I've never physically been here, but in the brave, new world of COVID I've ordered from here several times via delivery apps. I'm not a New Yorker, so I don't have the built-in aggression to certain pizza places and those places NOT BEING NEW YORK ENOUGH so I like it. It's pretty decent pizza and it definitely isn't "worse than any frozen pizza I've ever had" like another reviewer said. We get the wings, pizza, and knots. All good. We've tried a few of their entrees and they were OK, not great. Their pepperoni roll is DELICIOUS and very well-priced. The calzones were good. They have some nice specials and the food has always been packaged nice. I'd recommend it, unless you have NY pizza aggression issues. read more

*sigh* I was REALLY excited to get calamari for dinner & this is what i got... not even a pathetic lemon slice to go with them... 10 rings of calamari for $9...?????? I'm so incredibly upset & my calamari craving has not been met by any means. If you are looking for good calamari just look elsewhere Otherwise, the Hawaiian BBQ pizza was SO GOOD! Their wings are also pretty decent for the price. I wanted to give one a star but the pizza is actually pretty great. I don't know if i'll ever be able to get over how played so got on the calamari though!!! read more

NY Pizza Baby - Fried Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

The business was sold to new owners. I went there today and they were closed. They are not going to be doing business anymore and it's sad because new people took it over. I enjoyed Pizza there from the previous owner as a man by the name of Mo work there cooking the pizzas. He was not with the current owner now and I wanted to see if they knew where he went cuz I enjoyed the pizzas he made. However they closed out the place is all black and empty. It's sad. read more

Pizza was good. Not enough sauce for my taste though. Fries were on point. Overall 3 stars. Don't think I'll be running to order from them again though. read more

NY Pizza Baby - Pepperoni pizza and fries - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Horrible. I get that you shouldn't maybe order other firms from a pizza place besides pizza BUT... The PIZZA IS HORRIBLE!!!! Gross, worse than any frozen pizza I've ever had. It's like some weird casserole meats pizza. Add to that the very worst burger I've ever had outside of the ones they fed us in 1978 at public school in Georgia growing up (not sure if any meat was in it). Oh, and at least in elementary school the fries were NOT THESE cold, gross undercooked fried and... yes, like an idiot I ordered shrimp-- I won't even begin to tell you how bad the shrimp are. Tried one thinning they would taste better than they look. I was wrong. Just don't. And BTDubs, If they tell you you can add a side of fries and a COKE and send you a Pepsi? Well, that's just wrong. Never. Order from here. Just don't read more

I've never left a review but this was a pretty disappointing delivery . $8 for calamari appetizer and we thought it was a joke when we received it. We called and they confirmed it's a dollar per calamari . If calamari is too expensive for them to sell , they probably should not have this on their menu. Very disappointing as we are a family of five and it was literally one piece sample for everyone read more

NY Pizza Baby - Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Husband got takeout and this pizza is very enjoyable! We've been trying takeout from different places and this one stands out. Nice and thin and you actually want to eat the crust. Nice dusting of cornmeal. We have not tried anything else just the pizzas. read more

I've just recently moved to FL, and I was determined to find my new go-to pizza joint. My girlfriend and I have ordered from "NY Pizza Baby" three times now. Great flavor, affordable, and solid delivery times. Service seemed experienced and considerate each time. One caveat, I wouldn't say anything on the menu stands out as remarkable, perhaps some more interesting menu additions would let "NY Pizza Baby" earn that final star. *DELIVERY REVIEW ONLY, DIDN'T DINE IN* read more

Haven't had pizza this good in awhile!! Best my style pizza in winter park! The crust perfect crisp, great amount of topping not too much not too lil and the nicest staff ever!!! The delivery guy an older Spanish man was great and whoever the girl operating the phone was the sweetest!!! read more

NY Pizza Baby - a half eaten pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

If I could give this place a -100 I would. Ordered food Wednesday night and the food came burnt and was super late, they offered to bring us new food and that was late. Ordered a pizza tonight and over an hour late and then the restaurant had the audacity to say the pizza got delivered when I never received it. Very bad customer service will not be ordering from them again. read more

Best Meatball Sub I've ever had. Bread is warm fresh and lightly toasted. They don't drown the sub in marinara sauce, which I love because the bread doesn't end up soggy. I would ask for a little extra sauce on the side though. Marinara sauce is perfection! read more

NY Pizza Baby - Meatball Sub! Sooo delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Pizza is saucey which I do like. But wasn't cut in equal pieces .. it's like they didn't even care. Chicken is very plain. Order lemon pepper and it was just sitting in mixture. Didn't take long to get our order read more

NY Pizza Baby - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

This is not a safe place to get your pizza. Order delivery otherwise the parking lot is highly dangerous.

