!

30.00 pie . Greasy , flat. no substance and very little cheese. Have eaten there several times , but this was extremely disappointing. (Only one topping ) read more

Walked into this place for the first time ever. About to drop $25 ($27-28 with tax) on a 16" "Mediterranean" pie... Me: "Could I substitute the broccoli with Pepperoni?" Guy behind counter: "No we can't do that, because it's too expensive." Me: "Have a nice evening." (I walked out) Is common sense fading away from society, or something? I won't be back there again. Boardwalk Pizza (down the road) is a bit more expensive and super delicious. I think I'm going to head there this weekend. They don't provide ignorant excuses like Anthony's did to me. read more

If I could give them a zero stars I absolutely would. The so-called manager is rude, nasty and hangs up in your face. The wings were less than appetizing and they offer nothing other than too bad so sad this is the way we make them. I did not want anything other than an acknowledgement and apology and instead I was treated like a bigger on the street or less than this. I would not recommend this place to a starving person nor a dog. read more

Anthony's pizza 17-92 and Button Road. Like most in Casselberry we are long time customers over 20 years. Tonight we noticed the prices on menu are different than receipt. We questioned our waitress, the one who wears glasses and is loud speaking. Mind you we always have her as our server. Her response was I don't know, I don't know why the owner does what he does. No explanation, no let me find out nothing other than I don't know. She walked away and we heard her tell her coworker their questioning the prices. She looked over our way and saw my daughter looking right at her. My sister grabbed a menu off a table to look at the prices. The waitress said,again to coworker , now they looking at the menu and they should pay cash then if they don't want to pay the fees. The issue is not the credit card fees, we gladly pay it as always. We were trying to understand why the discrepancy between menu and bill. So maybe someone else can get the answer. Just wanted to say how disheartening. Time to give our hard earned money to another restaurant. And to our waitress. You should be ashamed of yourself. Next time think before you speak. Your voice travels! read more

It looks promising the people are friendly the atmosphere is nice but the pizza sitting in the case is old the sauce is non-existent the cheese is not tasty and the crust is mediocre I would never eat this again I didn't even finish what they gave me... 3.00 a slice and any frozen pizza on the planet is going to taste better read more

Anthony's Pizza - pizza - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

See all

Look closely at your receipt. They jack up the prices without telling you and also add 3% if you pay with a card on top of that.

Pizza was good but wayyyyy overprice... spent $15 on 2 pepperoni slices and a drink. I have been to over 50 pizzerias throughout the state of Florida from Jacksonville to Miami to Fort Myers and this was not the best but the most expensive. The service was normal and food was quick. Place looked clean and nice restaurant set up. read more

Tried this palace a couple times. Had it delivered and was great pasta and pizza. Last time pizza was uncut and pasta sauce wasn't the best.

I love their pizza and the service is so personable. The bianca is best I've had of white pizza. read more

Hubs and I stopped by here a couple weeks ago for the first time on a Friday night to grab dinner. They were super busy. They only do dine-in or carry out, no delivery. We ordered a calzone and a small Bianca pizza. Girl at the counter told us 30 minutes, so we settled in to wait at the small waiting area up front. It was closer to an hour before we got our order. There was quite a few staff working but it seemed very chaotic and we noticed several other customers who had phoned in their orders had incorrect orders on arrival to pick up. The staff was very quick to correct them or offer free drinks etc for their trouble. But it all seemed very disorganized. The food was ok but there was way too much oregano on the Bianca pizza. I don't know if we would return as the whole experience was overwhelming and the food was not good enough to justify all the craziness. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Bianca - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

Wow the spaghetti was amazing!! Big portions abd the garlic knots are simply delicious! I can't wait to go back!!! The pizza is good too !

Ordered a meat lovers calzone, just like the ones I had ordered 30 times before. It had 3 pieces of pepperonni, a little sausage and ham, no meatballs or bacon. When I called to ask why I got a calzone with lots of ricotta and mozzarella and almost no meat. The girl on the phone said that it was all pre portioned then just hung up. Been going there since they opened in 1987 but will not be going back. read more

Ehh... customer service was friendly... pizza ok... crust to thick for me. Good flavor but two slices at over $13 ? Didn't seem worth the price. Probably won't be back read more

Charlie and the staff at Anthony's are kind and give great customer service. We made a mistake on our order and they graciously made new pizza for us - which was going above and beyond! And the pizza crust and sauce were great. A big thank you to everyone at Anthony's (in Casselberry next to Publix) on 17-92! read more

Great pizza and garlic knots. Being from NY, this is the best pizza I've had,other than from a pizzeria in NYC. The service was great and everyone was friendly. I continue to go back. No problems. read more

The food here is excellent and tastes great but I've had a couple issues just lately. Last time I saw an order of Sicilian slices returned from the table, untouched I assume but way burnt. They went back in the display case to sell. Not cool. The arancini balls one time are normal size but getting soggy on a bed of cold lettuce, the last time very small, cut open and dried out. (I did say we were eating later) I also said no need to heat up my cheese slices since again we were eating later. They were heated. I ordered a side of sauce. Got to the car, not in there. Again the taste of the food is very good but check your take out orders. 3/3/21 just went back in to try again and the price of the items I always get went up 33%! While I know things have gone up---33%?!!! Nothing like a little price gouging as a side dish! When we opened the arancini, there was no ricotta, the sauce was burnt , what usually is a ground beef center was almost liquid. I can no longer recommend this restaurant. read more