I was excited to try this restaurant for the first time. And I must say I was a little bit disappointed. The ziti was good, although more sauce than pasta, the taste was definitely there. The garlic sauce wings, heavily oiled, but seasoned decently and had a good bite them. Not bad. However I was expecting a lot more when it came to the sides. I had ordered onion rings, that are priced at $5.50 and what I got was very upsetting. When I think onion rings I think of big, hot, round, crispy rings of deliciousness. And what I got were warm, tiny, soggy rings of dissatisfaction. And not even a good amount of them at that. Not sure if I'll try them again. But at least I know what I'm in for now. read more

NY Pizza Baby - Sad Onion Rings - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Just a terrible experience all around. Calzone was doughy and of the 6 garlic knots 3 were doughy and 3 were burnt. Staff is unprofessional and rude. Avoid at all costs! read more

I was driving by and stopped in because I wanted some pizza. Yeah, I know this is an a hole in the wall. Yeah I know that the rest of the merchants in the plaza are a little bit shady "". I don't really care about that, the pizza here is amazing the crust is the light and fluffy and still has a little crispiness to it. The toppings and the ingredients are top notch. I'm from New York this reminds me of eating in New York. Anybody who doesn't like the place or is complaining about the location is focusing on the wrong thing. The food here is outstanding. Everybody stop whining and come and eat here. read more

LOVE the lasagna pizza! My new guilty pleasures! And the jalapeño poppers are perfect!

This was our first time ordering from this place. Being former New Yorkers' my husband and I are always looking for good pizza here in Florida. We were in the mood for a sicilian and came across this place. To say we were extremely disappointed is an understatement. When we opened the box for the yummy thick pizza, this is what we received (see above photo). That is NOT a Sicilian pizza, that's a square regular cheese pizza. There is no way this place has any ties to NY what so ever otherwise they would've known that. So either please learn how to make a proper sicilian or just advertise "try a square pizza instead of round". Thank you read more

NY Pizza Baby - It's supposed to be a sicilian pizza, but received a square cheese instead - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I asked for two pizzas one spinach one extra meat. The spinach pizza was basically a cheese pizza. The "extra" meat was barely any meat at all. This is the second time I have ordered from them and the second time they have messed up an order they were not willing to do much for their mistake so they lost a customer read more

NY Pizza Baby - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Ordered delivery.. Best pizza ive had in a very long time.. Also hadxa meatball sub... sooo good..

Not to be dramatic, but I'm pretty sure NY pizza baby brought back my will to live in these trying college midterm times. It's like a new york city baker punched me in the face with gordan ramsey deliciousness level dough and then sprinkled garlic on me like that turkish salt guy. Needless to say, If they chucked a pizza directly at my face with dwayne the rock johnson force, i'd thank them. read more

Best pizza in the winter park area. Friendly staff and amazing food! Pricing is cheap and they deliver

3rd time I have ordered from them with mistakes. And by far the worst. Sub completely burnt. When I called about it, the person who answered would not give his name, said he was the GM, and said they get amazing reviews. He made it sound like it was my issue is was burnt. And the other 2 times they ran out of product, and said its not there fault. Well who's is it? Never got the credit promised for both those issues, and probably won't for this either. I would give a 0 star if I could. read more

NY Pizza Baby - Brun - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Twice we tried this place via Slice. Twice we had to cancel after a 2 hour wait with no pizza. No apology or attempt to make it better. Last time was the final straw - no my fault - is not a good excuse. read more

Just a nice cheap no frills pizza place. I would suggest ordering delivery at night -- the little strip mall that it is in can definitely get sketchy at night. There are a few chairs and tables set up inside, but no one was there and it was definitely cramped. We ordered pickup and arrived a few minutes after the suggested wait time (20 minutes) and still ended up waiting an additional 20 min for our pizza. There were at least 4 people working in that tiny back area and I only saw one other order go out for delivery besides ours. I have no idea why it took so long .... Crust was decent and the cheese was good, but they need to fix their cheese to sauce ratio. Less cheese and MORE sauce is needed (there was barely any on our pizza :(. ) They apparently have a happy hour for pickup available that seemed like a great deal. We might try it again, but the wait scares me a bit. read more

Three words: EGGPLANT PARMESAN PIZZA! The food is always hot and fresh. The only issue I have ever had is that when I have ordered hot wings, the sauce somehow is always under the wings. Odd. read more

This service is horrible. I ordered 20 pc wings and fries and I received a NY platter which everything it was old and super oily and on top of that I got charged 10$ extra & when I called I didn't get no refund because I ordered on the phone. read more

NY Pizza Baby - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

For New York style pizza and calzone, this is the best I have ever had in Orlando. Originally from NJ, I have lived here since 1983 and this is spot on. All components of both the pizza and calzone were amazing. The sauce was not too sweet or acidic, the crust was crispy on the outside and still doughy and flavorful. Well done guys! Definitely will be ordering again. read more

I recently went through a breakup....and for those that don't know, this requires copious amounts of junk food and moral support. Clearly disparaged by the breakup I decided to order pizza without first checking the stores reviews. Grubhub liked them and that was good enough for me. That was until the pizza came. We chose their rolling special on grubhub that includes a large pepperoni pizza, wings and garlic knots. The food came on time and we were all too excited. That was until we took our first bites. The only thing more painful then the breakup was this take-out. Which was the most nondescript, bland, forgettable pizza experience I have ever had. The garlic knots were rock solid. The sauce watery and bland, and then the pizza. The pizza was what hurt the most (to make me dislike something that is so fundamentally good and right like pizza),it's inconceivable! If you are someone who is brand new to the concept of pizza with absolutely no former frame of reference for the delicacy, and do not mind receiving the food slightly altered from how you ordered it then this is the spot for you! Otherwise do pizza a favor and shop elsewhere! read more

Been here a couple times and they never disappoint. Hands down the best NY style pizza for the money. The cashier was also very helpful in recommending us coupons read more

My pizza got here 1 hour late it was cold and I ask for light sauce and it was drench in tomato sauce first and last time .

Awesome staff and great pizza! I'd recommend to try it for yourself. I'm pretty picky when it comes to pizza and this is beyond acceptable food. read more

I really like their pizza a lot. But I like sauce and they don't skimp on it. The wings I have ordered were subpar and don't think I'll order those again. read more

Unfortunately, this restaurant just raised its prices. They had a decent entre lunch menu at a fair price, and now that is gone. I am bummed because I just discovered this restaurant a few weeks ago. This location is an actual hole in the wall restaurant with decent food that is an 8 out of 10. They are now higher in price than some restaurants in the area and there is NOT a nice place to sit. read more

Was craving NY pizza tonight and remembered passing this place recently. I didn't realize how close it was - less than 2/3 of a mile from my home. I called and ordered an XL (18") cheese pizza for pickup, since I don't live that far. It was ready when they said it would be (they quoted fifteen minutes, and it was coming out of the oven just as I arrived), and everyone in the shop was really nice, from the person who took my order to the person at the register; I picked up the pizza by myself, and one of the employees even held the door for me as I left. The pizza itself is pretty good, a little above average. The cheese is nice and gooey, the crust has some of those nice char marks, but it could definitely use just a bit more sauce. I'll just ask for a bit extra next time. My pizza was not at all greasy. Re: the safety of the strip mall. There were a few people hanging out in the parking lot, but they were together and all appeared to be patrons of the hookah bar next door - they were just normal people standing outside talking to each other, I certainly didn't feel unsafe at any time. I'm not denying the experiences of people who reviewed this place before me, but I'm really glad I just called and ordered before I came here to look at the reviews or I'd have missed out. I'll be giving this place more business in the future. read more

I've ordered many times from here. Every single time the Pizza was excellent. Having lived in NYC this is the closest I've had to my old pizzeria in Queens. Delivery is always on time. I do wish they would cut the giant pizza into a bit smaller pieces. However the taste and quality of their pizza is unparalleled. Love this place. read more

Ordered with UberEATS, got an 18 inch pizza just cheese and cinnamon sticks.. pizza was ok nothing spectacular however when we got to the cinnamon sticks the bread was Burt bad and hard the cinnamon was also Burt. Very little icing on it. Not worth a second try I'll stick to our normal places. read more

Ordered a pizza and chicken parm. Both dishes were too greasy and not that great. Not worth the price.

Best pizza in town fresh pizza perfect price and the service is excellent nice and clean place

I love this place!! David was so nice Mo whooped up the best cheese pizza & the crust was perfect. Definitely coming back tomorrow!!