We usually order Anthony's when we don't know what else to get but still a solid choice. However, I go for the pasta dishes most of the time and I somehow always forget that they are HUGE portions. I think next time I may try the kids portion and add shrimp; The shrimp Alfredo is my favorite. My fiancé orders the Italian sub toasted and he loves!!! It. Also they don't charge a delivery fee which allows us to tip the driver a bigger tip and I love that. read more

We've been going to Anthony's for 25 years and the good has always been fabulous. Unfortunately our last experience left us underwhelmed. Don't order the Calamari! Scary. Tough and greasy. Pizza undercooked and toppings slimy. Anthony's come back please! We miss you. Have to say the server was awesome. She was the only one working the tables and she did her best to make up for the poor food quality. read more

So expensive, food average. Go elsewhere since not worth the price. Upcharge for everything water awful un drinkable.

We decided to stop by and try their pizza as it has been a while since we have been to Anthony's. The Pizza was over cooked, dry and barely any sauce and cheese. Pizza Hut would have made a better choice. Will not be back. read more

The food is okay, the pizza was really greasy & in general the food was so expensive i think we got 1 Large pizza and a Large salad it was like $80 the service was good & fast i never went back though Angelina's pizza is more natural food / Organic so i would rather go there. The ambiance is okay just got it togo nothing special read more

Terrible pizza. Sauce on pizza is bad. Bad tasting. Garlic rolls are awful. Dry, dinner rolls with garlic just put on top. Save your money and go elsewhere. read more

This is hands down the best slice in Central Florida. I know that's not saying much.. but this place would survive up north.. it's that good. read more

Worst. Asked for extra well done. Got a soggy mess. Happens every time. Ask to have pizza cooked more, was told couldn't do it because it was cut. Got a pathetic "Sorry". And that's it. Do your self a favor. Go elsewhere. Last and final time. Too many pizza places in the area to get poor product and NO customer service. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Soggy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

I ordered a Sicilian pizza with pepperoni, ham, onions and mushrooms. The pizza was raw and the toppings were barely warm. You would think if you pay 35 bucks for a pizza, it would be edible. The antipasto salad consisted of romaine lettuce, 3 little balls of mozzarella, 2 pieces of tomatoe and a few black olives. The dressing tasted like wishbone Italian..very Orange in color. I called to complain and the girl on the phone told me "I don't know what to tell you, the cooked it"..then a long pause. I just told her OK, I'll never order pizza from you again and hung up. I wouldn't waste my money on their Sicilian Way overpriced and disgusting. read more

Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

See all

We had been going to Anthonys for years. They lost our business today when we got the wrong pizza and tried to call and get it redone. They blamed us for their mistake, refused to let us speak to a manager and hung up the phone on me. Bye Anthonys. I'm done. read more

I've come in to get the VIP pizza for years. The great thing about somewhere that's consistent is that no matter how long you've been gone, the taste remains the same! Love it! read more

Love this place. Little hole in the wall but the pizza is delish. Always are go to when we want pizza.

DELICIOUS! We stumbled across this cute little corner restaurant, and so glad we did! We had the meatball sub, and a Stromboli. The Stromboli was loaded with ricotta, mozzarella, and our toppings. The Bread and meatballs were home made and absolutely divine! The prices were great too in a world where everything seems so expensive. If you're thinking of going here, don't hesitate! read more

Anthony's Pizza - This is half the Stromboli and a meatball sub! - Pizza Near Me - Casselberry, Florida

Sweetest people with the best pizza for miles. We moved out near longwood and we still travel back to get their food. The salads, the fried zucchini, the pizza, the pasta, and the garlic bread that comes with. CHEFS KISS read more

Showed up tonight at 8:35 was told the dining room closed at 9:00. Told the lady it was 8:30 and the response was "dining Room is closed". She was rude af. No need for that. If you want to close early after a busy or crazy night no problem. Just don't be a c*nt about it. Place is on the decline for a reason read more

I have never had a bad pizza from this location until tonight! Pizza makers need to realize that pizza lovers can tell when the pizza is old and reheated and not cooked to order. I could sadly tell after 1 slice of my $23 pizza, that it was most likely the display margarita pizza that's been siting out most of the day. So disappointed!!!! Will not recommend anymore nor will I be back! -Sad long time customer read more

The food is 3/10, dingy lightning was a red flag . Waitress in there talking loud and inappropriate about wanting to fight a customer. Our waitress was very nice. This place needs to be cleaned up and workers need to have uniform clean attire. I wanted to like it. Eating and drinking in front of customers at the counter another red flag from the same waitress. read more

The worst pizza and can't get an order correct. I ordered a medium pizza with 4 items and extra cheese to go, what I usually order. When I got it home I noticed no extra cheese so I put more on myself but when it came to eating it we found the center dough was not cooked and fell off the pieces when taking them out. This Anthony's has gone downhill for the last few times we've been here but this is the last time. We won't be back! read more